
© John Nacion / NurPhotoIs a country of reinvented individuals a 'lonely crowd'? A Black Lives Matter rally held in front of Trump International Hotel & Tower New York on October 17, 2020.
American Awakening: Identity Politics and Other Afflictions of Our Time, by Joshua Mitchell. Encounter Books, US$28.99. 255 pages with Index
America seems to have gone mad. It still is the world's richest and most powerful country, with the oldest continuous government on earth, yet it is in deep crisis and divided between hostile camps that reject each other's legitimacy.
Paradoxically, what made America strong also makes it inherently fragile. Joshua Mitchell, a professor of government at Georgetown University, presents a cogent diagnosis of America's dark night of the soul in a remarkable new book that should be required reading for anyone who wants to make sense of today's United States.
A Chinese acquaintance quips, "Now you are having your own Cultural Revolution." In fact, the criticism and self-criticism sessions imposed on corporate employees and school personnel to root out hidden racism recall Mao's Red Guards. But America is not China, and this is not a Cultural Revolution; it is an eruption of Christian religious feeling channeled into secular obsessions.
Prof. Mitchell's thesis will elicit skepticism among overseas readers who are unaccustomed to viewing politics through the prism of religion, but America can be understood in no other way.
He diagnoses a spiritual crisis in America, as behooves a scholar of Alexis de Tocqueville, who in 1840 called America "a nation with the soul of a church." In most parts of the world religion seems a fossil, but America cannot be understood except as a Christian religious project.
When American religion goes wrong, Mitchell argues, it goes mad.
Comment: Of course this 'curated' content will only be what they have already selected for options. They've already cracked down on what is not permissible; in the end, they are just presenting an illusion of choice.