Best of the Web:


Network

Best of the Web: Wuhan summit between India and China another sign of faltering US global hegemony

xi jinping narendra modi
The anxiety syndrome in the American write-ups on the Wuhan summit is truly tragi-comic. An analyst at the Brookings Institution confidently predicted even before the summit between Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Chinese President Xi Jinping that the event was much ado about nothing. The US government-funded Voice of America in an analysis has now arrived at the same conclusion, after the summit. Why are these American analysts in such tearing hurry to debunk the Wuhan meeting?

It's geopolitics, stupid! The prestigious Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI) released a report today which says amongst other things that India's defence spending rose by 5.5 per cent to US$63.9 billion in 2017, overtaking that of France as one of the world's top five military spenders. The report estimates that one of the main motivations behind India's plans to expand, modernise and enhance the operational capability of its armed forces lies in its tense relations with China.

From the US perspective, the situation is ideal to advance the business interests of America's vendors of weaponry. Last year, business deals worth $15 billion were chalked up. Any improvement in India-China relations will profoundly hurt American interests. Fueling India-China tensions is a major objective of the US' regional strategy.

Blue Planet

Best of the Web: Russia-DPRK-ROK 'peace pipeline' gaining traction thanks to Korean thaw

Moon Jae-in and Vladimir Putin
© Sputnik / Grigoriy Sisoev
The two "peace pipelines" - one carrying Iranian natural gas via Pakistan to India and a second transporting Russian gas via North Korea to South Korea - surfaced as tantalizing ideas roughly a decade ago. They were promptly lampooned as "pipedreams". But the Russia-DPRK-ROK pipeline (RDR) is having the last laugh on its detractors, thanks to the "thaw" on the Korean Peninsula.

The South Korean President Moon Jae-in telephoned Russian President Vladimir Putin on Sunday to personally brief him on the outcome of the inter-Korean summit in Panmunjom last Friday. The Russian readout says that during the conversation, Putin "reaffirmed Russia's readiness to continue facilitating practical cooperation between the Republic of Korea and the DPRK, including through major trilateral projects in infrastructure and energy."

The South Korean media reported that Putin "stressed the need to take advantage of the success of the inter-Korean summit to launch economic cooperation projects between the two Koreas and Russia" and flagged, in particular, that "connecting railways, gas pipelines, and electric power transmission between Russia and the Korean Peninsula via Siberia will contribute to the stability and prosperity of the Korean Peninsula."

Earlier, in a statement in Moscow on Friday, Russian Foreign Ministry had welcomed the Panmunjom summit as "a significant step by Seoul and Pyongyang to national reconciliation and the establishment of strong relationships of independent value." The statement said, "We are ready to facilitate the establishment of practical cooperation between the DPRK and the Republic of Korea, including through the development of tripartite cooperation in the railway, electricity, gas and other industries."

Recycle

Best of the Web: Xi and Modi meet at SCO Summit: It's the Belt and Road Initiative against Washington's Indo-Pacific strategy all over again

Xi Jinping Narendra Modi China India
© AFP/Fred DufourChinese President Xi Jinping welcomes Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi during the BRICS Summit in Xiamen on September 4, 2017.


Modi and Xi meeting could have a crucial SCO subplot focusing on security and economic cooperation


All bets are off on the outcome of India Prime Minister Narendra Modi's potentially ground-breaking meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping this Friday and Saturday in Wuhan.

Things have not exactly started in auspicious mode.

After a meeting in Beijing of foreign ministers represented at the Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO), India, once again refused to support the New Silk Roads, known as the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) in the final communiqué.

Every other SCO member - represented by the foreign ministers of Russia, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan, Tajikistan and Pakistan - did.

So here we go again - back to the interminable, intractable India-Pakistan soap opera.

Comment: This puts Trump's threats to scrap the JCPOA and Netanyahu's accusations against Iran in a new light.

As for India, money talks, at the end of the day. If it's committed to INSTC, it'll find solutions to Kashmir, sooner or later.


Life Preserver

Best of the Web: Should North Korea think twice about ditching nukes after what happened to Libya? (VIDEO)

Kim Jong Un North Korea nukes
© Kim Hong-Ji / ReutersA poster with the image of North Korean leader Kim Jong-un during an anti-North Korea rally in central Seoul, South Korea, February 11, 2016.
The US says North Korean denuclearization should proceed along the Libyan scenario. RT's Murad Gazdiev remembers how Muammar Gaddafi was killed by US-backed rebels a few years after ditching nukes, and asks - is that a good idea?

