
© REUTERS/Russell CheynePedestrians walk in Princes Street in Edinburgh, Scotland, Britain March 4, 2020.
A group of academics has protested against a draft proposal by the Scottish authorities to replace biological sex with gender identity when collecting census data, arguing
the change would spell disaster for researchers.
In a letter
published by the
Times, several professors from across the UK said they had deep concerns about how data will be collected for the nation's upcoming census.
When the UK census kicks off in March, the Office for National Statistics will ask if a person's gender identity is the same as their legal sex, and, if not, will invite them to clarify what it is. Scotland, however, has postponed its own census until 2022, due to the Covid-19 crisis.
Although
hailed as a victory for the trans community, the group of academics, from the universities of Edinburgh, Essex and Manchester, sees things rather differently. The voluntary questionnaire is "conflating two distinct variables, of biological sex and gender identity", they wrote, adding that information about gender identities is welcome,
but can only be "properly understood" in combination with data on sex.
Even more troubling, according to the professors, is that
Scotland plans to do away with collecting data on biological sex altogether.
Comment: Mr. Nathan Robinson claimed that his tweets were intended as a joke and apologized to John Mulholland. after which The Guardian decided to fire him: See also: