Puppet MastersS

Clipboard

FISA court orders US govt. submit a plan to correct FBI FISA abuses uncovered in Horowitz investigation

DOJ sign
© Getty Images
The secret federal court that approved the warrants to conduct covert surveillance of former Trump campaign advisor Carter Page has ordered that it be provided a report detailing how the Federal Bureau of Intelligence (FBI) plans to ensure that the missteps detailed in Justice Department Inspector General (IG) Michael Horowitz's review are never repeated.

The letter issued Tuesday by the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court (FISC), signed by Presiding Judge Rosemary M. Collyer, opens by citing the Office of Inspector General (OIG) report's findings that the FBI both "provided false information" and "withheld material information" in its efforts to secure warrants to surveil Page:
"IN RE ACCURACY CONCERNS REGARDING FBI MATTERS SUBMITTED TO THE FISC

"This order responds to reports that personnel of the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) provided false information to the National Security Division (NSD) of the Department of Justice, and withheld material information from NSD which was detrimental to the FBI's case, in connection with four applications to the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court (FISC) for authority to conduct electronic surveillance of a U.S. citizen named Carter W. Page. When FBI personnel mislead NSD in the ways described above, they equally mislead the FISC."
...
"On December 9, 2019, the government filed with the FISC public and classified versions of the OIG Report. The OIG Report describes in detail the preparation of the four applications for electronic surveillance of Mr. Page. It documents troubling instances in which FBI personnel provided information to NSD which was unsupported or contradicted by information in their possession. It also describes several instances in which FBI personnel withheld from NSD information in their possession which was detrimental to their case for believing that Mr. Page was acting as an agent of a foreign power.

"In addition, while the fourth electronic surveillance application for Mr. Page was being prepared, an attorney in the FBI's Office of General Counsel (OGC) engaged in conduct that apparently was intended to mislead the FBI agent who ultimately swore to the facts in that application about whether Mr. Page had been a source of another government agency."

Comment: RT, 17/12/2019: What others say
While such open criticism of a federal agency is uncommon for the secretive FISA court, some observers were skeptical that procedural tweaks would generate sincere reform, given that FBI agents are already required to swear under threat of perjury that every application is truthful and accurate.



The court itself, meanwhile, seldom turns down an FBI request, with a minuscule 0.03 percent rejection rate over its 30-plus years in operation. There is little reason to expect that to change after January 10.







Star of David

Anti-Semitism envoy puts Israel, rather than Jews, front and center

Elan Carr
© UnknownSpecial Envoy to Monitor and Combat Anti-Semitism Elan Carr, outside Old City of Jerusalem.
Trump's anti-Semitism envoy inaccurately equates anti-Zionism with anti-Semitism, and considers Israel "a central tenet" of Judaism - despite vocal opposition from within the global Jewish community... Carr demands: "Every law enforcement office and every prosecutorial agency must force everybody who has even a hint of antisemitism to undergo a tolerance program."

In his first month on the job, February 2019, the new Special Envoy for Monitoring and Combating anti-Semitism quickly defined his top priority: policing the world based on a far-right, Israel-centric definition of anti-Semitism. And in the months since, he has escalated his extremist actions.

Elan Carr redefined Judaism by including Zionism as "a central tenet" of the culture and religion - a position incompatible with many progressive Jewish groups.

Carr's State Department bio indicates that he served on the National Council of the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC), was a voting member of the Conference of Presidents of Major American Jewish Organizations, and was the international president of the Jewish fraternity Alpha Epsilon Pi; all are committed to Israel.

Comment: Whether one agrees with Carr's conflation of terms and concepts, or disagrees, the muddle effect of redefinition is doing its damage to Jews and non-Jews alike - especially the Palestinians whose lives, for decades, have been ravaged by concepts, tenets and deliberate inhuman actions so commonplace to forego inspection and defy rectification. The slide: Make Israel's ethnic cleansing and the usurpation of Palestinian rights US governmentally approved and so universally acceptable it becomes the new logic. Carr fits this bill.


X

Tulsi Gabbard votes 'present' on Trump impeachment and slams the 'purely partisan process'

Gabbard
© Pacific Press/Sipa USA/NewscomDemocratic candidate for President Tulsi Gabbard
Rep. Tulsi Gabbard (D-Hawaii), a candidate for the Democratic presidential nomination, voted "present" on the two articles of impeachment against President Trump on Wednesday. This made her virtually the only the Democrat to effectively vote against sending the president's removal to the Senate. Rep. Jeff Van Drew (D-NJ) voted no on impeachment, but is expected to switch parties.

Gabbard is the first-ever representative to vote "present" during an impeachment inquiry, according to The Daily Beast.

In a statement, Gabbard said that Trump is guilty of wrongdoing, but that she could not endorse a "purely partisan process."

"When I cast my vote in support of the impeachment inquiry nearly three months ago, I said that in order to maintain the integrity of this solemn undertaking, it must not become a partisan endeavor," said Gabbard. "Tragically, that's what it has been."

Gabbard characterized her actions as a "stand for the center" โ€” a center that neither excuses Trump's wrongdoing, nor supports his ousting mere months before a presidential election.

Health

John Pilger: British NHS is 'completely contaminated' by private industry

Hospitalroom
© Reuters/Stefan WermuthA ward at St Thomas' Hospital in central London.
The UK national healthcare service has been infested by insatiable corporatism to the detriment of its patients, award-winning journalist John Pilger told RT. He warns that the situation is now set to get even worse.

The National Health Service (NHS) is on the edge the abyss and simple funding increase would hardly resolve this issue, the BAFTA award-winning documentary filmmaker told RT's Going Underground. The problem? UK healthcare has been plagued with a systemic flaw and its name is "corporate managerial culture that is rife throughout the NHS."

'Destructive corporatism'

Pilger believes that any additional funding would eventually go to management consultancy that he says only makes the situation in the NHS worse. In 2014 alone, between $350 million and $600 million worth of taxpayer money were spent on management consultancy, according to the University of Bristol.


Comment: See also:


Arrow Up

US Senate approves Trump's sanctions on Nord Stream 2, but it won't stop the Russian pipeline

Nord Stream 2
© AG/AgitecoNord Stream 2
The latest US sanctions are not just targeting Russia's Nord Stream 2 gas pipeline but the whole energy alliance between Russia and Europe, according to Alexander Rahr, research director at the German-Russian Forum.

RT talked to Rahr, following the approval of a bill by the US Senate, which would sanction companies involved in the construction of the Russian gas pipeline to Europe. The bill is expected to be signed by US President Donald Trump later this week.

European companies working on Nord Stream 2 will have enough time to complete the project before US sanctions are implemented, according to Rahr. Under the new bill they will have 30 days to stop their operations.
"European companies participating in Nord Stream 2 will have enough time and the US president knows that and he needs a bogeyman story for the Europeans. He understands that he can't stop Nord Stream 2, but the new bill will give him power in the future to pressure Europe."
There is certainly a risk that some companies cooperating in the energy sector with Russia will wind down operations and "run to the United States to save their business which is more profitable for them," Rahr explained. However, there are others that will stay and continue their business in Russia, he added.

Comment: See also:


Snakes in Suits

Former education minister Hassan Diab designated to be Lebanon's next prime minister

HDiab
© AP/Hussein MallaHassan Diab, new Prime Minister of Lebanon
The move follows media reports that the majority of Lebanese lawmakers selected former education minister Diab as the candidate for the post of prime minister.

Lebanon's President Aoun has named former education minister Hassan Diab as the country's next Prime Minister in a televised statement broadcast by Lebanese media.

Aoun previously delayed a parliamentary session to appoint a new prime minister, just a week after consultations had to be similarly postponed in the wake of the withdrawal of businessman Samir Khatib from the race. Khatib had been touted as a likely candidate for the vacant position.

Former Prime Minister Saad Hariri stepped down after a wave of protests ripped through Lebanon in the middle of October. The demonstrators took to streets to oppose a tax on internet calls made via the WhatsApp messenger.

Comment: See also:


Stock Up

What impeachment? Wall Street hits record highs with news of US-China trade deal

nyse bolsa valores
© Imagen Ilustrativa/ Brendan McDermid
Wall Street hit all-time highs again on Thursday as U.S. Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin said an initial U.S.-China trade deal would be signed in early January, adding to optimism that was fueled by a breakthrough in trade talks last week.

In an interview with CNBC on Thursday, Mnuchin said the agreement had already been put down on paper, and that it was completely finished and just undergoing a technical "scrub."

The S&P 500 .SPX hit a sixth straight intraday record high, its longest streak since January 2018, riding a wave that began last week with hopes of a trade truce between the world's top two economies and expectations for a smoother Brexit.