There was a time when tales of Gaddafi's death had Kim Jong-un keeping his both hands on the nuclear button, which, by his own admission, he cautiously kept on his desk.

Now US President Donald Trump, who not long ago had been erratically tweeting away about his own shiny red button, is suddenly an advocate for peace, welcoming Kim's push to ditch nukes. RT's Murad Gazdiev believes this bears the question - is Libya's history about to be repeated?

And when US officials speak about the "Libyan model", they mean the 2003 denuclearization, not the devastating West-assisted civil war of 2011. Don't they?


Binoculars

Best of the Web: The truth about Netanyahu's 'Iran files': Well known, old, purloined from Vienna

netanyahu
Netanbullshit
The dog and pony show the Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahoo provided yesterday (video, slideshow) was not based on material Israeli secret services acquired in Iran, but most likely from data Iran provided to the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) during the implementation period of the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA, pdf).

Ali Vaez, director of the Iran Project at the Crisis Group, was the first to propose this thesis:
Ali Vaez @AliVaez - 18:06 UTC - 30 Apr 2018
5/ It appears to me that what Israel has done is that it has probably hacked the @iaeaorg and gathered some new details from what Iran responded to the agency to close the outstanding issues in 2015: IAEA Board Adopts Landmark Resolution on Iran PMD Case
Several nuclear proliferation experts point out that there was nothing new in Netanyahoo's presentation:
Jeffrey Lewis @ArmsControlWonk - 00:14 UTC- 1 May 2018
Let's go through Netanyahu's dog-and-pony show. As you will see, everything he said was already known to the IAEA and published in IAEA GOV/2015/68 (2015). There is literally nothing new here and nothing that changes the wisdom of the JCPOA. 1/10
All the graphics, pictures and technical details Netanyahoo quoted were known to the IAEA and the negotiators of the agreement with Iran.

Comment: See also:


Che Guevara

Best of the Web: May Day: World Lefties' Temper-Tantrum Day! Annual Riot Hits Paris

may day riot paris
© Thomas Samson / AFPProtesters at the annual May Day workers' rally, in Paris, on May 1, 2018.
Police in Paris have used water cannons to break up a tumultuous rally. Amid May Day demonstrations, hooded individuals have been throwing smoke bombs and setting vehicles on fire in the French capital.

Live feeds from Paris showed chaotic scenes, as police attempt to disperse violent protesters while redirecting crowds of peaceful marchers to side streets. Loud bangs are heard in the background as smoke and tear gas billow down the streets.

Police pushed back against the rioters, peppering the crowd with tear gas grenades from behind riot shields and hitting the crowd with water cannon. Protesters lobbed firecrackers at the advancing force, as well as picking up and throwing back some of the gas canisters. Armored police vans and fire trucks are backed up advance.


Comment: In fairness, Labor Day is not a riot everywhere. In Russia, for example, which has 'been there, got the t-shirt' with respect to implementing extremist ideology, Labor Day is a family affair at which national flags, not Karl Marx banners, are waved:

may day moscow
© Maxim Shemetov / ReutersMay Day rally at Red Square in Moscow, Russia May 1, 2018.



2 + 2 = 4

Best of the Web: Robert Fisk: Damascus research center bombed by F.UK.US doesn't look like a chemical weapons facility

syria barzah research center bombed
© charly015.blogspot.com
The great 10th century Iraqi poet Abu Tayyib al-Mutanabbi once lived, O fated city, in the Emirate of Aleppo. He even led a revolt in Syria which was - familiar stuff, this - put down with great ruthlessness. Al-Mutanabbi actually spent two years in prison before reconciling himself to his loss and was subsequently released. Most Arab children in Syria can quote the man by heart and one of their favourite poems begins with these words:

When you see the teeth of a lion,
Don't think that the lion is smiling at you.

I was reminded of this lion while clambering through the ruins on the side of the Scientific Studies and Research Centre in the Damascus suburb of Barzeh last week. This was the centre - now famous from so many satellite pictures - destroyed by Donald Trump's missiles when they struck at "the heart of Syria's chemical weapons programme". Did they? Anything with a Strangelove name like the "Department of Pharmaceutical and Civilian Chemical Research" - the bit of the complex hit by at least 13 missiles - deserves to have its contents studied closely. I'd been refused permission to visit this Syrian institution for three days. If it was all in ruins - which it assuredly is, and on a scale much larger than the photographs suggest - why the delay?

