© Pascal Le Segretain/Getty Images
I don't know what did or did not happen between Woody Allen and Dylan Farrow more than 20 years ago, and neither does
Nicholas Kristof. What I do know is that Allen is a moral nihilist. This should not be taken as evidence that he sexually molested Mia Farrow's adopted daughter when she was 7 years old, or taken as a sign that he'd condone such behavior. But it does mean he espouses a philosophical outlook that renders him powerless to condemn it.
Let me be clear about two things right off the bat. First, I'm a great admirer of Allen's filmmaking - and like
Andrew Sullivan and
Rod Dreher, I think the artistry of his films can and should be judged apart from his (perhaps substantial) moral failings. Second, I consider nihilism to be a viable, albeit false and ultimately chilling, philosophical and existential position. In describing Allen as a nihilist, I am not issuing an indictment - simply describing an outlook that he has elaborated in several films and interviews over the years.
Allen's most thorough cinematic treatment of nihilism and its moral implications can be found in what may be his greatest film,
Crimes and Misdemeanors (1989). The movie tells the story of an ophthalmologist named Judah Rosenthal (played by Martin Landau) who decides to kill off his lover Dolores (Angelica Houston) when she threatens to divulge their affair to Judah's wife. (Allen's
Match Point (2005), an inferior film in almost every way, explores many similar themes.)
At first wracked with guilt over the murder, Judah eventually gets over his moral qualms. (As another character quips in the film, "comedy is tragedy plus time.") In a shocking subversion of Hollywood-style happy endings as well as Dostoevsky's
Crime and Punishment - in which the character Raskolnikov is driven by unremitting guilt to confess a pair of murders to the authorities - the film ends with Judah seemingly at complete peace with himself and thriving in every way: Happy, wealthy, successful, adored by a beautiful wife and daughter, with the latter soon to be married.
Comment: Lunches seized and tossed in trash at Salt Lake City elementary school for kids with unpaid balances