Comment: Significant events can and do have some type of effect on the stock market. At times even seemingly insignificant events can cause a tumble. That Wall Street is apparently unphased about the news of impeachment shows how little this fiasco means when it comes down to brass tacks.


Sheriff

Best of the Web: Putin's epic annual conference fielding questions from the world's media

putin 2019 press
© Sputnik / Alexandr Vilf
Hundreds of Russian and foreign journalists are attending the annual 'big press conference' with President Vladimir Putin. RT is reporting live from the event.

08:11 GMT The press conference is expected to last anywhere from three to four hours, and will primarily focus on domestic policy, including specific issues of various Russian regions voiced by the media from those places. Foreign policy is usually given about a quarter of the time.

08:11 GMT The Russian president usually hosts the 'big press conference' in December, using the occasion to provide a year-end report on the state of the nation to the Russian people. This Thursday's event is the 15th for Putin.

09:07 GMT Putin's big presser begins.

Comment: Comment: RT provides more detail on some of the discussion above:
Russia only seeks to protect itself from foreign meddling - Putin on 'sovereign internet' & 'foreign agents' laws

During his major annual press conference, Putin was asked about two controversial laws regarding 'sovereign internet' and 'foreign agents' - which have been criticized as big steps towards having a closed society.

The legislation, commonly known as the 'Sovereign Internet Bill,' was adopted earlier this year and took effect on November 1. It envisions a system that would ensure the autonomous functioning of the Russian-language segment of the global web in case of a global internet shutdown. Critics of the law, however, expressed concern that the government might use it to impose strict control over the web, manipulating the flow of information and censoring online content.

"Free internet and sovereign internet are not mutually exclusive concepts. The law is aimed only to prevent negative consequence of being potentially cut off from the global web, which controls are located primarily abroad," Putin stated, dismissing allegations of conspiring to impose strict state control over the web.

The law, which introduced the mandatory designation of 'foreign agent', was initially focused on foreign-funded NGOs, but later its scope was expanded to media outlets. Organizations designated as 'foreign agents' are obliged to disclose their leadership architecture, their spending, as well as undergoing frequent audits. Late this year, the law was expanded again, now affecting private individuals, too.

The legislation still requires certain improvements, the Russian president said, warning against a "broad interpretation" of it, especially regarding private individuals, to not harm actual humanitarian work. The law was expanded to private individuals since foreign-funded organizations have been trying to circumvent the restrictions - they have started receiving money from locals, who, in turn, receive cash from abroad, Putin explained.

"If you get money from abroad to partake in domestic political activities - say so explicitly. He who pays the piper calls the tune, you know. And if you receive funding from abroad, there are strong reasons to believe you are taking orders from those who pay you."

Every nation seeks to protect itself from foreign meddling, and the legislation has been designed as a tool to minimize that influence, Putin said. Similar legislation exists in many countries, and the 'foreign agent' designation itself originated from the US, where it has been in active use since the late 1930s, he noted. Unlike in the US, however, the repercussions in Russia for not being registered as a foreign agent while acting as one are very mild - organizations and individuals are only subject to fines, Putin added, bringing up the case of Russian gun activist Maria Butina.

"[In the US] it affects private individuals as well. Our citizen Maria Butina is a private individual. Yet she was thrown behind bars without any reason. What kind of agent is she? She's nowhere near being one. But she was jailed, spent time behind bars - and was even threatened with a lengthy prison term."
On the US initiated arms race:
Russian President Vladimir Putin has warned that a global arms race is inevitable if the US and Russia do not agree to extend the ten-year Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty (New START), which is due to expire in early 2021.

Speaking at a Q&A session with reporters in Moscow on Thursday, Putin said that Russia stands ready "to simply renew the existing New START agreement," even if it happens as fast as by the end of this year.

"They can send us the [agreement] tomorrow, or we can sign and send it to Washington. Let their designated official sign it too, including the president, if they're ready to do so."

"But so far our proposals have been left unanswered" by the US, Putin stressed.

"If the New START ceases to exist, nothing in the world will hold back an arms race. I believe this is bad."

Signed by the US and Russia in 2010, the treaty limits the development and deployment of nuclear weapons and their means of delivery.
On how dialogue is necessary dialogue between Kiev and the breakaway regions in Eastern Ukraine if they're to work towards peace:
Putin was asked about crisis resolution in Ukraine and the future of the Normandy Four talks between the leaders of Russia, Ukraine, France, and Germany. The president said that some progress has been made in resolving the crisis, but it is direct dialogue between the authorities in Kiev and the people of Ukraine living in the self-proclaimed Donetsk and Lugansk People's Republics that could really help the cause. Yet, this is precisely what is lacking.

"A direct dialogue with Donbass is needed. Yet, there is no dialogue."

Any move related to the status of the rebellious eastern Ukrainian regions should be coordinated with those regions, Putin said, adding that Kiev should not unilaterally take decisions on any "decentralization" issues that go beyond the framework of the Minsk Agreements which still remain the only plausible way to resolve the Ukrainian crisis.

Some positive steps have been made, the president admitted, such as troop withdrawal from several areas in eastern Ukraine, and the extension of the law on the special status of Donbass. Some new areas along the line of contact were further designated for troop withdrawal in 2020, during the latest Normandy Four meeting.

Yet, it is not enough, Putin added, questioning in particular Kiev's reluctance to pull its forces out from the entire line of contact in Donbass. "It was Kiev that cut the Donbass off by imposing a blockade of this territory," Putin told the media conference.
On the issue of security cooperation with countries and of terrorists, as highlighted by the Chechen militant killed in Berlin:
"We see how such people [like this terrorist] are freely roaming the European capitals," Putin told reporters at a Q&A event in Moscow on Thursday.

"And what will happen if people who are currently sitting in [prison] camps [for terrorists in Syria] come to you? Would you like that? Would allow them to freely walk in your cities too?"

Putin said there should be comprehensive cooperation between Moscow and Western states on tackling extremists. He reminded everyone that Moscow alerted the US about Tamerlan and Dzhokhar Tsarnaev before the brothers bombed the Boston Marathon in 2013.

"We requested for them to be extradited [to Russia] and said they were dangerous. We were then simply ignored... And here you had criminals like that strolling through Berlin."
Putin denies there's a military alliance with China, although it is helping it develop defensive technologies, the US, however, is seeking to form a military block in Asia with Japan and South Korea:
"This system does not push a nation to any form of aggression but only helps it defend its territory."

Besides, such a development would not significantly affect the regional or global balance of power as China is capable of creating such a system on its own, Putin argued. Russia only helps to develop it faster.

While little is known about the early warning system developed for China, such complexes usually involve a network of ground-based radars and orbital satellites. The devices are used for long-range detection of missile launches, giving a nation's air defenses the maximum time to respond to a sudden strike. Since it takes a matter of minutes for a strategic missile to reach its target, such a system is a game-changer, significantly increasing the chances of repelling a massive - and in all likelihood, nuclear - strike.
Putin highlighted that Russia has surpassing the US and Canada to become the world's number 1 exporter of wheat and other agricultural produce:
"The Soviet Union was always buying grain, we were one of the largest buyers of grain, wheat. I would like to mention that today Russia is the largest supplier of wheat to the world market, we are number one," he said, adding: "We are ahead of the United States and Canada."

According to data published by the Russian Federal State Statistics Service on Thursday, grain harvest in Russia increased by 6.5 percent this year, up to 120.6 million tons in net weight. The production figure is better than that projected by the Russian Ministry of Agriculture.

Putin earlier said that Russia has ensured its independence on the global wheat market. According to the Russian president, enormous natural resources should serve as a guarantee for high-quality food production and should be used specifically to increase the production of organic, non-GMO food products.
On the 25% discount Russia is ready to offer Ukraine on natural gas:
"I think we will find an agreement with Ukraine on gas," he said during his press conference, adding "there's no desire to escalate this situation with energy."

According to the president, Russian gas transit through Ukraine will continue despite the construction of alternative pipelines because Moscow itself is interested in keeping the route.
On the issue of Ukraine and how the US should put its money where it's mouth is:
Putin's words come as the US Senate approved a $738 billion defense budget this week, which includes funds to "counteract Russia" in different spheres, as well as sanctions against the Nord Stream-2 gas pipeline, and military assistance to Ukraine.

"They practically never give money - they only give guarantees for possible loans, and this is not real money. There is no real support, and the IMF, which is ruled by the US, requires that all discounts on energy resources, including gas, be canceled," said Putin. As a result, Ukraine's citizens will see more gas price hikes, he added.

