Society's Child
I dragged myself out of bed and opened my laptop. A few hours earlier, someone going by the username "headlessfemalepig" had sent me seven tweets. "I see you are physically not very attractive. Figured," the first said. Then: "You suck a lot of drunk and drug f****** guys c****." As a female journalist who writes about sex (among other things), none of this feedback was particularly out of the ordinary. But this guy took it to another level: "I am 36 years old, I did 12 years for 'manslaughter', I killed a woman, like you, who decided to make fun of guys c****." And then: "Happy to say we live in the same state. Im looking you up, and when I find you, im going to rape you and remove your head." There was more, but the final tweet summed it up: "You are going to die and I am the one who is going to kill you. I promise you this."
My fingers paused over the keyboard. I felt disoriented and terrified. Then embarrassed for being scared, and, finally, pissed. On the one hand, it seemed unlikely that I'd soon be defiled and decapitated at the hands of a serial rapist-murderer. On the other hand, headlessfemalepig was clearly a deranged individual with a bizarre fixation on me. I picked up my phone and dialed 911.
Two hours later, a Palm Springs police officer lumbered up the steps to my hotel room, paused on the outdoor threshold, and began questioning me in a steady clip. I wheeled through the relevant background information: I am a journalist; I live in Los Angeles; sometimes, people don't like what I write about women, relationships, or sexuality; this was not the first time that someone had responded to my work by threatening to rape and kill me. The cop anchored his hands on his belt, looked me in the eye, and said, "What is Twitter?"
Staring up at him in the blazing sun, the best answer I could come up with was, "It's like an e-mail, but it's public." What I didn't articulate is that Twitter is the place where I laugh, whine, work, schmooze, procrastinate, and flirt. It sits in my back pocket wherever I go and lies next to me when I fall asleep. And since I first started writing in 2007, it's become just one of the many online spaces where men come to tell me to get out.
The examples are too numerous to recount, but like any good journalist, I keep a running file documenting the most deranged cases. There was the local cable viewer who hunted down my email address after a television appearance to tell me I was "the ugliest woman he had ever seen." And the group of visitors to a "men's rights" site who pored over photographs of me and a prominent feminist activist, then discussed how they'd "spend the night with" us. ("Put em both in a gimp mask and tied to each other 69 so the b*****s can't talk or move and go round the world, any old port in a storm, any old hole," one decided.) And the anonymous commenter who weighed in on one of my articles: "Amanda, I'll f***ing rape you. How does that feel?"
None of this makes me exceptional. It just makes me a woman with an Internet connection. Here's just a sampling of the noxious online commentary directed at other women in recent years. To Alyssa Royse, a sex and relationships blogger, for saying that she hated The Dark Knight: "you are clearly retarded, i hope someone shoots then rapes you." To Kathy Sierra, a technology writer, for blogging about software, coding, and design: "i hope someone slits your throat and c**s down your gob." To Lindy West, a writer at the women's website Jezebel, for critiquing a comedian's rape joke: "I just want to rape her with a traffic cone." To Rebecca Watson, an atheist commentator, for blogging about sexism in the skeptic community: "If I lived in Boston I'd put a bullet in your brain." To Catherine Mayer, a journalist at Time magazine, for no particular reason: "A BOMB HAS BEEN PLACED OUTSIDE YOUR HOME. IT WILL GO OFF AT EXACTLY 10:47 PM ON A TIMER AND TRIGGER DESTROYING EVERYTHING."
A woman doesn't even need to occupy a professional writing perch at a prominent platform to become a target. According to a 2005 report by the Pew Research Center, which has been tracking the online lives of Americans for more than a decade, women and men have been logging on in equal numbers since 2000, but the vilest communications are still disproportionately lobbed at women. We are more likely to report being stalked and harassed on the Internet - of the 3,787 people who reported harassing incidents from 2000 to 2012 to the volunteer organization Working to Halt Online Abuse, 72.5 percent were female. Sometimes, the abuse can get physical: A Pew survey reported that five percent of women who used the Internet said "something happened online" that led them into "physical danger." And it starts young: Teenage girls are significantly more likely to be cyberbullied than boys. Just appearing as a woman online, it seems, can be enough to inspire abuse. In 2006, researchers from the University of Maryland set up a bunch of fake online accounts and then dispatched them into chat rooms. Accounts with feminine usernames incurred an average of 100 sexually explicit or threatening messages a day. Masculine names received 3.7.
There are three federal laws that apply to cyberstalking cases; the first was passed in 1934 to address harassment through the mail, via telegram, and over the telephone, six decades after Alexander Graham Bell's invention. Since the initial passage of the Violence Against Women Act, in 1994, amendments to the law have gradually updated it to apply to new technologies and to stiffen penalties against those who use them to abuse. Thirty-four states have cyberstalking laws on the books; most have expanded long-standing laws against stalking and criminal threats to prosecute crimes carried out online.
But making quick and sick threats has become so easy that many say the abuse has proliferated to the point of meaninglessness, and that expressing alarm is foolish. Reporters who take death threats seriously "often give the impression that this is some kind of shocking event for which we should pity the 'victims,'" my colleague Jim Pagels wrote in Slate this fall, "but anyone who's spent 10 minutes online knows that these assertions are entirely toothless." On Twitter, he added, "When there's no precedent for physical harm, it's only baseless fear mongering." My friend Jen Doll wrote, at The Atlantic Wire, "It seems like that old 'ignoring' tactic your mom taught you could work out to everyone's benefit.... These people are bullying, or hope to bully. Which means we shouldn't take the bait." In the epilogue to her book The End of Men, Hanna Rosin - an editor at Slate - argued that harassment of women online could be seen as a cause for celebration. It shows just how far we've come. Many women on the Internet "are in positions of influence, widely published and widely read; if they sniff out misogyny, I have no doubt they will gleefully skewer the responsible sexist in one of many available online outlets, and get results."
So women who are harassed online are expected to either get over ourselves or feel flattered in response to the threats made against us. We have the choice to keep quiet or respond "gleefully."
But no matter how hard we attempt to ignore it, this type of gendered harassment - and the sheer volume of it - has severe implications for women's status on the Internet. Threats of rape, death, and stalking can overpower our emotional bandwidth, take up our time, and cost us money through legal fees, online protection services, and missed wages. I've spent countless hours over the past four years logging the online activity of one particularly committed cyberstalker, just in case. And as the Internet becomes increasingly central to the human experience, the ability of women to live and work freely online will be shaped, and too often limited, by the technology companies that host these threats, the constellation of local and federal law enforcement officers who investigate them, and the popular commentators who dismiss them - all arenas that remain dominated by men, many of whom have little personal understanding of what women face online every day.
Reader Comments
Why wander I know just what you're talking about. Any women would, that is any woman who has managed to step out of the gender conditioning and actually see it; or, can face the traumatic reality. Unfortunately though this takes time and by the time you do manage to see what's going on you're middle age and your life opportunities and purpose have passed you by; you work it all out when it's too late. Then you're just in shock, left wondering - why? How can they be so cruel. Such is my experience anyhow.
Many-a-time I have sat there in a situation that was plain surreal, like I didn't exist and yes, sometimes they ask you a question, you go and answer and purposely are cut out. It's vicious and often done in a collective group, ie, when there is a group of men.
Strange world... why would they bother to be so mean.
got cutoff there.
2) ND has the most fundamentalist nutter abortion laws in the country. This coincides with Williston ND being the rape capital of the US (mostly due to oil boom and pushed under the rug). It is also a known but concealed fact that, ND has had a very long term and severe problem with familial molestation, according to one social worker I spoke with, possibly the highest in the country. Also ND has been rated #2 in the nation in the past for sexism based on stats involving violence on women, unequal pay etc. These problems were endemic way before the oil boom and are local in nature. The result of these combinations: if you are raped by a stranger or molested by your father and have plans on running to another state to abort a forced, possibly mongloid or STD infected rape pregnancy, you could be arrested strapped down for 8 months and forced to have the child.
This is just the beginning. I could go on forever. If you are female stay the heck out of ND. If your from here and don't notice a problem.... maybe you should get out for awhile.
I have been up against sexism and male/female bullying many times as a woman who started working in male-dominated trades and professions in the 70s (when it was really overt) and was completely flabbergasted when it reared it's ugly head again in the early 2000s.
Really, not much has changed with the prevailing attitudes, it seems, towards women....and women who are independent professionals tend to get the brunt of it, many times. Let's face it, men dominated the workforce for decades and many are resentful and feel threatened by women like me.
Add to that the illusion the internet has of relative anonymity and it provides the perfect breeding ground for these trolls, stalkers and other repressed/depressed types to vent.
And it's not just the sheeple males...among the (male dominated) alternative news sources I follow my comments frequently responded to by males (mostly younger) who post all kinds of insulting comments about everything from my lack of grey matter to my lack of looks.
I feel like saying "I'm freaking 55 dude and I was working at a career and raising a son on my own when your momma and daddy still had braces and pimples!"
But instead I refuse to respond....to do so only feeds the beast. I treat any immature child, throwing a tantrum or behaving badly the same way: I ignore him.
That being said, here is a lot of fear and frustration out there right now and most men have not had any good role models to help them develop emotional intelligence. Really, blame the mother's if you wanna blame someone...for not being firm enough and nipping that bad behavior in the bed.
But really, our culture likes to find someone to "blame" when things get tough. Blame the terrorists. Blame the government. Blame your parents. Blame the Mexicans. Blame the poor. Blame the rich.
Blame those damned, uppity women who have the audacity to think they can make their way through life w/o depending upon a man for support.
freudian slip about "nipping that bad behavior in the bud." i meant "bud" but "bed" has some meaning too...
I was really surprised during this episode to see good men lie for him and side with the bully gang. I have also noticed at other jobs that many men will be nice to me one on one then when the group is around turn the other way. It seems there is definitely a group dynamic to their behavior. I find it all incredibly cowardly.
I am proud of Amanda for being so courageous. I can't claim the same courage because I know what she is truly up against. This country is becoming less and less friendly to women, I almost want to leave myself, not sure if the grass is greener on the other side or not. Here in ND women seem to be hated by a good portion of the male population and relegated to child status in the local society as a whole. Locals rarely have lived in other areas and tend not to notice but women and men from other areas notice very quickly. As a woman in a high paying skilled labor job I have had quite a few issues, see most of the other females where I have worked are scrubbing toilets and floors. It seems I have lost my place. I wonder constantly what kind of background makes some men so insecure and angry towards women.
In ND as a single woman this is what you can expect: 1) If you speak around men you will often be ignored and talked over as if you don't exist or are invisible. Sometimes you will be asked questions and then ignored as you respond because they want to make sure you know you do not matter and your thoughts are not respected.