|
Signs Supplement: Climate
and Earth Changes
Hurricane Katrina Special - September 2005
MIAMI - Tropical Storm Katrina formed
Wednesday morning in the Bahamas and moved toward Florida,
threatening to hit the state with winds of 70 to 75 mph and
heavy rain when it makes landfall Thursday, the National Hurricane
Center said.
A 200-mile stretch of Florida's east coast from the Seven
Mile Bridge in the Keys north to Vero Beach was under a tropical
storm watch, meaning tropical storm conditions were likely
within 36 hours. The storm is expected to slowly cross the
state and could cause flooding as it dumps a foot of rain
or more in spots before heading into the Gulf of Mexico.
At 8 a.m. EDT, the season's 11th named storm had winds of
40 mph and was about 70 miles southeast of Nassau and about
250 miles east-southeast of Florida. It was moving to the northwest
at 8 mph and was expected to strengthen and that it could reach
hurricane strength of 74 mph.
Eric Blake, a hurricane center meteorologist, said Floridians
in the watch area should consider putting up hurricane shutters,
particularly in coastal and exposed areas. He said all residents
should stock up on hurricanes supplies such as water, batteries
and generator fuel.
"It's time for South Florida to start taking precautions,"
he said.
The Florida Panhandle was hit by Tropical Storm Cindy and
Hurricane Dennis earlier in the Atlantic hurricane season,
which began June 1, and four hurricanes last year, which caused
$19 billion in insured wind damage. Actual damage was about
double that, experts said.
In an average year, only a few tropical storms develop by
this time in the Atlantic, Caribbean and Gulf of Mexico. The
Atlantic hurricane season ends Nov. 30. |
Hurricane
Katrina slammed into Florida's densely populated southeastern
coast Thursday with sustained winds of more than 125 km/hour
and lashing rain.
Two people were killed by falling trees.
The storm strengthened into a Category
1 hurricane just before it hit land between Hallandale Beach
and North Miami Beach. Weather officials said flooding
was the main concern as the storm dropped a 30 cm or more of
rain in some spots.
There were no immediate reports of major damage or flooding
as the storm passed through the area. It's estimated 5.9 million
Florida residents were in Katrina's projected path.
Rain fell in horizontal sheets and wind gusts hit 147 km/h toppling
trees and street signs. Florida Power &
Light said more than 412,000 customers were without electricity.
"The message needs to be very clear. It's not a good night
to be out driving around," said National Hurricane Center
director May Mayfield.
The usually bustling streets of Miami Beach were largely deserted
as the storm pounded the area. Celebrities and partygoers are
in town for the MTV Video Music Awards. MTV called off its pre-awards
festivities Thursday and Friday.
Tourists and others hoping to get out of town before the storm
were stranded as airlines canceled flights at Miami and Fort
Lauderdale airports, which both closed Thursday night.
Before the hurricane struck, Floridians wary of Katrina prepared
by putting up shutters, stacking sandbags in doorways and stocking
up on supplies.
Water management officials lowered canal levels to avoid possible
flooding, and pumps were activated in several low-lying areas
of Miami-Dade.
Katrina was the second hurricane to hit the state this year
-- and the sixth since last August.
Katrina formed Wednesday over the Bahamas and was expected to
cross Florida before heading into the Gulf of Mexico.
After crossing the Florida peninsula, the storm could turn to
the north over the Gulf of Mexico and threaten the panhandle
early next week.
Katrina is the 11th named storm of the
Atlantic hurricane season, which began June 1. That's seven
more than normally form by mid-August in the Atlantic, Caribbean
and Gulf of Mexico. The season ends Nov. 30. |
FORT LAUDERDALE, Fla. - Hurricane Katrina
flooded streets, darkened homes and felled trees with wind
gusts reaching 92 mph as it plowed through South Florida and
emerged over the Gulf of Mexico early Friday. Four people were
killed and 1.3 million customers were
left without power.
Weather officials said flooding was the main concern as
the storm dropped up to 15 inches on parts of Miami-Dade
County. Katrina's plodding pace meant that strong wind and
heavy rain would continue to plague throughout the day.
Rain fell in horizontal sheets, seas were estimated at 15
feet and sustained winds were measured at 80 mph as the hurricane
made landfall Thursday night along the Miami-Dade and Broward
line. Florida Power &
Light said the vast majority of people without electricity
were in the two counties.
In an oceanfront condominium in Hallandale, Carolyne and Carter
McHyman said heavy downpours pelted their windows after the
eye passed.
"It's been horrible," Carolyne McHyman said.
"Basically all our windows are leaking. We just keep mopping
up and taping the windows, mopping up and taping again."
Katrina weakened into a tropical storm while over land, but
strengthened over the warm waters of the gulf Friday and became
a hurricane again with top sustained winds of 75 mph. At 5
a.m. EDT, Katrina was about 50 miles north-northeast of Key
West and emerging over the Gulf of Mexico, heading west at
5 mph.
Forecasters said Katrina would likely strengthen
and perhaps make a second landfall in the Florida Panhandle
early next week.
Gov. Jeb Bush urged residents of the Panhandle and northwest
Florida - areas hit by Hurricane Ivan last year and Hurricane
Dennis this year - to monitor the storm.
Katrina left a trail of mayhem in its wake along the southeast
coast.
In Key Biscayne, dozens of families were forced to evacuate
their homes after they became flooded under 3 feet of water.
Three mobile home parks in Davie sustained considerable damage,
including lost roofs. One person was trapped inside a mobile
home, but officials did not know whether the person was injured,
according to the Broward Emergency Management Agency.
An overpass under construction in Miami-Dade County collapsed
onto a highway, authorities said. No injuries were reported,
but the freeway - a main east-west thoroughfare - was closed
for 20 blocks.
In the Florida Keys, a tornado damaged a hanger and a number
of airplanes at the airport in Marathon, according to Monroe
County Sheriff's Office. Two nearby homes were also damaged.
In Tavernier in the upper Keys, part of the roof of a lumber
company collapsed, deputies said.
Three people were killed by falling
trees: A man in his 20s in Fort Lauderdale was crushed
by a falling tree as he sat alone in his car; a 54-year-old
man was killed by a falling tree in the Fort Lauderdale suburb
of Plantation; and a woman who was struck by a tree died
at a hospital in Hollywood.
A 79-year-old man in Cooper City also died
when his car struck a tree, officials said.
Three storm-related trauma patients were being treated in
Hollywood, including a driver in critical condition after a
tree fell on his car, said Frank Sacco, CEO of Memorial Healthcare
System. [...] |
NEW ORLEANS, Louisiana -- Parts of New
Orleans are flooded with up to six feet of water Monday after
some of the pumps that protect the low-lying city failed under
the onslaught from Hurricane Katrina, Mayor Ray Nagin said.
Nagin said the Lower 9th Ward of New Orleans, on the east
side of the city, was under five to six feet of rising water
after three pumps failed.
WGNO reporter Susan Roesgen, who is with the mayor at the
Hyatt hotel, said New Orleans police had received more than
100 calls about people in the area trapped on their roofs.
The National Weather Service reported the Industrial Canal,
in the eastern part of the city, had breached a levee and three
to eight feet of water could be expected.
The weather service reported
"total structural failure" in some parts of metropolitan
New Orleans, where Katrina brought wind gusts of 120
mph. While it offered no details, it said it had received "many
reports."
Katrina came ashore Monday morning in southeastern
Louisiana as a Category 4 storm, with winds topping 140 mph.
At 11 a.m. ET, the National Weather Service
said Katrina had degraded to a Category 3 storm with maximum
sustained winds near 125 mph.
New Orleans was prepared for a catastrophic direct hit from
the powerful storm. About a million
people fled the area, and about 10,000 people who couldn't
leave hunkered in the mammoth Louisiana Superdome.
The National Hurricane Center said that the western eye wall
was passing over the city at about 10 a.m. ET. (Watch video
update on Katrina's path)
While the counterclockwise spin of a hurricane
usually leaves the worst damage on its eastern edge, CNN meteorologist
Chad Myers cautioned that "there's not really an easy
side of a Category 4 storm"
on the Saffir-Simpson scale.
CNN's John Zarella said that the wind was howling through
the buildings in downtown New Orleans, ripping off chunks of
debris and causing whiteout conditions.
He said that water was rushing down the street and had risen
up to the wheel wells of parked cars.
Earlier, reporter Ed Reams from affiliate WDSU told CNN that
Katrina ripped away a large section of the Superdome's roof.
(See video of conditions within the darkened Superdome)
"I can see daylight straight up from inside the Superdome," Reams
reported.
National Guard troops moved people to the other side of the
dome. Others were moving beneath the concrete-reinforced terrace
level.
About 70 percent of New Orleans is below sea level and is
protected from the Mississippi River by a series of levees.
NHC deputy director Ed Rappaport told CNN that New Orleans
could expect a storm surge of 15 to 20 feet.
That surge wouldn't top New Orleans' levees, but CNN's Myers
noted that "there may be a 20-foot surge, but there may
be a 20-foot wave on top of that."
Louisiana Gov. Kathleen Blanco said it was too soon to feel
any sense of relief.
"We don't know yet," she said. "We still have
a long way to go throughout this day. We are watching. We are
worried of course."
At 11 a.m. ET, the storm was centered about
35 miles east-northeast of New Orleans and 45 miles west-southwest
of Biloxi, Mississippi. Hurricane force winds extended about
125 miles from the storm's center.
The storm was moving north at 15 mph.
The storm's eastern eye wall was approaching Biloxi and Gulfport,
Mississippi.
Authorities in Gulfport told CNN that 10
feet of water cover downtown streets.
"There is intense damage," said CNN's Gary Tuchman
from Gulfport. "We are watching the dismantling of a beautiful
town."
"We are watching these building deteriorate
and break down before our eyes," he said. "Because
the water is so deep, boats are floating up the street. There
is extensive damage here. This is essentially
right now like hell on earth."
In Biloxi, CNN meteorologist Rob Marciano reported that wind
gusts topping 100 mph were starting to pull the roofs off of
nearby buildings. (Watch video report from Biloxi, Mississippi)
Hurricane warnings are posted from Morgan City, Louisiana,
eastward to the Alabama-Florida state line, including New Orleans
and Lake Pontchartrain. This means winds of at least 74 mph
are expected in the warning area within the next 24 hours.
A tropical storm warning is in effect from the Alabama-Florida
state line eastward to Destin, Florida, and from west of Morgan
City to Intracoastal City, Louisiana. A tropical storm warning
is also in effect from Intracoastal City, Louisiana, west to
Cameron, Louisiana, and from Destin, Florida, eastward to Indian
Pass, Florida.
A tropical storm warning means tropical storm conditions,
including winds of at least 39 mph, are expected within 24
hours. [...] |
NEW ORLEANS, Louisiana - Hurricane Katrina
claimed its first victims in Louisiana as it slammed into barrier
islands while dumping torrential rain on a wide swath of the
US Gulf of Mexico coast and threatened more death and massive
destruction.
The hurricane made its first landfall as its northern eye
crossed the coast near Grand Isle, one of Louisiana's barrier
islands, at about 1000 GMT on Monday, said Martin Nelson,
an official with the
National Hurricane Center.
"We may have a second landfall later on,"
Nelson said in a brief telephone interview.
Although slightly weaker than on Sunday, the monster storm
has already forced hundreds of thousands of residents from
New Orleans to Biloxi, Mississippi, to flee and seek refuge
on higher ground. [...]
US President George W. Bush declared
a state of emergency that clears the way for federal
aid, and urged people to get out of the hurricane's path.
"We cannot stress enough the dangers this hurricane poses
to Gulf Coast communities. I ask citizens to put their safety
and the safety of their families first by moving to safe ground," Bush
said from his Texas ranch. [...]
Authorities also ordered evacuations in neighboring
Mississippi, which is also expected to be slammed by the monster
storm.
Since Katrina raged dangerously close to offshore
oil platforms, most of which have been evacuated, oil prices
hit new record highs after crossing 70 dollars a barrel in
Asia Monday and were expected to go higher.
The deadly storm wrought havoc in Miami and other areas of
south Florida last week, killing seven people, uprooting trees
and flooding entire neighborhoods.
About half a million people still had no electricity on Sunday.
Katrina is the 11th named Atlantic storm
this year and among the most powerful Atlantic hurricanes
on record. Records going back to 1851 show that only
three category-five hurricanes have hit the United States
in more than 150 years.
Of three category-five storms noted in history, Hurricane
Andrew killed more than two dozen people when it slammed into
south Florida in 1992, while Camille caused more than 250 deaths
in Mississippi in 1969, and "Labor Day" killed about
600 people in the Florida Keys in 1935. |
NEW ORLEANS - Hurricane Katrina turned
slightly to the east before slamming ashore early Monday with
145-mph winds, providing some hope that the worst of the storm's
wrath might not be directed at this vulnerable, below-sea-level
city.
Katrina, which weakened slightly overnight to a Category
4 storm, turned slightly eastward before hitting land, which
would put the western eyewall - the weaker side of the strongest
winds - over New Orleans.
But National Hurricane Center Director Max
Mayfield warned that New Orleans would be pounded throughout
the day Monday and that Katrina's potential 20-foot storm surge
was still more than capable of swamping the city.
Katrina, which a day before had grown
to a 175-mph, Category 5 behemoth, made landfall about
6:10 a.m. CDT east of Grand Isle in the bayou town of Buras.
The storm hammered the Gulf Coast with huge waves and tree-bending
winds. Exploding transformers lit up the predawn sky in Mobile,
Ala., while tree limbs littered roads and a blinding rain whipped
up sand on the deserted beach of Gulfport, Miss.
Katrina's fury also was felt at the Louisiana Superdome, normally
home of professional football's Saints, which became the shelter
of last resort for about 9,000 of the area's poor, homeless
and frail.
Electrical power at the Superdome failed at 5:02 a.m., triggering
groans from the crowd. Emergency generators kicked in, but
the backup power runs only reduced lighting and cannot run
the air conditioning.
About 370,000 customers in southeast
Louisiana were estimated to be without power, said
Chenel Lagarde, spokesman for Entergy Corp., the main energy
power company in the region. [...]
Mayor Ray Nagin said he believed 80 percent
of the city's 480,000 residents had heeded an unprecedented
mandatory evacuation as Katrina threatened to become the most
powerful storm ever to slam the city.
"It's capable of causing catastrophic damage,"
Mayfield said. "Even well-built structures will have tremendous
damage. Of course, what we're really worried about is the loss
of lives.
"New Orleans may never be the same."
Crude oil futures spiked to more than $70
a barrel in Singapore for the first time Monday as Katrina
targeted an area crucial to the country's energy infrastructure,
but the price had slipped back to $68.95 by midday in Europe.
The storm already forced the shutdown of an estimated 1 million
barrels of refining capacity.
Terry Ebbert, New Orleans director of homeland security, said
more than 4,000 National Guardsmen were mobilizing in Memphis
and would help police New Orleans streets. [...]
For years, forecasters have warned of the
nightmare scenario a big storm could bring to New Orleans,
a bowl of a city that's up to 10 feet below sea level in spots
and dependent on a network of levees, canals and pumps to keep
dry from the Mississippi River on one side, Lake Pontchartrain
on the other.
The fear is that flooding could overrun the
levees and turn New Orleans into a toxic lake filled with chemicals
and petroleum from refineries, as well as waste from ruined
septic systems.
Nagin said he expected the pumping system
to fail during the height of the storm. The mayor
said the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers was standing by to
get the system running, but water levels must fall first.
"We are facing a storm that most of
us have long feared," he said. "This is a once-in-a-lifetime
event."
Major highways in New Orleans cleared out late Sunday after
more than 24 hours of jammed traffic as people headed inland.
At the peak of the evacuation, 18,000 people an hour were streaming
out of southeastern Louisiana, state police said. [...]
New Orleans has not taken a direct
hit from a hurricane since Betsy in 1965, when an 8- to 10-foot
storm surge submerged parts of the city in seven feet of
water. Betsy, a Category 3 storm,
was blamed for 74 deaths in Louisiana, Mississippi and Florida.
Evacuation orders also were posted all along the Mississippi
coast, and the area's casinos, built on barges, were closed
early Saturday. Bands of wind-whipped rain increased Sunday
night and roads in some low areas were beginning to flood.
[...]
Katrina hit the southern
tip of Florida as a much weaker storm Thursday and was blamed
for nine deaths. It left miles of streets and homes flooded
and knocked out power to about 1.45 million customers. It
was the sixth hurricane to hit Florida in just over a year. |
NEW ORLEANS - When Hurricane Katrina hits
New Orleans on Monday, it could turn one of America's most
charming cities into a vast cesspool tainted with toxic chemicals,
human waste and even coffins released
by floodwaters from the city's legendary cemeteries.
Experts have warned for years that the levees and pumps
that usually keep New Orleans dry have no chance against
a direct hit by a Category 5 storm.
That's exactly what Katrina was as it churned toward the city.
With top winds of 165 mph and the power to lift sea level by
as much as 28 feet above normal, the
storm threatened an environmental disaster of biblical proportions,
one that could leave more than 1 million people homeless.
"All indications are that this
is absolutely worst-case scenario," Ivor van
Heerden, deputy director of the Louisiana State University
Hurricane Center, said Sunday afternoon.
The center's latest computer simulations indicate
that by Tuesday, vast swaths of New Orleans could be under
water up to 30 feet deep. In the French Quarter, the water
could reach 20 feet, easily submerging the district's iconic
cast-iron balconies and bars.
Estimates predict that 60 percent to 80 percent of the city's
houses will be destroyed by wind. With the flood damage, most
of the people who live in and around New Orleans could be homeless.
"We're talking about in essence having
- in the continental United States - having a refugee camp
of a million people," van Heerden said.
Aside from Hurricane Andrew, which struck Miami in 1992, forecasters
have no experience with Category 5 hurricanes hitting densely
populated areas.
"Hurricanes rarely sustain such extreme winds for much
time. However we see no obvious large-scale effects to cause
a substantial weakening the system and it is expected that
the hurricane will be of Category 4 or 5 intensity when it
reaches the coast," National Hurricane Center meteorologist
Richard Pasch said.
As they raced to put meteorological instruments in Katrina's
path Sunday, wind engineers had little idea what their equipment
would record.
"We haven't seen something this
big since we started the program," said Kurt Gurley,
a University of Florida engineering professor. He
works for the Florida Coastal Monitoring Program, which is
in its seventh year of making detailed measurements of hurricane
wind conditions using a set of mobile weather stations. [...] |
A Category 5 hurricane, the most severe
type measured, Katrina has been reported heading directly toward
the city of New Orleans. This would be a human catastrophe,
since New Orleans sits in a bowl below sea level. However,
Katrina is not only moving on New Orleans. It also is moving
on the Port of Southern Louisiana. Were
it to strike directly and furiously, Katrina would not only
take a massive human toll, but also an enormous geopolitical
one.
The Port of Southern Louisiana is
the fifth-largest port in the world in terms of tonnage,
and the largest port in the United States. The only
global ports larger are Singapore, Rotterdam, Shanghai
and Hong Kong. It is bigger than Houston, Chiba and Nagoya,
Antwerp and New York/New Jersey. It is a key link in U.S.
imports and exports and critical to the global economy.
The Port of Southern Louisiana stretches up and down the Mississippi
River for about 50 miles, running north and south of New Orleans
from St. James to St. Charles Parish. It is the key port for
the export of grains to the rest of the world -- corn, soybeans,
wheat and animal feed. Midwestern farmers and global consumers
depend on those exports. The United
States imports crude oil, petrochemicals, steel, fertilizers
and ores through the port. Fifteen percent of all U.S. exports
by value go through the port. Nearly half of the exports go
to Europe.
The Port of Southern Louisiana is a river port. It depends
on the navigability of the Mississippi River. The Mississippi
is notorious for changing its course, and in southern Louisiana
-- indeed along much of its length -- levees both protect the
land from its water and maintain its course and navigability.
Dredging and other maintenance are constant and necessary to
maintain its navigability. It is fragile.
If New Orleans is hit, the Port of
Southern Louisiana, by definition, also will be hit. No
one can predict the precise course of the storm or its consequences.
However, if we speculate on worse-case scenarios the following
consequences jump out:
- The port might become in whole or part unusable if levees
burst. If the damage to the river and
port facilities could not be repaired within 30 days when the
U.S. harvests are at their peak, the effect on global agricultural
prices could be substantial.
- There is a large refinery at Belle Chasse. It is the only
refinery that is seriously threatened by the storm, but if
it were to be inundated, 250,000 barrels per day would go off
line. Moreover, the threat of environmental danger would be
substantial
- About 2 percent of world crude production
and roughly 25 percent of U.S.-produced crude comes from
the Gulf of Mexico and already is affected by Katrina. Platforms
in the path of Katrina have been evacuated but others continue
pumping. If this follows normal patterns, most production
will be back on line within hours or days. However, if a
Category 5 hurricane (of which there have only been three
others in history) has a different effect, the damage could
be longer lasting. Depending on the effect on the Port of
Southern Louisiana, the ability to ship could be affected.
- A narrow, two-lane highway that handles approximately 10,000
vehicles a day, is used for transport of cargo and petroleum
products and provides port access for thousands of employees
is threatened with closure. A closure
of as long as two weeks could rapidly push gasoline prices
higher.
At a time when oil prices are in the mid-60-dollar range and
starting to hurt, the hurricane has an obvious effect. However,
it must be borne in mind that the Mississippi
remains a key American shipping route, particularly for the
export and import of a variety of primary commodities from
grain to oil, as well as steel and rubber. Andrew Jackson
fought hard to keep the British from taking New Orleans because
he knew it was the main artery for U.S. trade with the world.
He was right and its role has not changed since then.
This is not a prediction. We do not know the path of the storm
and we cannot predict its effects. It
is a warning that if a Category 5 hurricane hits the Port of
Southern Louisiana and causes the damage that is merely at
the outer reach of the probable, the effect on the global system
will be substantial. |
Authorities along the shattered Gulf Coast
searched Tuesday for survivors and worked to rescue residents
stranded in the wake of Hurricane Katrina, which is blamed
for dozens of deaths and the destruction of countless homes
and businesses.
The storm ripped ashore in Louisiana Monday morning with
winds topping 140 mph before scourging Mississippi and Alabama.
Katrina caused widespread flooding across the region, and
floodwaters were still rising Tuesday in New Orleans after
a hole opened in a levee protecting the city.
The storm is blamed for at least 68 deaths and that toll is
almost certain to rise.
"We know we've had some loss of life. We really don't
know how much. There are credible accounts of 50 to 80 in Harrison
County. Those are not confirmed, but they're credible," Mississippi
Gov. Haley Barbour said Tuesday.
"And I hate to say it, I think there are going to be
more."
A man in Biloxi told CNN affiliate WKRG-TV he believed his
wife was killed after she was ripped from his grasp when their
home split in half.
"She told me, 'You can't hold me,' ... take care of the
kids and the grandkids..."
While Louisiana officials have not confirmed any deaths there,
New Orleans Mayor Ray Nagin said there have been reports of
bodies floating in the floodwaters. Two storm-related traffic
fatalities were reported in Alabama.
The storm killed 11 people last week when it made its initial
landfall in Florida.
'This is our tsunami'
In Mississippi, streets and homes were flooded as far as six
miles inland.
Barbour plans to make a helicopter tour of the hardest hit
areas today.
In Biloxi, a 25-foot storm surge crashed in from the Gulf
of Mexico on Monday and inundated structures there. Up to 30
people are believed to have been killed when one apartment
complex on the beach collapsed in the storm.
"This is our tsunami," Biloxi Mayor A.J. Holloway
told the Biloxi Sun Herald newspaper, referring to the December
26, 2004, tsunami that killed more than 226,000 people in the
Indian Ocean region.
In the daylight of Tuesday morning, the waters had receded
in Biloxi, but debris littered the streets and the ground floors
of several structures.
Cement trash cans used as barriers in front of buildings were
strewn about like cardboard boxes, and paper scraps hung from
the highest branches of the trees still standing.
CNN Correspondent Miles O'Brien, standing in front of the
once-luxurious Beau Rivage casino, said at least a dozen gaming
places were closed and damaged from Katrina -- costing the
state $500,000 a day in lost tax revenues.
Charles Curtis, a Biloxi resident who works in a casino that
is now split in half, said he and his wife stood on top of
their refrigerator as the water rose around them.
"The Back Bay of Biloxi came through our front door," he
said, referring to the shallow, marshy strip that borders the
north of the city.
"We were ready to punch a hole through the ceiling if
we had to" escape, Curtis said.
Hotel worker Suzanne Rodgers returned to her beachfront home
near Biloxi, but, she told CNN, "there is nothing there.
There's debris hanging from trees."
"All I found that belonged to me was a shoe,"
she said. "There's nothing left."
Separately, the Mississippi Emergency Management Agency in
Jackson confirmed five Katrina-related deaths, a spokeswoman
said.
Water poured into New Orleans from Lake Pontchartrain after
a two-block-long breach opened overnight in a section of a
levee that protects the low-lying city.
Nagin had said that about 80 percent of the city was flooded
and that some areas were under 20 feet of water.
CNN's John Zarrella, in a hotel on Canal Street, said the
water level was "much higher" than it had been during
the height of Katrina's onslaught, rising all morning Tuesday
and topping the sandbags meant to keep the water out of the
building.
"Water has now filled the basement of the hotel,"
he said. "All of the entrances to our hotel are completely
surrounded, and the water is slowly creeping up the side of
the building.
"Yesterday during the hurricane, the
water was no where near this high."
In the city's 9th Ward neighborhood, rescue efforts continued
throughout the night, with authorities in boats plucking residents
from submerged homes after water topped another levee.
CNN's Adaora Udoji, monitoring the rescue efforts, said authorities
had ferried at least 500 people from their homes, flooded with
as much as six feet of water. Some residents reported water
rose so fast they did not have time to grab their shoes.
Louisiana Gov. Kathleen Blanco told CNN Monday that a 50-inch
water main was severed during the storm, cutting the supply
of drinkable water.
In Mobile, Alabama, the storm pushed water from Mobile Bay
into downtown, submerging large sections of the city, and officials
imposed a dusk-to-dawn curfew.
An oil drilling platform broke away from
its moorings and lodged under a bridge that carries U.S. Highway
98 over the Mobile River.
The Alabama National Guard activated 450 troops to secure
Mobile. Two other Alabama battalions, or about 800 troops,
were activated to assist in Mississippi.
When can I go home?
The Federal Emergency Management Agency is preparing to house "at
least tens of thousands of victims ... for literally months
on end," the agency's director, Michael Brown, said Monday
night.
Veteran FEMA staffers who have surveyed the
destruction are reporting some of the worst damage they have
ever seen, he said.
Louisiana and Mississippi officials urged evacuees as well
as those stranded by flooding from the storm to stay put.
"It's too dangerous to come home," said Blanco,
who ordered state police to block re-entry routes to all but
emergency workers.
The American Red Cross said it is launching the largest relief
operation in its history.
More than 75,000 people are being housed in nearly 240 shelters
across the region, and Red Cross President Marty Evans told
CNN, "We expect that to grow"
as people who can't return home seek somewhere to stay.
More than 1.7 million homes and businesses in Louisiana, Mississippi,
Alabama and Florida were without electricity, according to
utility companies serving the region.
Katrina was downgraded to a tropical depression Tuesday. As
of the 11 a.m. ET update from the National Hurricane Center,
Katrina was about 25 miles south of Clarksville, Tennessee,
moving north-northeast at 21 mph.
On Katrina's way north Monday night through Mississippi, its
outer bands spawned tornados in Georgia. Three twisters were
reported there, one in central Peach County and two in the
northwest counties of Carroll and Paulding. One person in Carroll
County was critically injured. |
MIAMI - Hurricane Katrina may sting U.S.
economic growth by choking energy supplies even as the damages
caused by the storm spur massive rebuilding and emergency government
spending.
Economists, while emphasizing
that few concrete damage assessments have yet been made, said
the major hurricane that struck the country's key Louisiana
energy gateway would help sustain high oil, gasoline and
natural gas prices.
A seasonal downturn in demand expected after next weekend
and a higher-than-usual build-up in inventories ahead of the
North American winter had led to forecasts energy prices might
ease in coming months.
Some economists said U.S. gross domestic growth had been already
showing signs of easing and may now slow more rapidly if fallout
from Katrina boosts oil to $100 a barrel for a month, or U.S.
gasoline prices to $3.50 a gallon, for a few months.
"The impact on the consumer spending in such a scenario
would be very dramatic, cutting the growth rate by as much
as 3 percent and push real GDP growth in the fourth quarter
closer to zero," Global Insight said in a preliminary
analysis.
The Lexington, Massachusetts, economics consultancy said that,
if oil stayed at the current $65 to $70 level for a couple
of more months because of energy flow disruptions, GDP growth
would be cut 0.3 percent to 0.5 percent in the fourth quarter.
On Monday, at least two oil rigs were
adrift in the Gulf of Mexico, where Katrina raged through
offshore fields. Fearing the worst, oil companies
had shut rigs and closed refineries along the coast. U.S.
oil futures jumped nearly $5 a barrel in opening trade to
touch a peak of $70.80 before settling back.
"It looks like the potential disruption has helped to
further boost gasoline prices and that could be some additional
headwind for the economy," said senior economist Patrick
Fearon at A.G. Edwards & Sons Inc. in St. Louis.
Fearon said A.G. Edwards may later this week trim its forecast
of a 4 percent annualized GDP rise in the third quarter.