"They accuse us of something in relation to Ukraine. They claim they want to help. But what do they want us to do? Help Ukraine replenish its budget at Russia's expense? Give them money yourself, give good loans at good rates for a long period," the Russian president suggested.
On how his hardest moments as President were Russia's terror attacks:
During Thursday's Q&A session in Moscow, reporters asked Putin what events affected him the most during his years in power. The president said that the "most difficult" moments for him personally were the two major terrorist attacks in Moscow and the city of Beslan in the North Ossetia region in southern Russia in the early 2000s.

"I will never forget it," Putin said.

The first tragedy occurred in October 2002, when Chechen militants took 916 people hostage in the Dubrovka Theater Center in Moscow. The standoff lasted for nearly four days, after which 130 people died and others were freed, as SWAT teams stormed the building and killed all the militants.

In 2004 in Beslan, terrorists took more than 1,000 students and teachers hostage in a school during celebrations of the beginning of the school year. More than 330 of them died during a three-day siege. All of the terrorists were killed, except for one attacker who was captured alive and sentenced to life in prison.

When asked about the brightest moments, Putin preferred to talk about the most important achievements, among which he stressed growing incomes.



Bullseye

EU citizens should worry about what Johnson left out of his second Queen's Speech

queen elizabeth
© Pool via REUTERS / Matt Dunham
Queen's Speeches are like London buses: there's none for years and then two turn up at once - and the comparison between October's speech and today's should worry EU citizens living in Britain.

A week after newly re-elected Tory Prime Minister Boris Johnson secured a Labour Party-destroying majority, he has drawn up and handed his revamped plans to the Queen to read out at the opening of (yet another) Parliament, as is the tradition. Quite an annoying tradition for her, because she only did this for Johnson a couple of months ago, and it's fair to say little progress has been made.

It's hard to know whether she finds the whole process dull or laborious, because the Queen reads like a well-bred automaton who's seeing the words for the first time. Presumably this is so she doesn't let slip any political leanings that may influence events. I think, however, we can safely assume she would vote Conservative.

Light Saber

Sen. McConnell rips Dem's impeachment effort: 'Most rushed, least thorough & most unfair' vote in history which sets 'toxic' precedent

Mitch McConnell
© REUTERS/Aaron P. BernsteinSenate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY)
Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell addressed the House voting to impeach President Donald Trump from the Senate floor and said the effort is "rushed" and unlike any other in history.

Speaking from the Senate floor on Thursday morning, McConnell blasted the impeachment inquiry into President Donald Trump as "the most rushed, least thorough and most unfair" in American history.

House Dems were celebratory on Wednesday night after passing articles of impeachment against Trump. The charges are abuse of power and obstruction of Congress. McConnell said the standard for the charges are based on a "pandora's box of subjective political impeachment" and they set a "toxic" precedent.

Comment: And the circus rolls on. After the vote, Pelosi said the matter would not be sent immediately to the Senate. Trump shot back


He then pronounced Pelosi's move as political suicide march for the Democratic Party, with Steve Scalise weighing in:
Trump noted the difference as he fired back at Democrats at a campaign rally in Battle Creek, Michigan.

"We did not lose one Republican vote and three Democrats voted for us," he said. "The Republican Party has never been so affronted but they have never been so united as they are right now."
"Think of it, three Democrats went over to our side, no Republicans - it's unheard of."
Taking aim at the impeachment saga itself, Trump did not mince words, calling it "illegal, unconstitutional and partisan," and predicting it would spell the end of the Democratic Party since Democrats "have branded themselves with an eternal mark of shame."
"The do-nothing Democrats are declaring their deep hatred and disdain for the American voter. This lawless partisan impeachment is a political suicide march for the Democratic Party"

Still, there were some voices of sanity to be heard if you tried hard enough. Tulsi Gabbard distinguished herself by refusing to participate in the hysterics and garnered some support for doing so:
Voting "present" instead of "yes" or "no" in Wednesday's full House vote for two impeachment articles passed in committee last week, Gabbard became one of only a tiny minority of Democrats to swim against the current in her own party.

"I could not in good conscience vote for impeachment because removal of a sitting President must not be the culmination of a partisan process, fueled by tribal animosities that have so gravely divided our country," Gabbard said in a lengthy statement after the vote.



While the sanest of the sane, Russian president Vladimir Putin called out the lunacy for what it was:
"This is just political infighting. A party that lost the elections, the Democrats, now seeks to achieve its goals with some other means. They first accused Trump of colluding with Russia but later it turned out that there was no collusion and it could not be used as a reason to impeach him, so they came up with accusations related to some alleged pressure he exerted on Ukraine..."