Society's Child
An unelected all-male council from a village in India's Baghpat district handed down the ruling on July 30, ordering Meenakshi Kumari, 23, and her sister, 15, to be raped as well as paraded naked with blackened faces.
The council deemed this an appropriate punishment for their brother's elopement with a married woman from the higher Jat caste. The brother, known as Ravi, is reportedly from the Dalit caste, which is India's lowest, formerly known as the "untouchables." He ran away with his beloved despite fears of retribution.
"Nothing could justify this abhorrent punishment. It's not fair. It's not right. And it's against the law. Demand that the local authorities intervene immediately," Amnesty International said, calling on people worldwide to sign their petition to persuade the Indian government to intervene.
Fearing for their safety, both sisters fled their village along with their family back in May. Their house was looted soon thereafter.
The Jat caste is very powerful in the village, Amnesty quoted Sumit Kumar, another of Meenaksh's brothers, as saying. "The Jat decision is final."
Amnesty UK's Urgent Action Coordinator, Rachel Alcock, told the Mirror that such "disgusting" punishments are common in the villages all over India. "These Khap courts routinely order vile sexually violent punishments against women. India's Supreme Court has rightly declared such orders illegal."
The Supreme Court has labeled such local councils "kangaroo courts" and branded their decisions as illegal. However, this has not halted such local trials in various states.
Meenakshi has filed a petition with the Supreme Court, asking for protection. Harassment complaints have also been launched against locals and the police from her village.
As for the supposedly runaway lovers, there have been conflicting reports over their whereabouts and whether the woman consented to elope.
According to Amnesty's version of events, there are concerns over the safety of Ravi's lover. Zee Media reported that the couple were allegedly in love with each other prior to the woman's marriage. After she was married to another man in February, she reportedly fled and eloped with Ravi in March.
The Times of India says the runaway couple "had to return, due to pressure from the girl's family and the UP [Uttar Pradesh] police," citing the text of Meenakshi's petition. The petition reportedly claimed that the "elopement invited the wrath of the Jat community and UP Police and as a retaliatory measure her family members were abducted and tortured by police."
Meenakshi's brother was allegedly accused in "a false narcotics case" and arrested.
According to the New Indian Express, the couple was found in the city of Meerut, two months after they eloped, and the woman accused Ravi of abducting her. Local police denied the existence of a council "diktat" altogether, saying that the man has been jailed in Meerut, awaiting trial on charges of abducting a married woman.
The widespread problem of rape in Indian society was brought into the global spotlight in December 2012, when a brutal gang rape case in Delhi prompted thousands of people to protest in the streets and hold candlelight vigils. Six men, including one underage teenager, took part in the horrific attack, raping and killing a 23-year-old physiotherapy student. Four adult attackers were eventually sentenced to hang, while one hanged himself in prison. The court, however, has stayed the executions to allow for appeals.
The public outcry persuaded the Indian government to double prison terms for rapists to 20 years. New legislation was also introduced, making it a crime for police officers to refuse to open cases when allegations of rape are made.
The National Crime Records Bureau estimated that one woman gets raped every 22 minutes in India. In May 2014, two teenage cousins were gang-raped and murdered in the small village of Katra Shahadatganj, in Uttar Pradesh.
Comment: There is a psychological theory that can explain why this conscienceless judge thinks that rape as a form of punishment is appropriate. From Political Ponerology, p. 119:
Any human group affected by the process described herein is characterized by its increasing regression from natural common sense and the ability to perceive psychological reality. Someone considering this in terms of traditional categories might consider it an instance of "turning into half-wits" or the development of intellectual deficiencies and moral failings. A ponerological analysis of this process, however, indicates that pressure is being applied to the more normal part of the association by pathological factors present in certain individuals who have been allowed to participate in the group because the lack of good psychological knowledge has not mandated their exclusion.See also:
Thus whenever we observe some group member being treated with no critical distance, although he betrays one of the psychological anomalies familiar to us, and his opinions being treated as at least equal to those of normal people, although they are based on characteristically different view of human matters, we must derive the conclusion that this human group is affected by a ponerogenic process and if measures are not taken the process shall continue to its logical conclusion.
We shall treat this in accordance with the above described first criterion of ponerology, which retains its validity regardless of the qualitative and quantitative features of such a union: the atrophy of natural critical facilities with respect to pathological individuals becomes an opening to their activities, and, at the same time, a criterion for recognizing the association in concern as ponerogenic.
Such a state of affairs simultaneously consists as a liminal (watershed) situation, whereupon further damage to people's healthy common sense and critical moral faculties becomes even easier. Once a group has inhaled a sufficient dose of pathological material to give birth to the conviction that these not-quite-normal people are unique geniuses, it starts subjecting its more normal members to pressure characterized by corresponding paralogical and paramoral elements.
- Psychopath alert: 'If you can't prevent rape, you enjoy it,' says India's top police official
- Psychopaths in our midst: Indian politician beaten by villagers after 'entering a woman's home and raping her at 2am'
Well I was just reading a bunch of posting from the Times of India about gun violence in America and they all thought that that American should be disarmed, but then again I think every post was from a man, so I guess that would work out well for that culture of fools.
Good Lord...and yet, while our great leaders whom could do something sit and evidently do nothing.