
© Handout / DVIDS / AFPFILE PHOTO: US-made 155mm cluster munitions
The recent US decision to send cluster munitions to Ukraine is immoral, unethical, and criminal. We've already seen the horrific results of the use of such weapons - civilians mutilated and murdered (often decades later) in Iraq and
Southeast Asia, for example, and
in Lebanon.
In addition to the ethical reasons not to send these weapons to Ukraine, there are pragmatic reasons why, from a military perspective. They are pointless for Ukraine, in spite of Western
promises that they will "do more damage across a larger area than standard unitary artillery shells by releasing bomblets, or submunitions."
In reality, while covering a wider area than a conventional high explosive munition, the cluster bomblets do not inflict more powerful damage, certainly not against Russian fortified positions. Their use is mainly for targeting troops in the open and lightly armoured vehicles. Not a game changer for Kiev.
According to former US Marine Corps intelligence officer Scott Ritter, "these are the worst weapon in the world for trench warfare. With trench warfare, you need a high explosive round that collapses bunkers, that collapses trenches."
If the US knows that cluster munitions won't change facts on the ground for Ukraine, why is it sending them? Because, as President Joe Biden himself has said, Ukraine is "running out of ammunition and we're low on it." So, the US might as well offload its old stock of cluster munitions. They will not, as Biden claimed, "stop those tanks from rolling." Nor will they - as the Biden administration claims - "save civilian lives." They will almost certainly be used to kill, maim, and terrorize more Donbass civilians immediately and for years to come.
Comment: Obrador's position seems to reflect that of some factions within the US, which have resigned themselves to accepting that they've lost the war on Russia, and that it's time to bow out before even greater losses are incurred; and perhaps they'd also like to redirect their dwindling resources to continue provocations elsewhere, such as against China, or pivoting nations in Africa: