Society's ChildS


Yoda

Best of the Web: Craig Murray: Observations on Israel's defense in the International Court of Justice

International Court of Justice
© ICJThe International Court of Justice
[...]

As with the South African case, according to court procedure the Israeli case was introduced by their "agent", permanently accredited to the court, Tal Becker of the Israeli Ministry of Foreign Affairs. He opened with the standard formula "it is an honour to appear before you again on behalf of the state of Israel", managing to imply purely through phrasing and tone of voice that the honour lay in representing Israel, not in appearing before the judges.

Becker opened by going straight to the Holocaust, saying that nobody knew more than Israel why the Genocide Convention existed. 6 million Jewish people had been killed. The Convention was not to be used to cover the normal brutality of war.

The South African case aimed at the delegitimisation of the state of Israel. On 7 October Hamas had committed massacre, mutilation, rape and abduction. 1,200 had been killed and 5,500 maimed. He related several hideous individual atrocity stories and played a recording he stated to be a Hamas fighter boasting on WhatsApp to his parents about committing mass murder, rape and mutilation.

Comment: Mr Murray also detailed the immense efforts he went to in order to report on these proceedings:
There was a very good feel at the end of the South African presentation on day one. Everyone felt it had gone extremely well, and left very little room for the court to wriggle away from provisional measures. We left the public gallery, and I went with [Jeremy] Corbyn and [Jean Luc] Mèlenchon to meet the South African delegation. This caused some concern to the security officials, who told us that members of the public had to leave immediately and not meet delegates or speak to the media, who were grouped outside the court but still within the precincts.

jermey corbyn
Jean Luc Mèlenchon and Jeremy Corbyn
This was fairly impractical as the media very much wanted to speak with Corbyn and Melenchon. There was a lot of flapping of arms and waving. All my friends of the queue had left, while I stayed sticking close to Jeremy, partly because I didn't like to leave him unsupported, but mostly because his wife Laura was somewhere looking after my phone. The ICJ staff seemed scared to tell off Corbyn and Melenchon, so kept getting pretty shirty with me as a proxy, saying we must leave.

It was quite strange. The situation was very friendly; there was no tension. There were about sixty delegates and about the same number of journalists, who were all supposed to be there. Then there were Corbyn, Melenchon and me, who were apparently supposed to have left, but whose presence made no actual difference to events. People being in slightly the wrong place entirely peacefully after proceedings had finished, seemed to me an unnecessary source of anger. But a succession of female officials arrived, getting increasingly cross.
Amaar Hijazi Palestine Deputy Foreign Minister
© TRT World/YouTubeAmaar Hijazi, Palestine's Deputy Foreign Minister
At this stage the South African delegation returned to their allocated office inside the building to finalise the formal press statement. We went with them. I was chatting to Amaar Hijazi, Palestine's Deputy Foreign Minister, who I know a bit. One of the ICJ ladies came in with a clipboard, asked for silence, and then asked the assembled group in the manner of a public proclamation:

"is this a legal meeting or a political meeting?"

Nobody seemed inclined to answer. So I replied "That's rather a philosophical question. I am not sure if you can make that simple binary distinction". Rather more usefully, Varsha assured her it was a legal meeting, and the official said "good, political meetings off the premises", waving her clipboard for no apparent reason. After a bit of a conflab we went out again.

I was enjoying Melenchon enormously; he seemed to have unlimited stores of bonhomie and was unstoppably voluble with everyone. Whether the security guards wanted a lecture on workers' cooperatives I am not sure, but they certainly got one.

We wandered back out the front door again and back into interviews. Two ladies came up to me looking very stern and said I must leave. Jeremy was giving an interview to Israeli TV and Melenchon had bustled back into the building.

One of the ladies said to me, "I am asking you to leave and you are refusing to do what I say".

I replied, "Oh no, certainly not. Of course I am doing what you say. Just very slowly".

By now I had three enormous security officers with me, as I tried to keep an eye on Jeremy as he drifted through the milling journalists, while I kept running in to people I knew. I have to say the security people were very friendly, and seemed unsure why they were shadowing me too. Shortly a fourth turned up, a mountain of a man with a bald head and beard, who said "here you are, we've been looking for you everywhere", which seemed strange. Possibly they couldn't see me surrounded by their massive bouncers.

Laura had somehow got in, and gave me back my phone. Jeremy was slowly heading for the gates, but he is incapable of being impolite and not having a friendly word with anybody who addresses him, whoever they are. Once we were outside the gates he showed no sign of stopping with the much larger crowd outside, so I said my farewells and headed back to the hotel. My toes had gone very painful again and I was keen for another warm bath.

After the bath I went down to look for some food. I felt exhausted and drained. It was not just the cold night standing in the queue with no sleep, it was the immediately preceding 40 hour, four economy-flight journey from Bali, with virtually no sleep either, to get here. I hadn't been in a bed, I calculated, for 85 hours.

I was also feeling a bit unappreciated. I had in fact played a role in this happening at all. Copies of my initial articles on invoking the Genocide Convention had been physically in front of South African cabinet ministers when they took the initial decision on 8 December to ask their excellent legal services to prepare a case. It was not me that arranged that and I cannot break confidence by telling you how it came about. I didn't expect any acknowledgement, but it seemed an unfair twist of fate that had me standing all night in the cold trying to get in.

I was, dear reader, simply wallowing in exhaustion and self-pity, and in a kind of ridiculous teenage sulk. My tired brain was fogged and I was seriously worried about finding the energy to write up day one, which I had to do immediately. I wasn't sure that my body was physically capable of another night of no sleep and standing in the freezing cold. I was fed up with being in exile over this laughable terrorism investigation, and I was missing my children.

I made up my mind - I could not do another night. I would have to explain to readers that I had done what I could. A great feeling of relief came over me, and I decided to go to bed.

That very second, out of the lift walked the eminent British lawyer Tayab Ali, with a short, unassuming bearded Arab gentleman.

"Hello Craig, how's it going", he asked, but they were evidently in a hurry, going somewhere: "This is Ghassan".

We shook hands briefly and then the realisation struck me.

"Are you the surgeon?"

Ghassan looked diffident, slightly abashed.

"The surgeon from Gaza?".

"Yes, I am Ghassan Abu Sitta."

"I am honoured, sir. Greatly honoured".

He looked slightly embarrassed, and they dashed off to their meeting.
Ghassan Abu SItta
Dr. Ghassan Abu SItta in Gaza
I felt even more embarrassed. I had just met the man who had stayed operating in Shifa hospital while Israel bombs and missiles struck it and Israeli snipers fired through the windows. He had continued to operate with no electricity, with no bandages, with no antiseptic, with no anaesthetic. He had worked 20 hours a day, amputating the limbs of children or trying to piece them back together. He stayed and stayed and stayed through weeks under fire. He did this for love: he is a top British plastic surgeon and could have been in the UK making millions.

I felt deeply ashamed. This man had endured so much, and done so much, and seen so much suffering. Here was I giving up over sore toes and lack of sleep, and over wanting to be important. I had an epiphany; I realised I can be a dreadful egoist, and I hated myself for it. Nothing stopped hurting, but I had a new surge of adrenaline and decided to get on with it. Perhaps nothing I did would help prevent genocide, but we all have to do that which is within our power to try.

I accept you may wish to scoff, but for me that encounter with Mr Abu Sitta revealed an important element of greatness - the ability to inspire others to do more that they believed they could, to transmit will. Even without actually saying anything.

I did, however, retain the sense to know that I had to prepare, so I got a taxi to a camping shop. There I bought the warmest sleeping bag I could afford, a reflective groundsheet, thermal socks and a flask.

I then took a taxi back, went straight to my room and started to write. The first three paragraphs flowed very easily. Then suddenly I was opening my very groggy eyes with my head on the keyboard, not sideways but leaning on my forehead. I had been asleep like that for three hours.

After that it was like wading through treacle. The phrases still rushed into my head as always, but there was a strange disconnect to my fingers and what they typed, which often was a phrase that sounded a bit like the one I was trying to get down. I recall typing "to assist them" as "his big cyst hen". It was slow going.

At 11pm I went to see if there was a queue yet for the public gallery the next day. Nobody was there. I was worried that after the arguments at the gate the previous morning, with many people disappointed, the queue would start to form much earlier for Day 2. I decided to just publish what I had written so far, with an explanatory first paragraph, and check the queue regularly. The cold walk woke me up. It was notably warmer than the previous night - plus 2 rather than minus 5 - but the ground was all wet with a heavy dew and there was a lot more wind chill.

I checked again at 1.30am, still nobody had come. But at 3am there were eight people in the queue. I rushed back to the hotel, picked up my sleeping bag and groundsheet and published the now almost finished Day 1 article. I joined the queue as number 9 of the 14 who would be let in. I met a wonderful Dutch lady who had joined the queue with the intention of giving me her place if I arrived too late. I am ashamed to say I forget her name.

I was disappointed that not one of my new friends from the previous night's queue was there again. I felt we had bonded through a pretty tough experience and a mutual cause. Almost all had said they intended to do both nights, and I presume the cold and exhaustion just got to people. This second night was much more jolly, I think because it was not quite so cold.

The reflective groundsheet was a big success, dry and surprisingly effective at stopping the cold seeping up. The mummy sleeping bag proved more of a problem. I am not as slender as I used to be, and with several layers of clothing and my ski jacket all on, it was a very tight fit. I got the zip up pretty well, but I couldn't do the last bit that would bring the cowl over my head, not least because by that stage the bag had immobilised my arms.

Thankfully several wonderful young ladies came to help and zipped me up tight. This involved a lot of laughing. We could have invented a whole new genre of internet porn, in which fully clothed old men get zipped into bags. Although it probably already exists. I am not going to google for it, given the frequency with which the security services seize or steal my electronic devices. It might be misunderstood.

craig murray sleeping bag ICJ
Journalist Craig Murry camping out in front of the International Court of Justice
So at 3.30am I lay down my head, and did in fact sleep until about 5.30am. It was not comfortable, but it was not cold. I then wandered off to find a bush for a pee. When I returned, three women had taken over my groundsheet and were using my sleeping bag as a blanket. They joked that they had occupied my sleeping bag. I said I perfectly understood - surely their ancestors had a sleeping bag there 3,000 years ago. It was not brilliant repartee, but this kind of thing kept us going. The 14 of us who made the public gallery took group pictures.

Craig Murry obsevers International court of justice israel
Journalist Craig Murray and others who obtained seats in the public gallery of the International Court of Justice.
There were some changes from the day before. We are to be allowed pens. But in view of "people wandering around" the day before, they said huffily, we were to be escorted in via a back door and leave the same way, and strictly forbidden from talking or interacting with anybody not in our group. So we entered the tiny public gallery. It has only two rows, and I now discovered that if you sit in the second row you cannot see anything. From the hall you can't even tell there is a second row to the gallery. Once again, I marveled at the lack of attention to the dreadful design of the courtroom.
gallery international court of justice
View of the public gallery in the International Court of Justice
Luckily for me, a young man who apparently should not have been there was ejected from a front row seat, and finally I got to watch the Israeli presentation.

(continue above)



Yoda

Best of the Web: Craig Murray: Observations on the first day of proceedings of the International Court of Justice

international court of justice hall
The International Court of Justice chambers
[...]

I have written of my faith in the International Court of Justice, in its history of impartial judgment and in its system of election by the UN General Assembly. The ICJ has rather unfairly been tarnished by the reputation of its much younger sister the International Criminal Court. The ICC is rightly derided as a Western tool, but that really is not true of the ICJ. On Palestine alone, it has ruled that the Israeli "wall" in the West Bank is illegal and that Israel has no right of self-defence in the territory of which it is the occupying power. It ruled that the UK must decolonise the Chagos Islands, a cause close to my own heart.

There was every reason for those of us opposing the genocide to have travelled hopefully to the Hague.

In addition to the normal fifteen judges of the court, each of the parties to the dispute - South Africa and Israel - had exercised their right to nominate an additional judge. After the judges filed in to the court, proceedings started with these two judges taking an oath of impartiality, which gave us the first Israeli lie of the case before it had even started.

Arrow Up

Americans identifying as Democrat hits record low at 27%

US president Joe Biden speaks to the press before flying to Camp David, on the south lawn of the White House on 13 January 2024 in Washington DC.
© Samuel Corum/Getty ImagesUS president Joe Biden speaks to the press before flying to Camp David, on the south lawn of the White House on 13 January 2024 in Washington DC.
A Gallup poll released on Friday reveals that a record low percentage of Americans who identify as Democrats in 2023 hit a record low, when independent 'leaners' are excluded.

Just 27% of Americans self-identify as Democrats, the smallest figure in the party's history according to the survey. That said, self-identifying Republicans also hit 27%, though it did not mark the lowest figure in the party's history - which was in 2013 when just 25% of Americans identified as such. The previous low for Democrats was in 2017 and 2015 at 29%.

Independents, meanwhile, take the cake - with 43% of Americans identifying as such.

Comment: The political party paradigm seems to be, mostly, a false dichotomy, because, ultimately, at this point of ponerogenisis, apart from a few brave, principled outliers - like Trump in the US, and Corbyn in the UK - most parties and their leadership further the same establishment agenda. And that's before even factoring in vote rigging...

At the same time, the sudden loss of support for the Democrats perhaps reflects just how galvanizing US support for Israel's Gaza genocide, under Biden, has been:


Attention

The homeless camps' disease trifecta

street encampment
© Valerie Macon/AFP/Getty ImagesActivists help protect homeless from being displaced by street cleaning and power washing from the Los Angeles sanitation service in Hollywood, California • February, 2021
The Portland, Oregon, area is currently experiencing an explosion of shigellosis, a highly infectious, often antibiotic-resistant intestinal disease caused by contact with human feces.

Most of the outbreak — at least 218 cases in 2023, 45 of them reported in December — has taken place in Old Town, a once-lively restaurant and shopping destination near downtown Portland that's now the site of numerous homeless encampments whose residents often use sidewalks as restrooms.

The Portland City Council, alarmed at a surge in the area's homeless population, now estimated at about 6,000, in June 2023 passed severe restrictions on camping in public places. Tents and campsites are now technically banned during daytime hours and limited to certain designated areas at night. But no one in famously progressive Portland tried to enforce the legislation until the fall, when this latest infestation of shigella bacteria (there had been a similar outbreak among the homeless in 2021) began to generate headlines.

Comment: The legal system is another vector to eliminate population.


Cow

Zuckerberg beefs up again: Billionaire raising prime cows on island retreat


Comment: Well, at least he's setting a good example, for once...


Wagyu cattle
© Getty Images / PA / Jens BüttnerWagyu cattle
Meta founder, Chairman and CEO, Mark Zuckerberg, has announced that he has become a rancher. The billionaire revealed his new passion project in an Instagram post on Wednesday, to a typically mixed reaction.

Zuckerberg said he has begun raising cattle at his Ko'olau Raunch, a multi-million-dollar compound in Kauai, Hawaii, in order to create "some of the highest quality beef in the world." The billionaire said he will breed wagyu and angus cows, feeding them macadamia nuts and beer produced at the ranch.

"We want the whole process to be local and vertically integrated. Each cow eats 5,000 - 10,000 pounds of food each year, so that's a lot of acres of macadamia trees," Zuckerberg wrote, sharing photos of his daughters planting trees at the property.

Comment: Zuckerborg goes off script, is there an error in his programming?


Car Black

Ukraine conflict prompts steep drop in car thefts in Russia

car thief automobile breakin
Thieves used to sell their illicitly obtained vehicles in Ukraine and the Baltic countries before borders closed, an insurance lobby says

The number of car thefts in Russia dropped sharply in 2023, largely due to the Ukraine conflict, the business daily Kommersant reported on this week, citing data from the Internal Affairs Ministry and the Russian Union of Insurers.

According to the report, over January-November of last year, some 6,580 vehicle thefts were recorded in the country, a 22.9% drop against 2022. While the total number of car thefts has been dropping for several years, experts noted that the decline was especially significant in 2023.

Igloo

Threat of rolling blackouts announced amid record cold in Canada, residents told to reduce power usage

cold canada
The extreme cold drove up demand on the power grid prompting Alberta's energy operator to declare a grid alert. Sarah Offin reports.

A critical emergency alert was issued on Saturday evening urging Albertans to reduce electricity use to minimize potential outages across the province.

In an alert sent at around 6:36 p.m., the Alberta Electric System Operator (AESO) said extreme cold is resulting in high power demand across the province, which places the electricity grid at a high risk of rotating power outages.


Comment: Indeed, in the year of global boiling, record cold is putting a strain on systems across the northern Hemisphere. However, it's not just Earth Changes that are responsible here, Western governments have brought these energy and infrastructure issues about through their deindustrialisation 'green' agenda.


Comment: Much of the West is at increasing risk of rolling blackouts:


Recycle

Electric buses withdrawn in south London after TWO burst into flames in 48hours

electric bus fire
© X/RodCam24The Met declared a critical incident following the blaze on Thursday
A fleet of electric buses have been withdrawn in south London after a double-decker caught fire on Thursday.

The fire started during the morning rush hour in Wimbledon and the electric bus was quickly evacuated.

Transport for London (TfL) said electric buses on route 200, which runs between Raynes Park and Mitcham, had been removed from service "as a precaution".

Another bus caught fire on Friday, which TfL said was "unrelated".


Comment: As you will read below it was also an electric bus.


Comment: Meanwhile over in the US: Reality hits: Hertz is selling 20,000 electric vehicles to buy gasoline cars instead

And Norway: Electric bus fleet froze in the cold


Ice Cube

And so it begins: Israel's ice hockey teams barred from world championship events over safety concerns

israel hockey team
© Getty ImagesIsrael's men's team were set to play in Division Two of the world championships in April.
The International Ice Hockey Federation has barred Israel from competing in its world championship events.

In a statement on Wednesday, the IIHF said the decision was made for the "safety and security of all participants".

There was no mention of the ongoing Israel-Hamas war in the statement.

Comment: It looks like we might be seeing Israel start to get the 'Russia treatment' in international events. It's highly doubtful, however, that Israel will react as magnanimously as Russia.

See also:


Info

Trump Jr. condemns Zelensky for US journalist's 'murder'

Donald Trump, Jr.
© AP / Andrew HarnikDonald Trump, Jr. speaks at the Machine Shed in Urbandale, Iowa, Thursday, Jan. 11, 2024.
The ex-US president's son questioned sending aid to a country where American citizens are killed.

The death of journalist and filmmaker Gonzalo Lira is a "murder," and the blame for it lies with Ukrainian President Vladimir Zelensky, the son of former US President Donald Trump stated on his page on the social network X (formerly Twitter).

Gonzalo Lira, a national of the US and Chile, has died while in jail in Ukraine. Lira passed away on January 11, with his family reporting his death the following day. The US Department of State then confirmed it.

Comment: See also: