Science & Technology
"It was a rare and impressive event," says Atanackov.
It could easily have been 10 times more impressive. In fact, Earth narrowly dodged a meteor storm.
The European outburst occurred as Earth skirted a filament of debris from Comet 21P/Giacobini-Zinner. If that filament had shifted in our direction by a mere 0.005 AU (~500,000 miles), Earth would have experienced a worldwide storm of 1000+ meteors per hour. These conclusions are based on a computer model of the comet's debris field from the University of Western Ontario's Meteor Physics Group.
Western Ontario postdoctoral researcher Auriane Egal created the model and predicted the outburst before it happened. Egal's model was in good agreement with a rival model from NASA, so confidence was high. Meteors seen over Europe came from the larger filament on the right.
According to the models, Earth's L1 and L2 Lagrange points were both forecast to have storm-level activity--especially L2 which would experience the Earth-equivalent of 4000+ meteors per hour. This prompted NASA to take a close look at the danger to spacecraft.
"The US has four space weather spacecraft at L1: ACE, SOHO, Wind, and DSCOVR," says Bill Cooke of NASA's Meteoroid Environment Office. "There is only one operational spacecraft at L2 - the European Space Agency's GAIA - which was where most of the Draconid activity was expected to take place. GAIA shut down science operations for a few hours around the projected storm peak and re-oriented to turn the hard side of the vehicle towards the incoming debris. All of the spacecraft came through the Draconids without incident, and this shower provided a good test of our ability to forecast meteor activity outside of Earth orbit."
Many readers have wondered if the outburst has anything to do with Comet 21P/Giacobini-Zinner's close approach to Earth last month. "No," says Cooke. "The models show the outburst experienced at Earth was mainly caused by material ejected from the comet from 1945 to the mid 1960's. The meteoroids were more than half a century old."
Reader Comments
Our simulations predict low Draconid activity is expected on Earth, with a maximum of less than a few tens of meteors per hour around midnight the 9th of October, confirming previous model s. At the L1 and L2 Lagrange points, however, the flux estimates suggest a 'meteoroid storm'. The Gaia spacecraft at the L2 region might be able to detect small (~ {mu}g) Draconid meteoroid impacts centered in a two-hour window around 18h30 UT on the 8th of October, 2018.Shock - a "simulations" proven wrong
1955 - no clear correlation between these conditions and the shower intensity was found
1972 - predictions of strong activity, but none occurred
2011 - first successful detailed Draconid prediction
2012 - radar storm occurred ... when no strong storm was expected
In 2018, Earth will be passing just 0.0171 AU (256,000 km) inside the orbit of comet 21P/Giacobini-Zinner on October 9.0, only 22.7 days after the comet itself passed through the same region of space
Simulations confirm that the planet will cross the meteoroid streams through a gap left between the 1946 and 1952 trails
Closest approach will be to the 1953 trail at a distance of 0.00249 AU. Unfortunately, this trail is probably only sparsely populated due to the close encounter with the Earth in 1985.







Comment: We've been relatively lucky up until this point, but there will become a time when the meteor threat will become very real indeed: