Russian woman protesting decriminalization of domestic violence in front of Russia’s state parliament building holds a sign with a famous quote from Russian literature about a father who kills his son: "'I gave you life, and it is mine to take.' 11,756 boys and girls subjected to domestic violence in 2015.”
On Tuesday Russian think tank Public Opinion Endowment released the results of the poll on attitudes to the decriminalization of domestic violence. The poll revealed that 55 percent of Russians think that the law should list domestic violence as a criminal offense.
Some 25 percent of poll participants said that they supported the recent decriminalization of domestic violence (it still remains a civil offense and is punishable by fines or civil arrest). A total of 21 percent of respondents could not answer the question directly.
In the same poll 79 percent of participants said that domestic violence cannot be justified and 11 percent said it was entirely dependant on the situation. Some 10 percent of respondents could not give an unambiguous answer to the question.
When researchers asked Russians how common they believed it was for families to face domestic violence, 42 percent said that domestic violence took place in the minority of Russian homes. Some 24 percent think that the majority of Russian families face domestic violence, at least from time to time, and 19 percent found the question too difficult to answer.
Russia decriminalized 'first-time' domestic violence in February 2017. The sponsors of the motion justified the move by explaining how a legal inconsistency had arisen several months earlier: starting in mid-2016, first-time attacks on people who were not family members or relatives were no longer treated under the criminal code, but the civil code. The situation with first-time attacks on family members remained unchanged - potentially leading to a situation where parents could, theoretically at least, assault their children with impunity, while complete strangers could not.
Still the decriminalization sparked staunch opposition in the mass media and on social networks, as well as concerned statements from abroad. Russian lawmakers had responded to the criticism by saying they were motivated by the opinions of their voters and public opinion polls, which at the time had shown that the majority of Russians support the idea.
A year after the changes came into force, the head of Russia's Central Investigative Committee said that the number of crimes against women and children had increased and suggested that there may be a link.
Comment: Perhaps the increase in crimes is simply that more are being reported now that the law has changed:
What Russian legislators realized is that people don't like sending family members to prison and that police, who in many parts of Russia are not particularly attentive, had no incentive to investigate whether Vlad hit his son or not, if it was reported at all, which returns us to our first point. The fine creates an incentive for police to respond to reports as well as encourages more reports. A win-win.
Is this really that hard to understand? The law was meant to encourage better enforcement of domestic violence laws in an attempt to - wait for it - decrease domestic violence. What a novel concept, right?
And guess what? The law is working! More women are reporting first-offense or minor cases of abuse, and the police are responding to the complaints. This is a GOOD THING.
Reader Comments
to our Newsletter