
© News Forensics
When was Poland Poland?Recently I wrote an article on the possibility of war between Russia and Poland and I said that Poland had not really existed as a nation until the end of WWI.
One of my contributors correctly pointed out that what we call "Poland" has a long history going back to the Kingdom of Poland in 1035.
For this intelligent commenter, "nation" means one thing; for me — when I wrote my article at least — it means, or meant, another. We are/were
both right — from different perspectives.
For me, history is important. But events in the distant past are of less importance to what is happening today than those most recently. It is the chain of causation that matters. As far as "nations" are concerned — they are all different — and certainly not today as they once were.
The word "nation" comes from the Latin "natio" which means "breed" or "race", not as we define such things
now — but in terms of a world that
in 100 BC was mostly tribal.In other words, the core meaning of "nation" has to do with tribalism, which is very clear when we look at the Polish example.
On the other hand, past history tells us much about human nature, which, of course, can inform us as to
why things happen as they do in the here and now.
Tribalism, for example has not gone way — just transformed.
Comment: Other ancient settlements across Europe, that were situated on similarly wet terrain, even on the bodies of water themselves, seem to point to there being extremely wet periods, in addition to other clues showing defensive measures were of importance, perhaps due to societal unrest:
- Crannogs: Scotland's mysterious ancient artificial islands
- Crannogs: DNA points to elites living on Western Europe's neolithic artificial islands
- Bronze Age Britons were riddled with parasites but had the finest of fabrics
- Surfers ear: Why do Panama's ancient skulls show signs of damage by cold?
Also check out SOTT radio's: