Why exactly shouldn't banks be able to trade physical commodities? To see one argument, take a look at a big report from David Kocieniewski in today's New York Times.
According to Kocieniewski, a Goldman Sachs-owned company has been involved in an elaborate plan to move around aluminum in a way that has inflated market prices. The report states that every time an American consumer buys a product containing aluminum, they pay a price that has been affected by this maneuver. Sources told The New York Times that in total the plan has cost American consumers more than $5 billion over the last three years.
Kocieniewski's investigation centers on Metro International Trade Services, an aluminum storage company that Goldman Sachs bought three years ago. According to the Times, since Goldman bought the company the average wait time at the storage facility has gone up more than 20-fold. As the wait times are longer, the companies' revenues for storing the aluminium are higher. This cost is reflected in the market price of aluminum.
Aluminum storage facilities are not allowed to mindlessly sit on aluminum - industry standards require them to move 3,000 tons of the metal every day. However, according to the Times, Metro International gets around this law by moving the metal between its own warehouses every day. One analyst estimated that around 90% of the metal moved each day went to another Goldman-owned warehouse.
The body that governs the industry has shown little interest in reforming the practice, Kocieniewski writes. This may be because the body - the London Metals Exchange - collects 1% of the rent from aluminum storage facilities. Limiting the amount of rent received would cost it millions.
This all makes for a somewhat absurd working environment. Workers told the Times that they'd routinely see the same drivers making three or four round trips a day. Some warehouses reportedly sat empty 12 or more hours a day, the Times reports, despite the huge backlog.
If the practice is as the Times describes it, it is very hard to see what value is given to society by the activity. A loose coalition of companies that use aluminium - including Boeing and Coca-Cola - have begun to put pressure on Goldman. However, the issue may go beyond aluminum - JP Morgan, Blackrock and Goldman have all been given approval by the SEC to buy a large amount of copper available on the market and stockpile it, Kocieniewski reports.
Here is a full article on the doings of this alu commodity rig, along with Goldman's entry into cornering the copper market... of course they are not alone. JP Morgan and Citibank are running the same type commodity scams. [Link]It is odd that Bloomberg ran with the story. They are usually in lockstep with defense of the too-big-to-fail banks.