One of the most well-known surgeons who operates on children under the guise of "gender affirming care" is Dr. Sidhbh Gallagher. She is recognized as both a renegade in her field and a human rights disaster in the making.
Dr. Gallagher is infamous for her social media content, which misguides children into thinking that their bodies are wrong and should consider surgical interventions. Dr. Gallagher recruits adolescent customers by glamorizing the surgical experience. By telling these children that they are born in the wrong body and therefore a member of a marginalized demographic, she is able to convince these kids that they have a gender identity misalignment (that did not exist until they gained access to social media).
The way that activists like Dr. Gallagher talk about "transgender kids'' is similar to how one may talk about racial groups, sexual orientation, populations defined by immutable characteristics, using both quantitative and qualitative data in order to measure characteristics in these populations. "Transgender" does not work the same way. Since gender is socially constructed, the way it manifests in our culture is completely dependent on the way that society views gender norms. Unlike the gay/lesbian population, which is measurable and cross-culturally remains consistent over time, gender-diverse populations manifest based on the sociocultural norms that change over time. It is impossible to define a group of people based on a philosophical belief that has no basis in material reality. Similar to being straight, being LGB is something that you
are. "Trans" is something that you
do, whether that entails pursuing medical intervention or simply going off of self-identification. Two people may undergo medical interventions for
completely unrelated reasons and barely have anything in common. A middle-aged male who pursues this treatment due to autogynephilic transvestism has a completely different reality and experience than a teenage girl on the autism spectrum who is unsure of their identity. In Iran, gay men are forced to undergo these procedures as a way to "convert" them, turning gay men into a transsexually-constructed medical victims, whose culture could not stand the fact that some men are more feminine and not interested in women. What we refer to as "transgender" takes different forms depending on societal context - it is currently being forced upon children. In actuality, "transgender" is a sociopolitical/ideological term that is attributed to various groups of people, based on the notion that their biological sex is irrelevant to their human existence. This creates a lot of confusion,
especially when it comes to children. Perhaps the first mistake was turning a clinically-defined population into an identity group in the first place.
Comment: Recruiting criminal prisoners is at best a gamble: