
© Ukrainian Presidential Press Service/AFPValery Zaluzhny
In his masterpiece, the pre-World War II
'Le fil de l'épée,' a young Charles de Gaulle observes that soldiers and politicians usually can't get along well: They're too different by temperament, socialization, and purpose. And yet the man who would brilliantly succeed at being both a military and a political leader also insisted that,
ultimately, they must cooperate to serve their country. That cooperation is precisely what has just broken down in Ukraine, in the middle of a large war that is going very badly for Kiev.
For, make no mistake, while there are several important aspects (discussed below) to the drawn-out dismissal of Ukraine's commander-in-chief, Valery Zaluzhny,
the fundamental fact remains that it is a story of failure, the failure of a key relationship in any state, but especially one fighting a war it is losing.Zaluzhny, it is important to note, was not a particularly bad commander-in-chief. It is true that Kiev's war effort is failing but there is no good reason to blame him or, at least, him most of all.
He is a mediocre strategist instead of the quiet genius that some
silly Western hype used to depict. Yet,
the causes of Ukraine's current, quite-possibly fatal difficulties on the battlefield in logistics and manpower
are fundamental, not a matter of one less-than-brilliant general. Remember: Once short on clients, soldiers, and supplies, even Napoleon (and Zaluzhny definitely is no Napoleon) was defeated: There are things in war,
especially in a war of attrition, that crushingly outweigh individual talent.
Hence, the ouster of his commander-in-chief is precisely what President Vladimir Zelensky is trying to pretend it is not: a political operation, not a result of level-headed analysis of strategic necessity and a systematic reboot.
Comment: Arnaud Bertrand explains the possible significance of this incident; however, as shown in the response that follows, it's possible that these weren't fishermen: Either way, US provocations in the region make for a very tense situation indeed. However, over many years Russia has repeatedly shown, in the face of brazen attacks by the US, and its proxy Ukraine, that the multipolar world are in it for the long game, and, unlike the desperate West-Israel, they aren't going to throw it all away with rash miscalculations.