The Economic Outlook Group in Princeton Junction, New Jersey,
said Katrina's effect on energy prices would add to risks facing
the U.S. economy and could prompt the Federal Reserve to skip
a widely expected interest rate hike when it meets Sept 20.
"This is not to say they will not resume raising rates
in November and December. It's just that Fed officials may
want to evaluate the extent of Katrina's impact on business
activity, consumer demand and on inflation pressures," Economic
Outlook said.
Katrina, which last week hit south Florida, was expected to
cause a total of $10 billion to $26 billion in insured damages,
according to hurricane modeling firms. It
could be the most expensive storm to ever hit the United States.
"There will be a lot of rebuilding that is going to need
to occur. These things do spur GDP growth,"
said Ken Mayland, president of ClearView Economics in Pepper
Pike, Ohio.
Diane Swonk, chief economist at Mesirow Financial in Chicago,
said wages lost by workers and revenues missed at shops and
other businesses would be generally short-lived and replaced
by stepped-up demand for construction and other workers and
higher sales at home-supplies outlets.
The storm may also have damaged the Port
of Southern Louisiana, the world's fifth largest port by tonnage
and the biggest in the United States, and may affect exports
and imports of agricultural and other products, according to
Swonk.
"Depending on the extent of damage,
that will put pressure on other ports. A drought in
the Midwest has slowed some barges and there could be some
transitory impact on our GDP,"
Swonk said.
Freight railroads might pick up some of that transport business
if the port is hobbled, she said.
Travel, leisure and gambling businesses in Louisiana, Mississippi
and Alabama may lose some tourist visits to other U.S. destinations,
such as Las Vegas and Florida, during the cleanup and rebuilding
ahead, she said. |
Because hurricanes form over warm ocean
water, it is easy to assume that the recent rise in their number
and ferocity is because of global warming.
But that is not the case, scientists say. Instead, the severity
of hurricane seasons changes with cycles of temperatures
of several decades in the Atlantic Ocean. The
recent onslaught "is very much natural," said William
M. Gray, a professor of atmospheric science at Colorado State
University who issues forecasts for the hurricane season.
From 1970 to 1994, the Atlantic was relatively quiet, with
no more than three major hurricanes in any year and none at
all in three of those years. Cooler water in the North Atlantic
strengthened wind shear, which tends to tear storms apart before
they turn into hurricanes.
In 1995, hurricane patterns reverted to the active mode of
the 1950's and 60's. From 1995 to 2003, 32 major hurricanes,
with sustained winds of 111 miles per hour or greater, stormed
across the Atlantic. It was chance, Dr.
Gray said, that only three of them struck the United States
at full strength.
Historically, the rate has been 1 in 3.
Then last year, three major hurricanes, half of the six that
formed during the season, hit the United States. A fourth,
Frances, weakened before striking Florida.
"We were very lucky in that eight-year
period, and the luck just ran out," Dr. Gray said.
Global warming may eventually intensify hurricanes somewhat,
though different climate models disagree.
In an article this month in the journal Nature, Kerry A. Emanuel,
a hurricane expert at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology,
wrote that global warming might have already had some effect.
The total power dissipated by tropical cyclones in the North
Atlantic and North Pacific increased 70 to 80 percent in the
last 30 years, he wrote.
But even that seemingly large jump is not what has been pushing
the hurricanes of the last two years, Dr. Emanuel said, adding, "What
we see in the Atlantic is mostly the natural swing." |
Chalk up the city of New Orleans as a
cost of Bush's Iraq war.
There were not enough helicopters to repair the breeched
levees and rescue people trapped by rising water. Nor are
there enough Louisiana National Guards available to help
with rescue efforts and to patrol against looting.
The situation is the same in Mississippi.
The National Guard and helicopters are off on a fools mission
in Iraq.
The National Guard is in Iraq because fanatical neoconsevatives
in the Bush administration were determined to invade the Middle
East and because the incompetent Secretary of Defense Rumsfeld
refused to listen to the generals, who told him there were
not enough regular troops available to do the job.
After the invasion, the arrogant Rumsfeld found out that the
generals were right. The National Guard was called up to fill
in the gaping gaps.
Now the Guardsmen, trapped in the Iraqi
quagmire, are watching on TV the families they left behind
trapped by rising waters and wondering if the floating bodies
are family members. None know where their dislocated
families are, but, shades of Fallujah, they do see their
destroyed homes.
The mayor of New Orleans was counting on helicopters to put
in place massive sandbags to repair the levee. However, someone
called the few helicopters away to rescue people from rooftops.
The rising water overwhelmed the massive pumping stations,
and New Orleans disappeared under deep water.
What a terrible casualty of the Iraqi war--one
of our oldest and most beautiful cities, a famous city, a historic
city.
Distracted by its phony war on terrorism, the US government
had made no preparations in the event Hurricane Katarina brought
catastrophe to New Orleans. No contingency plan existed. Only
now after the disaster are FEMA and the Corp of Engineers trying
to assemble the material and equipment to save New Orleans
from the fate of Atlantis.
Even worse, articles in the New Orleans Times-Picayune
and public statements by emergency management chiefs in New
Orleans make it clear that the Bush administration slashed
the funding for the Corp of Engineers' projects to strengthen
and raise the New Orleans levees and diverted the money to
the Iraq war.
Walter Maestri, emergency management chief for Jefferson Parish,
told the New Orleans Times-Picayune (June 8, 2004): "It
appears that the money has been moved in the president's budget
to handle homeland security and the war in Iraq, and I suppose
that's the price we pay. Nobody locally is happy that the levees
can't be finished, and we are doing everything we can to make
the case that this is a security issue for us."
Why can't the US government focus on America's
needs and leave other countries alone? Why are American troops
in Iraq instead of protecting our own borders from a mass invasion
by illegal immigrants? Why are American helicopters blowing
up Iraqi homes instead of saving American homes in New Orleans?
How can the Bush administration be so incompetent as to expose
Americans at home to dire risks by exhausting American resources
in foolish foreign adventures? What kind
of "homeland security" is this?
All Bush has achieved by invading Iraq is to kill and wound
thousands of people while destroying America's reputation.
The only beneficiaries are oil companies capitalizing on a
good excuse to jack up the price of gasoline and Osama bin
Laden's recruitment.
What we have is a Republican war for oil company profits while
New Orleans sinks beneath the waters. [...]
Paul Craig Roberts has held a number of academic appointments
and has contributed to numerous scholarly publications. He
served as Assistant Secretary of the Treasury in the Reagan
administration. His graduate economics education was at the
University of Virginia, the University of California at Berkeley,
and Oxford University. He is coauthor of The Tyranny of Good
Intentions. He can be reached at: paulcraigroberts@yahoo.com |
Problems Escalate To 'Another
Level'
New Orleans Mayor Ray Nagin is "very upset"
that an attempt to fix the breach in the levee at the 17th Street
canal has failed, and he said the challenges that the city is
facing have "escalated to another level." [...]
Nagin said the sandbagging was scheduled
for midday, but the Blackhawk helicopters needed to help
did not show up. He said the sandbags were ready and all
the helicopter had to do was "show up."
He said after his afternoon helicopter tour of the city,
he was assured that officials had a plan and a timeline to
drop the sandbags on the levee breach.
He said he was told that the helicopters may have been diverted
to rescue about 1,000 people in a church, but
he is still not sure who gave the order.
He advised people still trapped in New Orleans to evacuate
to the west bank area if they can safely get there.
"If they can't, (they should) seek higher ground,"
the mayor said.
He said the water that is flowing out of the breach, which
is about a 2-block breach at the 17th Street canal, will continue
to flow "unimpeded at an accelerated level within 12 to
15 hours." [...] |
In 2001,
FEMA warned that a hurricane striking New Orleans was one of
the three most likely disasters in the U.S. But the Bush administration
cut New Orleans flood control funding by 44 percent to pay
for the Iraq war.
Biblical in its uncontrolled rage and scope, Hurricane Katrina
has left millions of Americans to scavenge for food and shelter
and hundreds to thousands reportedly dead. With its main
levee broken, the evacuated city of New Orleans has become
part of the Gulf of Mexico. But the damage wrought by the
hurricane may not entirely be the result of an act of nature.
A year ago the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
proposed to study how New Orleans could be protected from
a catastrophic hurricane, but the Bush administration ordered
that the research not be undertaken.
After a flood killed six people in 1995, Congress created
the Southeast Louisiana Urban Flood Control Project, in which
the Corps of Engineers strengthened and renovated levees and
pumping stations. In early 2001, the Federal Emergency Management
Agency issued a report stating that a hurricane striking New
Orleans was one of the three most likely disasters in the U.S.,
including a terrorist attack on New York City.
But by 2003 the federal funding for
the flood control project essentially dried up as it was
drained into the Iraq war. In
2004, the Bush administration cut funding requested by the
New Orleans district of the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
for holding back the waters of Lake Pontchartrain by more
than 80 percent. Additional cuts at the beginning of this
year (for a total reduction in funding of 44.2 percent since
2001) forced the New Orleans district of the Corps to impose
a hiring freeze. The Senate had debated adding funds
for fixing New Orleans' levees, but it was too late.
The New Orleans Times-Picayune, which before the hurricane
published a series on the federal funding problem, and whose
presses are now underwater, reported online: "No one can
say they didn't see it coming ... Now in the wake of one of
the worst storms ever, serious questions are being asked about
the lack of preparation."
The Bush administration's policy of turning over wetlands
to developers almost certainly also contributed to the heightened
level of the storm surge. In 1990, a federal task force began
restoring lost wetlands surrounding New Orleans. Every two
miles of wetland between the Crescent City and the Gulf reduces
a surge by half a foot. Bush had promised "no net loss" of
wetlands, a policy launched by his father's administration
and bolstered by President Clinton. But he reversed his approach
in 2003, unleashing the developers. The Army Corps of Engineers
and the Environmental Protection Agency then announced they
could no longer protect wetlands unless they were somehow related
to interstate commerce.
In response to this potential crisis, four leading environmental
groups conducted a joint expert study, concluding in 2004 that
without wetlands protection New Orleans could be devastated
by an ordinary, much less a Category 4 or 5, hurricane. "There's
no way to describe how mindless a policy that is when it comes
to wetlands protection," said one of the report's authors.
The chairman of the White House's Council on Environmental
Quality dismissed the study as "highly questionable," and
boasted, "Everybody loves what we're doing."
"My administration's climate change policy will be science
based," President Bush declared in June 2001. But in 2002,
when the Environmental Protection Agency submitted a study
on global warming to the United Nations reflecting its expert
research, Bush derided it as "a report put out by a bureaucracy,"
and excised the climate change assessment from the agency's
annual report. The next year, when the EPA issued its first
comprehensive "Report on the Environment,"
stating, "Climate change has global consequences for human
health and the environment," the White House simply demanded
removal of the line and all similar conclusions. At the G-8
meeting in Scotland this year, Bush successfully stymied any
common action on global warming. Scientists, meanwhile, have
continued to accumulate impressive data on the rising temperature
of the oceans, which has produced more severe hurricanes.
In February 2004, 60 of the nation's leading scientists, including
20 Nobel laureates, warned in a statement,
"Restoring Scientific Integrity in Policymaking":
"Successful application of science has played a large
part in the policies that have made the United States of America
the world's most powerful nation and its citizens increasingly
prosperous and healthy ... Indeed, this principle has long
been adhered to by presidents and administrations of both parties
in forming and implementing policies. The administration of
George W. Bush has, however, disregarded this principle ...
The distortion of scientific knowledge for partisan political
ends must cease." Bush completely ignored this statement.
In the two weeks preceding the storm in the Gulf, the trumping
of science by ideology and expertise by special interests accelerated.
The Federal Drug Administration announced that it was postponing
sale of the morning-after contraceptive pill, despite overwhelming
scientific evidence of its safety and its approval by the FDA's
scientific advisory board. The United Nations special envoy
for HIV/AIDS in Africa accused the Bush administration of responsibility
for a condom shortage in Uganda -- the result of the administration's
evangelical Christian agenda of "abstinence."
When the chief of the Bureau of Justice
Statistics in the Justice Department was ordered by the White
House to delete its study that African-Americans and other
minorities are subject to racial profiling in police traffic
stops and he refused to buckle under, he was forced out of
his job. When the Army Corps of Engineers' chief contracting
oversight analyst objected to a $7 billion no-bid contract
awarded for work in Iraq to Halliburton (the firm at which
Vice President Cheney was formerly CEO), she was demoted
despite her superior professional ratings. At the National
Park Service, a former Cheney aide, a political appointee
lacking professional background, drew up a plan to overturn
past environmental practices and prohibit any mention of
evolution while allowing sale of religious materials through
the Park Service.
On the day the levees burst in New Orleans, Bush delivered
a speech in Colorado comparing the Iraq war to World War II
and himself to Franklin D. Roosevelt: "And he knew that
the best way to bring peace and stability to the region was
by bringing freedom to Japan."
Bush had boarded his very own "Streetcar Named Desire." |
Paramedic Rescue Operation
I have finally reconnected with my best friend who is a
paramedic who was sent from Georgia 2 days ago to Gulf Port,
Mississippi before the hurricane hit.
He just reached me within the last 10 mins via emergency cell
phone to tell me he was alive.
Thousands of bodies have been discovered throughout Mississippi
in Gulf Port, Waveland,Hancock County,Bay of St.Louis.
They are hanging in trees and they are pulling them out 30
at a time. Entire families found drowned in their homes and
washing up on shore.
The stories he could tell me were brief. National Guard is
on the scene and arresting anyone seen on the streets.
The numbers are staggering and what
I have been told tonight will shake people to their foundation
as the numbers will be coming out in the next 24-hours of
just how many people have actually perished in these and
3 other beach communities.
|
For schoolteacher Jared Wood the scariest
moment of Hurricane Katrina was not the killer winds or waters,
it was the looter threatening to thrash him for trying to take
his picture.
With most of New Orleans submerged and thousands of people
trapped by waters strewn with bodies, authorities also fought
an outbreak of plundering by locals taking away food, appliances,
jewels, clothes and even guns.
But when their food ran out in Katrina's wake, the 29-year-old
Wood and his companion Erin O'Shea, 28, both normally law-abiding
teachers from upper New York State, judged it necessary to
join the larcenous throngs.
"We looted a store because we
had no food and we had to do something," Wood
told AFP outside their French Quarter hotel while waiting
for a ride to nearby Baton Rouge. "It was really scary
while we were in there."
The pair said they leapt through a smashed window of a local
Winn-Dixie supermarket and started to stock up on soup, power
bars and soy milk while other looters gathered armfuls of soda
and beer.
"We were trying to get stuff that would sustain us. Some
people were going by and they had a plant,"
O'Shea said, shrugging in disbelief at the range of items hauled
away.
She said that in the aftermath of Katrina, an intelligence
network sprouted on the largely deserted streets of New Orleans
letting looters know where the best pickings were.
"It's all hush hush, word of mouth thing. We've been
finding out just by traveling around," O'Shea said.
But any camraderie among thieves stopped when Wood whipped
out a camera and tried to take pictures of the looting in the
Winn-Dixie shop.
"This guy was saying, 'Give me your camera or I'm going
to beat the crap out of you,'" O'Shea said.
Wood also shuddered at the memory. "That guy wanted to
kill me. It wasn't my smartest moment."
The pair saw one man scrounging among shelves of pharmaceuticals,
apparently for drugs. But the teachers were more interested
in getting their hands on O'Shea's favorite tabloid fare.
"So we took her Star magazine and we got out,"
Wood said.
Jeanette Brase, a 76-year-old retiree from the midwestern
state of Iowa who was visiting New Orleans with her husband,
said the looting was the only frightening part of her ordeal.
She never thought she would witness such behavior first-hand,
Brase said after seeing looters stream in and out of a local
pharmacy: "It's something you hear about and see on TV."
"It's actually kind of sickening. I don't know if they
(the police) can stop them or if they just have too much to
do."
Rosemary Rimmer-Clay, 51, a social worker from Brighton, England,
who was here with her two grown sons, said Katrina made her
trip "90 percent boredom and 10 percent sheer terror."
"The police said there was rioting and we saw people
running with bags full of inappropriate items. It looked quite
dodgy," she said. "It felt like a film set and we
were in the middle of it."
Authorities sought to tighten security, with gangs of armed
men reported roaming the city and one store emptied of its
entire collection of weapons, according to the Times-Picayune
newspaper.
One police officer was shot in the head but was expected to
survive, the newspaper said.
In the Mississippi town of Biloxi, thieves were reported to
have taken slot machines from devastated casinos.
Louisiana governor Kathleen Blanco said looting was a growing
problem but not the top priority. "We don't like looters
one bit, but first and foremost is search and rescue," she
said.
At least one looter, however, was feeling pangs of remorse.
O'Shea said she and Wood had to return home by Tuesday in
time for the start of classes and "I plan on sending a
check to the Winn-Dixie for 50 dollars when I get back." |
Tuesday night, as water rose to 20 feet
through most of New Orleans, CNN relayed an advisory that food
in refrigerators would last only four hours, would have to
be thrown out. The next news item from
CNN was an indignant bellow about
"looters" of 7/11s and a Walmart. Making
no attempt to conceal the racist flavor of the coverage, the
press openly describes white survivors as "getting food
from a flooded store," while blacks engaged in the same
struggle for survival are smeared as "looters."
The reverence for property is now the underlying theme of
many newscasts, with defense of The Gap being almost the
first order of duty for the forces of law and order. But
the citizens looking for clothes to wear and food to eat
are made of tougher fiber and are more desperate than the
polite demonstrators who guarded The Gap and kindred chains
in Seattle in 1999. The police in New Orleans are only patrolling
in large armed groups. One spoke of "meeting
some resistance," as if the desperate citizens of New
Orleans were Iraqi insurgents.
While I must admit the footage of two NOPD ladies looting
a Wal-Mart was priceless, the sanctimonious and unmistakably
racist tone of the correspondent (and Tucker himself) was
apalling. This was certainly not confined to MSNBC, though.
A sidenote: During the shot inside
the Wal-Mart, the correspondent hounded the looters, who
were loading up on supplies and a few choice gifts for
their children, one man said to him that no one was worried
about their lives, so why in the bloody hell would he worry
about Wal-Mart's profit-loss ratio? Though
I don't endorse looting, he has a point there. Cable
news focused sharply on the forgotten and abandoned of
New Orleans while not mentioning once (I withstood it all
for around 3.5 hours) that these were folks of our very
own Third World, the most economically disenfranchised
class in the States. Where was the bus convoy to guide
them to safety. In state government and FEMA terms, that
would've been a pennance.
Also on Tuesday night the newscasts were reporting that in
a city whose desperate state is akin the Dacca in Bangladesh
a few years ago, there were precisely
seven Coast Guard helicopters in operation. Where
are the National Guard helicopters? Presumably strafing Iraqi
citizens on the roads outside Baghdad and Fallujah.
As the war's unpopularity soars, there will be millions asking,
Why is the National Guard in Iraq, instead of helping the afflicted
along the Gulf in the first crucial hours, before New Orleans,
Biloxi, and Mobile turn into toxic toilet bowls with thousands
marooned on the tops of houses?
As thousands of trapped residents face the real prospect of
perishing for lack of a way out of the flooding city, Bush's
first response was to open the spigots of the Strategic Petroleum
Reserve at the request of oil companies and to order the EPA
to eliminate Clean Air standards at power plants and oil referiners
across the nation, supposedly to increase fuel supplies--a
goal long sought by his cronies at the big oil companies.
In his skittish Rose Garden press conference, Bush told the
imperiled people of the Gulf Coast not to worry, the Corps
of Engineers was on the way to begin the reconstruction of
the Southland. But these are the same
cadre of engineers, who after three years of work, have yet
to get water and electrical power running in Baghdad for more
than three hours a day.
It didn't have to be this bad. The entire city of New Orleans
needn't have been lost. Hundreds of people need not have perished. Yet,
it now seems clear that the Bush administration sacrificed
New Orleans to pursue its mad war on Iraq.
As the New Orleans Times-Picayune has reported in a devastating
series of articles over the last two years, city and state
officials and the Corps of Enginners had repeatedly requested
funding to strengthen the levees along Lake Pontchartrain that
breeched in the wake of the flood. But the Bush administration
rebuffed the requests repeatedly, reprograming the funding
from levee enhancement to Homeland Security and the war on
Iraq.
This year the Bush administration slashed
funding for the New Orleans Corps of Engineers by $71.2 million,
a stunning 44.2 percent reduction from its 2001 levels. A
Corps report noted at the time that "major hurricane
and flood protection projects will not be awarded to local
engineering firms. . . . Also, a study to determine ways
to protect the region from a Category 5 hurricane has been
shelved for now."
Work on the 17th Street levee, which breached
on Monday night, came to a halt earlier this summer for the
lack of $2 million.
"It appears that the money has been moved in the president's
budget to handle homeland security and the war in Iraq, and
I suppose that's the price we pay,"
Walter Maestri, emergency management chief for Jefferson Parish,
Louisiana told the Times-Picayune in June of last year. "Nobody
locally is happy that the levees can't be finished, and we
are doing everything we can to make the case that this is a
security issue for us."
These are damning revelations that should
fuel calls from both parties for Bush's resignation or impeachment.
The greatest concern for poor people in these days has come
from President Hugo Chavez of Venezuela, who
fresh from a chat with Fidel Castro, has announced that
Venezuela will be offering America's poor discounted gas through
its Citgo chain. He's says his price will knock out the predatory
pricing at every American pump. Citgo should issue to purchasers
of each tankful of gas vouchers for free medical consultations
via the internet with the Cuban doctors in Venezuela.
No politician in America has raised the issue of predatory
pricing as gasoline soars above $3. The last time there was
any critical talk about the oil companies was thirty years
ago.
Maybe the terrible disaster along the
Gulf coast will awaken people to the unjust ways in which
our society works. That's often the effect of natural
disasters, as with the Mexican earthquake, where the laggardly
efforts of the police prompted ordinary citizens to take
matters into their own hands. |
Bring
Them Home...NOW!
The National Guard Belongs in New Orleans and Biloxi. Not Baghdad |
By NORMAN SOLOMON
August 31, 2005 |
The men and women of the National Guard
shouldn't be killing in Iraq. They should be helping in New
Orleans and Biloxi.
The catastrophic hurricane was an act of God. But the U.S.
war effort in Iraq is a continuing act of the president.
And now, that effort is hampering the capacity of the National
Guard to save lives at home.
Before the flooding of New Orleans drastically escalated on
Tuesday, the White House tried to disarm questions that could
be politically explosive. "To those of you who are concerned
about whether or not we're prepared to help, don't be, we are," President
Bush said. "We're in place, we've got equipment in place,
supplies in place, and once the -- once we're able to assess
the damage, we'll be able to move in and help those good folks
in the affected areas."
Echoing the official assurances, CBS
News reported: "Even though more than a third of Mississippi's
and Louisiana's National Guard troops are either in Iraq
or supporting the war effort, the National Guard says there
are more than enough at home to do the job."
But after New Orleans levees collapsed
and the scope of the catastrophe became more clear, such
reassuring claims lost credibility. The Washington
Post reported on Wednesday: "With thousands of their
citizen-soldiers away fighting in Iraq, states hit hard by
Hurricane Katrina scrambled to muster forces for rescue and
security missions yesterday -- calling up Army bands and
water-purification teams, among other units, and requesting
help from distant states and the active-duty military."
The back-page Post story added: "National Guard officials
in the states acknowledged that the scale of the destruction
is stretching the limits of available manpower while placing
another extraordinary demand on their troops -- most of whom
have already served tours in Iraq or Afghanistan or in homeland
defense missions since 2001."
Speaking for the Mississippi National Guard, Lt. Andy Thaggard
said: "Missing the personnel is the big thing in this
particular event. We need our people." According
to the Washington Post, the Mississippi National Guard "has
a brigade of more than 4,000 troops in central Iraq" while "Louisiana
also has about 3,000 Guard troops in Baghdad."
National Guard troops don't belong in Iraq. They should be
rescuing and protecting in Louisiana and Mississippi, not patrolling
and killing in a country that was invaded on the basis of presidential
deception. They should be fighting the effects of flood waters
at home -- helping people in the communities they know best
-- not battling Iraqi people who want them to go away.
Let's use the Internet today to forward and
post this demand so widely that the politicians in Washington
can no longer ignore it:
Bring the National Guard home. Immediately.
Norman Solomon is the author of the new book "War
Made Easy: How Presidents and Pundits Keep Spinning Us to
Death." |
WASHINGTON - Hurricane
Katrina is likely to have only a modest impact on the U.S.
economy as long as the hit to the energy sector proves transitory,
White House economic adviser Ben Bernanke said on Wednesday.
"Clearly, it's going to affect the Gulf Coast economy
quite a bit," Bernanke told CNBC television.
"That's going to be enough to have at least a noticeable
or at least some impact on the aggregate (national) data.
"Looking forward ... reconstruction is going to add jobs
and growth to the economy," he added. "As
long as we find that the energy impact is only temporary and
there's not permanent damage to the infrastructure, my guess
is that the effects on the overall economy will be fairly modest."
He added that most indications suggested the effect on the
energy sector would indeed be temporary.
Bernanke, chairman of President George W. Bush's Council of
Economic Advisers, said the administration's decision to release
oil from emergency stockpiles should be helpful.
"There are some petroleum refineries that don't have
crude and by allowing them to draw from the Strategic Petroleum
Reserve they will be able to produce more gasoline," he
said.
Bernanke said the bond market's reaction to the hurricane,
pushing market-set interest rates lower, showed more concern
about the potential hit to growth than to the risk of a broad
inflation surge due to soaring energy prices.
"I think that is a vote of confidence
in the Federal Reserve," the former Fed governor said. "People
are confident that inflation will be low despite these shocks
to gasoline and oil prices." |
WASHINGTON -- President Bush sought Thursday
to reassure victims of Hurricane Katrina that the federal government
was doing its best to send aid to the thousands of displaced
and stranded people.
"I understand the anxiety of people on the ground,"
Bush told ABC's "Good Morning America." "...
But I want people to know there's a lot of help coming."
Bush said he would visit the affected areas, but the trip
was still being coordinated.
Bush surveyed Katrina's destruction from Air Force One on
his way from Crawford, Texas, to Washington Wednesday.
Back at the White House, he announced
a massive federal mobilization to help victims of the storm,
but said recovery "will take years."
"We're dealing with one of the worst natural disasters
in our nation's history," Bush said in an address from
the Rose Garden, surrounded by members of his Cabinet.
"I can't tell you how devastating the sights were."
"The folks on the Gulf Coast are going to need the help
of this country for a long time. This is going to be a difficult
road. The challenges that we face on the ground are unprecedented,
but there's no doubt in my mind that we're going to succeed." (Transcript)
He told communities affected by the storm, "The country
stands with you" and pledged, "We'll do all in our
power to help you."
Bush announced that he has created a Cabinet-level task force
to coordinate hurricane relief efforts across federal agencies,
headed by Homeland Security Director Michael Chertoff.
The head of the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA),
Michael Brown, will be in charge of the federal response on
the ground in Louisiana, Mississippi and Alabama.
The White House also announced Wednesday
that Bush has asked his father, former President George H.W.
Bush, and former President Bill Clinton to spearhead an international
relief effort for hurricane victims, similar to the effort
they undertook for victims of last year's tsunami in South
Asia.
Bush said the federal government's first priority is to rescue
those still trapped and provide medical assistance. FEMA, the
Coast Guard and the Department of Defense have sent resources
to help with the search-and-rescue effort, he said.
The federal government also will use more than 400 trucks
from the Department of Transportation to bring food, water
and supplies to those whose homes have been damaged or destroyed,
and plans are being made to provide housing, education and
health care for the displaced, he said.
The president said the federal government would also undertake
a "comprehensive recovery effort"
to rebuild devastated communities and restore infrastructure,
including roads and bridges wiped out by Katrina, an effort
he said would take years. [...]
Bush also braced the country for a coming
surge in energy prices in the wake of the destruction Katrina
wrought on oil production in the Gulf of Mexico.
The Department of Energy is releasing supplies from the nation's
Strategic Petroleum Reserve to limit disruptions of supplies
to oil refineries, which "will help take some pressure
off of gas prices," and the Environmental Protection Agency
has waived rules requiring low-pollution blends in some areas
in order to increase availability of gas and diesel, he said.
"But our citizens must understand
this storm has disrupted the capacity to make gasoline and
distribute gasoline," the president said. [...] |
Shippers on the Mississippi
river are warning of disruption to supply chains and logistics
across North America as the commercial impact of Hurricane
Katrina extends far beyond initial worries about energy markets.
The port of New Orleans, a major
gateway for commodities from grain to steel, remains closed while
damage to navigational aids and debris also prevents larger
ocean-going vessels from entering the Mississippi.
Rick Couch, president of Osprey shipping line, said: "This
comes at a very bad time with the US agricultural harvest
just a few weeks away. Some traffic can be diverted to Houston
and ports upriver, but congestion is already building up."
Chemical plants and manufacturers have also warned that damage
to local transport infrastructure could hinder recovery efforts
after earlier shutdowns.
Big US retailers have been pushing to restock and resupply
their stores in the hurricane-affected areas, with Wal-Mart
and Home Depot setting up emergency centres at their headquarters
to co-ordinate operations.
But the direct impact of the storm on sales at national chains
will be offset by their comparatively limited exposure in Louisiana
and Mississippi, whose combined population of around 7.5m is
less than half the size of Florida's 17.4m. New Orleans itself
is the 35th largest retail market in the US in terms of square
footage of retail space, according to the International Council
of Shopping Centers.
