
© Strategic Culture Foundation
One major theme of Homer's
Iliad - which somehow seems as fresh and as vivid today as when first written - is its description of how even the greatest of states in Western civilization fail to reclaim what they lose. "Attempts to repair one loss lead only to more losses", Emily Wilson
writes in her introduction to the
Iliad (2023).
"Loss can never be recouped."As Wilson sets out her story, one cannot escape the analogy to today - to a Biden seeking to recoup the American 'reputation' (
Kleos in Greek
). In the case of leaders of the ancient world too, the goal of achieving undying
kleos runs through the poem.
Today, we might refer to it as one's 'legacy'. In the
Iliad it is definitional and gives mortal leaders the chance to live on after death with honour and glory. For Team Biden, Ukraine was supposed to be their Troy. Russia, like Hector, was tricked into a fight and (and as Team Biden had hoped) is killed under Troy's walls.
But in today's world, it didn't work out that way. And now the U.S. faces the humiliation of a clear Russian victory in Ukraine, and a collective
Russian leadership that says it intends to retrieve all lands and cities that were culturally Russian. Western Ukraine, they say, can go 'wherever it likes'.The military facts on the ground are relentless and cannot be undone. But the White House hopes to keep a morsel of
kleos by simply having Ukrainian forces ceasing to fight, falling back onto defensive lines - yet never saying 'defeat'. The kinetic component to the conflict barely would 'tick over' at low revs. And, as Gideon Rachman has
written in the
Financial Times, to "flip the narrative to one of [repeatedly insisting] that Putin has failed". The aim being that Washington quietly can 'steal away'.
Well, there are two big problems: First, Russia doesn't agree; it doesn't agree at all. And secondly, Zelensky and his associates were grievously tricked. Not in this case, by the goddess Athena, but by the mortal Messrs Johnson and Blinken.
Comment: The current spate of 'Swatting' incidents seems to be falling on public figures from both sides of the aisle (although it still seems conservatives are more prominently targeted). This dangerous (and generally ineffective) trend will hopefully not continue.
See also: