© forward.com
First, a painful, but needed, clarification:
Basement crazies.
Neocons.
Zionists.
Israel Lobbyists.
Judaics.
Jews.
Somewhere along this list we bump into the proverbial "elephant in the room". For some this bumping will happen earlier in the list, for others a little later down the list, but the list will be more or less the same for everybody. Proper etiquette, as least in the West, would want to make us run away from that topic. I won't. Why? Well, for one thing I am constantly accused of not discussing this elephant. Furthermore,
I am afraid that the role this elephant is playing is particularly toxic right now. So let me try to deal with this beast, but first I have to begin with some caveats.
First, terminology. For those who have not seen it, please read my article
Why I use the term AngloZionist and why it is important. Second, please read my friend Gilad Atzmon's article
Jews, Judaism & Jewishness (or, even better, please read his seminal book
The Wondering Who). Please note that Gilad specifically excludes Judaics (religious Jews,) from his discussion. He writes "I do not deal with Jews as
a race or an
ethnicity. I also generally avoid dealing with Judaism (the religion)". I very much include them in my discussion. However, I also fully agree with Gilad when he writes that
Jews Are Not a Race But Jewish Identity is Racist (those having any doubts about Jews not being a race or ethnicity should read Shlomo Sand's excellent book
The Invention of the Jewish People). Lastly, please carefully review my definition of racism as spelled out in my "
moderation policies":
Racism is, in my opinion, not so much the belief that various human groups are different from each other, say like dog breeds can be different, but the belief that the differences between human groups are larger than within the group. Second, racism is also a belief that the biological characteristics of your group somehow pre-determine your actions/choices/values in life. Third, racism often, but not always, assumes a hierarchy amongst human groups (Germanic Aryans over Slavs or Jews, Jews over Gentiles, etc.). I believe that God created all humans with the same purpose and that we are all "brothers in Adam", that we all equally share the image (eternal and inherent potential for perfection) of God (as opposed to our likeness to Him, which is our temporary and changing individual condition).
To sum it all up, I need to warn both racists and rabid anti-anti-Zionists that I will disappoint them both:
the object of my discussion and criticism below will be limited to categories which a person chooses to belong to or endorse (religion, political ideas, etc.) and not categories which one is born with (race, ethnicity).
Comment: See also: Blackwater Founder Erik Prince is Trump's secret advisor