And does it matter? Well, yes. I am reminded of the much more famous Iraqi "baby milk factory" bombed by the Americans in 1991 which General Colin Powell called "a biological weapons factory, of that we are sure". My colleague Patrick Cockburn wrote of this last week, recalling his visit to the factory only hours after the bombing. After the war, it turned out that the building probably had been an infant formula factory after all - although what can't you do with a glass of milk?

Attention

Best of the Web: Shocker: Russian doping 'whistleblower' claims fail to stand up in court - he made it up

Grigory Rodchenkov
© Grigory Rodchenkov / Global Look Press
Russian officials plan to sue Grigory Rodchenkov, whose testimony played a key part in the country's Olympic bans, after a sports court rejected his claims. But most believe it's too late to reverse the impact of the doping saga.The scandal over Olympic doping has been running since 2014, and most of the allegations have been known for years. What's changed?

In a landmark ruling in February, the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS), the highest legal authority in such cases, reversed the life bans of 28 Russian sportsmen and gave them back their medals, many of them from the Sochi Olympics in 2014.

But it was only this week that a 160-page summary of the session exposed exactly how the allegations that led to the exclusion of entire Russian teams in various sports from Rio 2016 and PyeongChang 2018 failed to stand up to legal scrutiny.

Comment: And the Russians aren't even in the top five when it comes to doping: Guess who the worst doping cheaters were in 2016? Italy, France, US, Australia, Belgium - WADA


Chart Bar

Flashback Best of the Web: Jihadi Manpower, not 'civil war': Mercenaries from 81 different nationalities are fighting in Syria

Brit jihadists
© Stringer / Reuters'Woohoo! This is so much fun! I'm getting paid American dollars to ride this American tank and pretend I'm Syrian!'
It's estimated that the three-year conflict in Syria has drawn foreign fighters to its frontlines at a rate faster than any such war in modern memory, including the struggle of the Afghan mujahideen against the Soviet Union in the 1980s. The group that likely boasts the majority of such combatants is the Islamic State, the powerful terrorist organization that now commands a stretch of territory from central Syria to the environs of Iraq's capital, Baghdad.

The presence of these foreign jihadists has dominated media attention of late. Earlier this week, reports emerged of an American fighter slain in Syria in a battle with another Islamist faction. On Thursday, the White House identified nearly a dozen Americans believed to have joined the conflict in Syria. A British national is suspected to have beheaded American journalist James Foley this month, while a pair of Australians have gained notoriety for their habit of posting selfies on social media of them grinning while clutching the severed heads of Assad regime soldiers.

The Soufan Group, a New York-based intelligence firm, estimated in June that there were at least 12,000 foreign fighters from 81 countries in the Syrian conflict, including some 3,000 European nationals. Given the Islamic State's ascendance - and its slick online recruitment operation - it's probable that the bulk of the Western militants are in its ranks. The Economist published a handy graphic of the breakdown this week:

Comment:
The total numbers are probably higher...
Understatement of the decade.

The Russians alone have sent about 70,000 to hell since 2015. The total number of foreign fighters shipped into Syria since 2011 is probably around 200,000, or higher.

One country heftily contributing to 'Jihadi Manpower', and not even mentioned above, is Pakistan, a Muslim country of some quarter-billion people and lots and lots of unemployed, Saudi-madrassa-educated young males.

A 'civil war' this most certainly aint. It's a dirty, dirty proxy war, and elites from Washington to Islamabad are all in on it.


Cross

Best of the Web: Speaking the Unspeakable: The Assassination and Martyrdom of Thomas Merton

A Quasi-Review of The Martyrdom of Thomas Merton by Hugh Turley & David Martin
"Killing a man who says 'No!' is a risky business," the priest replied, "because even a corpse can go on whispering 'No! No! No! with a persistence and obstinacy that only certain corpses are capable of. And how can you silence a corpse?" - Ignazio Silone, Bread and Wine
thomas merton
Fifty years have elapsed since Thomas Merton died under mysterious circumstances in a cottage at a Red Cross Conference Center outside Bangkok, Thailand where he was attending an international inter-faith monastic conference. The truth behind his death has been concealed until now through the lies and deceptions of a cast of characters, religious, secular, and U.S. governmental, whose actions chill one to the bone. But he has finally found his voice through Hugh Turley and David Martin, who tell the suppressed truth of Merton's last minutes on earth on December 10, 1968.

This is an extraordinary book in so many ways. First, because the authors prove beyond a shadow of a doubt that the Trappist monk and anti-war writer Thomas Merton was assassinated and did not die in a fabricated accident, as has been claimed for all these years.

Comment: The CIA can't help doing what it does for satanic forces, but it's appalling that a monastery appears to be covering up the murder of one of its own.