Traditionally, hurricane damage has resulted in stronger sales
for home improvement retailers.
"I see complete disaster with flooding
prevalent, so while Home Depot and Lowes might benefit in the
longer term, in the short term I don't think there's going
to be much of anything going on,"
said Bill Sims, a retail analyst at Citigroup.
Higher fuel prices and operational disruptions resulting from
the storm will add to problems faced by struggling US airlines
such as Delta Air Lines and Flyi, the parent company of Independence
Air.
"Delta is already bleeding cash
and at near-term risk of insolvency. The added financial
pressure may hasten an already likely bankruptcy filing,
which will probably occur within weeks," said
Standard Poors, the debt ratings agency. "Closure of
refineries...is already raising gasoline prices significantly
and is having an effect on jet fuel, as well,"
S&P said. |
Airlines and oil companies
are working on plans to supply jet fuel to at least ten U.S.
airports that could be shut down due to a lack of jet fuel
caused by refinery and pipeline shutdowns from hurricane Katrina.
The airports in most jeopardy for closure include Atlanta,
Charlotte, Ft. Lauderdale, Ft. Myers, Orlando, Tampa, Washington
Dulles and West Palm Beach.
AAG has learned that ChevronTexaco and Shell had cargoes
loaded prior to the shutdowns destined for Florida ports.
However, with the Colonial and Plantation pipelines shutdown
due to a lost of power it could be sometime for shipments
to reach airports from Atlanta to Washington D.C.
With future supply uncertain, airlines are working on plans
to allocate jet fuel at critically short airports. While some
airports may have up to five days of supply we have to expect
that we won't receive additional shipments for some time. We
either run down to flumes or we try to make it last as long
as possible, said one airline fuel manager. Today, airlines
are working on plans to allocate fuel in hopes of extending
available supply at problem locations.
Initial reports vary as to the extent of damage to Gulf Coast
refining. But a longer term problem
may not be refining infrastructure but providing shelter for
refinery workers.
"One of our refineries is scheduled to be back up soon
but our real problem is finding housing for our workers. Most
of their homes are destroyed or under water. Unless
we can solve the housing problem we will not be fully operational
for some time," said one major oil company representative. |
Lines at Atlanta area gas pumps grew along
with prices this afternoon as word spread of possible fuel
shortages.
By noon today, several metro Atlanta gas stations had posted
prices above $3.15 per gallon. Some
metro area stations were charging as much as $4.75 a gallon,
according to a Web site that keeps track of such things,
www.atlantagasprices.com.
Prices were rising so fast in some areas that
signs at gas stations no longer matched what was being charged
at the pumps.
Declaring that there's "credible evidence"
of price-gouging at the gas
pumps, Gov. Sonny Perdue late Wednesday signed an executive
order threatening to impose heavy fines on gasoline retailers
who overcharge Georgia drivers.
"When you prey upon the fears and the paranoia, it is
akin to looting, and it is abominable," Perdue said at
a hastily called, 6 p.m. press conference.
The anti-gouging law does not prevent retailers from selling
gas at higher rates but bars them from charging what the governor
called "unreasonable or egregious"
prices. It was last used after Hurricane Ivan hit Georgia.
Perdue also urged motorists to limit Labor Day vacation travel
if possible.
"There is no reason to panic. There
is plenty of gas on the way. The only way we would have problems
is if people rush out and try to horde and try to accumulate
gasoline they won't need for a while," the governor said
today. |
Ouch!
$6 gas near Atlanta
Georgia governor outlaws gouging as stations jack up cost, lines
form |
WorldNetDaily.com
Posted: August 31, 2005 |
As impacts of Hurricane Katrina affect
both the production and transportation of fuel, gas
stations in the Atlanta area today dramatically jacked up their
prices, with one charging $5.87
a gallon.
WSB-TV in Atlanta confirmed to WND that a retailer in a
rural area outside the city had priced its gas at $5.87,
and the TV station indicated it had another
unconfirmed report of $5.99. [...]
Most Atlanta stations that raised their prices placed them
at between $3.50 and $4.
There were '70s-era gas lines at several stations.
Mike Brown, owner of Georgetown Chevron in Chamblee, Ga.,
said his station had run out of gasoline.
"People are just lined up,'' he
told Bloomberg. "All of a sudden, people are panicking.'' [...]
Meanwhile, several gas stations in the
Milwaukee area ran out of fuel for several hours at a time,
having to post "Out of Gas"
signs at their pumps. The outages were blamed more on logistical
problems on the supply end than any increase in demand, Forbes.com
reported.
As WorldNetDaily reported, many of
the nation's truck drivers are encountering unprecedented
fuel rationing at truck stops as they brace for a spike in
prices. |
Hurricane Katrina while only
causing minor damage to NASA spaceport facilities along the
Gulf Coast is surrounded by a region facing long term recovery
problems that will impact the ability of work to be conducted
in the New Orleans area.
Reports say that NASA will relocate critical External Tank
work to Florida and aim for a May 2006 launch window as the
earliest date for a return to flight.
Damaged roofs and water leaks were found throughout the 832-acre
Michoud complex, where Lockheed Martin manufactures the shuttle's
external fuel tank.
In Michoud's main manufacturing building, concrete roof panels
were blown away by winds gusting to 125 mph, leaving a large
hole, the Orlando Sentinel reported.
Stennis Space Center is used by NASA to test rocket engines.
That facility reported serious roof and water damage. Stennis
is currently being used by state and federal officials as a
shelter and base for relief operations.
If NASA is to meet its March 4-19 launch window, a newly redesigned
fuel tank must leave Michoud by barge for Kennedy Space Center
by mid-November. NASA officials say the chance of that occurring
appears remote. The next launch window is May 3-22. |
NEW ORLEANS (AP) - New Orleans descended
into anarchy Thursday as corpses lay abandoned in street medians,
fights and fires broke out, cops turned in their badges and
the governor declared war on looters who have made the city
a menacing landscape of disorder and fear.
"They have M-16s and they're locked
and loaded," Gov. Kathleen Blanco said of 300 National
Guard troops who landed in New Orleans fresh
from duty in Iraq.
"These troops know how to shoot and kill, and they are
more than willing to do so, and I expect they will."
With 80 percent of New Orleans submerged, authorities
blamed the floods for their inability to get the relief
operation into high gear.
"For those who wonder why it is difficult
to get these supply and medical teams into place, the answer
is, they are battling an ongoing dynamic problem with the
water," said Homeland Security Chief Michael Chertoff.
Four days after Hurricane Katrina roared in with a devastating
blow that inflicted potentially thousands of deaths, the fear,
anger and violence mounted Thursday.
"I'm not sure I'm going to get
out of here alive," said Canadian tourist Larry Mitzel,
who handed a reporter his business card in case he goes missing. "I'm
scared of riots. I'm scared of the locals. We might get caught
in the crossfire."
The chaos deepened despite the promise
of 1,400 National Guardsmen a day to stop the looting,
plans for a $10 billion recovery bill in Congress and a government
relief effort President Bush called the biggest in U.S. history.
New Orleans' top emergency management official called that
effort a "national disgrace" and questioned when
reinforcements would actually reach the increasingly lawless
city.
About 15,000 to 20,000 people who had
taken shelter at New Orleans convention center grew
ever more hostile after waiting for buses for days amid the
filth and the dead. Police Chief Eddie Compass said there
was such a crush around a squad of
88 officers that they retreated when they went in
to check out reports of assaults.
"We have individuals who are getting raped, we have individuals
who are getting beaten," Compass said. "Tourists
are walking in that direction and they are getting preyed upon."
Col. Henry Whitehorn, chief of the Louisiana
State Police, said he heard of numerous instances of New Orleans
police officers - many of whom from flooded areas - turning
in their badges.
"They indicated that they had
lost everything and didn't feel that it was worth them going
back to take fire from looters and losing their lives," Whitehorn
said.
A military helicopter tried to land at the convention center
several times to drop off food and water. But the rushing crowd
forced the choppers to back off. Troopers then tossed the supplies
to the crowd from 10 feet off the ground and flew away.
In hopes of defusing the situation at the convention center,
Mayor Ray Nagin gave the refugees permission to march across
a bridge to the city's unflooded west bank for whatever relief
they could find. But the bedlam made that difficult.
"This is a desperate SOS,"
Nagin said in a statement. "Right now we are out of resources
at the convention center and don't anticipate enough buses."
At least seven bodies were scattered outside the convention
center, a makeshift staging area for those rescued from rooftops,
attics and highways. The sidewalks were
packed with people without food, water or medical care, and
with no sign of law enforcement.
An old man in a chaise lounge lay dead in
a grassy median as hungry babies wailed around him. Around
the corner, an elderly woman lay dead in her wheelchair, covered
up by a blanket, and another body lay beside her wrapped in
a sheet.
"I don't treat my dog like that,"
47-year-old Daniel Edwards said as he pointed at the woman
in the wheelchair.
"You can do everything for other countries,
but you can't do nothing for your own people,"
he added. "You can go overseas with the military, but
you can't get them down here."
The street outside the center, above the floodwaters, smelled
of urine and feces, and was choked with dirty diapers, old
bottles and garbage.
"They've been teasing us with buses for four days,"
Edwards said. "They're telling us they're going to come
get us one day, and then they don't show up."
Every so often, an armored state police vehicle cruised in
front of the convention center with four or five officers in
riot gear with automatic weapons. But
there was no sign of help from the National Guard.
At one point the crowd began to chant "We want help!
We want help!" Later, a woman, screaming, went on the
front steps of the convention center and led the crowd in reciting
the 23rd Psalm, "The Lord is my shepherd ..."
"We are out here like pure animals," the Issac Clark
said.
"We've got people dying out here - two babies have died,
a woman died, a man died," said Helen Cheek. "We
haven't had no food, we haven't had no water, we haven't had
nothing. They just brought us here and dropped us."
Tourist Debbie Durso of Washington, Mich.,
said she asked a police officer for assistance and his response
was, "'Go to hell - it's every man for himself.'"
"This is just insanity," she said. "We have
no food, no water ... all these trucks and buses go by and
they do nothing but wave."
FEMA director Michael Brown said the agency
just learned about the situation at the convention center Thursday
and quickly scrambled to provide food, water and medical care
and remove the corpses.
The director of the Federal Emergency
Management Agency said Thursday those New Orleans residents
who chose not to heed warnings to evacuate before Hurricane
Katrina bear some responsibility for their fates.
Michael Brown also agreed with other public officials that
the death toll in the city could reach into the thousands.
"Unfortunately, that's going to be
attributable a lot to people who did not heed the advance
warnings," Brown told CNN.
"I don't make judgments about why people chose not
to leave but, you know, there was a mandatory evacuation
of New Orleans," he said.
"And to find people still there is just heart-wrenching
to me because, you know, the mayor did everything he could
to get them out of there.
"So, we've got to figure out some way to convince people
that whenever warnings go out it's for their own good," Brown
said. "Now, I don't want to
second guess why they did that. My job now is to get relief
to them."
Brown was upbeat in his assessment of
the relief effort so far, ticking off a list of accomplishments: more
than 30,000 National Guard troops will be in the city within
three days, the hospitals are being evacuated and
search and rescue missions are continuing. [...]
Asked later on CNN how he could blame
the victims, many of whom could not flee the storm because
they had no transportation or were too frail to evacuate
on their own, Brown said he was not blaming anyone.
"Now is not
the time to be blaming," Brown said. "Now
is the time to recognize that whether they chose to evacuate
or chose not to evacuate, we have to help them."
Speaking on CNN's "Larry King Live," Homeland
Security Secretary Michael Chertoff said the evacuation of
New Orleans should be completed by the end of the weekend.
At the hot and stinking Superdome, where 30,000 were being
evacuated by bus to the Houston Astrodome, fistfights and fires
erupted amid a seething sea of tense, suffering people who
waited in a lines that stretched a half-mile to board yellow
school buses.
After a traffic jam kept buses from arriving for nearly four
hours, a near-riot broke out in the
scramble to get on the buses that finally did show up, with
a group of refugees breaking through a line of heavily armed
National Guardsmen.
One military policeman was shot in the leg as he and a man
scuffled for the MP's rifle, police Capt. Ernie Demmo said.
The man was arrested.
Some of those among the mostly poor
crowd had been in the dome for four days without air conditioning,
working toilets or a place to bathe. An ambulance
service airlifting the sick and injured out of the Superdome
suspended flights as too dangerous after it
was reported that a bullet was fired at a military
helicopter.
NEW ORLEANS, Louisiana (CNN) -- The evacuation of patients
from Charity Hospital was halted Thursday after the facility came
under sniper fire twice. [...]
"A single sniper or two snipers shouldn't
have to shut down a hospital evacuation for two hours now," Dr.
Ruth Berggren told CNN.
"I look outside, I'm not seeing any military."
Berggren's husband, Dr. Tyler Curiel, witnessed both incidents.
"We were coming in from a parking deck at Tulane Medical
Center, and a guy in a white shirt
started firing at us," Curiel said. "The
National Guard [troops], wearing flak jackets, tried to get
a bead on this guy. "
"If they're just taking us anywhere, just anywhere, I
say praise God," said refugee John Phillip. "Nothing
could be worse than what we've been through."
By Thursday evening, 11 hours after the military began evacuating
the Superdome, the arena held 10,000 more people than it did
at dawn. National Guard Capt. John Pollard said evacuees from
around the city poured into the Superdome and swelled the crowd
to about 30,000 because they believed the arena was the best
place to get a ride out of town.
As he watched a line snaking for blocks through
ankle-deep waters, New Orleans' emergency operations chief
Terry Ebbert blamed the inadequate response on the Federal
Emergency Management Agency.
"This is not a FEMA operation. I haven't
seen a single FEMA guy," he said. He added: "We can
send massive amounts of aid to tsunami victims, but we can't
bail out the city of New Orleans."
FEMA officials said some operations had to be suspended in
areas where gunfire has broken out, but are working overtime
to feed people and restore order.
A day after Nagin took 1,500 police officers off search-and-rescue
duty to try to restore order in the streets, there were continued
reports of looting, shootings, gunfire and carjackings - and
not all the crimes were driven by greed.
When some hospitals try to airlift patients, Coast Guard Lt.
Cmdr. Cheri Ben-Iesan said, "there are people just taking
potshots at police and at helicopters, telling them, 'You better
come get my family.'"
Outside a looted Rite-Aid drugstore, some
people were anxious to show they needed what they were taking.
A gray-haired man who would not give his name pulled up his
T-shirt to show a surgery scar and explained that he needs
pads for incontinence.
"I'm a Christian. I feel bad going in
there," he said.
Earl Baker carried toothpaste, toothbrushes and deodorant.
"Look, I'm only getting necessities," he said.
"All of this is personal hygiene. I ain't getting nothing
to get drunk or high with."
Several thousand storm victims had arrived in Houston by Thursday
night, and they quickly got hot meals, showers and some much-needed
rest.
Audree Lee, 37, was thrilled after getting a shower and hearing
her teenage daughter's voice on the telephone for the first
time since the storm. Lee had relatives take her daughter to
Alabama so she would be safe.
"I just cried. She cried. We cried together,"
Lee said. "She asked me about her dog. They wouldn't let
me take her dog with me. ... I know the dog is gone now."
While floodwaters in the city appeared to stabilize, efforts
continued to plug three breaches that had opened up in the
levee system that protects this below-sea-level city.
Helicopters dropped sandbags into the breach and pilings were
being pounded into the mouth of the canal Thursday to close
its connection to Lake Pontchartrain, state Transportation
Secretary Johnny Bradberry said. The next step called for using
about 250 concrete road barriers to seal the gap.
In Washington, the White House said
Bush will tour the devastated Gulf Coast region on Friday and
has asked his father, former President George H.W. Bush,
and former President Clinton to lead a private fund-raising
campaign for victims.
The president urged a crackdown on the lawlessness.
"I think there ought to be zero tolerance of people breaking
the law during an emergency such as this - whether it be looting,
or price gouging at the gasoline pump, or taking advantage
of charitable giving or insurance fraud," Bush said. "And
I've made that clear to our attorney general. The citizens
ought to be working together."
Donald Dudley, a 55-year-old New Orleans
seafood merchant, complained that when he and other hungry
refugees broke into the kitchen of the convention center and
tried to prepare food, the National Guard chased them away.
"They pulled guns and told us we
had to leave that kitchen or they would blow our damn brains
out," he said. "We don't want their help.
Give us some vehicles and we'll get ourselves out of here!" |
"Free people are free to make mistakes and commit crimes
and do bad things. For suddenly the biggest problem in the
world to be looting is really notable."
- Sec-Def Donald Rumsfeld 4-11-03; comments on the looting
of Baghdad
The changes that are taking place in the military under
the deceptive name of "transformation" have nothing
to do with national defense. Rather, the military is being
converted into a taxpayer-subsidized security apparatus for
multinational corporations. Its primary task is to seize
dwindling resources through force of arms and crush indigenous
movements that resist US aggression.
On the home front, the changes brought on by transformation
are equally dramatic. Traditional defenses
provided by the National Guard have been substantially weakened
to allow the Pentagon to insert itself into domestic affairs
and establish an ongoing military presence within the United
States. Donald Rumsfeld has already stated that the
military will play a greater role in dealing with the aftereffects
of any future terrorist attack. There's no doubt that he will
honor that commitment.
The media has echoed the government line that transformation
is simply intended to revamp the military for the wars of the
next century. They have highlighted the effects of base closures
on local economies and unemployment. They have also emphasized
the Pentagon's intention to create smaller, more agile military
units that can be quickly deployed anywhere around the world
in less than 48 hours. But, the media have avoided analyzing
the overall objectives of these changes or their effect on
homeland security.
Rumsfeld has savaged the National Guard;
40% of who are now serving in Iraq. That means, that the
American people are 40% "less safe"
in the event of terrorist attack or a natural disaster, like
Hurricane Katrina, regardless of how one looks at it. Instead
of strengthening the damaged Guard, Rumsfeld is executing a
plan that will wreak further havoc on domestic preparedness
and expose the American public to even greater risk.
For example, "Rumsfeld called for 30 Air Guard units
scattered around many states to lose their aircraft and flying
missions." (Liz Sidot; Ass Press 8- 27-05) How can the
states be expected to conduct routine patrols or reconnaissance
missions if their planes have been taken by Washington? And,
why would Rumsfeld want to take them when more terrorist attacks
are expected in the future?
In Pennsylvania Rumsfeld tried to "dissolve the Pennsylvania
Air National Guard division without the Governor's authority".
(Ass Press)
Why?
The move was a conspicuous attempt to undermine Pennsylvania's
defenses and put more power under the direct control of the
Defense Dept.
Rumsfeld also tried to "transfer"
all 15 "Pacific Northwest and Oregon National Guard fighter
jets that patrolled Seattle's skies after 9-11"; leaving
the region with no protection from aerial assault. (Northwest's
F- 15's Should Stay Put" Seattle PI staff, 8-27-05) Consider
the risk to a "target-rich"
area like the Pacific Northwest, with its exposed industries,
harbors and nuclear power plants, if it was stripped of its
first line of defense?
Rumsfeld's behavior has been identical everywhere across the
country. He is determined to undermine the National Guard and
limit the states' ability to protect themselves against attack. His
intention is to smash America's internal defenses, which are
currently under control of the states' governors, and introduce
the military into homeland security. It is a clear attempt
to centralize authority and further militarize the country.
By weakening America's defenses, Rumsfeld has paved the way
for deploying troops and aircraft within the country and setting
the precedent for a permanent military presence within the
nation. It is one giant step towards
direct military rule.
There is no other conceivable reason for weakening national
defense during a period when there is an increased likelihood
of a terrorist incident.
Rumsfeld's conduct is hardly surprising. He has a long history
of support for military regimes. Just months ago he was coaching
South American leaders to resume their use of the military
in domestic policing activities to undercut the Leftist political
movements that are at the forefront of change throughout the
region. It's clear that he has something similar in mind for
the American people.
Are we talking about the possibility of martial law?
We only need to look at developments in England to know what
Americans could be facing following another terrorist attack.
Tony Blair has managed to manipulate the London bombings into
a mandate for regressive "anti-terror"
legislation that suspends habeas corpus, due process, and the
presumption of innocence.
Blair is now claiming the right to deport Muslims without
judicial review, suspend free speech, and use deadly force
against terrorist suspects. At the same time, he has concealed
his motives behind a public relations smokescreen that make
his actions look like they are a reasonable response to a national
security threat. In fact, Blair's actions are part of a broader
strategy to eviscerate civil liberties for the Islamic community. The
Prime Minister's "The rules of the game have changed" speech;
was a carefully scripted declaration of martial law for Muslims.
The American people can expect similar edicts from Washington
following the next terrorist attack at home.
Transformation and Foreign Policy
When the military is adapted to the narrow interests of elites
it becomes little more than a resource-acquisition tool; a
bloody-weapon to be used by private industry. We can see the
effects of this in both Iraq and Afghanistan, where the military
is providing security for the corporations that are extracting
the regional resources. It's nothing more than massive "protections-racket" designed
to legitimize theft.
The goal of transformation is to make the military conform
to the corporate model; converting it into a top-down, highly-technological
mechanism programmed for maximum efficiency and lethality.
The Pentagon is no longer expecting to fight large territorial
conflicts, but instead is developing a fighting force to "preemptively"
attack those nationalist or revolutionary forces that may disrupt
global commerce.
When Bush says, "We will confront emerging threats before
they fully materialize," he is articulating the theory
of aggression on which transformation is based. The
new military is designed to initiate hostilities wherever America
can expand its grip on vital natural resources. This is the
only way that Washington can maintain its dominant position
in the world economy.
The Cost of Global War
One official from the World Bank estimated
that the US will spend in excess of $900 Billion per year to
maintain the global military presence that the Bush administration
has in mind; nearly double the current Pentagon budget.
This is probably accurate. The New World Order requires a
gluttonous, iron-fisted military to maintain its supremacy
and to preserve the existing economic paradigm.
So far, the dream of a transformed military has proved to
be a dismal failure. The insufficient number of soldiers in
Afghanistan and Iraq has spawned violent resistance-movements
in both countries that show no sign of abating. Rumsfeld's
dream of small groupings of elite warriors striking with lightening
speed and subduing entire populations has turned out to be
a catastrophic fantasy. America now has 8 battalions bogged-down
in a desert maelstrom where high-tech wizardry is less help
than a few more
"boots on the ground". At
home, the National Guard is in a shambles. The
men who would normally be assisting the victims of America's
greatest natural disaster are now hunkered-down in encampments
outside Baghdad and Falluja unable to help in the task for
which they were trained. As the costs and casualties
of the Iraq debacle continue to mount, Rumsfeld's crazed vision
of transformation will be exposed as one of the principle theories
that led the country down this ruinous path.
Mike Whitney lives in Washington state. He can be reached
at: fergiewhitney@msn.com |
NEW ORLEANS - Dirty, fearful and exhausted,
they pressed their faces against the metal gates, begging and
pleading for the chance to board a bus and get away from a
refuge that had become a nightmare.
After five days in the stinking, crowded and sweltering
confines of the New Orleans Superdome, the thousands of people
who emerged formed a slow-moving tide of desperation looking
for escape and relief.
The Superdome was meant to be a hurricane
refuge, but those who sought shelter there described a lawless "concentration
camp" where two children were reportedly raped and other
refugees terrorized by rioters.
Around 40 National Guard, armed with assault rifles, guarded
the door to a shopping mall through which the packed crowds
were being slowly filtered to buses waiting in ankle-deep flood
waters outside.
"Make a hole!" one guardsman shouted, as he carried
the limp and sweaty body of a woman -- one of many who collapsed
from dehydration and exhaustion.
People held children and dogs over their heads to keep them
from getting crushed, as babies were passed forward into the
waiting arms of guardsmen who cradled them and fed them water.
Those lucky enough to get out told tales of
rapes, child molestations, shootings, a man who jumped off
the roof and a fire that broke out in the giant sport arena
where up to 20,000 people had taken shelter from Hurricane
Katrina.
The floors of the stadium were soaked from the rain that seeped
in during the storm after part of the roof collapsed, and a
pervading stench testifid to the overflowing
toilets that had forced people
to relieve themselves in hallways and stairwells.
"The odor from that place would knock you off your feet," said
Lorraine Banks as she made her way past the dozens of police
officers and soldiers trying to keeping order and handing out
water in the shopping mall.
"They had bowel movements on the floor this high,"
the 53-year-old nurse said, as she gestured to her knee.
One 13-year veteran of the New Orleans police force said he
and other officers who had been at the Superdome since Sunday
were outraged at what they saw as a lack of preparation that
allowed the situation in the covered stadium to deteriorate
so badly and so quickly.
"This city knew something like this would
happen a long time ago. They did nothing to prepare for this.
They just rolled the dice and hoped for the best," said
the officer who asked not to be identified.
"People were raped in there. People were killed in there.
We had multiple riots," he said, adding there was no way
to police the mass of up to 20,000 people suddenly thrown together
in such a confined space and such horrific conditions.
"You can't be trapped in there for so long without going
crazy. People were locked in the dome
like prisoners," he said. "There was no ventilation. We
had 80-, 90-year-old people who needed medication and couldn't
get it."
According to Baron Duncan, the nights inside the arena were
the worst, with the pitch darkness and debilitating humidity
accentuating the rank smell from backed up toilets.
"The stench was unbearable. We were treated like animals," Duncan
said. "There was shooting ... our lives were in danger. A
seven-year-old girl and an eight-year-old boy got raped."
Medics brought the worst cases out to a cordoned-off hallway
for treatment before they were loaded onto the buses.
Latanya Howard, 34, was using a piece of cardboard to fan
a woman who had collapsed against a wall.
"People have been passing out left and right and we had
limited medical supplies," she said, describing the scene
inside the arena. "Then we come
out and they talk to us like dogs. No wonder they were fighting."
The evacuation of the Superdome began late Wednesday for those
with serious health problems. Officials would not estimate
how long it would take to empty the arena completely.
"People are still walking in here as fast as we can get
them out," said Lieutenant Colonel Scott Elliot of the
Texas National Guard.
The Superdome was opened Sunday as a refuge of last resort.
After the flooding, thousands more came or were brought there
in hopes of making it onto the first buses out of the city.
Maintaining order had been difficult, Elliot said as he surveyed
the swarm of angry, shouting people pressing up against the
barricades between the shopping mall and the buses.
Despite one guardsman being shot in the leg, he said the general
feeling among the troops was that they were happy to be able
to help.
"This is the most important thing they've
ever done," Elliot said. "I just got back from Iraq
last month. It's nothing like this. These are our people."
Much of the frustration voiced by the evacuees concerned the
lack of information. People were prevented
from leaving the arena because of the flooding and were
desperate for news of what had happened to their friends, neighbors,
family members and homes.
One woman, Judy Smith, sat sobbing in a chair in the mall
with her four grandchildren sitting on the floor next to her.
"I've lost my children," Smith sobbed. "You've
got to find my daughter, Ashley Smith .... You've got to tell
her her babies are alright. One almost drowned but we saved
him."
Many blamed the officials for failing to give them any updates
on the situation.
"We didn't have anyone telling us anything,"
said Rosemary Atkins, 60, as she waited with her grandson for
her daughter and other grandson to make their way through
the barricades.
"We kept asking the guards (what was going on) and they
said they didn't know."
Norma Blanco Johnson, waiting for a bus with her daughter
and infant grandaughter, said her main concern was her three
sons, who she hadn't seen since before the hurricane hit.
"I don't know what happened to them," Johnson said,
adding that her anxiety and fear had only been multiplied by
the experience of sheltering in the Superdome.
"This was no way to treat a human being.
I lost everything and then I went through hell. I have no place
left. I have nowhere to go and all I have are these," she
said, pointing to her soiled clothes.
Audrey Jordan vented her anger at New Orleans officials, saying
they had known for years that a hurricane of Katrina's intensity
could cause a breach in the low-lying city's water defences.
"They wanted to pay millions of dollars to rebuild a
stadium, but they couldn't even fix the levee,"
Jordan said.
"We were treated like this was a concentration
camp," she said of the Superdome.
"One man couldn't take it. He jumped over the railing
and died." |
The deplorable looting in New Orleans
puts an ugly public face on a crisis that Bush administration
policies have made worse.
Two things happened in one day that tell much about the
abysmal failure of the Bush administration to get a handle
on poverty in America. The first was the tragic and disgraceful
shots of hordes of New Orleans residents scurrying down the
city's hurricane-ravaged streets with their arms loaded with
food, clothes, appliances, and in some cases guns, looted
from stores and shops. That same day,
the Census Bureau released a report that found the number
of poor Americans has leaped even higher since Bush took
office in 2000.
While criminal gangs who take advantage of chaos and misery
did much of the looting, many desperately poor, mostly black
residents saw a chance to grab items they can't afford. They
also did their share of the looting. That makes it no less
reprehensible, but it's no surprise. New
Orleans has one of the highest poverty rates of any of America's
big cities. According to a report by Total Community
Action, a New Orleans public advocacy group, nearly
one out of three New Orleans residents -- the majority of whom
are black -- lives below the poverty level. A spokesperson
for the United Negro College Fund noted that the city's poor
live in some of the most dilapidated and deteriorated housing
in the nation.
But New Orleans is not an aberration. Nationally, according
to Census figures, blacks remain at the bottom of the economic
totem pole. They have the lowest median income of any group.
