Lauren Irwin
The HillThu, 24 Apr 2025 03:29 UTC

© Misty DropeA home damaged by tornadoes in March in Arkansas.
Arkansas is appealing the Trump administration's denial of federal aid for the state's recovery efforts after a string of deadly and destructive tornado storms.
Gov. Sarah Huckabee Sanders (R-Ark.) requested help for people who were impacted by the mid-March tornadoes, some of the state's worst since 1997.The Trump administration denied Sanders's request for funding through the
Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA). She wrote again to Trump to
appeal the denial.
In a letter, signed by both Arkansas senators and its four representatives, the lawmakers asked Trump to reconsider.
"As Governor Sanders noted in her request, these storms caused catastrophic damage across the state, resulting in disastrous amounts of debris, widespread destruction to homes and businesses, the deaths of three Arkansans, and injuries to many more."
They noted that just weeks later, the state was hit with
another round of severe storms, including a "generational flood event" that compounded damage for many of the same counties and included three more deaths.
The lawmakers said:
"Given the cumulative impact and sheer magnitude of destruction from these severe weather events, federal assistance is vital to ensure that state and local communities have the capabilities needed to rebuild. The entire Arkansas delegation is eager to assist in any way possible to ensure the expedited evaluation of these requests."
The Arkansas delegation said a preliminary assessment of damage had an
estimated cost of $8.8 million and asked that Sanders's request for a 30-day extension on submitting a disaster declaration be granted. The state needs additional time to conduct analysis on the damage in 63 of its 75 counties, they said.
The denial comes as the Trump administration has criticized the agency and its efforts. The president has long critiqued the agency, including on the campaign trail and his
first few days back in office.
Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem said in late March that she has
plans to "eliminate" FEMA, which Trump said was "great." In January, the president said he would sign an executive order to fundamentally reform and overhaul the agency or consider getting rid of it all together.
In another Arkansas request to the administration for aid, Sanders said the help is "crucial" to her state's rebuilding process.
"I am formally appealing the denial of Individual Assistance," she wrote in a letter to Trump. "I respectfully ask that you consider the significant strain the citizens of Arkansas have endured over the past month."
Comment: Based on the FEMA non-response to North Carolina's hurricane, it is not without reason its 'service' is in elimination. President Trump and First Lady Melania saw first-hand the magnitude of disaster and FEMA's lack of commitment to fulfill its purpose. Replacement assistance is critical as emergencies increase in numbers and magnitude.
More from the
Arkansas Advocate:
Brian Hughes, a spokesman for the National Security Council, which advises the president on issues of national security, said:
"The Federal Government focuses its support on truly catastrophic disasters — massive hurricanes, devastating earthquakes, or wide-scale attacks on the homeland. State and local governments often remain an impediment to their own community's resilience."
Hughes called on states to take on a more extensive role:
"States must have adequate emergency management staff, adoption and enforcement of modern building codes, responsible planning and strategic investment to reduce future risk, commonsense policies that prioritize preparedness over politics, disaster reserve funds to handle what should be routine emergencies, pre-negotiated mutual aid and contingency contracts that speed up recovery, and above all, an appetite to own the problem."
Hughes said Trump has promptly authorized "life-saving emergency support to states during and in the immediate aftermath of disasters."
Michael Coen, who served as chief of staff at FEMA during the Obama and Biden administrations, said:
"The president has 'broad discretion' to approve or deny disaster requests, regardless of whether they meet specified conditions. If Trump intends to curtail federal support, he should give states clear guidelines if they're expected to build emergency management programs to take on what the feds once handled. Not all states have the capacity to replicate those functions. And disasters are expected to increase in frequency and severity because of climate change."
Meanwhile, FEMA has said it will no longer match 100% of North Carolina's spending to recover from September's Hurricane Helene. Democratic Gov. Josh Stein said the cost share was crucial to the state's efforts to rebuild. FEMA should give states a clear outline of the role it will play.
"The need in western North Carolina remains immense — people need debris removed, homes rebuilt, and roads restored. I am extremely disappointed and urge the President to reconsider FEMA's bad decision, even for 90 days."
See also:
Comment: Based on the FEMA non-response to North Carolina's hurricane, it is not without reason its 'service' is in elimination. President Trump and First Lady Melania saw first-hand the magnitude of disaster and FEMA's lack of commitment to fulfill its purpose. Replacement assistance is critical as emergencies increase in numbers and magnitude.
More from the Arkansas Advocate: See also: