
Gender identity clinics should screen patients, says lead author of new paper
Brown University Professor Lisa Littman recently published a blockbuster study on the "transgender" phenomenon, presenting evidence that
parts of it might be a "social contagion" - a maladaptive coping technique for troubled teens, spread by peer groups and the Internet. Brown issued a press release about the study,
then promptly retracted it and replaced it with a
weasely non-statement that just drew more attention to Littman's research.
This was in response to a furious outcry from transgender activists, and I can see why they find this study such a threat.
The
study itself is not actually about "gender dysphoria" as it has previously been defined in the scientific literature. Rather,
it is about the newer phenomenon of "rapid-onset gender dysphoria" (ROGD). Prior to about ten years ago, cases of gender dysphoria typically involved a long history of a child rejecting identification with his or her biological sex, going back before puberty.
By contrast, "rapid-onset gender dysphoria"
involves a post-pubescent child, usually a girl, with no history of dysphoria suddenly claiming within a period of weeks or months not to identify with her biological sex. Not only is rapid-onset gender dysphoria sudden, but
it tends to occur in clusters.
Parents have described clusters of gender dysphoria outbreaks occurring in pre-existing friend groups with multiple or even all members of a friend group becoming gender dysphoric and transgender-identified in a pattern that seems statistically unlikely based on previous research. Parents describe a process of immersion in social media, such as 'binge-watching' Youtube transition videos and excessive use of Tumblr, immediately preceding their child becoming gender dysphoric. These descriptions are atypical for the presentation of gender dysphoria described in the research literature and raise the question of whether social influences may be contributing to or even driving these occurrences of gender dysphoria in some populations of adolescents and young adults.
Let's be clear on what the statistical background is. "
The expected prevalence of transgender young adult individuals is 0.7%. Yet more than a third of the friendship groups described in this study had 50% or more of the AYAs in the group becoming transgender-identified in a similar time frame, a localized increase to
more than 70 times the expected prevalence rate." AYA is an acronym for "adolescents and young adults." Remember it, because it's going to come up a lot.
Comment: See also: