© Jerod MacDonald-Evoy/Arizona MirrorElection ballots for audit.
Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Christopher Coury ruled that the audit must halt from 5 p.m. Friday to noon on Monday. But that order was contingent on the Arizona Democratic Party, which brought the lawsuit seeking to block the audit, posting a $1 million bond to cover any expenses that the Senate wrongfully incurs due to the delay. The Senate's lease of Veterans Memorial Coliseum, where the audit is being conducted, ends on May 14.
Roopali Desai, the Democrats' attorney, said the party won't put up the bond. That means the audit will continue uninterrupted.
Nonetheless, the audit will still have to comply with several other orders Coury issued during a hearing on Friday.
The judge ordered the Senate and its audit team to comply with all laws governing the right to a secret ballot and the confidentiality of voter registration data, and to provide copies of all relevant policies and procedures to the court, which the audit team has never made public. He also ordered that the auditors use only red pens on the audit floor, an issue that came up after an Arizona Republic reporter who's working as a volunteer observer noted that the auditors were using blue pens.
State election rules require that only red pens be used near ballots because the tabulation machines that are used to count them will read any markings made in blue or black ink.
In a lawsuit filed Thursday afternoon, the Democratic Party and Maricopa County Supervisor Steve Gallardo alleged that the audit was unlawful because the Senate and its contractors were violating various laws regarding the confidentiality of ballots and voter registration data, and had failed to abide by other requirements on election procedures.
Attorney Kory Langhofer, who represents the Senate, argued that the lawsuit should be barred by lawmakers' legislative immunity from being served with lawsuits during the legislative session. He also argued that the Democratic Party and Gallardo lack standing to sue, and that the lawsuit violates the separation of powers between the legislative and judicial branches.
Langhofer told the Arizona Mirror that the Senate will still appeal the ruling to defend lawmakers' right to legislative immunity during the session. A hearing with a duty justice of the Arizona Supreme Court is scheduled for 3 p.m.
Coury ordered the attorneys to file briefings over the weekend on the legislative immunity, separation-of-powers and standing arguments, and will hold another hearing at 11 a.m. Monday.
Desai argued in the lawsuit that, in addition to the laws protecting ballot secrecy and voter registration information, the Senate and its audit team are ignoring other requirements in state statute and the secretary of state's election procedures manual, which has the force of law, that govern other aspects of the election process.
For example, Desai noted in the lawsuit that the manual requires counties to ensure that election workers have training in signature verification, which is used to confirm the identities of voters who cast early ballots. She argued that the Senate's auditors aren't following that requirement.
Langhofer said Cyber Ninjas, the Florida-based cybersecurity company that's leading the Senate's audit team, is contractually bound to follow all applicable state and federal laws, including on issues like the confidentiality of voter data. But not all of the laws that the Democrats cited are relevant, he said.
"A lot of (election procedures manual) procedures they cited just don't apply here," Langhofer said.
The Senate's attorneys also said that the auditors who are counting the 2.1 million ballots from the election in Maricopa County are bound by non-disclosure agreements to keep the information they see confidential, which the Senate and its audit team had never publicly disclosed prior to Friday's court hearing.
About the Author:
Jeremy Duda is an associate editor of the Arizona Mirror, formerly worked for the Capitol Times, where he spent eight years covering the Governor's Office and two years as editor of the Yellow Sheet Report. He also wrote for Hobbs News-Sun and the Daily Herald of Provo, Utah. Jeremy is also the author of the history book If This Be Treason: the American Rogues and Rebels Who Walked the Line Between Dissent and Betrayal.
Reader Comments
to our Newsletter