Bush's war and economic policies don't help matters. His tax
cuts redistributed billions to the rich and corporations. The
Iraq war has drained billions from cash-starved job training,
health and education programs. Increased American dependence
on Saudi oil has driven gas and oil prices skyward. Corporate
downsizing, outsourcing and industrial flight have further
fueled America's poverty crisis. All of this happened on Bush's
watch.
The two million new jobs in 2004 Bush touts as proof that
his economic policies work have been mostly smoke and mirrors
number counting. The bulk of these jobs are low-paying jobs
with minimal benefits and little job security in retail and
service industries. A big portion of the nearly 40 million
Americans who live below the official poverty line fill these
jobs. They're the lucky ones. They have jobs. Many young blacks,
such as those who ransacked stores in New Orleans, don't. The
poverty crisis has slammed them the hardest of all. Even during
the Clinton-era economic boom, the unemployment rate for young
black males was double, and in some parts of the country, triple
that of white males.
During the past couple of years, state and federal cutbacks
in job training and skills programs, the competition for low-
and semi-skilled service and retail jobs from immigrants, and
the refusal of many employers to hire those with criminal records
have further hammered black communities and added to the Great
Depression levels of unemployment among young blacks. The tale
of poverty is more evident in the nearly one million blacks
behind bars, the HIV/AIDS rampage in black communities, the
sea of black homeless persons, and the raging drug and gang
violence that rips apart many black communities.
Then there are the children. One third
of America's poor are children. Worse, the Children's
Defense Fund found that nearly one million black children
live in extreme poverty. That's the greatest number of black
children trapped in dire poverty in nearly a quarter century.
Bush officials claim the poverty numbers do not surprise them.
They contend that past trends show that poverty peaks and then
declines a year after the jump in new job growth. But
the poverty numbers have steadily risen for not one, but all
five years of this administration. There has been no sign of
a turnaround. For that to happen, Bush would have to
reverse his tax and war spending policies, and commit massive
funds to job, training and education programs, as well as providing
tax incentives for businesses to train and hire the poor. That
would take an active, national lobbying effort by congressional
Democrats and civil rights and anti-poverty groups. That's
not likely either. The poor are too nameless, faceless and
numerous to target with a sustained lobbying campaign.
While the NAACP hammers Bush on the war and his domestic policies,
poverty has not been their top priority. The fight for affirmative
action, economic parity, professional advancement and busing
replaced battling poverty, reducing unemployment, securing
quality education, promoting self-help and gaining greater
political empowerment as the goals of all African-Americans.
That effectively left the one out of four blacks who wallow
below the official poverty level out in the cold.
The looting in New Orleans, though
deplorable, put an ugly public face on a crisis Bush administration
policies have made worse. The millions in America
who grow poorer, more desperate, and greater in number, are
bitter testament to that.
Earl Ofari Hutchinson is an author and political analyst.
He is the author of 'The Crisis in Black and Black' (Middle
Passage Press). |
Anarchy
in New Orleans
Chaos rules with 200,000 still stranded in the city. Looting,
gunfire and a death toll still unknown |
By Andrew Buncombe in New Orleans
and Andrew Gumbel
The Independent
02 September 2005 |
The effort to rescue as many as 200,000
people left stranded and hungry in the sinking city of New
Orleans ran the risk of catastrophic breakdown last night,
as under-prepared and under-resourced
federal authorities faced the hostility of heavily armed
residents seemingly bent on shooting their way out of town
if necessary. [...]
Survivors grew increasingly panicky
last night as the transport they had been promised out
of the city failed to materialise. "We are
out here like pure animals. We don't have help,"
an elderly pastor told the Associated Press outside the city's
Convention Centre, where corpses were laid out directly in
front of the living. From the centre, a line of buses could
be seen along the interstate highway, but they were going
nowhere. [...]
The Bush administration hurriedly sent
a fresh consignment of 10,000 National Guardsmen into the
disaster area to try to maintain order - bringing the total
number of men in uniform to 28,000. President George
Bush himself said he would adopt a
"zero tolerance" attitude to lawlessness and urged
people to work together. "I understand the anxiety of
people on the ground," he told a television interviewer. "So
there is frustration. But I want people to know there's a lot
of help coming."
But the President found himself the target
of an unusual degree of anger from across the political spectrum,
as editorial writers demanded to know why he had sat out the
first full day of the disaster, and present and former government
officials detailed the numerous ways in which Congress and
the White House has cut funding for the very emergency management
programmes that the New Orleans area so desperately needs.
Despite the administration's efforts
to catalogue the naval ships, helicopters, floating hospitals
and essential supplies it was deploying, reports from along
the Gulf Coast suggested it was not arriving nearly fast
enough. "We're not getting any help yet," the
fire chief in Biloxi, Mississippi, told the Knight-Ridder
news service. "We need water.
We need ice. I've been told it's coming, but we've got people
in shelters who haven't had a drink since the storm."
Local officials already overwhelmed by the scale of the catastrophe
said they were particularly bewildered by the failure of the
Army Corps of Engineers to stem the gush of water pouring into
New Orleans through broken levees protecting the city from
both the Gulf to the south and Lake Ponchartrain to the north. "I'm
extremely upset about it," said Louisiana's Governor,
Kathleen Blanco.
The Army Corps, like every other authority charged with preventing
the flooding of New Orleans, has had its budget cut repeatedly
in recent years. The Federal Emergency Management Administration
has had its resources diverted towards the Bush administration's "war
on terror", and many of the National Guardsmen who might
have been in place to intervene sooner have been diverted to
Iraq.
The prospect of an ugly, elemental battle
for survival in New Orleans was made worse by the fact that
even before Hurricane Katrina it was the poorest urban area
in the United States. The ghastly spectacle of overwhelmingly
black residents caged in an unsanitary sports stadium and left
almost entirely to their own devices could not but evoke memories
of the darkest days of segregation and overtly racist Jim Crow
laws in the American South. The potential for racial conflict
has been quietly side-stepped in much of the US media coverage
to date, but it is also impossible to ignore.
Tales of gun stores being looted and
armed gangs roaming the streets were reminiscent of the opening
salvos of the Los Angeles riots of 1992. Police said
their officers had been shot at, and news crews for at least
one major national network let it be known that they had
hired private security guards to guarantee their safety.
Looters raided shops and public buildings and used either
rubbish bins or inflatable mattresses to float their takings
down the water-filled streets.
The prospect of a major societal breakdown
was not restricted to the disaster area. As the first evacuees
were welcomed to their new temporary home, the Astrodome
in Houston, officials felt obliged to deny that the dispossessed
were being held in prison-like conditions. The Astrodome
was "not a jail", the chief executive of Harris
County, which encompasses Houston, insisted at a news conference.
The Astrodome's new residents will be issued passes that
will let them leave and return as they please, something
that wasn't permitted in New Orleans. Organizers also plan
to find ways to help the refugees contact relatives.
Officials from President Bush down
to Marc Morial, a former mayor of New Orleans, said the impact
of Katrina was worse than that of the 11 September attacks
on New York, and so required an even more energetic response. "So
many of the people who did not evacuate could not evacuate,
for whatever reason," said Mr Morial. "They are
people who are African-American, mostly but not completely,
and people who were of little or limited economic means.
They are the folks, we've got to get them out of there." |
President Bush faced not only the fallout
of Hurricane Katrina but also an intense political storm yesterday
as relief experts, government officials and newspaper editorials
criticised everything from his administration's disaster preparedness
policies to the manner in which he made his public entry into
the growing crisis on the Gulf coast.
The New York Times said of a speech he made
on Tuesday: "Nothing about the President's demeanour
yesterday - which seemed casual to the point of carelessness
- suggested that he understood the depth of the current crisis."
No less trenchant - and more heartfelt - was the Biloxi Sun
Herald in Mississippi which surveyed the disaster around its
editorial offices and asked: "Why
hasn't every able-bodied member of the armed forces in south
Mississippi been pressed into service?"
As when the Asian tsunami hit last year, Mr Bush found himself
on holiday at his Texas ranch when disaster struck. As
with the tsunami, he was soon in the firing line for reacting
slowly - he spent Monday on a
fundraising tour of the American West -
and failing to provide adequate leadership. As survivors
complained of a lack of water, food and medical supplies yesterday,
fingers from across the political spectrum were pointed at
the White House.
Experts on the Mississippi Delta pointed out that a plan to
shore up the levees around New Orleans was abandoned last year
for lack of government funding. They noted that flood-control
spending for south-eastern Louisiana had been chopped every
year that Mr Bush has been in office, that hurricane protection
funds have also fallen, and that the local army corps of engineers
has also had its budget cut. The emergency management chief
for Jefferson parish told the Times-Picayune newspaper: "It
appears that the money has been moved in the President's budget
to handle homeland security and the war in Iraq, and I suppose
that's the price we pay."
The torrent of criticism contrasted sharply to the reaction
to the 11 September attacks, when political sniping was put
on hold and dissenters were told their complaints were both
unwelcome and unpatriotic. The change
in tone partly suggests a growing disenchantment with Mr Bush.
The usually restrained New York Times said: "Why were
developers permitted to destroy wetlands and barrier islands
that could have held back the hurricane's surge? Why was Congress,
before it wandered off to vacation, engaged in slashing the
budget for correcting some of the gaping holes in the area's
flood protection?" |
While Katrina's dead have not yet been
counted, it's not too soon to hammer home a point: government
policies have real consequences in people's lives.
Like many of you who love New Orleans, I find myself taking
short mental walks there today, turning a familiar corner,
glimpsing a favorite scene, square or vista. And worrying
about the beloved friends and the city, and how they are
now.
To use a fine Southern word, it's tacky to start playing the
blame game before the dead are even counted. It is not too
soon, however, to make a point that needs to be hammered home
again and again, and that is that government policies have
real consequences in people's lives. This
is not "just politics" or blaming for political advantage. This
is about the real consequences of what governments do and do
not do about their responsibilities. And about who winds up
paying the price for those policies.
This is a column for everyone in the path
of Hurricane Katrina who ever said, "I'm sorry, I'm just
not interested in politics," or, "There's nothing
I can do about it," or, "Eh, they're all crooks anyway." Nothing
to do with me, nothing to do with my life, nothing I can do
about any of it. Look around you this morning. I suppose the
NRA would argue, "Government policies don't kill people,
hurricanes kill people."
Actually, hurricanes plus government policies kill people.
[...]
It is a fact that the Clinton administration
set some tough policies on wetlands, and it is a fact that
the Bush administration repealed those policies -- ordering
federal agencies to stop protecting as many as 20 million
acres of wetlands. Last year, four environmental groups
cooperated on a joint report showing the Bush administration's
policies had allowed developers to drain thousands of acres
of wetlands.
Does this mean we should blame Bush for the fact that New
Orleans is underwater? No, but it means
we can blame Bush when a Class 3 or Class 2 hurricane puts
New Orleans underwater. [...]
In fact, there is now a government-wide movement away from
basing policy on science, expertise and professionalism, and
in favor of choices based on ideology. If you're wondering
what the ideological position on flood management might be,
look at the pictures of New Orleans -- it seems to consist
of gutting the programs that do anything.
Unfortunately, the war in Iraq is directly related to the
devastation left by the hurricane. About 35 percent of Louisiana's
National Guard is now serving in Iraq, where four out of every
10 soldiers are guardsmen. Recruiting for the Guard is also
down significantly because people are afraid of being sent
to Iraq if they join, leaving the Guard even more short- handed.
The Louisiana National Guard also notes
that dozens of its high-water vehicles, humvees, refuelers
and generators have also been sent abroad. (I hate
to be picky, but why do they need high-water vehicles in
Iraq?) This, in turn, goes back to the original policy decision
to go into Iraq without enough soldiers and the subsequent
failure to admit that mistake and to rectify it by instituting
a draft.
The levees of New Orleans, two of which are now broken and
flooding the city, were also victims of Iraq war spending.
Walter Maestri, emergency management chief for Jefferson Parish,
said on June 8, 2004, "It appears that the money has been
moved in the president's budget to handle homeland security
and the war in Iraq."
This, friends, is why we need to pay attention
to government policies, not political personalities, and to
know whereon we vote. It is about our lives.
Molly Ivins writes about politics, Texas and other bizarre
happenings. |
WASHINGTON (AP) -- President Bush, facing
blistering criticism for his administration's response to Hurricane
Katrina, said Friday "the results are not acceptable" and
pledged to bolster relief efforts with a personal trip to the
Gulf Coast.
"We'll get on top of this situation," Bush
said, "and we're going to help the people that
need help."
He spoke on the White House grounds just boarding his presidential
helicopter, Marine One, with Homeland Security Department secretary
Michael Chertoff to tour the region. The department, which
oversees the Federal Emergency Management Agency, has been
accused of responding sluggishly to the deadly hurricane.
"There's a lot of aid surging toward
those who've been affected. Millions of gallons of water. Millions
of tons of food. We're making progress about pulling people
out of the Superdome," the president said.
For the first time, however, he stopped defending
his administration's response and criticized it. "A lot
of people are working hard to help those who've been affected.
The results are not acceptable,"
he said. "I'm heading down there right now."
Bush hoped that his tour of the hurricane-ravaged states would
boost the spirits of increasingly desperate storm victims and
their tired rescuers, and his visit was aimed at tamping down
the ever-angrier criticism that he has engineered a too-little,
too-late response.
Four days after Katrina made landfall in southeastern Louisiana,
Bush was to get a second, closer look at the devastation wrought
by the storm's 145 mph winds and 25-foot storm surge in an
area stretching from just west of New Orleans to Pensacola,
Florida. In all, there are 90,000 square miles under federal
disaster declaration.
In Mobile, Alabama, the president was to get a briefing on
the damage, followed by a helicopter survey of areas along
the Alabama, Mississippi and Louisiana coasts. He was to walk
through hard-hit neighborhoods in Biloxi, Miss.
But Bush was avoiding an in-person visit
to the worst areas of New Orleans, mostly drowned in rank
floodwaters and descending in many areas into lawlessness
as desperate residents await rescue or even just food and
water. Instead, the president was taking an aerial tour of
the city and making an appearance at the airport several
miles from the center of town. [...]
So Bush has tried to respond to Katrina in a way that evokes
the national goodwill he cultivated after the Sept. 11, 2001,
terrorist attacks -- and that does not recall the criticism
his father, former President Bush, endured after Hurricane
Andrew slammed Florida in 1992.
But he began facing questions about his leadership in the
crisis almost immediately. New Orleans officials, in particular,
were enraged about what they said was a slow federal response.
"They don't have a clue what's going on down there,"
Mayor Ray Nagin told WWL-AM Thursday night.
Seeking to deflect the criticism, Michael Brown, director
of the Federal Emergency Management
Agency, asserted earlier Friday: "In this catastrophic
event, everything that we had pre-positioned and ready to go
became overwhelmed immediately after the storm." [...] |
WASHINGTON--U.S. Spy satellites have been
called into service to help federal emergency officials cope
with the devastating aftermath of Hurricane Katrina, officials
said Wednesday.
The little-known National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency,
which analyzes satellite images for the espionage community
and combat troops, has provided scores of images of hard-hit
areas, including New Orleans, before
and after the storm struck.
The agency said one of its main aims is to survey damage to
regional transportation for the Federal Emergency Management
Agency, which can then use the data to organize relief efforts.
FEMA officials could not be reached for comment.
"NGA can determine the overall damage to a transportation
network infrastructure--what bridges are out, what roads are
flooded--which is critical for FEMA getting relief supplies
into the disaster area," said NGA spokesman Stephen Honda.
The Pentagon agency, previously known as the National Imagery
and Mapping Agency, joined the hurricane effort on Friday when
it gave FEMA 100 graphic images showing the location of hospitals,
police stations, highways, and schools in the storm's path
along the Gulf coast.
After the storm, the agency gave FEMA its first cloud-free
satellite image of downtown New Orleans. The image was snapped
by a commercial satellite.
NGA, which once concentrated wholly on overseas
targets, has become more involved in domestic security and
relief efforts since the September 11, 2001, attacks on Washington
and New York.
NGA analysis has aided security efforts at large public events
including the Super Bowl and the 2004 presidential conventions.
Its satellite imagery has also provided assistance to Asian
tsunami relief efforts and in fighting forest fires. |
WASHINGTON - Hurricane Katrina's second
wave -- soaring gasoline and home-heating prices -- may be
less deadly and destructive than the storm itself but poses
much greater risks to the world's biggest economy.
U.S. economic health is so dependent on
keeping its increasingly indebted households shopping that
another drain on their already-stretched budgets could batter
the economy.
American consumers, whose spending on goods, services and
houses accounted for 76 percent of U.S. gross domestic product
in the second quarter, have shrugged off many shocks over the
past decade -- most notably the dot.com bubble burst of 2000
and the September 11, 2001 attacks.
They have done so largely by accumulating more and more relative
cheap debts.
But economists worry that a fresh, even
temporary, spike in energy costs as a result of damage
to the Gulf region's oil infrastructure may be a shock too
many.
"This is a very delicate moment," said Nouriel Roubini,
economics professor at New York University. "The
economy is already very imbalanced. On top of that, we've had
a massive oil shock and now we have a natural disaster that
might be something of a tipping point."
WHISPERS OF RECESSION
As the loss of life and scale of the damage to local housing
and commercial infrastructure becomes clear, muttering of recession
was not far from the lips of some economists.
Policy-makers insist, with some justification, that with economic
growth well above 3 percent so far this year, talk of a nationwide
contraction is far-fetched. Income and jobs are rising, corporate
profits are high and inflation and long-term borrowing costs
are low.
President George W. Bush met with Federal Reserve Chairman
Alan Greenspan on Thursday and, analysts reckon, will likely
have heard that message from the central bank chief.
To be sure, the Gulf region will see a sudden sharp shock
that will feel and look like one of the deepest recessions
they have known.
Initial estimates of the cost of replacing insured property
and goods in the area is as high as $26 billion, higher than
the $22 billion of damage incurred by 1992's Hurricane Andrew
-- America's costliest storm to date.
This huge bill has even more historical resonance when compared
with the $32 billion of insured losses following the September
11, 2001 attacks.
And total damage from Katrina, including uninsured items,
could be as high as $40 billion, according to Merrill Lynch.
Yet, the most affected states -- Louisiana, Mississippi and
Alabama -- account for less that 3 percent of overall U.S.
gross domestic product.
And, despite the huge losses, reconstruction and rebuilding
will most certainly boost activity sharply there by yearend.
FUEL FEARS
But with gasoline prices set to soar and remain above $3 per
gallon and amid pre-winter fears of rising home heating costs,
the timing of this regional catastrophe could have massive
ripple-effect.
If this new national energy shock -- crude
oil prices had already doubled in 18 months prior to Katrina
-- adds to growing fears of a housing bubble, rising short-term
interest rates and swelling trade deficits, the nationwide
horizon darkens significantly.
"The oil price impact will be the biggest for the national
economy," economists at Goldman Sachs said in a research
note.
Goldman estimates average U.S. crude
oil prices of $70 per barrel for September -- close
to Thursday's level of $69.45 -- could
force a rise of $50-$60 billion annualized in energy spending
that would force cutbacks in spending on other goods and
knock half a percentage point off third-quarter GDP.
But they outlined a worst-case scenario of fuel rationing.
"Demand rationing, not seen in this country since 1979,
would certainly lower consumer confidence and cause a much
more widespread hit to the economy,"
they added, saying this could force the Fed to pause its campaign
of raising interest rates.
Bush on Thursday urged Americans to not to buy gasoline if
they do not need it but stopped short of raising the prospect
of rationing.
Rationing or not, the soaring consumer oil bill remains the
biggest national economic burden.
As the price of houses and equities held by many Americans
continue to rise, families are saving
nothing from their after-tax incomes and incurring greater
amounts of debt to fuel seemingly insatiable consumption habits.
Figures released on Thursday show the national household saving
rate, at minus 0.6 percent, was the lowest on record -- falling
negative for only the second time ever.
With household debt now up 60 percent in just five years,
rising short-term interest rates will already be crimping wallets. Consumer
mortgage interest payments alone were up 14 percent in the
last year.
And, as with the devastation on the ground, poorer Americans
will take a disproportionate hit from the energy price spike.
Consumer spending on gas, fuel oil and natural gas accounts
for just 2.4 percent of the income of the richest fifth of
households but 11.2 percent of the poorest fifth, said David
Kelly, Senior Economic Advisor at Putnam Investments
"Sadly, it is the poorest Americans in the regions and
areas that have seen the weakest recovery from the recession
of 2001 who are being hurt most by higher oil prices," he
said. |
Motorists were warned last night that
petrol prices seem certain to pass £1 a litre within
days after Hurricane Katrina wiped out many of the oil refineries
on the US Gulf coast.
As US oil companies bought up 20 shiploads
of European petrol yesterday, the wholesale price of petrol
on the Rotterdam spot market soared to a record of $855 a
tonne (more than $100 a barrel),
up more than 20% in two days and something experts said would
feed through to the forecourt within days.
Article continues The Petrol Retailers' Association calculated
that the spot price rise could add almost 10p a litre to pump
prices if it were passed on in full to consumers, something
the oil companies may be reluctant to do.
Prices yesterday were around 92p a litre for unleaded and
96p for diesel. Wholesale diesel prices in Rotterdam also set
record highs yesterday, so the £1 a litre diesel price
could be seen by the weekend and by Monday at the latest, a
PRA spokesman, Ray Holloway, said. [...]
Petrol prices in Britain are among the highest in Europe because
of the duty and VAT charged on them but are still cheaper than
Denmark, Norway and the Netherlands.
Pump prices in the US, where fuel taxes are much lower, have
risen to over $3 a gallon (42p a litre) in many states.
A White House economic adviser, Ben Bernanke, said yesterday
they would rise further but then fall back as the situation
in Louisiana became more stable.
Hurricane Katrina forced the closure of about nine refineries
in Louisiana, Alabama and Mississippi, which together refine
about 10% of America's gasoline. However, demand is slowing
as the US holiday season ends.
Oil prices, by contrast, fell back slightly yesterday from
record highs earlier in the week. US crude futures fell below
$69 after setting a record just below $71.
Traders said oil supplies were not the big problem, especially
as the US government on Wednesday promised to release some
of the country's 700m barrel strategic petroleum reserve, some
of which is stored in old salt mines in Louisiana. That was
because of a disruption to crude production offshore in the
Gulf of Mexico, where rigs were torn adrift by the storm. Some
have since washed up onshore.
But the strategic reserve contains only oil,
not gasoline or diesel, hence the scramble to buy from Europe.
The Treasury responded to the rising fuel price by stressing
it had announced in July that a duty increase planned for yesterday
would be scrapped because of high oil prices. Fuel duty, now
47.1p a litre, has not risen for two years. |
WASHINGTON - Concerns grew Thursday that
Hurricane Katrina could have wide-reaching effects on the nation's
economy, causing record gasoline prices to surge even higher,
key agricultural crops to rot in Midwestern fields and warehouses,
and some of the nation's troubled airlines to collapse.
As estimates of the economic damage mounted, Federal Reserve
Chairman Alan Greenspan came under increasing pressure to
scrap or delay further Fed interest rate increases. In
a hastily arranged White
House meeting, President Bush summoned the Fed chief to discuss
what could be done to lessen the hurricane's economic toll.
Details of the meeting were not disclosed, but many experts
predicted that Greenspan would work to avoid a possible economic
slowdown.
Experts warned that gasoline prices - driven higher because
of storm-related damage to the Gulf Coast's energy infrastructure
- were the greatest concern and might be approaching levels
that would soon ripple through the economy.
If that happens, prices of basic items could soar, pushing
up inflation. The Gulf Coast accounts for about 20% of the
nation's oil and natural gas supplies.
High gasoline costs - and accusations of gouging amid prices
as high as $5 a gallon - also appeared to be fueling a consumer
backlash. But the Bush administration took no immediate steps
Thursday to halt the run-up in pump prices.
After a lunch with Greenspan, Bush warned of temporary gas
shortages in the coming weeks and called on Americans to conserve
energy.
"Don't buy gas if you don't need it," the president
said at a White House appearance.
With eight major refineries incapacitated,
Bush said, "It's going to be hard to get gasoline to some
markets."
He did not elaborate, but oil industry experts
said the Midwest, the South and perhaps the Atlantic seaboard
would probably experience shortages.
Some economists said Katrina's toll could be more far-reaching
than the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks, for example, because of
its potential effects on trade and key sectors of the U.S.
economy.
The U.S. is the world's biggest agricultural
exporter. Most crop exports float down the Mississippi River
on barges and then are transferred to ships at one of the Gulf
Coast ports.
Massive damage to the region's ports would
idle the barges that transport oil, sugar and grain along the
Mississippi River.
That would mean that farmers in the South and Midwest who
depend on the waterway to ship their goods to foreign markets
would lose a cheap shipping route. On
Thursday, many fully loaded barges drifted with nowhere to
go.
Retailers who use Gulf Coast ports to receive their imports
also have to scramble to find alternative docks.
Although they generally aren't predicting a recession soon,
many economists have lowered their estimates for economic growth,
in part because of Katrina. Experts who previously predicted
that growth in the current quarter would exceed an annualized
rate of 4% now expect the pace to fall below 3.5%. Others think
growth could fall below 3%. The economy expanded by 3.3% in
the April-June quarter.
Federal Reserve policymakers have raised their benchmark short-term
rate 10 times, by a total of 2.5 percentage points, since June
2004 in an effort to control inflation.
Until recently, most analysts had thought the Fed would boost
its key rate an additional three-quarters of a point before
stopping. But now many traders are betting that there will
be only one more quarter-point increase - from 3.5% to 3.75%
- in the so-called federal funds rate, the interest banks charge
each other for very short-term loans. The central bank's next
rate-setting meeting is Sept. 20.
"What Katrina has done is shift the economic focus from
inflation to growth," said David M. Jones, a Denver economic
consultant and veteran Fed watcher.
"I think what you'll see is the Fed pausing at its next
meeting, citing special circumstances,"
he said.
The crisis has hit the airlines particularly hard, with a
surge in jet fuel prices and the loss of passenger traffic
in the Gulf Coast region. Carriers such as Delta Air Lines
and Northwest Airlines already were perilously close to filing
for bankruptcy protection, and Northwest said Thursday that
it now had even less time to slash costs if it hoped to avoid
a filing.
Concerned about a possible economic slowdown triggered by
high energy costs, investors have driven down bond interest
rates this week. That also represents an immense bet that the
Federal Reserve's rate-raising days are coming to a swift close
as a result of the hurricane.
Greenspan had no comment after meeting with Bush. The central
bank, however, joined other federal regulatory agencies late
Thursday in issuing a plea that banks in the affected region
help people get back on their financial feet by doing such
things as waiving ATM fees, increasing the amount allowed for
daily cash withdrawals and permitting
people to get at their savings without having to pay penalties.
Although Greenspan is much praised as an economic crisis manager,
his ability to cope with the current threat to growth may be
much more limited than in such upheavals as the Mexican peso
crisis, the Asian financial panic and the aftermath of the
2001 terrorist attacks.
That's because in each of these previous events, the Fed chairman's
primary focus was on the health of the nation's financial markets,
something he could readily affect by announcing the Fed's readiness
to open the spigot on credit.
By contrast, the key problem now is the physical
condition of oil and gas drilling platforms in the Gulf of
Mexico, as well as refineries and pipelines in Louisiana and
Mississippi - something that no amount of money can immediately
improve.
Analysts said again Thursday that it
could be weeks before energy industry executives assessed
the condition of their facilities. But these analysts
warned that if the damage was substantial, it could have
significant and long-lasting repercussions.
The biggest danger is that Katrina has seriously damaged Gulf
Coast refineries, which account for 10% of U.S. refining capacity. Without
these refineries, the oil being drawn from government stockpiles
can't be turned into useable products for the areas they serve. [...]
There was some promising news. Valero
Energy Corp. said power was restored to its big St. Charles,
La., refinery, enabling employees to start repairs. Two of
the major pipelines that distribute oil and gasoline from
the gulf also were back up, but running well below their
normal capacity.
The White House, in another step aimed at easing the crisis,
waived rules requiring that only U.S.-flagged ships could carry
oil between U.S. ports so that foreign vessels could help get
products to refiners faster.
Bush also has temporarily lifted clean-air rules for gasoline
and lent crude oil from the U.S. Strategic Petroleum Reserve
to companies such as Exxon Mobil Corp. and Valero, whose Gulf
Coast refineries are low on crude.
Gasoline prices had been rising in California and nationwide
because of tight supplies even before the hurricane hit. Hawaii
had taken the unusual step of imposing caps on its gas prices.
Bernard Picchi, senior managing director at Foresight Research
Solutions, said the surge in gas prices was causing "a
huge drain in people's disposable incomes,"
and could soon become "exactly the kind of wake-up call" that
would spark widespread conservation.
Gosselin reported from Washington, Peltz from Los Angeles.
Times staff writers Edwin Chen and Richard Simon in Washington,
Claire Hoffman in Los Angeles and special correspondent Dana
Calvo in Houston contributed to this report. |
An
antigay activist group based in Philadelphia says that the
disaster wrought by Hurricane Katrina reflects God's judgment
on New Orleans for hosting the gay Southern Decadence party.
In a statement issued Wednesday, Repent America described
"homosexuals engaging in sex acts in the public streets" at
the annual event, which draws some 125,000 revelers to the
Big Easy each Labor Day weekend.
"Although the loss of lives is deeply
saddening, this act of God destroyed a wicked city," said
Repent America director Michael Marcavage.
"May it never be the same."
Marcavage is a notorious foe of gays. He and three other Repent
America members were charged with felonies last year connected
with a demonstration they staged at Philadelphia's gay pride
observance. A judge dismissed all charges in February.
The head of the predominantly gay Metropolitan Community Church
responded to Marcavage's assessment of the tragedy. The Reverend
Doctor Cindy Love said she doesn't believe God punishes anyone
with natural disasters. "I really believe that the use
of scripture in this way is an affront to the life and love
of Jesus Christ,"
she said. (Sirius/OutQ) |
In
New Orleans, state officials have described the chaotic aftermath
of Hurricane Katrina as a national disgrace.
And increasingly across the country, questions are being
asked: "How could this happen?" "Why
is help taking so long?"
and "How can thousands of Americans be stranded?".
President George Bush was visiting some of the devastated
areas of the south on Friday amid growing anger over the federal
response to the disaster.
Officials insist their response has been effective - rejecting
widespread criticism that the administration was too slow to
react to the crisis. [...]
The head of the New Orleans emergency operations, Terry Ebbert,
has questioned when reinforcements will actually reach the
increasingly lawless city.
"This is a national disgrace. Fema has
been here three days, yet there is no command and control," Mr
Ebbert said.
"We can send massive amounts of aid
to tsunami victims, but we can't bail out the city of New Orleans."
One man, George Turner, who was still waiting to be evacuated,
summed up much of the anger felt by the refugees.
"Why is it that the most powerful country
on the face of the Earth takes so long to help so many sick
and so many elderly people?" he asked.
"Why? That's all I want to ask President Bush."
And John Rhinehart, the administrator of a
New Orleans hospital without power and water, said:
"I'm beginning to wonder if the government is more concerned
about the looting than people who are dying in these hospitals."
There is widespread agreement among commentators that somewhere
there has been a breakdown in the system.
The Biloxi Sun Herald in Mississippi asked: "Why hasn't
every able-bodied member of the armed forces in south Mississippi
been pressed into service?"
[...] |
President George Bush has conceded the
initial response to Hurricane Katrina was "not acceptable" but
has said every effort is being made to save lives.
Heavily-armed National Guardsmen have begun pouring into
New Orleans, where thousands remain stranded without food
or water amid rising lawlessness.
A large military convoy carrying aid also entered the city
on Friday.
Visiting the region, Mr Bush said order would be restored
and New Orleans would emerge from its "darkest days".
"My attitude is, if it's not going exactly right, we're
going to make it go exactly right. If there's problems, then
we'll address the problems," Mr Bush said.
"Every life is precious and so we are going to spend
a lot of time saving lives, whether it be in New Orleans or
on the coast of Mississippi. We have a responsibility to help
clean up this mess."
Speaking in Mobile, Alabama, Mr Bush said a $10.5bn (£5.7bn)
emergency aid approved by the Senate was "just a small
down-payment" on the cost of helping people rebuild.
He went on to visit Biloxi, on the Mississippi coast, where
he comforted a woman who wept as she described how she had
lost everything. [...]
The BBC's Matt Frei, in New Orleans, says
conditions in the convention centre, where up to 20,000 people
are stranded, are the most wretched he has seen anywhere, including
crises in the Third World.
"You've got an entire nursing home evacuated five days
ago - people in wheelchairs sitting there and slowly dying," he
says. [...]
The situation has been made worse by a lack of trust between
the mainly poor, African-American population left behind in
New Orleans and the predominately white police force, our correspondent
adds.
Up to 60,000 people could still be
stranded in the city, the US coastguard says. [...]
The muddy floodwaters are now toxic with fuel, battery acid,
rubbish and raw sewage.
According to the White House, about 90,000 sq miles (234,000
sq km) have been affected by the hurricane. |
WASHINGTON (CNN) -- In a five-day, tabletop
exercise last summer, emergency preparedness officials faced
an imaginary "worst-case scenario"
in which a hurricane hit the New Orleans, Louisiana, area.
A fictional Category 3 Hurricane Pam, with "winds
of 120 mph, up to 20 inches of rain... and a storm surge
that topped the levees," was the picture presented to
officials from 50 federal, local and volunteer organizations,
according to a Federal Emergency Management Agency dispatch
from July 23, 2004.
Participants drew up action plans for dealing with the storm's
aftermath in which calls for evacuation were partially heeded,
water pumps were overwhelmed, corpses floated in the streets
and as many as 60,000 people died -- mostly by drowning.
FEMA Director Michael Brown told CNN's Larry King on Wednesday, "When
I became the director of FEMA a couple of years ago, I decided
it was time we did some really serious catastrophic disaster
planning. So the president gave me money through our budget
to do that. And we went around the country to figure out what's
the best model we can do for a catastrophic disaster in this
country? And we picked New Orleans, Louisiana."
Organizers said "Hurricane Pam" was based on weather
and damage information developed by the National Weather Service
and other agencies.
"Hurricane Katrina caused the same kind of damage that
we anticipated," Brown said Wednesday. "So we planned
for it two years ago. Last year, we exercised it. And unfortunately
this year, we're implementing it."
A Department of Homeland Security document described the resulting
action plans from last year's exercise: Participants determined
a need for 1,000 shelters for 100 days. They decided they already
had 784 and would need to find the remainder.
The state of Louisiana had resources to operate shelters for
three to five days, and plans were made for how federal and
other sources could replenish those.
The document also lists the allocation of up to 800 searchers
for search-and-rescue operations and plans for disposing of
more than 30 million cubic yards of debris and hazardous waste.
The group of participants also devised plans for immunization
against diseases, the re-supplying of hospitals and establishment
of triages at university campuses.
After the drill, FEMA concluded that progress had been made,
and that hurricane planning would continue.
But one of the drill participants, Col. Michael
L. Brown, then-deputy director of the Louisiana emergency preparedness
department, told the Baton Rouge Advocate newspaper that, in
a worst-case scenario, there would be only so much government
agencies could do.
"Residents need to know they'll be on
their own for several days in a situation like this," Brown,
who is not related to the FEMA director, told the paper. |
(CNN) -- New Orleans Mayor Ray Nagin blasted
the slow pace of federal and state relief efforts in an expletive-laced
interview with local radio station WWL-AM.
The following is a transcript of WWL correspondent Garland
Robinette's interview with Nagin on Thursday night. Robinette
asked the mayor about his conversation with President Bush:
NAGIN: I told him we had an
incredible crisis here and that his flying over in Air Force
One does not do it justice. And that I have been all around
this city, and I am very frustrated because we are not able
to marshal resources and we're outmanned in just about every
respect.
You know the reason why the looters got out of control? Because
we had most of our resources saving people, thousands of people
that were stuck in attics, man, old ladies. ... You pull off
the doggone ventilator vent and you look down there and they're
standing in there in water up to their freaking necks.
And they don't have a clue what's going on down here. They
flew down here one time two days after the doggone event was
over with TV cameras, AP reporters, all kind of goddamn --
excuse my French everybody in America, but I am pissed.
WWL: Did you say to the president
of the United States, "I need the military in here"?
NAGIN: I said, "I need
everything."
Now, I will tell you this -- and I give the president some
credit on this -- he sent one John Wayne dude down here that
can get some stuff done, and his name is [Lt.] Gen. [Russel]
Honore.
And he came off the doggone chopper, and he started cussing
and people started moving. And he's getting some stuff done.
They ought to give that guy -- if they don't want to give
it to me, give him full authority to get the job done, and
we can save some people.
WWL: What do you need right
now to get control of this situation?
NAGIN: I need reinforcements,
I need troops, man. I need 500 buses, man. We ain't talking
about -- you know, one of the briefings
we had, they were talking about getting public school bus drivers
to come down here and bus people out here.
I'm like, "You got to be kidding me.
This is a national disaster. Get every doggone Greyhound bus
line in the country and get their asses moving to New Orleans."
That's -- they're thinking small, man. And this is a major,
major, major deal. And I can't emphasize it enough, man. This
is crazy.
I've got 15,000 to 20,000 people over at the convention center.
It's bursting at the seams. The poor people in Plaquemines
Parish. ... We don't have anything, and we're sharing with
our brothers in Plaquemines Parish.
It's awful down here, man.
WWL: Do you believe that the
president is seeing this, holding a news conference on it but
can't do anything until [Louisiana Gov.] Kathleen Blanco requested
him to do it? And do you know whether or not she has made that
request?
NAGIN: I have no idea what they're
doing. But I will tell you this: You know, God is looking down
on all this, and if they are not doing everything in their
power to save people, they are going to pay the price. Because
every day that we delay, people are dying and they're dying
by the hundreds, I'm willing to bet you.
We're getting reports and calls that are breaking my heart,
from people saying, "I've been in my attic. I can't take
it anymore. The water is up to my neck. I don't think I can
hold out." And that's happening as we speak.
You know what really upsets me, Garland? We told everybody
the importance of the 17th Street Canal issue. We said,
"Please, please take care of this. We don't care what
you do. Figure it out."
WWL: Who'd you say that to?
NAGIN: Everybody: the governor,
Homeland Security, FEMA. You name it, we said it.
And they allowed that pumping station next to Pumping Station
6 to go under water. Our sewage and water board people ...
stayed there and endangered their lives.
And what happened when that pumping station went down, the
water started flowing again in the city, and it starting getting
to levels that probably killed more people.
In addition to that, we had water flowing through the pipes
in the city. That's a power station over there.
So there's no water flowing anywhere on the east bank of Orleans
Parish. So our critical water supply was destroyed because
of lack of action.
WWL: Why couldn't they drop
the 3,000-pound sandbags or the containers that they were talking
about earlier? Was it an engineering feat that just couldn't
be done?
NAGIN: They said it was some
pulleys that they had to manufacture. But, you know, in a state
of emergency, man, you are creative, you figure out ways to
get stuff done.
Then they told me that they went overnight, and they built
17 concrete structures and they had the pulleys on them and
they were going to drop them.
I flew over that thing yesterday, and it's in the same shape
that it was after the storm hit. There is nothing happening.
And they're feeding the public a line of bull and they're spinning,
and people are dying down here.
WWL: If some of the public called
and they're right, that there's a law that the president, that
the federal government can't do anything without local or state
requests, would you request martial law?
NAGIN: I've already called for
martial law in the city of New Orleans. We did that a few days
ago.
WWL: Did the governor do that,
too?
NAGIN: I don't know. I don't
think so.
But we called for martial law when we realized that the looting
was getting out of control. And we redirected all of our police
officers back to patrolling the streets. They were dead-tired
from saving people, but they worked all night because we thought
this thing was going to blow wide open last night. And so we
redirected all of our resources, and we hold it under check.
I'm not sure if we can do that another night with the current
resources.
And I am telling you right now: They're showing
all these reports of people looting and doing all that weird
stuff, and they are doing that, but people are desperate and
they're trying to find food and water, the majority of them.
Now you got some knuckleheads out there, and
they are taking advantage of this lawless -- this situation
where, you know, we can't really control it, and they're doing
some awful, awful things. But that's a small majority of the
people. Most people are looking to try and survive.
And one of the things people -- nobody's
talked about this. Drugs flowed in and out of New Orleans and
the surrounding metropolitan area so freely it was scary to
me, and that's why we were having the escalation in murders.
People don't want to talk about this, but I'm going to talk
about it.
You have drug addicts that are now walking
around this city looking for a fix, and that's the reason why
they were breaking in hospitals and drugstores. They're looking
for something to take the edge off of their jones, if you will.
And right now, they don't have anything to take the edge off.
And they've probably found guns. So what you're seeing is drug-starving
crazy addicts, drug addicts, that are wrecking havoc. And we
don't have the manpower to adequately deal with it. We can
only target certain sections of the city and form a perimeter
around them and hope to God that we're not overrun.
WWL: Well, you and I must be
in the minority. Because apparently there's a section of our
citizenry out there that thinks because of a law that says
the federal government can't come in unless requested by the
proper people, that everything that's going on to this point
has been done as good as it can possibly be.
NAGIN: Really?
WWL: I know you don't feel that
way.
NAGIN: Well,
did the tsunami victims request? Did it go through a formal
process to request?
You know, did the Iraqi people request that
we go in there? Did they ask us to go in there? What is more
important?
And I'll tell you, man, I'm probably going
get in a whole bunch of trouble. I'm probably going to get
in so much trouble it ain't even funny. You probably won't
even want to deal with me after this interview is over.
WWL: You and I will be in the
funny place together.
NAGIN: But
we authorized $8 billion to go to Iraq lickety-quick. After
9/11, we gave the president unprecedented powers lickety-quick
to take care of New York and other places.
Now, you mean to tell me that a place where
most of your oil is coming through, a place that is so unique
when you mention New Orleans anywhere around the world, everybody's
eyes light up -- you mean to tell me that a place where you
probably have thousands of people that have died and thousands
more that are dying every day, that we can't figure out a way
to authorize the resources that we need? Come on, man.
You know, I'm not one of those drug addicts.
I am thinking very clearly.
And I don't know whose problem it is. I don't
know whether it's the governor's problem. I don't know whether
it's the president's problem, but somebody needs to get their
ass on a plane and sit down, the two of them, and figure this
out right now.
WWL: What can we do here?
NAGIN: Keep talking about it.
WWL: We'll do that. What else
can we do?
NAGIN: Organize people to write
letters and make calls to their congressmen, to the president,
to the governor. Flood their doggone offices with requests
to do something. This is ridiculous.
I don't want to see anybody do anymore goddamn press conferences.
Put a moratorium on press conferences. Don't do another press
conference until the resources are in this city. And then come
down to this city and stand with us when there are military
trucks and troops that we can't even count.
Don't tell me 40,000 people are coming here.
They're not here. It's too doggone late. Now get off your asses
and do something, and let's fix the biggest goddamn crisis
in the history of this country.
WWL: I'll say it right now,
you're the only politician that's called and called for arms
like this. And if -- whatever it takes, the governor, president
-- whatever law precedent it takes, whatever it takes, I bet
that the people listening to you are on your side.
NAGIN: Well, I hope so, Garland.
I am just -- I'm at the point now where it don't matter. People
are dying. They don't have homes. They don't have jobs. The
city of New Orleans will never be the same in this time.
WWL: We're both pretty speechless
here.
NAGIN: Yeah, I don't know what
to say. I got to go.
WWL: OK. Keep in touch. Keep
in touch. |
From a speech by Bush at the
Rose Garden May 2004:
"There's a lot of people in the world who don't believe
that people whose skin color may not be the same as ours
can be free and self-govern. I reject that. I reject that
strongly. I believe that people who practice the Muslim faith
can self-govern. I believe that people whose skins aren't
necessarily -- are a different color than white can self-govern." |
WASHINGTON, Sept. 3 - Faced with one of
the worst political crises of his administration, President
Bush abruptly overhauled his September schedule on Saturday
as the White House scrambled to gain control of a situation
that Republicans said threatened to undermine Mr. Bush's second-term
agenda and the party's long-term ambitions.
In a sign of the mounting anxiety
at the White House, Mr. Bush made a rare Saturday appearance
in the Rose Garden before live television cameras to announce
that he was dispatching additional active-duty troops to
the Gulf Coast. He struck
a more somber tone than he had at times on Friday during
a daylong tour of the disaster region, when he had joked
at the airport in New Orleans about the fun he had had
in his younger days in Houston. His demeanor on
Saturday was similar to that of his most somber speeches
after the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks.
"The magnitude of responding to a crisis over a disaster
area that is larger than the size of Great Britain has created
tremendous problems that have strained state and local capabilities," said
Mr. Bush, slightly exaggerating the stricken land area. "The
result is that many of our citizens simply are not getting
the help they need, especially in New Orleans. And that is
unacceptable."
The president was flanked by his high military and emergency
command: Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld, Homeland Security
Secretary Michael Chertoff and Gen. Richard B. Myers, chairman
of the Joint Chiefs of Staff.
As Mr. Bush spoke, Vice President Dick Cheney and Karl Rove,
the president's senior political adviser, listened on the sidelines,
as did Dan Bartlett, the counselor to the president and Mr.
Bush's overseer of communications strategy. Their
presence underscored how seriously the White House is reacting
to the political crisis it faces.
"Where our response is not working, we'll make it right," Mr.
Bush said, as Mr. Bartlett, with a script in his hand, followed
closely.
His speech came as analysts and some Republicans warned that
the White House's response to the crisis in New Orleans, which
has been widely seen as slow and ineffectual, could further
undermine Mr. Bush's authority at a time when he was already
under fire, endangering his Congressional agenda.
Mr. Chertoff said Saturday: "Not an hour goes by that
we do not spend a lot of time thinking about the people who
are actively suffering. The United States, as the president
has said, is going to move heaven and earth to rescue, feed,
shelter" victims of the storm.
The White House said Mr. Bush would return to Louisiana and
Mississippi on Monday, scrapping his plans for a Labor Day
address in Maryland. The rest of Mr. Bush's schedule next week
was in flux.
The White House also postponed a major visit to Washington
next week by President Hu Jintao of China. In a statement issued
on Saturday, the White House said both Mr. Hu and Mr. Bush
had agreed that "in the present circumstances, it was
best not to have" the meeting, which would have demanded
much of the president's attention over the next days on growing
difficulties between the United States and China over trade
frictions, North Korea's nuclear program and China's military
buildup.
The last-minute overhaul of the president's plans reflected
what analysts and some Republicans said was a long-term threat
to Mr. Bush's presidency created by the perception that the
White House had failed to respond to the crisis. Several said
the political fallout over the hurricane could complicate a
second-term agenda that includes major changes to Social Security,
the tax code and the immigration system.
"This is very much going to divert the agenda,"
said Tom Rath, a New Hampshire Republican with ties to the
White House. "Some of this is momentary. I think the
Bush capital will be rapidly replenished if they begin to
respond here."
Donald P. Green, a professor of political
science at Yale University, said: "The possibility for
very serious damage to the administration exists. The unmistakable
conclusion one would draw from this was this was a massive
administration failure."
And Newt Gingrich, the former House speaker, urged Mr. Bush
to quickly propose a rebuilding plan for New Orleans and the
rest of the Gulf Coast, arguing that an ambitious gesture could
restore his power in Congress. [...]
The silence of many prominent Democrats reflects
their conclusion that the president is on treacherous political
ground and that attacking him would permit the White House
to dismiss the criticism as partisan politics-as-usual, a senior
Democratic aide said.
Scott McClellan, the White House press secretary, disputed
the notion that Mr. Bush's long-term political viability was
endangered and said Saturday that he was confident the administration
would be able to push ahead successfully with its second-term
agenda. "There are a number of priorities, and we will
address all of them,"
he said.
For all the enormity of the destruction and the lingering
uncertainty about how many years it will take to "rebuild
the great city of New Orleans," as Mr. Bush said in his
remarks on Saturday, some Republicans
suggested that the impact could prove fleeting in this age
of fast-moving events, and that Mr. Bush's visit to
the region on Friday had helped some in addressing concerns
about his response.
"Next Tuesday the Roberts hearings
start, and that's going to occupy a significant part of the
daily coverage," said Richard N. Bond, a former
Republican chairman, referring to the Supreme Court confirmation
hearings of Judge John G. Roberts Jr. [...]
But Mr. Bush, reflecting concern within the White House about
the president's standing among blacks, notably said in his
radio address that "we have a responsibility to our brothers
and sisters all along the Gulf Coast, and we will not rest
until we get this right and the job is done."
Both Republicans and Democrats noted that
the reaction to the crisis has been nothing like what happened
after the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, when both parties
joined in a bipartisan show of unity in the face of a clear
and identifiable outside threat.
Hurricane Katrina struck at a time, they said, when Mr. Bush
was already in a weakened state, with his approval rating in
many national polls at the lowest level of his presidency and
his political capital in Washington diminishing. [...]
|
Charities and the federal
government launched what aid agencies predicted could be the
longest and costliest relief effort in U.S. history, as workers
began arriving last night in states devastated by Hurricane
Katrina, and as the U.S. military organized an intensive response
by already stretched National Guard and active duty forces.
The American Red Cross, working in concert with the Federal
Emergency Management Agency, called its plan to house and
feed tens of thousands of people its biggest response to
a single natural disaster in the organization's 124-year
history. With deep flooding that may not recede for weeks
in areas across three states, charities said thousands could
remain homeless for more than a year and that the rebuilding
would probably take even longer.
"This disaster response is going to exceed our response
to last year's back-to-back four hurricanes"
in Florida, said Red Cross spokeswoman Devorah Goldburg. That
effort included serving 16.5 million meals and providing the
equivalent of 430,000 nights of shelter.
"We're anticipating that Katrina will exceed those numbers."
The needs were as immense as they were varied, ranging from
urgent search-and-rescue requests to pressing demands for shelter
and clean water, and daunting longer-range challenges that
were barely coming into focus last night.
The Air Force, Navy and Army began mobilizing
troops and equipment to augment National Guard units, including
helicopters with night-search gear and amphibious watercraft
with civilian teams for rescuing stranded citizens. The Navy
and U.S. Merchant Marine readied five ships in Norfolk and
Baltimore: the hospital ship USNS Comfort, as well as helicopter-carrying
vessels and ships that can carry landing craft, construction
equipment, Humvees, forklifts, food, fuel and water-purification
equipment.
'Sheer magnitude'
For the first time, the Pentagon yesterday created a joint
domestic task force -- headed by a three-star general and based
in Mississippi -- to coordinate emergency operations by Guard
and active-duty forces across four states. Driving the U.S.
military response was the realization of the "sheer magnitude" of
the catastrophe once dawn broke, said Michael Kucharek, spokesman
for U.S. Northern Command in Colorado Springs.
The Red Cross had opened more than
200 shelters yesterday in concert with FEMA, which
mobilized before the storm when President Bush designated
Louisiana and Mississippi disaster areas. That allowed FEMA
rescue workers to bring in water, ice and ready-to-eat meals
before Katrina hit.
While rescue units pulled stranded residents from floodwater
yesterday, a 50-member FEMA team was in Louisiana, making plans
to buy, order and move hundreds of thousands of mobile homes
into the area. FEMA will reimburse flood victims for rental
housing, FEMA spokeswoman Natalie Rule said. The need was made
more urgent yesterday when Louisiana officials decided to evacuate
the Superdome, a city-designated shelter damaged by wind and
flooding and made miserable for its inhabitants by a lack of
electricity and clean water. [...]
Floodwaters 'holding us back'
"We're getting phone calls asking for teams to rescue
people still trapped in their homes," especially in New
Orleans and the Mississippi cities of Biloxi and Gulfport,
said Maj. George Hood, national community relations secretary
for the Salvation Army. The charity was feeding and housing
storm victims on the perimeters of the disaster. "We
have a team 400 or 500 people in Jackson, Mississippi, [waiting
for] the green light, but it's the floodwaters holding us back," Hood
said. Accurate information about
the disaster area was scarce, "because nothing is working," he
said. [...] |
NEW ORLEANS (Reuters) - New Orleans began
the gruesome task of collecting its thousands of dead on Sunday
as the Bush administration tried to save face after its botched
rescue plans left the city at the mercy of Hurricane Katrina.
Except for rescue workers and scattered groups of people,
streets in the once-vibrant capital of jazz and good times
were all but abandoned after a mass exodus of hundreds of
thousands of refugees into neighboring Texas and other states.
Battered and sickened survivors made no attempt to disguise
their anger: "We have been abandoned by our own country, " Aaron
Broussard, president of Jefferson Parish, just south of New
Orleans, told NBC's Meet the Press.
"It's not just Katrina that caused all these deaths in
New Orleans," Broussard said. "Bureaucracy has committed
murder here in the greater New Orleans area, and bureaucracy
has to stand trial before Congress now."
After a nightmare confluence of natural disaster and political
ineptitude that al Qaeda-linked Web sites called evidence of
the "wrath of God" striking America, National Guard
troops and U.S. marshals patrolled the city, stricken in the
days after the hurricane by anarchic violence and looting.
[...]
President George W. Bush, who in a rare admission of error,
conceded on Friday that the results of his administration's
relief efforts were unacceptable, said on Saturday he would
send 7,200 more active-duty troops over three days.
Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld toured a medical facility
at New Orleans' international airport on Sunday. He
spoke and shook hands with military and rescue officials but
walked right by a dozen refugees lying on stretchers just feet
away from him, most of them extremely sick or handicapped.
Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice was touring the Mobile,
Alabama, area, in her native state.
A further 10,000 National Guard troops were being sent to
storm-hit Louisiana and Mississippi, raising the total to 40,000. A
total of 54,000 military personnel are now committed to relief
efforts.
Lawmakers promised to allocate more relief money in coming
weeks after Bush signed a $10.5 billion aid package for Gulf
Coast areas hit by Katrina. [...]
'TWO CATASTROPHES'
Defending the administration's response and disaster planning,
Chertoff said the hurricane and flood in New Orleans were "two
catastrophes" that presented an unprecedented challenge.
"That perfect storm of combination of catastrophes exceeded
the foresight of the planners and maybe anybody's foresight," the
homeland security chief said.
Critics have said the Federal Emergency Management
Agency has lost its effectiveness since it became part of the
Homeland Security Department in a post-September 11 reorganization.
Rice was slammed by critics on the Internet
after she attended a New York performance of the Monty Python
musical "Spamalot" on Wednesday, a day after New
Orleans flooded.
After returning to Washington, she defended the administration
against charges the slow government response and prolonged
suffering of New Orleans' predominantly black storm victims
were signs of racial neglect.
"That Americans would somehow in a color-affected
way decide who to help and who not to help, I just don't believe
it," said Rice, the administration's highest-ranking black
official.
The Washington Post reported on Sunday
that Bush administration officials were blaming state and
local authorities for the disaster response problems. The
newspaper said the administration was rebuffed in an effort
to take control of police and National Guard units reporting
to Louisiana Gov. Kathleen Blanco, a Democrat. |
Defending the U.S. government's response
to Hurricane Katrina, Homeland Security
Secretary Michael Chertoff argued Saturday that government
planners did not predict such a disaster ever could occur.
But in fact, government officials, scientists
and journalists have warned of such a scenario for years.
Chertoff, fielding questions from reporters, said government
officials did not expect both a powerful hurricane and a breach
of levees that would flood the city of New Orleans.
"That 'perfect storm' of a combination
of catastrophes exceeded the foresight of the planners, and
maybe anybody's foresight," Chertoff said.
He called the disaster "breathtaking in its surprise."
But engineers say the levees preventing this below-sea-level
city from being turned into a swamp were built to withstand
only Category 3 hurricanes. And officials have warned for years
that a Category 4 could cause the levees to fail.
Katrina was a Category 4 hurricane when it struck the Gulf
Coast on September 29.
Last week, Michael Brown, head of the Federal
Emergency Management Agency, told CNN his agency had recently
planned for a Category 5 hurricane hitting New Orleans.
Speaking to "Larry King Live" on August 31, in the
wake of Katrina, Brown said, "That Category 4 hurricane
caused the same kind of damage that we anticipated. So we planned
for it two years ago. Last year, we exercised it. And unfortunately
this year, we're implementing it."
Brown suggested FEMA -- part of the Department
of Homeland Security -- was carrying out a prepared plan, rather
than having to suddenly create a new one.
Chertoff argued that authorities actually had assumed that "there
would be overflow from the levee, maybe a small break in the
levee. The collapse of a significant portion of the levee leading
to the very fast flooding of the city was not envisioned."
He added: "There will be plenty of time to go back and
say we should hypothesize evermore apocalyptic combinations
of catastrophes. Be that as it may, I'm telling you this is
what the planners had in front of them. They were confronted
with a second wave that they did not have built into the plan,
but using the tools they had, we have to move forward and adapt."
But New Orleans, state and federal officials have long painted
a very different picture.
"We certainly understood the potential
impact of a Category 4 or 5 hurricane" on New Orleans,
Lt. General Carl Strock, chief of engineers for the U.S. Army
Corps of Engineers, said Thursday, Cox News Service reported.
Reuters reported that in 2004, more than 40 state, local and
volunteer organizations practiced a scenario in which a massive
hurricane struck and levees were breached, allowing water to
flood New Orleans. Under the simulation, called "Hurricane
Pam," the officials "had to deal with an imaginary
storm that destroyed more than half a million buildings in
New Orleans and forced the evacuation of a million residents,"
the Reuters report said.
In 2002 the New Orleans Times-Picayune ran a five-part series
exploring the vulnerability of the city. The newspaper, and
other news media as well, specifically addressed the possibility
of massive floods drowning residents, destroying homes and
releasing toxic chemicals throughout the city. (Read: "Times-Picayune"
Special Report: Washing awayexternal link)
Scientists long have discussed this possibility as a sort
of doomsday scenario. [...]
But Chertoff seemed unaware of all the warnings. [...]
Chertoff also argued that authorities did not have much notice
that the storm would be so powerful and could make a direct
hit on New Orleans.
"It wasn't until comparatively late,
shortly before -- a day, maybe a day and a half, before landfall
-- that it became clear that this was going to be a Category
4 or 5 hurricane headed for the New Orleans area."
As far back as Friday, August 26, the
National Hurricane Center was predicting the storm could
be a Category 4 hurricane at landfall, with New Orleans directly
in its path. Still, storms do change paths, so the
possibility existed that it might not hit the city.
But the National Weather Service prediction proved almost
perfect. [...] |
The federal official in charge of the
bungled New Orleans rescue was fired from his last private-sector
job overseeing horse shows.
And before joining the Federal Emergency Management Agency
as a deputy director in 2001, GOP activist Mike
Brown had no significant experience that would have qualified
him for the position.
The Oklahoman got the job through an old college friend who
at the time was heading up FEMA.
The agency, run by Brown since 2003, is now at the center
of a growing fury over the handling of the New Orleans disaster.
"I look at FEMA and I shake my head," said a furious
Gov. Mitt Romney yesterday, calling the response
"an embarrassment."
President Bush, after touring the Big Easy, said he was "not
satisfied" with the emergency response to Hurricane Katrina's
devastation.
And U.S. Rep. Stephen Lynch predicted there would be hearings
on Capitol Hill over the mishandled operation.
Brown - formerly an estates and family lawyer - this week
has has made several shocking public admissions, including
interviews where he suggested FEMA was unaware of the misery
and desperation of refugees stranded at the New Orleans convention
center.
Before joining the Bush administration in 2001, Brown spent
11 years as the commissioner of judges and stewards for the
International Arabian Horse Association, a breeders' and horse-show
organization based in Colorado.
"We do disciplinary actions, certification
of (show trial) judges. We hold classes to train people to
become judges and stewards. And we keep records," explained
a spokeswoman for the IAHA commissioner's office. "This
was his full-time job . . . for 11 years," she added.
Brown was forced out of the position after
a spate of lawsuits over alleged supervision failures.
"He was asked to resign," Bill
Pennington, president of the IAHA at the time, confirmed last
night.
Soon after, Brown was invited to join the administration by
his old Oklahoma college roommate Joseph Allbaugh, the previous
head of FEMA until he quit in 2003 to work for the president's
re-election campaign.
The White House last night defended Brown's appointment. A
spokesman noted Brown served as FEMA deputy director and general
counsel before taking the top job, and that he has now overseen
the response to "more than 164 declared disasters and
emergencies," including last year's record-setting hurricane
season. |
Les Evenchick, an independent Green who
lives in the French Quarter of New Orleans in a 3-story walkup,
reports that 90 percent of the so-called looters are simply
grabbing water, food, diapers and medicines, because the federal
and state officials have refused to provide these basic necessities.
Les says that "it's only because of the looters that
non-looters -- old people, sick people, small children --
are able to survive."
Those people who stole televisions and large non-emergency
items have been selling them, Les reports (having witnessed
several of these "exchanges") so that they could
get enough money together to leave the area.
Think about it:
- People were told to leave, but all the bus stations
had closed down the night before and the personnel sent
packing.
- Many people couldn't afford tickets anyway.
- Many people are stranded, and others are refusing to
leave their homes, pets, etc. They don't have cars.
You want people to stop looting? Provide
the means for them to eat, and to leave the area.
Some tourists in the Monteleone Hotel paid
$25,000 for 10 buses. The buses were sent (I guess there were
many buses available, if you paid the price!) but the military
confiscated them to use not for transporting people in the
Dome but for the military. The tourists were not allowed to
leave. Instead, the military ordered the tourists to the now-infamous
Convention Center.
How simple it would have been for the State and/or US government
to have provided buses for people before the hurricane hit,
and throughout this week. Even evacuating 100,000 people trapped
there -- that's 3,000 buses, less than come into Washington
D.C. for some of the giant antiwar demonstrations there. Even
at $2,500 a pop -- highway robbery -- that would only be a
total of $7.5 million for transporting all of those who did
not have the means to leave.
Instead, look at the human and economic cost of not doing
that!
So why didn't they do that?
On Wednesday a number of Greens tried to
bring a large amount of water to the SuperDome. They were prevented
from doing so, as have many others. Why
have food and water been blocked from reaching tens of thousands
of poor people?
On Thursday, the government used the excuse that there were
some very scattered gunshots (two or three instances only)
-- around 1/50th of the number of gunshots that occur in New
York City on an average day -- to shut down voluntary rescue
operations and to scrounge for 5,000 National Guard troops
fully armed, with "shoot to kill" orders -- at a
huge economic cost.
They even refused to allow voluntary workers who had rescued
over 1,000 people in boats over the previous days to continue
on Thursday, using the several gunshots (and who knows who
shot off those rounds?) to say "It's too dangerous". The
volunteers didn't think the gunshots were dangerous to them
and wanted to continue their rescue operations and had to be "convinced" at
gunpoint to "cease and desist."
There is something sinister going down --
it's not just incompetence or negligence.
How could FEMA and Homeland Security
not have something so basic as bottled drinking water in
the SuperDome, which was long a part of the hurricane plan? One
police officer in charge of his 120-person unit said yesterday
that his squad was provided with only 70 small bottles of
water.
Two years ago, New Orleans residents -- the only area in the
entire state that voted in huge numbers against the candidacy
of George Bush -- also fought off attempts to privatize the
drinking water supply. There have also been major battles to
block Shell Oil's attempt to build a Liquid Natural Gas facility,
and to prevent the teardown of public housing (which failed),
with the Mayor lining up in the latter two issues on the side
of the oil companies and the developers.
One of the first acts of Governor Kathleen Blanco (a Democrat,
by the way) during this crisis was to turn off the drinking
water, to force people to evacuate. There was no health reason
to turn it off, as the water is drawn into a separate system
from the Mississippi River, not the polluted lake, and purified
through self-powered purification plants separate from the
main electric grid. If necessary, people could have been told
to boil their water -- strangely, the municipal natural gas
used in stoves was still functioning properly as of Thursday
night!
There are thousands of New Orleans residents who are refusing
to evacuate because they don't want to leave their pets, their
homes, or who have no money to do so nor place to go. The government
-- which could have and should have provided water and food
to residents of New Orleans -- has not done so intentionally
to force people to evacuate by starving them out. This is a
crime of the gravest sort.
We need to understand that the capability
has been there from the start to drive water and food right
up to the convention center, as those roads have been clear
-- it's how the National Guard drove into the city.
Let me say this again: The government is intentionally not
allowing food or water in.
This is for real.
MSNBC interviewed dozens of people who had
gotten out. Every single one of them was white.
The people who are poor (primarily Black but many poor Whites
as well) are finally being allowed to leave the horrendous
conditions in the SuperDome; many are being bussed to the AstroDome
in Houston.
Call them "People of the Dome."
If people resist the National Guard coming to remove them
against their will, will New Orleans become known as the first
battle in the new American revolution?
Mitchel Cohen is co-editor of "G", the newspaper
of the NY State Greens. He can be reached at: mitchelcohen@mindspring.com |
NEW ORLEANS - People left homeless by
Hurricane Katrina told horrific stories of rape, murder and trigger
happy guards in two New Orleans centers that were set
up as shelters but became places of violence and terror.
Police and National Guard troops on Saturday closed down
the two centers -- the Superdome arena and the city's convention
centre -- but then penned them in outside in sweltering heat
to keep them from trying to walk out of the city.
Military helicopters and buses staged a massive evacuation
to take away thousands of people who waited in orderly lines
in stifling heat outside the flooded convention centre.
The refugees, who were waiting to be taken to sports stadiums
and other huge shelters across Texas and northern Louisiana,
described how the convention centre and the Superdome became
lawless hellholes beset by rape and murder.
Several residents of the impromptu shantytown
recounted two horrific incidents where those charged with keeping
people safe had killed them instead.
In one, a young man was run down and then shot by a New Orleans
police officer, in another a man seeking help was gunned down
by a National Guard soldier, witnesses said.
Police here refused to discuss or confirm either incident.
National Guard spokesman Lt. Col Pete Schneider said
"I have not heard any information of a weapon being discharged."
"They killed a man here last night,"
Steve Banka, 28, told Reuters. "A young lady was being
raped and stabbed. And the sounds of her screaming got to this
man and so he ran out into the street to get help from troops,
to try to flag down a passing lorry of them, and he jumped
up on the truck's windscreen and they shot him dead."
Wade Batiste, 48, recounted another tale of horror.
"Last night at 8 p.m. they shot a kid
of just 16. He was just crossing the street. They ran him over,
the New Orleans police did, and then they got out of the car
and shot him in the head," Batiste said.
The young man's body lay in the street by
the Convention Center's entrance on Saturday morning, covered
in a black blanket, a stream of congealed blood staining the
street around him. Nearby his family sat in shock.
A member of that family, Africa Brumfield,
32, confirmed the incident but declined to be quoted
about it, saying her family did not wish to discuss it. But
she spoke of general conditions here.
"There is rapes going on here. Women cannot go to the
bathroom without men. They are raping them and slitting their
throats. They keep telling us the buses are coming but they
never leave," she said through tears.
People here said there
were now 22 bodies of adults and children stored inside the
building, but troops guarding the building refused
to confirm that and threatened to beat reporters seeking
access to the makeshift morgue.
People trying to walk out are forced back at gunpoint - something
troops said was for their own safety. "It's sad, but how
far do you think they would get,"
one soldier said.
"They have us living here like animals,"
said Wvonnette Grace-Jordan, here with five children, the youngest
only six weeks old. "We have only had two meals, we
have no medicine and now there are thousands of people defecating
in the streets. This is wrong. This is the United States
of America."
One National Guard soldier who asked not to
be named for fear of punishment from his commanding officer
said of the lack of medical attention at the centre, "They
(the Bush administration) care more about Iraq and Afghanistan
than here."
The Louisiana National Guard soldier said, "We are doing
the best we can with the resources we have, but almost all
of our guys are in Iraq."
Across town at the Superdome, where as many as 38,000 refugees
camped out until Wednesday night when evacuation buses first
came, the 4,000 still there were corralled outside, hoping
to get on four waiting buses with seats for only 200.
The scene at the sports stadium was one of abject filth. Crammed
into a small area after the building was shut to them last
night, those remaining sat amid heaps of garbage, piled in
places waist high. The stench of human waste pervaded the interior
of the now vacant stadium.
One police officer told Reuters there
were 100 people in a makeshift morgue at the Superdome, mostly
people who died of heat exhaustion, and that six babies
had been born there since last Saturday, when people arrived
to take shelter.
At the arena, too, there was much talk of bedlam after dark.
"We found a young girl raped and killed
in the bathroom," one National Guard soldier told Reuters. "Then
the crowd got the man and they beat him to death." |
EDWARDS AIR FORCE BASE, California --
Air-raid sirens, Frank Sinatra songs and Muhammad Ali trash
talk blared over the Southern California desert in a demonstration
of new acoustic technology for crowd control and disaster communications.
In mid-90's morning heat at Edwards Air Force Base, HPV
Technologies and American Technology demonstrated prototypes
of non-lethal sonic devices for a group of military and law
enforcement guests, including representatives of the U.K.
Home Office.
Representatives of both companies say that
within days, they will ship some units of their respective
products to areas hit by Hurricane Katrina, so authorities
can use the tools for crowd control, aid distribution and rescue
operations.
Costa Mesa, California-based HPV showed off three sizes of
its Magnetic Acoustic Device, or MAD, a black square panel
composed of multiple speakers. The units on display ranged
from about 4 to 10 feet across.
The device uses magnets approximately 6 inches tall and 9.25
inches wide to convert electrical pulses into sound waves,
and is capable of aiming sound precisely for thousands of feet
-- like the sonic equivalent of a laser, or spotlight.
Its path and reach can be affected by environmental factors
such as nearby flat surfaces, hills, bodies of water or strong
bursts of wind.
A series of test sounds beamed out by MAD, including gunfire,
music and instructional commands, were audible and intelligible
at distances of up to a mile.
When a subject is at close range in MAD's
sonic path, and it is set to high volume, the sound can be
excruciating.
The ability to broadcast instructions or alerts at great distances
with minimal distortion could be useful for authorities and
rescue crews in areas where other communications systems are
unavailable.
American Technology is donating four devices -- three MRADs
(medium-range acoustic devices) and one LRAD (long-range acoustic
device). The four devices will be shipped
out Friday to a Marine military police unit that is deploying
to the Gulf States area for disaster-relief efforts.
"We are donating the use of one of our
most powerful prototypes, LTPMS-2, for use in Mississippi as
soon as possible, because the governor of that state said that
the biggest problem they have right now is the fact that they
have no communications infrastructure to get information or
instructions out to people," he said. "They can very
easily put this on a truck and send sound out for a minimum
of at least a mile in either direction."
The Los Angeles Sheriff's Department, which hosted the event
as a guest of the Air Force base, is considering using MAD
to replace conventional public address systems and as a non-lethal "area
denial option" -- a way to clear crowds in civil unrest
without using chemical agents, rubber bullets or the like.
"You don't appreciate how powerful this stuff is until
you stand a mile away and can't see the transmitter -- but
can hear every word in a Queen song," said Cmdr. Sid Heal,
who heads the Los Angeles Sheriff's Department technology exploration
program. "At a quarter mile, it sounds as clear as a car
radio; at a half a mile, you have to raise your voice to talk
to the guy next to you; at three quarters of a mile, laborers
raking up leaves were putting in music requests." |
NEW ORLEANS - Reeling from the chaos of
this overwhelmed city, at least 200
New Orleans police officers have walked away from their jobs
and two have committed suicide, police officials said
on Saturday.
Some officers told their superiors they were leaving, police
officials said. Others worked for a while and then stopped
showing up. Still others, for reasons not always clear, never
made it in after the storm.
The absences come during a period of extraordinary stress
for the New Orleans Police Department. For nearly a week, many
of its 1,500 members have had to work around the clock, trying
to cope with flooding, an overwhelming crush of refugees, looters
and occasional snipers.
P. Edwin Compass III, the superintendent of police, said most
of his officers were staying at their posts. But in an unusual
note of sympathy for a top police official, he said it was
understandable that many were frustrated. He said morale was "not
very good."
"If I put you out on the street and made you get into
gun battles all day with no place to urinate and no place to
defecate, I don't think you would be too happy either," Mr.
Compass said in an interview.
"Our vehicles can't get any gas. The water in the street
is contaminated. My officers are walking around in wet shoes."
Fire Department officials said they did not know of any firefighters
who had quit. But they, too, were sympathetic to struggling
emergency workers.
W. J. Riley, the assistant superintendent of police, said
there were about 1,200 officers on duty on Saturday. He said
the department was not sure how many officers had decided to
abandon their posts and how many simply could not get to work.
Mr. Riley said some of the officers who left
the force "couldn't handle the pressure"
and were "certainly not the people we need in this department."
He said, "The others are not here because they lost a
spouse, or their family or their home was destroyed."
Police officials did not identify the officers
who took their lives, one on Saturday and the other the day
before. But they said one had been a patrol officer, who a
senior officer said "was absolutely outstanding." The
other was an aide to Mr. Compass. The superintendent said his
aide had lost his home in the hurricane and had been unable
to find his family.
Because of the hurricane, many police officers and firefighters
have been isolated and unable to report for duty. Others evacuated
their families and have been unable to get back to New Orleans.
Still, some officers simply appear to have given up.
A Baton Rouge police officer said he had a friend on the New
Orleans force who told him he threw his badge out a car window
in disgust just after fleeing the city into neighboring Jefferson
Parish as the hurricane approached. The Baton Rouge officer
would not give his name, citing a department policy banning
comments to the news media.
The officer said he had also heard of an incident in which
two men in a New Orleans police cruiser were stopped in Baton
Rouge on suspicion of driving a stolen squad car. The men were,
in fact, New Orleans officers who had ditched their uniforms
and were trying to reach a town in north Louisiana, the officer
said.
"They were doing everything to get out of New Orleans," he
said. "They didn't have the resources to do the job, or
a plan, so they left."
The result is an even heavier burden on those who are patrolling
the street, rescuing flood victims and trying to fight fires
with no running water, no electricity, no reliable telephones.
Police and fire officials have been begging federal authorities
for assistance and criticizing a lack of federal response for
several days.
"We need help," said Charles Parent, the superintendent
of the Fire Department. Mr. Parent again appealed in an interview
on Saturday for replacement fire trucks and radio equipment
from federal authorities. And Mr. Compass again appealed for
more federal help.
"When I have officers committing suicide," Mr.
Compass said, "I think we've reached a point when I don't
know what more it's going to take to get the attention of those
in control of the response."
The National Guard has come under criticism for not moving
more quickly into New Orleans. Lt. Gen. H Steven Blum, the
head of the National Guard Bureau, told reporters on Saturday
that the Guard had not moved in sooner because it had not anticipated
the collapse of civilian law enforcement. [...] |
Last September, a Category
5 hurricane battered the small island of Cuba with
160-mile-per-hour winds. More than
1.5 million Cubans were evacuated to higher ground ahead
of the storm. Although the hurricane
destroyed 20,000 houses, no one died.
What is Cuban President Fidel Castro's secret? According
to Dr. Nelson Valdes, a sociology professor at the University
of New Mexico, and specialist in Latin America, "the
whole civil defense is embedded in the community to begin
with. People know ahead of time where they are to go."
"Cuba's leaders go on TV and take charge,"
said Valdes. Contrast this with George W. Bush's reaction to
Hurricane Katrina. The day after Katrina hit the Gulf Coast,
Bush was playing golf. He waited three days to make a TV
appearance and five days before visiting the disaster site.
In a scathing editorial on Thursday, the New York Times said, "nothing
about the president's demeanor yesterday - which seemed casual
to the point of carelessness - suggested that he understood
the depth of the current crisis."
"Merely sticking people in a stadium
is unthinkable" in Cuba, Valdes said. "Shelters all
have medical personnel, from the neighborhood. They have family
doctors in Cuba, who evacuate together with the neighborhood,
and already know, for example, who needs insulin."
They also evacuate animals and veterinarians,
TV sets and refrigerators, "so that people aren't reluctant
to leave because people might steal their stuff," Valdes
observed.
After Hurricane Ivan, the United Nations
International Secretariat for Disaster Reduction cited Cuba
as a model for hurricane preparation. ISDR director
Salvano Briceno said, "The Cuban way could easily be
applied to other countries with similar economic conditions
and even in countries with greater resources that do not
manage to protect their population as well as Cuba does."
Our federal and local governments had more than ample warning
that hurricanes, which are growing in intensity thanks to global
warming, could destroy New Orleans. Yet, instead of heeding
those warnings, Bush set about to prevent states from controlling
global warming, weaken FEMA, and cut the Army Corps of Engineers'
budget for levee construction in New Orleans by $71.2 million,
a 44 percent reduction.
Bush sent nearly half our National Guard troops and high-water
Humvees to fight in an unnecessary war in Iraq. Walter Maestri,
emergency management chief for Jefferson Paris in New Orleans,
noted a year ago, "It appears that the money has been
moved in the president's budget to handle homeland security
and the war in Iraq."
An Editor and Publisher article Wednesday said the Army Corps
of Engineers "never tried to hide the fact that the spending
pressures of the war in Iraq, as well as homeland security
- coming at the same time as federal tax cuts - was the reason
for the strain,"
which caused a slowdown of work on flood control and sinking
levees.
"This storm was much greater than protection we were
authorized to provide," said Alfred C. Naomi, a senior
project manager in the New Orleans district of the corps.
Unlike in Cuba, where homeland security
means keeping the country secure from deadly natural disasters
as well as foreign invasions, Bush has failed to keep our
people safe. "On a fundamental
level," Paul Krugman wrote in yesterday's New York Times, "our
current leaders just aren't serious about some of the essential
functions of government. They like waging war, but they don't
like providing security, rescuing those in need or spending
on prevention measures. And they never, ever ask for shared
sacrifice."
During the 2004 election campaign, vice presidential candidate
John Edwards spoke of "the two Americas."
It seems unfathomable how people can shoot at rescue workers.
Yet, after the beating of Rodney King aired on televisions
across the country, poor, desperate, hungry people in Watts
took over their neighborhoods, burning and looting. Their anger,
which had seethed below the surface for so long, erupted. That's
what's happening now in New Orleans. And we, mostly white,
people of privilege, rarely catch a glimpse of this other America.
"I think a lot of it has to do with race and class,"
said Rev. Calvin O. Butts III, pastor of the Abyssinian Baptist
Church in Harlem. "The people affected were largely
poor people. Poor, black people."
New Orleans Mayor Ray Nagin reached a breaking point Thursday
night. "You mean to tell me that a place where you probably
have thousands of people that have died and thousands more
that are dying every day, that we can't figure out a way to
authorize the resources we need? Come on, man!"
Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff had boasted earlier
in the day that FEMA and other federal agencies have done a "magnificent
job" under the circumstances.
But, said, Nagin, "They're feeding the people a line
of bull, and they are spinning and people are dying. Get off
your asses and let's do something!"
When asked about the looting, the mayor said that except for
a few "knuckleheads," it is the result of desperate
people trying to find food and water to survive.
Nagin blamed the outbreak of violence and crime on drug addicts
who have been cut off from their drug supplies, wandering the
city, "looking to take the edge off their jones."
When Hurricane Ivan hit Cuba, no curfew was
imposed; yet, no looting or violence took place. Everyone was
in the same boat.
Fidel Castro, who has compared his government's preparations
for Hurricane Ivan to the island's long-standing preparations
for an invasion by the United States, said, "We've been
preparing for this for 45 years."
On Thursday, Cuba's National Assembly sent a message of solidarity
to the victims of Hurricane Katrina. It says the Cuban people
have followed closely the news of the hurricane damage in Louisiana,
Mississippi and Alabama, and the news has caused pain and sadness.
The message notes that the hardest hit are African-Americans,
Latino workers, and the poor, who still wait to be rescued
and taken to secure places, and who have suffered the most
fatalities and homelessness. The message concludes by saying
that the entire world must feel this tragedy as its own.
Marjorie Cohn, a contributing editor to t r u t h o u
t, is a professor at Thomas Jefferson School of Law, executive
vice president of the National Lawyers Guild, and the US
representative to the executive committee of the American
Association of Jurists. |
WHITE HOUSE -- President Bush heads back
to America's Gulf Coast today (Monday) for an update on efforts
to help the victims of Hurricane Katrina. It will be his second
visit to the storm-ravaged area in four days.
This is the Labor Day Holiday in the United States. But
there is no celebration along the Gulf Coast, where many
are focusing on surviving from one day to the next.
Soldiers and supplies have been pouring into the region, and
the chaos that plagued so many communities has begun to ease.
But a week after the hurricane struck, search and rescue efforts
are continuing, with stranded storm victims being plucked one
by one off rooftops in the hard-hit city of New Orleans. Hundreds-of-thousands
of people are displaced, and many towns are piles of rubble
and debris. [...] |
NEW ORLEANS - Police shot and killed at
least five people Sunday after gunmen opened fire on a group
of contractors traveling across a bridge on their way to make
repairs, authorities said.
Deputy Police Chief W.J. Riley said police shot at eight
people carrying guns, killing five or six.
Fourteen contractors were traveling across
the Danziger Bridge under police escort when they came under
fire, said John Hall, a spokesman for the Army Corps of Engineers.
They were on their way to launch barges into Lake Pontchartrain
to help plug the breech in the 17th Street Canal, Hall said.
None of the contractors was injured, Mike
Rogers, a disaster relief coordinator with the Army Corps of
Engineers, told reporters in Baton Rouge.
The bridge spans a canal connecting Lake Pontchartrain and
the Mississippi River.
No other details were immediately available. |
Associated Press reports that at
least five people shot dead by police as they walked across
a New Orleans bridge yesterday were contractors working for
the US Defence department.
A spokesman for the Army Corps of Engineers said the victims
were contractors on their way to repair a canal. The contractors
were on their way across the bridge to launch barges into
Lake Pontchartrain, in an operation to fix the 17th Street
Canal, according to the spokesman.
The shootings took place on the Danziger Bridge, across a
canal connecting Lake Pontchartrain to the Mississippi River.
Early on Sunday, Deputy Police Chief W.J. Riley of New Orleans
said police shot at eight people, killing five or six.
No other details were immediately available. |
NEW YORK Accompanying her husband, former
President George H.W.Bush, on a tour of hurricane relief centers
in Houston, Barbara Bush said today, referring to the poor
who had lost everything back home and evacuated, "This
is working very well for them."
The former First Lady's remarks were aired this evening
on National Public Radio's "Marketplace" program.
She was part of a group in Houston today at the Astrodome
that included her husband and former President Bill Clinton,
who were chosen by her son, the current president, to head
fundraising efforts for the recovery. Sen. Hilary Clinton and
Sen. Barack Obama were also present.
In a segment at the top of the show on the surge of evacuees
to the Texas city, Barbara Bush said: "Almost
everyone I've talked to says we're going to move to Houston."
Then she added: "What I'm hearing which
is sort of scary is they all want to stay in Texas. Everyone
is so overwhelmed by the hospitality.
"And so many of the people in the arena
here, you know, were underprivileged anyway, so this--this
(she chuckles slightly) is working very well for them." |
The Navy has hired Houston-based Halliburton
Co. to restore electric power, repair roofs and remove debris
at three naval facilities in Mississippi damaged by Hurricane
Katrina.
Halliburton subsidiary KBR will also perform damage assessments
at other naval installations in New Orleans as soon as it
is safe to do so.
KBR was assigned the work under a "construction capabilities" contract
awarded in 2004 after a competitive bidding process. The company
is not involved in the Army Corps of Engineers' effort to repair
New Orleans' levees. |
Imagine an America where everyone is displaced.
It's survival of the fittest as all law and order has broken
down. Martial law has been declared with 24 hr curfews, Posse
Comitatus has been overturned and there are troops on the streets
shooting anyone who disobeys their orders. Thousands and thousands
of people are starving but the authorities will not allow aid
in any significant amounts. Large crowds are quelled with the
use of sonic lasers, whilst overhead drone aircraft monitor
the area, checking for any anomalous activity.
Any form of Local and State government has been abandoned
and officials have been forcibly removed against their wills.
The elite infiltrators of the Federal Government watch on
from afar, in control of everything, answering to no one
and getting fat off the profits of their own corrupt inactivity
which brought about the situation in the first instance.
They like it that way, it suits them down to the ground,
why should they do anything to improve the situation?
This is the nightmare situation of a New World Order takeover
in America. It is what we have been warning the world about
for years. It is no longer some distant
possibility on the horizon that our children may have to endure
and fight against, it is here, it is now. New
Orleans is a testing ground for this exact scenario, all this
is going on there now. We are witnessing in New Orleans, the
construction of a microcosm for a "New America" and
a New World Order.
If it keeps on rainin', levee's goin'
to break
The overriding issue that is simply being ignored by the mainstream
media is that it was the federal government itself that lowered
the guard in cutting off key funding to protect Louisiana from
natural disasters.
The New Orleans district of the US Army Corps of Engineers
bore the brunt of a record $71.2
million reduction in federal funding for fiscal year 2006.
The Army Corps of Engineers sought $105 million for hurricane
and flood programs in New Orleans, while the White House slashed
the request to about $40 million. Congress finally approved
$42.2 million, less than half of the agency's request
The Bush administration has been cutting funding for federal
disaster relief funds since 2001 while doubling funding in other
areas to pump up the biggest growth in government for decades,
easily outstripping that of Bill Clinton.
A report from the Best
of New Orleans news website outlines the details.
"...Among emergency specialists, 'mitigation' -- the
measures taken in advance to minimize the damage caused by
natural disasters -- is a crucial part of the strategy to save
lives and cut recovery costs. But since 2001, key federal disaster
mitigation programs, developed over many years, have been slashed
and tossed aside. FEMA's Project Impact, a model mitigation
program created by the Clinton administration, has been canceled
outright. Federal funding of post-disaster mitigation efforts
designed to protect people and property from the next disaster
has been cut in half. Communities across the country must now
compete for pre-disaster mitigation dollars."
The Bush administration's move to merge FEMA with Homeland
Security meant that the two had to compete
for funding. Straightforward projects that would have massively
reduced the devastation we are now seeing, such as raising
houses, were cast aside in favor of anti-terrorism measures.
In early 2001, FEMA
issued a report stating that a hurricane striking New
Orleans was one of the three most
likely disasters in U.S., including a terrorist attack on
New York City!. "The New Orleans hurricane scenario," The
Houston Chronicle wrote in December 2001,
"may be the deadliest of all." But by 2003 the federal
funding for the flood control project essentially dried up
as it was drained into the Iraq war.
Walter Maestri, emergency management chief for Jefferson Parish,
Louisiana was quoted on June 8, 2004 in the New Orleans Times-Picayune,
as saying "It appears that the money has been moved in
the president's budget to handle homeland security and the
war in Iraq, and I suppose that's the price we pay. Nobody
locally is happy that the levees can't be finished, and we
are doing everything we can to make the case that this is a
security issue for us".
Ultimately, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers is directed,
along with 15 other agencies, by the Federal Emergency Management
Agency. "It is FEMA who is really calling the shots and
setting priorities here," Lt. Gen. Carl A. Strock, commander
of the corps has
said.
Much of the Netherlands lies below sea level and after the
1953 flood which killed 1,800 people, the Dutch launched a
major flood prevention program called the Delta
Plan. Engineers fortified dykes and bolstered other water
defenses against a future disaster and there hasn't been one
since. Had a similar project been in place for New Orleans
and had Bush not cut the funding, the misery and turmoil being
visited on that area would have been avoided.
Not only is the Bush Administration directly responsible for
the ferocity of this disaster, the blame also lies with Clinton.
10 years ago, the Clinton administration cut
98 flood control projects, including one in New Orleans,
saying such efforts should be local projects, not national.
A $120 million hurricane project, approved and financed annually
from 1965 was killed by the Clinton administration after being
approved by the Army Corps of Engineers. It was designed to
protect more than 140,000 West Bank residents east of the Harvey
Canal.
The New York Times has
reported that there were vivid reasons to push for the
greatest level of protection. One was Hurricane Betsy, a
midgrade storm that swamped much of New Orleans in 1965.
In 1969, Hurricane Camille, the second-most-powerful Atlantic
storm recorded, passed within 60 miles and demolished the
Mississippi coast.
Bob Sheets, a meteorologist who directed the National Hurricane
Center until retiring in 1995, has said that he and other federal
forecasters gave hundreds of talks about storm risks, and New
Orleans was always the case study for catastrophe since the
1970s. He has said of the city officials: "Essentially
they did nothing."
Despite all this, In an interview on Thursday the 1st September,
on "Good Morning America," President Bush said,
"I don't think anyone anticipated the breach of the levees."
Furthermore, the mainstream media, despite
several reports emerging to the contrary, republished
Bush's comments. The New York Times declared
that
"The response will be dissected for years.
But on Thursday, disaster experts and frustrated
officials said a crucial shortcoming may have
been the failure to predict that the levees
keeping Lake Pontchartrain out of the city
would be breached, not just overflow."
This April
2005 article in Popular Science proves that Bush's comments
were grossly inaccurate. "At 20 feet below sea level,
new Orleans is a prime target. An ambitious new levee system
would decrease the risk."
As World
Net Daily reported, a year ago, New Orleans reviewed
its hurricane disaster plans after Hurricane Ivan gave the
city a major scare forcing the evacuation of nearly 1 million
people from the area. Governor Kathleen Blanco and Mayor
Ray Nagin both acknowledged after the Ivan near miss they
needed a better evacuation plan.
Even the AP
noted at the time, "New Orleans dodged the knockout
punch many feared from the hurricane, but the storm exposed
what some say are significant flaws in the Big Easy's civil
disaster plans." The big flaws were that there simply
were no civil disaster plans and FEMA had no intention of
developing any.
So it is clear that Officials at the Army Corps of Engineers
and emergency managers and hurricane experts knew for years,
that the levees surrounding the New Orleans area were built
to withstand only a relatively weak Category 3 hurricane. Hurricane
Katrina, a Category 4 mega-storm, thus had devastating consequences.
Still funding was slashed and the disaster was allowed to happen.
When The Levee Breaks I'll have no place
to stay
In the aftermath of the disaster it has become obvious that
the Government has no interest in alleviating the suffering
and helping to restore civility in the region.
In particular FEMA, which has endlessly drilled for such situations,
has been a key hindrance. After the authorities in Baton Rouge
had prepared a field hospital for victims of the storm, FEMA
sent its first batch of supplies, all of which were designed
for use against chemical attack, including drugs such as Cipro,
which is designed for use against anthrax. The
London Guardian reported, "We called them up and asked
them: 'Why did you send that, and they said that's what it
says in the book'," said a Baton Rouge official.
Yet don't think for one second that FEMA is simply incompetent.
FEMA is criminally negligent. FEMA has done nothing to aid
the situation, in fact there have been reports that FEMA has
cut emergency communication lines and has been turning back
fuel and water supplies being sent by outside agencies such
as Wal Mart. This is because the Federal Government wants complete
control over the situation.
Even American
Red Cross officials have said that FEMA authorities would
not allow them to deliver aid. "The Homeland Security
Department has requested and continues to request that the
American Red Cross not come back into New Orleans,"
said Renita Hosler, spokeswoman for the Red Cross.
Even Jack Cafferty, the CNN anchor known for his straight-talking,
has declared: "I remember the riots in Watts. I remember
the earthquake in San Francisco. I remember a lot of things.
I have never seen anything as badly handled as this situation
in New Orleans. Where the hell is the water for these people?
Why can't sandwiches be dropped to those people in that Superdome
down there? It's a disgrace. And don't think the world isn't
watching."
Former
FEMA officials have admitted that Government disaster
officials had an action plan if a major hurricane hit New
Orleans. They simply didn't execute it when Hurricane Katrina
struck. Ronald Castleman, the former regional director for
the Federal Emergency Management Agency and John Copenhaver,
a former FEMA regional director during the Clinton administration
who led the response to Hurricane Floyd in 1999, said they
were bewildered by the slow FEMA response.
We even have blogs
from former New Orleans residents who have managed to
get to safety. One exclaiming that:
"There are supplies sitting in Baton Rouge for the folks
in New Orleans, but the National Guard has the city surrounded
and is not letting anyone in or out. They are turning away
people with s[QUOTE]upplies, claiming it is too dangerous...Our
goverment is KILLING the people of New Orleans. This is the
message I am now sending to all major media sources, national
and worldwide, as well as posting to email lists, blogs, etc.
The story is getting out that the people there are not getting
supplies, but the truth of WHY is not. "
The LA Times interviewed
a survivor who said, "The only thing the authorities
have given us is a bunch of false hope,". she had survived
Tuesday through Friday on scavenged scraps of food inside
the cavernous hall. "They just left us here to die."
The Federal response was further
criticised by New Orleans deputy police commander W.S.
Riley who reported to AFP that Guardsmen 'played cards' as
the chaos unfolded and many were dying. He stated that for
three days there was no assistance.
"The guard arrived 48 hours after the hurricane with 40
trucks. They drove their trucks in and went to sleep."
There have also been suggestions that part
of the levee around N.O. was dynamited after the first section
broke in an attempt to prevent Uptown (the rich part of town)
from being flooded. Apparently they used too much dynamite,
thus flooding part of the Bywater.
Reports
and comments from officials today have indicated that
President Bush's visit is nothing more than a staged photo
op.
ZDF News reported that the president's visit was a completely
staged event. Their crew witnessed how the open air food distribution
point Bush visited in front of the cameras was torn down immediately
after the president and the herd of 'news people' had left
and that others which were allegedly being set up were abandoned
at the same time. The people in the area were once again left
to fend for themselves, said ZDF. [War And Piece]
"2 minutes ago the President drove past in his convoy.
But what has happened in Biloxi all day long is truly unbelievable.
Suddenly recovery units appeared, suddenly bulldozers were
there, those hadn't been seen here all the days before, and
this in an area, in which it really wouldn't be necessary to
do a big clean up, because far and wide nobody lives here anymore,
the people are more inland in the city...The extent of the
natural disaster shocked me, but the extent of the staging
is shocking me at least the same way. With that back to Hamburg." [Daily
Kos]
White House officials do not deny that they craft elaborate
events to showcase Bush, but they maintain that these events
are designed to accurately dramatize his policies and to convey
qualities about him that are real.
The Times-Picayune of New Orleans has
called for the firing of FEMA director Michael Brown
and has heavily criticized the government for its awful response.
Jefferson Parish President Aaron
Broussard has charged that Federal bureaucrats have 'Murdered'
the Flood Victims in New Orleans. Yet Broussard also stated
that "FEMA needs more congressional funding. It needs
more presidential support . . . FEMA needs to be empowered
to do the things it was created to do."
FEMA is now simply a federalized front group for the corrupt
money hoarding Department of Homeland Security, the Orwellian
titled agency that has nothing to do with security and everything
to do with limiting the freedoms of people all over the country.
Local officials no longer have any authority and have been forcibly
evacuated, even despite the fact that they wished to stay
and oversee the recovery efforts.
Mayor Nagin has also said that the National Guard's Blackhawk
helicopter carrying the sandbags to plug the hole in the levee
on 17th St. Canal was intentionally
diverted away. Nagin was quoted as demanding to federal
officials "Get
Off Your Asses And Do Something". Nagin is clearly
paranoid about the whole situation, is running around playing
the part of the good cop to FEMA's bad cop. This sets the table
for FEMA to sweep in and heroically save the day at a later
date. Nagin has also
warned "If the CIA slips me something and next week
you don't see me, you'll all know what happened."
Cryin' won't help you, prayin' won't
do you no good
Martial
law was declared in New Orleans midday Tuesday 30th August.
Posse Comitatus has been overturned and the National Guard
has authorization to shoot
and kill anyone they deem to be "hoodlums".
Governor Kathleen Blanco has declared that "These troops
are fresh back from Iraq, well trained, experienced, battle
tested and under my orders to restore order in the streets,".
This is a microcosm of the New America. The
LA Times reported that "their mission simply, is
to turn New Orleans into a police State - to "regain
the city" as 1st Sgt. John Jewell has said. Police have been
ordered to stop saving lives and start saving property
by shooting anyone who attempt to get food and water. The
police are looting
themselves to stay alive whilst the ordinary people are
starving. This is the new police state America.
Some of the most sophisticated military
equipment used in the Iraq war to quell the insurgency is
now being used in New Orleans. We have continually highlighted
how such equipment was developed specifically for domestic
use and now this has come to pass. Five Silver Fox "unmanned
aerial vehicles," or UAVs, equipped with thermal
imaging technology to detect the body heat of storm survivors,
have been deployed in New Orleans.
Also being deployed are acoustic devices
for crowd control and disaster communications, sonic
Laser equipment that is currently in use in Iraq. The
device uses magnets approximately 6 inches tall and 9.25
inches wide to convert electrical pulses into sound waves,
and is capable of aiming sound precisely for thousands of
feet. This allows for the ability to blast out orders that
can be heard for miles and allows for crowds to be fired
upon and dispersed by soundwaves.
Those who fall in line with the curfews and the orders are
still treated like criminals in this New America. Footage has
shown that men women and even children are being separated
and thoroughly
frisked and searched before being rescued. It seems that
survival comes second to being a civilian subject.
The ground troops have begun "combat
operations" "to take this city back" in
the aftermath from those they have termed "insurgents".
These are terms also being used in Iraq, but now they fit
perfectly here to describe anyone who disobeys or does not
fall in line in the New America. The troops have declared
their shock at having to shoot at US citizens and being shot
back at, yet the majority of these people are deliberately
being deprived of food and water by the federal authorities,
they are desperate and have been forced into this situation.
Those who were grabbed in the immediate aftermath were shipped
into the Superdome and simply left there without any aid. This
represents nothing more than a concentration camp as starving
and thirsty refugees were not allowed to leave, trapped until
the authorities deemed it appropriate to move them.
The media covering the event have been appalled by this activity
and the reality of the New America it seems is sinking in in
some instances. Fox
reporter Geraldo Rivera was filled with tears in his eyes
and his voice fluttered with sorrow as he made an on-air plea
to authorities to allow the estimated 30,000 storm victims
at the center to be allowed to move to a safer, cleaner area. "Let
them walk out of here, let them walk the hell out of here!"
Checkpoints have been set up throughout the area to make sure
no one leaves and no one gets in without the say so of the
federal authorities. It is clear that an emergency response
should not be conducted this way. It is also clear that this
is no ordinary emergency response. This is a blueprint, a litmus
test for the New America, the police state, the New World Order.
When the levee breaks, mama, you got to
move
Whilst the disaster evolves it has already been decided who
will restore order and who will reap the profits of the lucrative
cleanup contracts. Dick Cheney affiliated Halliburton
have again been rewarded that task as they have so many
times. After 9/11, in Afghanistan and in Iraq Halliburton and
the elite government infiltrators reap the rewards again and
again. Last week Alex Jones joked on his how that Halliburton
may get the contract to clean up - the sad reality is that
even the things we joke about are now coming to pass every
time.
The agenda is clear, they allow the disaster to happen, or
they manufacture the disaster in the case of 9/11, and then
they reap the financial rewards first and the control mechanism
rewards that categorize their New America a little later.
It has also emerged that FEMA Outsourced
the disaster plans to political cronies and major donors.
They outsourced the hurricane recovery planning to the Baton
Rouge-based consulting firm Innovative Emergency Management
(IEM), Inc. IEM's team partners for the more than $500,000
contract are Dewberry of Arlington, VA, URS Corporation of
San Francisco, and James Lee Witt Associates. Witt was FEMA
Director under Bill Clinton. IEM's president is Madhu Beriwal.
The company was founded in 1985. Dewberry and URS are engineering
firms. IEM is also a Defense Department contractor and has
contracts with the U.S. Army Training and Doctrine Command
(TRADOC) along with team members Booz Allen Hamilton and
Lockheed Martin.
These people all have their hands in the honey pot, they benefit
from such tragic events, wars and disasters every time
Going down... going down now... going
down...
We have seen recently the precedent being set for the eventuality
we now see unfolding. The constant ratcheting up of fear based
control through the exploitation of terror attacks and terror
alerts. The technology that we have monitored through its development
stages is now being put into place.
Everything we have covered over the
last few years is becoming an actuality in New Orleans at
this time. We can only report it further and get the
important information out in place of controlled mainstream
media that refuse to or are prevented from reporting the
real issues.
This is a major event in the agenda for a New America and
a New World Order and it may be a make or break one.
This New America is being controlled by corrupt elite criminals
who seek to achieve the degradation and enslavement of humanity
through war, "revolution," sickness, starvation,
depression, and now "natural" disaster. A
disaster has been turned into a drill for martial law. This
is not an accident. It is part of a relentless process of demoralization
designed to make the people accept tyranny and excessive control
over their lives. |
One of the earliest and perhaps clearest
alarms about Hurricane Katrina's potential threat to New Orleans
was sounded not by the Weather Channel or a government agency
but by a self-described weather nerd sitting on a couch in
Indiana with a laptop computer and a remote control.
"At the risk of being alarmist,
we could be 3-4 days away from an unprecedented cataclysm
that could kill as many as 100,000 people in New Orleans,"
Brendan Loy, who is 23 and has no formal meteorological training,
wrote on Aug. 26 in his blog. "If I were in New
Orleans, I would seriously consider getting the hell out
of Dodge right now, just in case."
Loy's posting that Friday afternoon came three days before
the hurricane struck and two days before the mayor of New Orleans,
Ray C. Nagin, issued an evacuation order. Posts over the next
several days, in aggregate, seem now like an eerie rewriting
of the tale of Chicken Little, in which the sky does in fact
fall.
In the cooperative and competitive world of blogs, Loy's
has gotten some serious praise. Mickey Kaus, whose kausfiles
blog is featured on Slate.com, wrote on Friday that "Loy's
blog for the past week is a pretty extraordinary document,"
adding that "it should maybe be in the Smithsonian,
if you can put a blog in the Smithsonian."
Glenn Reynolds, who blogs at Instapundit.com, linked to Loy's
Web site several times beginning on Aug. 26. That's the Internet
equivalent of a northeaster, and all over, blogs started linking
to Loy's. (Jeff Masters and Charles
Fenwick, among others, also gave early and dire warnings about
New Orleans on their highly trafficked weather blogs.)
According to Blog Pulse from Intelliseek, which measures blog
links, Loy's was the most frequently cited nonnews source among
hurricane-related blogs. On Aug. 28, it was ranked 14th among
most frequently linked-to sites of all sorts.
That was more weight than Loy, who weighs 160 and is 6 foot
2, is accustomed to throwing around. A second-year law student
at Notre Dame, he began blogging in 2002--writing about football
(his blog's name combines Notre Dame's football team, the Fighting
Irish, with that of his college team, the Trojans of the University
of Southern California), his cats, his dog, his fiancee Becky,
the Red Sox, politics, "The Lord of the Rings"
and weather.
"Hurricane Hugo was the first storm that I paid attention
to, when I was 7 or 8," he said in a telephone interview
from South Bend, Ind. "I found them fascinating and became
kind of a weather nerd, watching the Weather Channel religiously." Loy
joined online discussions with other hurricane watchers, and
monitored the National Hurricane Center's Web site, whose satellite
pictures he regularly posts and analyzes on his blog.
He called for Mayor Nagin to issue
an evacuation order days before the mayor issued one,
and his posts on the subject grew increasingly agitated. "It's
definitely true that I am more willing to pull the trigger," he
acknowledged,
"because I don't have to deal with the consequences if
they had had an evacuation and the storm hadn't hit. It's easy
for me to sit here and say, 'Everyone leave.'"
He derives little pleasure from being proved right.
"The results are so dire, and I knew they would be so
dire, that I was fervently praying that I'd be wrong. There's
always some vindication that comes from being right, but I
would much rather have been wrong and be getting 1,000 hits
a day now instead of 25,000."
Classes started last week, and Loy has put an end to all-night
blogging. Recent entries have been as likely to be about his
cats or football as Katrina. He will keep chasing hurricane
information, but he says that if a hurricane approached him,
he would heed his own advice.
"As much as I'm enthralled by high waves and strong winds," he
said, "I understand the powers of these things. I might
leave the computer running and have a Webcam hooked up and
hope the power didn't go out so I could see what was happening
from a remote location, but I wouldn't stick around." |
Racism in America doesn't dress up in
a cowl and flowing white robes anymore. Instead, it dons an
immaculate blue suit and tie and conceals itself behind the
lofty language of democracy, freedom and human dignity; but,
it's racism all the same.
We've seen an explosion of racism in America since George
Bush took office. It started out after 9-11 and was aimed
exclusively at Muslims; a vulnerable group with a paltry
voice in government. The administration took full advantage
of their political weakness by tossing whomever they chose
in prison without due process and without concern for their
personal health or safety. Many, of course, were brutalized
and traumatized by a system that still boldly touted human
rights from the presidential podium.
It was all lies.
The cruelty and inhumanity has steadily escalated over the
last five years; the predictable outcome whenever sadism and
arrogance replace the rule of law. The chronicle of abusive
treatment at American facilities across the globe is vast and
extensive, and stories abound of the imaginative and finely-detailed
methods of maximizing human suffering. Although they may have
failed at everything else, the Bush administration has proved
to be an astute practitioner of torture.
The primary target of these crimes has been
Muslims. There are no Christian or Jewish inmates at either
Guantanamo nor Abu Ghraib. In fact, there are especially lenient
laws for Israeli spies who steal top-secret information from
the Pentagon and pass it on through their respective lobbies.
Both of the indicted leaders of AIPAC, the American-Israeli
lobby, have been released on bond while Muslims, who have been
charged with no crime at all, continue to languish in Guantanamo
Bay. This is the current state of America's apartheid judicial
system.
New Orleans adds a new chapter to the Bush digest of calculated
bigotry. While the wealthy white families were able to beat
a hasty retreat out of doomed city, the poor and black were
left to sink in the toxic stew unleashed by America's greatest
natural disaster.
No one who saw the televised footage of the Convention center
and the Superdome had any misgivings about what they were seeing.
America's long-lost companion, racial-hatred, had stuck its
ugly head up into the camera lens and was pouring out onto
living rooms across the land.
Bush critic Michael Moore may have summarized the feelings
of the nation best when he noted, "C'mon, they're black!
I mean, it's not like this happened to Kennebunkport"..."Can
you imagine leaving white people on their roofs for five days?
Don't make me laugh!"
Moore's right; the brunt of the catastrophe was directed at
society's cast-offs; the poor and black who couldn't simply
load up the $40,000 SUV and take off. They were left to face
the rising waters and the government neglect without any prospect
of real assistance. When you can't buy
your way out, you're left to rot; that's how the "invisible
hand" of the free market operates. The
message is clear; if you have nothing, you are nothing.
Americans have been patting themselves on the back for years
about the great strides that have been made in civil rights
and social justice. It's all rubbish.
Just take a look at the faces of the people who were left to
drown in the noxious soup of a force-4 hurricane. We all know
who these people are; they are the "other America";
the America that is scrupulously kept out of the media so that
the narrative of prosperity, equality and justice can flood
the airwaves like the effluent coursing down Bourbon Street. Nothing
has been accomplished in civil rights. Even the band-aid programs
like bussing, welfare and affirmative action have been dismantled
by people who believe that we all begin life on a level playing
field.
What nonsense.
There's no level playing field anymore than there is
"compassionate conservatism"; Bush proved that by
withholding food and water from starving people for 3 days.
What we all saw last week on national TV was the moral equivalent
of the Rodney King beating multiplied times 30,000; that's
the number of people locked away in the feces-infected Superdome.
It gave us a good look into America's dark-heart, where the
evil secret we keep tucked-away in a vault can always be denied;
racism.
Abandoning those people during a national
tragedy was the most blatant, despicable act of racism I've
seen in my 53 years of life. The beating of Rodney King pales
by comparison.
Presently, the African Americans who were stranded in New
Orleans are being trundled off to the four corners of the Western
states where they'll be disposed of quietly in filthy encampments
or religious facilities. Their rage and frustration sent shivers
of distress through the body politic and put a hefty dent in
our collective sense of self-esteem. Once again, Bush and his
vindictive troupe have proved that it is always possible to
sink ever-lower in the bottomless well of moral corruption.
Mike Whitney lives in Washington state. He can be reached
at: fergiewhitney@msn.com |
George, you call yourself a Christian.
You claim that you invaded Iraq because I told you to. You
say that you were anointed to lead America.
George, don't you remember that My greatest commandment
is to love your neighbor as yourself? I sent Hurricane Katrina
to test you, so that you could show Me and the world that
you truly are compassionate, as you claim, that you truly
are a capable leader, as you claim, that you truly listen
to Me and carry out My will.
Instead, you showed the world your callous indifference, and
your inability or unwillingness to assume leadership in a time
of crisis. Your failure has cost thousands of lives, people
who could have been rescued and sustained. Your failure has
further besmirched the reputation of your government, which
has shown itself to be an unfeeling and incompetent bunch,
caring only about enriching themselves and gathering power.
Do you not recall My words:
Trust not in oppression, and become not vain in robbery:
if riches increase, set not your heart upon them.
But your response to My test, hurricane Katrina, was to ignore
the victims and instead do some political fundraising, and
then send in the Marines when law and order broke down.
You failed the test, George.
You blew it.
Carol Wolman, MD is a psychiatrist and antiwar activist.
She can be reached at: cwolman@mcn.org |
As
President Bush scurries back to the Gulf Coast, it is clear
that this is the greatest challenge to politics-as-usual in
America since the fall of Richard Nixon in the 1970s.
Then as now, good reporting lies at the heart of what is
changing.
But unlike Watergate, "Katrinagate" was public service
journalism ruthlessly exposing the truth on a live and continuous
basis.
Instead of secretive "Deep Throat"
meetings in car-parks, cameras captured the immediate reality
of what was happening at the New Orleans Convention Center,
making a mockery of the stalling and excuses being put forward
by those in power.
Amidst the horror, American broadcast journalism just might
have grown its spine back, thanks to Katrina.
National politics reporters and anchors here come largely
from the same race and class as the people they are supposed
to be holding to account.
They live in the same suburbs, go to the same parties, and
they are in debt to the same huge business interests.
Giant corporations own the networks, and Washington politicians
rely on them and their executives to fund their re-election
campaigns across the 50 states.
It is a perfect recipe for a timid and self-censoring journalistic
culture that is no match for the masterfully aggressive spin-surgeons
of the Bush administration.
'Lies or ignorance'
But last week the complacency stopped, and the moral indignation
against inadequate government began to flow, from slick anchors
who spend most of their time glued to desks in New York and
Washington.
The most spectacular example came last Friday
night on Fox News, the cable network that has become the darling
of the Republican heartland.
This highly successful Murdoch-owned station sets itself up
in opposition to the "mainstream liberal media elite".
But with the sick and the dying forced to
sit in their own excrement behind him in New Orleans, its early-evening
anchor Shepard Smith declared civil war against the studio-driven
notion that the biggest problem was still stopping the looters.
On other networks like NBC, CNN and ABC it was the authority
figures, who are so used to an easy ride at press conferences,
that felt the full force of reporters finally determined to
ditch the deference.
As the heads of the Homeland Security department
and the Federal Emergency Management Agency (Fema) appeared
for network interviews, their defensive remarks about where
aid was arriving to, and when, were exposed immediately as
either downright lies or breath-taking ignorance.
And you did not need a degree in journalism to know it either.
Just watching TV for the previous few hours would have sufficed.
Iraq concern
When the back-slapping president told the Fema boss on Friday
morning that he was doing "a heck of a job" and spent
most of his first live news conference in the stricken area
praising all the politicians and chiefs who had failed so clearly,
it beggared belief.
The president looked affronted when a reporter covering his
Mississippi walkabout had the temerity to suggest that having
a third of the National Guard from the affected states on duty
in Iraq might be a factor.
It is something I suspect he is going to have to get used
to from now on: the list of follow-up questions is too long
to ignore or bury.
And it is not only on TV and radio where the gloves have come
off.
The most artful supporter of the administration on the staff
of the New York Times, columnist David Brooks, has also had
enough.
He and others are calling the debacle the "anti 9-11": "The
first rule of the social fabric - that in times of crisis you
protect the vulnerable - was trampled," he wrote on Sunday.
"Leaving the poor in New Orleans was
the moral equivalent of leaving the injured on the battlefield."
Media emboldened
It is way too early to tell whether this really will become "Katrinagate" for
President Bush, but how he and his huge retinue of politically-appointed
bureaucrats react in the weeks ahead will be decisive.
Government has been thrown into disrepute,
and many Americans have realised, for the first time, that
the collapsed, rotten flood defences of New Orleans are a symbol
of failed infrastructure across the nation.
Blaming the state and city officials, as the president is
already trying to do over Katrina, will not wash.
Beyond the immediate challenge of re-housing the evacuees
and getting 200,000-plus children into new schools, there will
have to be a Katrina Commission, that a newly-emboldened media
will scrutinise obsessively.
The dithering and incompetence that will be exposed will not
spare the commander-in-chief, or the sunny, faith-based propaganda
that he was still spouting as he left New Orleans airport last
Friday, saying it was all going to turn out fine.
People were still trapped, hungry and dying on his watch,
less than a mile away.
Black America will not forget the government failures, nor
will the Gulf Coast region.
Tens of thousands of voters whose lives have been so devastated
will cast their mid-term ballots in Texas next year - the president's
adopted home state.
The final word belongs to the historic newspaper at the centre
of the hurricane - The New Orleans Times-Picayune. At the weekend,
this now-homeless institution published an open letter: "We're
angry, Mr President, and we'll be angry long after our beloved
city and surrounding parishes have been pumped dry.
"Our people deserved rescuing. Many who could have been,
were not. That's to the government's shame." |
As Americans began heading home from the
Labor Day weekend, gasoline stations today continued to report
spot shortages, but the country appeared, at least as of this
afternoon, to have avoided the massive supply problems that
some had feared.
Throughout the weekend, station attendants and analysts
said they saw unrelenting demand from drivers who were worried
they would find themselves stranded, were panicked by rumors
about service stations closing early, or both.
Officials said they continued to make progress in resuming
the production and distribution of gasoline and other fuels,
which was severely disrupted by Hurricane Katrina last week.
But they noted that most refineries and oil production in and
along the Gulf of Mexico remained shut down for the seventh
day in a row.
Gasoline demand was heaviest along busy thoroughfares between
big population centers and vacation destinations, often knocking
out several gasoline stations along heavy traffic routes for
hours to days at a time.
"It could three or five stations on one stretch running
out, that's a fairly real situation that is happening," said
Justin McNaull, a spokesman for AAA, formerly known as the
American Automobile Association.
Mr. McNaull added that his group had not received any reports
of motorists stranded in tourist destinations unable to return
home because they could not refuel.
"The challenge that gas station operators are having now
is not knowing when the next shipment is coming and how much
they will be getting," he said. [...]
Nationally, the average retail price for gasoline was $3.057
a gallon this morning, up from $2.867 on Sunday and $2.307
a month ago, according to AAA.
In the New York region, prices seemed to range from $2.95
a gallon to $3.75 a gallon, according to a spot survey done
by the staffs of Senators Charles E. Schumer, Democrat of New
York, and John Corzine, Democrat of New Jersey. Both politicians
called on the Federal Trade Commission to investigate gasoline
price increases and suggested it might help to lift the federal
gasoline tax at least temporarily.
Gasoline supplies will likely remain
tight through much of the coming week if not longer,
industry officials and analysts said, as refiners slowly
resume operations in the gulf region. It can take several
days to restart those facilities, because of the danger of
explosions and other accidents.
Of the 10 refineries that were shut down by
the storm initially, eight have not resumed operations, two
are restarting and hope to be operational in the coming days,
and three still do not have electricity, the Energy Department
said on Sunday.
At least four refiners that produce
about 5 percent of the nation's gasoline and other oil-based
fuels have sustained significant damage and could be out
of commission for a month or more for repairs, officials
and analysts said. Among them are ConocoPhillips' Belle Chase,
La. facility; Exxon Mobil's Chalmette, La. plant; and ChevronTexaco's
large refinery in Pascagoula, Miss. [...] |
Having repaired the breach in one of the
main levees, workers under the orders of engineers yesterday
began to pump out the waters that have been covering 80% of
New Orleans. However, the residents and authorities alike know
very well that what will be revealed will not be at all pleasant. "It'll
be ugly and be another wakeup call for the nation," warned
the Mayor of New Orleans, Ray Nagin. He said it would take
three weeks to pump out the water and another few weeks to
clear away the rubble caused by the hurricane.
United States President George W. Bush announced that he
would be leading the inquiry into the way the disaster caused
by Katrina was handled. "What
I intend to do is to lead an investigation to find out what
went right and what went wrong, but
the enquiry won't be pointing the finger at anyone. We
want to make sure that we can respond properly if there's
a WMD attack or another major storm."
Emergency teams continue to rescue people from their homes
(in many cases from their apartments on the upper floors) and
from the places used as some kind of shelter.
"In some cases it's dead easy. They are sitting in front
of their front doors clutching their bags. But some don't want
to leave and we can't force them," said Joe Youdell, a
member of the Kentucky Air National Guard. [...] |
Britons returning from New Orleans have
described the horrifying conditions there.
They were among the thousands forced to seek refuge from
the floods that engulfed the city following Hurricane Katrina.
Some 96 Britons still remain unaccounted for. [...]
JENNY SACHS
Jenny Sachs, of Sheffield, told how soldiers had to smuggle
her out of the Superdome in secret.
She was one of about 30 Britons who, realising they could
not escape the city, had fled to the stadium for shelter.
"It has hit me more now I am at home, when you can have
clean water, how bad it was," she said.
She said people had been raped and that others were beaten
up.
"A guy was brought in who had seven stab wounds and was
covered in blood."
The military told all non-US citizens to
stay together for safety, Ms Sachs added.
They later told them they would be secretly
smuggled out in groups of 10 under cover of darkness as it
had become too dangerous for them to remain in the stadium,
she told BBC News.
"When we were leaving, people were going
'Where are you going?' and giving us looks.
"But the military got us out, which we were all thankful
for." [...]
MIKE BROCKEN
Radio Merseyside presenter Mike Brocken, from Chester, was
on holiday in New Orleans with his wife and teenage daughter
when the hurricane hit.
The family stayed in the hotel for the first few days and
then decided to move to the Superdome, as looting was becoming
widespread in the city.
"The situation was becoming more and more dangerous all
the time - it was horrific really and by Wednesday dinnertime
our hotel had run out of diesel for its generator so everything
was closing down.
"We were going to go inside the Superdome.
I approached two members of the National Guard and they said
to stay outside because they knew it was hell in there."
Mr Brocken said members of the National Guard
took him and his family "under their wing"
and saw that they were placed in the baseball stadium.
"Everyone talks about the National Guard in rather derogatory
ways historically, but I've got to say that but for them, and
one man in particular, I may well have lost my family." [...] |
Paul Craig Roberts has
held a number of academic appointments and has contributed
to numerous scholarly publications. He served as Assistant
Secretary of the Treasury in the Regan administration.
Roberts followed up his commentary Impeach Bush Now, Before
More Die with an interview on The Alex Jones show on Monday
5th September 2005. The former Assistant Secretary had noted
of the New Orleans disaster "If terrorists had achieved
this result, it would rank as the greatest terrorist success
in history." and went on to spell out how the disaster
was left to happen. He succeeded these comments on Monday
by laying out the facts again and asserting that the Federal
government has been criminally negligent and should be held
up to accountability.
Mr Roberts believed that such comments would bring him much
criticism from so called Patriots (the flag waving kind), yet
he was surprised at the amount of people who agreed and even
informed him that it was far worse then what he'd gone on record
with.
Roberts reviewed the way in which the federal government had
slashed funding for flood prevention schemes and pumped everything
into the war in Iraq and the war on Terror. He also went on
to admit that the military was turning on the people, treating
them as subjects, overturning the Posse Comitatus Act.
Roberts agreed that FEMA has deliberately
withheld aid, and cut emergency communication lines, and
automatically made the crisis look worse in order to empower
the image of a police state emerging to "save the day". He
even insinuated that the shoot to kill policy was part of
the overall operation in order get an awful precedence set
to aid the military industrial complex takeover of America.
"The power of the Federal Government
is now greater than at any time, it'll never go back and the
Posse Comitatus Act has been eroding ever since it was passed
in 1878..." Roberts asserted.
Roberts further commented "There is no excuse for this,
we have never had in our history the federal government take
a week to respond to a disaster...this is the first time ever
that the help was not mobilized in advance. The proper procedure
is that everything is mobilized and ready to go"
Mr Roberts commented that the American people are being
"brainwashed" and no longer believe what the founding
fathers said over and over, that your worst enemy is always
your own government and never confuse Patriotism with support
for the government. He asserted that the mentality is "like
that of the brown shirts that followed Hitler" and that
the government is deadly dangerous, "you can't let the
military take over policing".
On the question of where this is all leading and what the
government is gearing up for, Mr Roberts suggested that "It
does look like there is a push coming from inside the bowels
of the police authorities and it seems to be independent of
whoever the President is or who or whatever party is in office.
It just gets worse and it's hard to say that it's Bush doing
it, he may not even know what's going on... it's enough for
us to say that New Orleans demonstrated massive federal incompetence,
if it were laid on private people would be tantamount to criminal
negligence... some kind of accountability has to be exercised"
The private corporations own and run everything and are turning
America into a third world police state, when questioned as
to how we can stop this Mr Roberts stated:
"The longer it goes on it will be harder
and harder to stop...It depends on how much resistance or what
kind of resistance they meet, but I think one thing we can
do is demand accountability for this failure, do not buy the
Karl Rove lie that this was a failure of State and Local Government"
Roberts urged listeners to look at the Patriot
Act, which suspends Habeas Corpus, where they can now suspend
you indefinitely, a massive erosion of civil liberties. He
was quick to point out though that we should not assign the
government omnipotence, we can make people aware of the situation
and try to explain illogical actions that have no reasonable
explanation.
Roberts read out an email from an emergency management official
who said that the feds are involved in everything they do,
everything has to be approved by the feds. FEMA sets the table,
Mr Roberts suggested, every major agency in New Orleans has
been federalized, the State and Local officials have no authority.
"They might screw up occasionally but why is it that
NOTHING that was supposed to be done was done?"
Roberts questioned.
"The whole problem is...failure, massive
unacceptable failure, criminal negligence... it has caused
the US it's largest and most strategic international Port through
which 25% of all our oil and gas comes... look at the price
of gasoline, this is a tremendous impact... I don't see how
a recession can be avoided... We have lost our most influential
port through what appears to be INTENTIONAL incompetence, it's
very hard to understand"
Roberts went on to stress that this
event is WORSE than 9/11 because it was announced days ahead
of the event and contingency plans were intentionally ignored. The
officials on the scene have said there was a complete stand
down of the government and intentional incompetence. Furthermore
they did nothing ON PURPOSE in order to provoke the resulting
chaos and anarchy so they could say "look how out of
control everything is - we have to have limits on freedom
and troops on the streets." |
WASHINGTON - The Bush administration was
warned by congressional investigators this summer that some
first responders were concerned that their training and equipment
was tilting too much toward combatting terrorism rather than
natural disasters.
It's too early to tell whether the shift affected the slow
federal response to Hurricane Katrina. But it led some emergency
personnel to raise red flags.
The emphasis changed once the Federal Emergency
Management Agency lost its independence and joined the 22-agency
Homeland Security Department in March 2003.
The mammoth department was created in 2002 as a response to
the lack of coordination prior to the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist
attacks, and its emphasis clearly is terrorism. Officials developed
an "all hazards" policy that used the same training
exercises and equipment to prepare for two distinct types of
disasters: a terrorist attack and an event of nature.
The agency in the past four years awarded $11.3 billion to
state and local governments to prepare and respond to a terrorist
attack.
Congress' Government Accountability Office reported in July
that of 39 first responder departments surveyed, 31 disagreed
that the training and grant funds worked for all types of hazards.
"In addition, officials from four
first responder departments went on to say that DHS required
too much emphasis on terrorism-related activities in requests
for equipment and training,"
the GAO said. [...] |
A visibly angry Mayor Daley said the
city had offered emergency, medical and technical help to the
federal government as early as Sunday to assist people in the
areas stricken by Hurricane Katrina, but as of Friday, the
only things the feds said they wanted was a single tank truck.
That truck, which the Federal Emergency Management Agency
requested to support an Illinois-based medical team, was
en route Friday.
"We are ready to provide more help than
they have requested. We are just waiting for their call," said
Daley, adding that he was "shocked"
that no one seemed to want the help.
Meanwhile, U.S. Sen. Barack Obama (D-Ill.)
said he would call for congressional hearings into the federal
government's preparations and response.
"The response was achingly slow, and that, I think, is
a view shared by Democrats, Republicans, wealthy and poor,
black and white," the freshman senator said. "I have
not met anybody who has watched this crisis evolve over the
last several days who is not just furious at how poorly prepared
we appeared to be."
Response 'baffling'
The South Side Democrat called FEMA's slow response
"baffling."
"I don't understand how you could have
a situation where you've got several days' notice of an enormous
hurricane building in the Gulf Coast, you know that New Orleans
is 6 feet below sea level. ... The notion that you don't have
good plans in place just does not make sense," Obama said.
Obama said he expects his counterparts in Louisiana, Mississippi
or Alabama will call for congressional hearings, but he is
ready if they do not. "It's heartbreaking and infuriating
and, I think, is embarrassing to the American people.''
Daley said the city offered 36 members of
the firefighters' technical rescue teams, eight emergency medical
technicians, search-and-rescue equipment, more than 100 police
officers as well as police vehicles and two boats, 29 clinical
and 117 non-clinical health workers, a mobile clinic and eight
trained personnel, 140 Streets and Sanitation workers and 29
trucks, plus other supplies. City personnel are willing to
operate self-sufficiently and would not depend on local authorities
for food, water, shelter and other supplies, he said.
Flanked at a Friday press conference by a who's who from city
government, religious organizations and business, the mayor
also announced formation of the Chicago Helps Fund for storm
victims.
"I'm calling upon every resident of Chicago to donate
what they can afford, whether it's 50 cents or 50 dollars," the
mayor said.
People can make tax-deductible cash or check donations at
any of Bank One's 330 Chicago area branches or by check at
Chicago Helps, c/o Bank One, 38891 Eagle Way, Chicago 60678-1388.
A phone line to take credit card donations will be set up.
[...] |
WASHINGTON - The federal government's
costs related to Hurricane Katrina could easily approach $100
billion, many times as much as for any other natural disaster
or the $21 billion allocated for New York City after the terrorist
attacks of Sept. 11, 2001.
"There is no question but that
the costs of this are going to exceed the costs of New
York City after 9/11 by a significant multiple," predicted
Senator Judd Gregg, Republican of New Hampshire and chairman
of the Senate Budget Committee.
Administration officials said today that rescue
and relief operations in Louisiana and Alabama are costing
well over $500 million a day and are continuing to rise.
Less than four days after Congress approved $10.5 billion
in emergency assistance, White House officials said they would
be asking for an even bigger amount in the next day or two.
News agencies, quoting congressional officials, said President
Bush is likely to ask for an additional $40 billion. But administration
officials said that even their second request will itself be
only a "stop gap" measure while officials try to
make a comprehensive estimate.
Though it is still too early for specific
estimates, the costs are all but certain to wreak havoc with
Mr. Bush's plans to reduce the federal deficit and possibly
his plans to further cut taxes.
On Monday, Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist hastily postponed
plans to push for a vote on repealing the estate tax, a move
that would benefit the wealthiest 1 percent of households but
would cost more than $70 billion a year once fully implemented.
House and Senate leaders are also grappling with their pre-Katrina
plan to propose $35 billion in spending cuts over the next
five years for entitlement programs like Medicaid, student
loans, food stamps and cash welfare payments to low-income
families.
Those spending cuts could suddenly prove politically unpalatable
to Mr. Bush and Republican lawmakers, who are trying to rebuff
criticism that the federal government shortchanged the hurricane's
poorest victims.
"Democrats think this is the worst possible time to be
cutting taxes for those at the very top and cutting the social
safety net of those at the very bottom,"
said Thomas S. Kahn, staff director for Democrats on the House
Budget Committee.
Budget analysts said the magnitude and unique characteristics
of Hurricane Katrina make it unlike any previous natural disaster.
These are some of the extraordinary costs:
- Providing shelter for as many as 1 million people for months
or even a year.
- Assuming a potentially high share of uninsured property
losses that stem from flooding, which is not covered by private
insurers.
- Providing education and health care to hundreds of thousands
of people forced to live outside their home states. Medicaid,
which pays for health care to very low-income people, is usually
a cost shared by federal and state governments. But administration
officials say they expect that the federal government will
pick up the full bill for people who were evacuated and that
eligibility standards will be relaxed.
"Katrina could easily become a milestone in the history
of the federal budget," said Stanley Collender, a longtime
Washington budget analyst. "Policies that never would
have been considered before could now become standard." |
US growth is likely to slow in the remaining
months of this year because of Hurricane Katrina's destruction,
US Treasury Secretary John Snow says.
Mr Snow forecast that as much as 0.5% may
be knocked off the US's annual gross domestic product (GDP).
The US, the world's largest economy, had been expected to
grow by close to 3.5% this year.
However, that was before Katrina blew ashore, killing thousands
and causing damages of close to $100bn (£55bn).
Oil production facilities in the Gulf of Mexico were hit hard
and the subsequent surge in crude and petrol prices are likely
to brake US growth, Mr Snow said.
"It would seem to make sense to think that we could see
a loss of GDP growth rate in the quarters ahead of a half a
percent or so," Mr Snow said late on Tuesday.
See-saw effect
The concern is that consumers will spend less in shops as
they have to pay more for fuel and heating, while companies
will either have to pass on their higher costs or let them
eat into their profits, analysts said.
Mr Snow's comments were echoing an earlier report from the
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD).
According to the economic think-tank, high
world oil prices are here to stay and the price shocks pose
a threat to key economies such as the US, UK and Germany.
Growth in the US might "somewhat more subdued"
in the second half of 2005, the OECD said.
Despite the concerns, the US is well placed for growth and
any slowdown should be short-lived.
Mr Snow said that he expected growth to pick
up again in 2006, adding that the reconstruction and repair
effort following Katrina would prove to be a powerful economic
stimulus.
GDP growth in 2006 should get a boost of 0.5% from rebuilding,
Mr Snow estimated. |
WASHINGTON -- Hurricane Katrina will reduce
employment by 400,000 people in coming months while trimming
economic growth by as much as a full percentage point in the
second half of this year, according to a Congressional Budget
Office assessment obtained by The Associated Press.
The CBO report said that Katrina's impact was likely to
be "significant but not overwhelming" to the overall
U.S. economy, especially if energy production along the Gulf
Coast returns to pre-hurricane levels quickly.
"Last week, it appeared that larger economic impacts
might occur, but despite continued uncertainty, progress in
opening refineries and restarting pipelines now makes those
larger impacts less likely," CBO Director Douglas Holtz-Eakin
said in a letter to congressional leaders.
The CBO assessment was in line with the predicted impact of
Katrina being made by many private forecasters, who have also
cautioned that the effects could be much worse if rising energy
prices cause consumers to cut back on their spending.
The CBO report said that it expected
economic growth in the second half of the year would be reduced
by between 0.5 percentage point and 1 percentage point. It
put total job losses at around 400,000.
CBO, the nonpartisan agency that provides economic and budget
advice to Congress, said before Katrina struck the expectations
were that the economy would grow at an annual rate of between
3 percent and 4 percent in the second half of the year with
employment growing by 150,000 to 200,000 workers per month. |
NEW ORLEANS - The U.S. government agency
leading the rescue efforts after Hurricane Katrina said on
Tuesday it does not want the news media to take photographs
of the dead as they are recovered from the flooded New Orleans
area.
The Federal Emergency Management Agency, heavily criticized
for its slow response to the devastation caused by the hurricane,
rejected requests from journalists to accompany rescue boats
as they went out to search for storm victims.
An agency spokeswoman said space was needed on the rescue
boats and that "the recovery of
the victims is being treated with dignity and the utmost respect."
"We have requested that no photographs of the deceased
be made by the media," the spokeswoman said in an e-mailed
response to a Reuters inquiry.
The Bush administration also has prevented
the news media from photographing flag-draped caskets of U.S.
soldiers killed in Iraq, which has sparked criticism that the
government is trying to block images that put the war in a
bad light.
The White House is under fire for its handling of the relief
effort, which many officials have charged was slow and bureacratic,
contributing to the death and mayhem in New Orleans after the
storm struck on Aug. 29. |
Blame
Amid the Tragedy
Gov. Blanco and Mayor Nagin failed their constituents. |
BY BOB WILLIAMS
The Wall Street Journal
Wednesday, September 7, 2005 12:01 a.m. EDT |
As the devastation of Hurricane Katrina
continues to shock and sadden the nation, the question on many
lips is, Who is to blame for the inadequate response?
As a former state legislator who represented the legislative
district most impacted by the eruption of Mount St. Helens
in 1980, I can fully understand and empathize with the people
and public officials over the loss of life and property.
Many in the media are turning their eyes toward the federal
government, rather than considering the culpability of city
and state officials. I am fully aware of the challenges of
having a quick and responsive emergency response to a major
disaster. And there is definitely a time for accountability; but
what isn't fair is to dump on the federal officials and avoid
those most responsible--local and state officials who failed
to do their job as the first responders. The
plain fact is, lives were needlessly lost in New Orleans due
to the failure of Louisiana's governor, Kathleen Blanco, and
the city's mayor, Ray Nagin.
The primary responsibility for dealing with emergencies does
not belong to the federal government. It belongs to local and
state officials who are charged by law with the management
of the crucial first response to disasters. First response
should be carried out by local and state emergency personnel
under the supervision of the state governor and his emergency
operations center.
The actions and inactions of Gov. Blanco
and Mayor Nagin are a national disgrace due to their failure
to implement the previously established evacuation plans
of the state and city. Gov.
Blanco and Mayor Nagin cannot claim that they were surprised
by the extent of the damage and the need to evacuate so many
people.
Detailed written plans were already in place to evacuate more
than a million people. The plans projected that 300,000 people
would need transportation in the event of a hurricane like
Katrina. If the plans had been implemented, thousands of lives
would likely have been saved.
In addition to the plans, local, state and federal officials
held a simulated hurricane drill 13 months ago, in which widespread
flooding supposedly trapped 300,000 people inside New Orleans.
The exercise simulated the evacuation of more than a million
residents. The problems identified in
the simulation apparently were not solved.
A year ago, as Hurricane Ivan approached, New Orleans ordered
an evacuation but did not use city or school buses to help
people evacuate. As a result many of the poorest citizens were
unable to evacuate. Fortunately, the hurricane changed course
and did not hit New Orleans, but both Gov. Blanco and Mayor
Nagin acknowledged the need for a better evacuation plan. Again,
they did not take corrective actions. In 1998, during a threat
by Hurricane George, 14,000 people were sent to the Superdome
and theft and vandalism were rampant due to inadequate security.
Again, these problems were not corrected.
The New Orleans contingency plan is still, as of this writing,
on the city's Web site, and states: "The safe evacuation
of threatened populations is one of the principle [sic] reasons
for developing a Comprehensive Emergency Management Plan." But
the plan was apparently ignored.
Mayor Nagin was responsible for giving the order for mandatory
evacuation and supervising the actual evacuation: His Office
of Emergency Preparedness (not the federal government) must
coordinate with the state on elements of evacuation and assist
in directing the transportation of evacuees to staging areas.
Mayor Nagin had to be encouraged by the governor to contact
the National Hurricane Center before he finally, belatedly,
issued the order for mandatory evacuation. And sadly, it apparently
took a personal call from the president to urge the governor
to order the mandatory evacuation.
The city's evacuation plan states: "The city of New Orleans
will utilize all available resources to quickly and safely
evacuate threatened areas."
But even though the city has enough school and transit buses
to evacuate 12,000 citizens per fleet run, the mayor did not
use them. To compound the problem, the buses were not moved
to high ground and were flooded. The plan also states that "special
arrangements will be made to evacuate persons unable to transport
themselves or who require specific lifesaving assistance. Additional
personnel will be recruited to assist in evacuation procedures
as needed."
This was not done.
The evacuation plan warned that "if an evacuation order
is issued without the mechanisms needed to disseminate the
information to the affected persons, then we face the possibility
of having large numbers of people either stranded and left
to the mercy of a storm, or left in an area impacted by toxic
materials." That is precisely what happened because of
the mayor's failure.
Instead of evacuating the people, the mayor ordered the refugees
to the Superdome and Convention Center without adequate security
and no provisions for food, water and sanitary conditions.
As a result people died, and there was even rape committed,
in these facilities. Mayor Nagin failed in his responsibility
to provide public safety and to manage the orderly evacuation
of the citizens of New Orleans. Now he wants to blame Gov.
Blanco and the Federal Emergency Management Agency. In an emergency
the first requirement is for the city's emergency center to
be linked to the state emergency operations center. This was
not done.
The federal government does not have the authority
to intervene in a state emergency without the request of a
governor. President Bush declared an emergency prior to Katrina
hitting New Orleans, so the only action needed for federal
assistance was for Gov. Blanco to request the specific type
of assistance she needed. She failed to send a timely request
for specific aid.
In addition, unlike the governors of New York, Oklahoma and
California in past disasters, Gov. Blanco failed to take charge
of the situation and ensure that the state emergency operation
facility was in constant contact with Mayor Nagin and FEMA.
It is likely that thousands of people died because of the failure
of Gov. Blanco to implement the state plan, which mentions
the possible need to evacuate up to one million people. The
plan clearly gives the governor the authority for declaring
an emergency, sending in state resources to the disaster area
and requesting necessary federal assistance.
State legislators and governors nationwide need to update
their contingency plans and the operation procedures for state
emergency centers. Hurricane Katrina had been forecast for
days, but that will not always be the case with a disaster
(think of terrorist attacks). It must be made clear that the
governor and locally elected officials are in charge of the "first
response."
I am not attempting to excuse some of the
delays in FEMA's response. Congress and the president need
to take corrective action there, also. However, if citizens
expect FEMA to be a first responder to terrorist attacks or
other local emergencies (earthquakes, forest fires, volcanoes),
they will be disappointed. The federal government's role is
to offer aid upon request.
The Louisiana Legislature should conduct an immediate investigation
into the failures of state and local officials to implement
the written emergency plans. The tragedy is not over, and real
leadership in the state and local government are essential
in the months to come. More importantly, the hurricane season
is still upon us, and local and state officials must stay focused
on the jobs for which they were elected--and not on the deadly
game of passing the emergency buck.
Mr. Williams is president of the Evergreen Freedom Foundation,
a free market public policy research organization in Olympia,
Wash. |
BEIJING - China's most important state-run
newspaper has accused US President George W. Bush and his administration
of "negligence of duty" in its response to the disaster
wrought by Hurricane Katrina.
People's Daily, the ruling Communist Party's
mouthpiece, said there was no excuse for Bush's slow reaction
to the unfolding tragedy.
"For the Bush administration, 'unexpected' perhaps can
be a lame excuse, but it can never explain away the government
negligence of duty," it said in an opinion piece carried
on its English language website Thursday.
"As a matter of fact, ever since 'September
11', the Congress had cut anti-flood allocation to Louisiana,
which later became a main reason for the slow rescue work this
time," said the officially controlled paper.
"In the face of the hurricane, Americans accepted the
challenge but failed to beat it off. This is really a shame
on the United States."
It said the anarchy and chaos seen in New Orleans after the
hurricane looked to the world like America was "fighting
a city war at home".
"New Orleans has become Baghdad,"
it said.
"People have reason to feel disgusted:
when Indonesia was hit by the tsunami last year, everybody
lent a helping hand and nobody looted. But now this happened
in the United States, showing people another side of this 'civilized
country'.
"In fact, it revealed the fragility of American society,
as well as despair and disorder in a state of anarchy."
Katrina left hundreds of thousands of people homeless and
possibly thousands dead after it swept through the Gulf of
Mexico coastal region on August 29, causing devastation to
New Orleans.
Bush has been lambasted at home for a lag in dispatching troops
and relief supplies to the afflicted region despite graphic
television images of chaos and neglect.
He has acknowledged shortcomings and promised to lead an inquiry
into "what went wrong." |
Note: Bradshaw and Slonsky are paramedics
frorm California that were attending the EMS conference in
New Orleans. Larry Bradsahw is the chief shop steward, Paramedic
Chapter, SEIU Local 790; and Lorrie Beth Slonsky is steward,
Paramedic Chapter, SEIU Local 790. [California]
Two days after Hurricane Katrina struck New Orleans, the
Walgreen's store at the corner of Royal and Iberville streets
remained locked. The dairy display case was clearly visible
through the widows. It was now 48 hours without electricity,
running water, plumbing. The milk, yogurt, and cheeses were
beginning to spoil in the 90-degree heat. The owners and
managers had locked up the food, water, pampers, and prescriptions
and fled the City. Outside Walgreen's windows, residents
and tourists grew increasingly thirsty and hungry.
The much-promised federal, state and
local aid never materialized and the windows at Walgreen's
gave way to the looters. There was an alternative.
The cops could have broken one small window and distributed
the nuts, fruit juices, and bottle water in an organized
and systematic manner. But they did not. Instead they spent
hours playing cat and mouse, temporarily chasing away the
looters.
We were finally airlifted out of New Orleans two days ago
and arrived home yesterday (Saturday). We have yet to see any
of the TV coverage or look at a newspaper. We are willing to
guess that there were no video images or front-page pictures
of European or affluent white tourists looting the Walgreen's
in the French Quarter.
We also suspect the media will have been inundated with "hero" images
of the National Guard, the troops and the police struggling
to help the "victims"
of the Hurricane. What you will not
see, but what we witnessed,were the real heroes and sheroes
of the hurricane relief effort: the working class of New Orleans. The
maintenance workers who used a fork lift to carry the sick
and disabled. The engineers, who rigged, nurtured and kept
the generators running. The electricians who improvised thick
extension cords stretching over blocks to share the little
electricity we had in order to free cars stuck on rooftop parking
lots. Nurses who took over for mechanical ventilators and spent
many hours on end manually forcing air into the lungs of unconscious
patients to keep them alive. Doormen who rescued folks stuck
in elevators. Refinery workers who broke into boat yards, "stealing" boats
to rescue their neighbors clinging to their roofs in flood
waters. Mechanics who helped hot-wire any car that could be
found to ferry people out of the City. And the food service
workers who scoured the commercial kitchens improvising communal
meals for hundreds of those stranded.
Most of these workers had lost their homes, and had not heard
from members of their families, yet they stayed and provided
the only infrastructure for the 20% of New Orleans that was
not under water.
On Day 2, there were approximately 500 of us left in the hotels
in the French Quarter. We were a mix of foreign tourists, conference
attendees like ourselves, and locals who had checked into hotels
for safety and shelter from Katrina. Some of us had cell phone
contact with family and friends outside of New Orleans. We
were repeatedly told that all sorts of resources including
the National Guard and scores of buses were pouring in to the
City. The buses and the other resources must have been invisible
because none of us had seen them.
We decided we had to save ourselves. So we pooled our money
and came up with $25,000 to have ten buses come and take us
out of the City. Those who did not have the requisite $45.00
for a ticket were subsidized by those who did have extra money.
We waited for 48 hours for the buses, spending the last 12
hours standing outside, sharing the limited water, food, and
clothes we had. We created a priority boarding area for the
sick, elderly and new born babies. We waited late into the
night for the "imminent" arrival of the buses. The
buses never arrived. We later learned
that the minute they arrived to the City limits, they were
commandeered by the military.
By day 4 our hotels had run out of fuel and water. Sanitation
was dangerously abysmal. As the desperation and despair increased,
street crime as well as water levels began to rise. The hotels
turned us out and locked their doors, telling us that the "officials"
told us to report to the convention center to wait for more
buses. As we entered the center of the City, we finally encountered
the National Guard. The Guards told us we would not be allowed
into the Superdome as the City's primary shelter had descended
into a humanitarian and health hellhole. The guards further
told us that the City's only other shelter, the Convention
Center, was also descending into chaos and squalor and that
the police were not allowing anyone else in. Quite naturally,
we asked, "If we can't go to the only 2 shelters in the
City, what was our alternative?" The guards told us that
that was our problem, and no they did not have extra water
to give to us. This would be the start
of our numerous encounters with callous and hostile "law
enforcement".
We walked to the police command center at Harrah's on Canal
Street and were told the same thing, that we were on our own,
and no they did not have water to give us. We now numbered
several hundred. We held a mass meeting to decide a course
of action. We agreed to camp outside the police command post.
We would be plainly visible to the media and would constitute
a highly visible embarrassment to the City officials. The police
told us that we could not stay. Regardless, we began to settle
in and set up camp. In short order, the police commander came
across the street to address our group. He
told us he had a solution: we should walk to the Pontchartrain
Expressway and cross the greater New Orleans Bridge where the
police had buses lined up to take us out of the City. The
crowed cheered and began to move. We called everyone back and
explained to the commander that there had been lots of misinformation
and wrong information and was he sure that there were buses
waiting for us. The commander turned
to the crowd and stated emphatically, "I swear to you
that the buses are there."
We organized ourselves and the 200 of us set off for the bridge
with great excitement and hope. As we marched pasted the convention
center, many locals saw our determined and optimistic group
and asked where we were headed. We told them about the great
news. Families immediately grabbed their few belongings and
quickly our numbers doubled and then doubled again. Babies
in strollers now joined us, people using crutches, elderly
clasping walkers and others people in wheelchairs. We marched
the 2-3 miles to the freeway and up the steep incline to the
Bridge. It now began to pour down rain, but it did not dampen
our enthusiasm.
As we approached the bridge, armed Gretna
sheriffs formed a line across the foot of the bridge. Before
we were close enough to speak, they began firing their weapons
over our heads. This sent the crowd fleeing in various
directions. As the crowd scattered and dissipated, a few
of us inched forward and managed to engage some of the sheriffs
in conversation. We told them of our conversation with the
police commander and of the commander's assurances. The
sheriffs informed us there were no buses waiting. The commander
had lied to us to get us to move.
We questioned why we couldn't cross
the bridge anyway, especially as there was little traffic
on the 6-lane highway. They responded that the West Bank
was not going to become New Orleans and there would be no
Superdomes in their City. These
were code words for if you are poor and black, you are not
crossing the Mississippi River and you were not getting out
of New Orleans.
Our small group retreated back down Highway 90 to seek shelter
from the rain under an overpass. We debated our options and
in the end decided to build an encampment in the middle of
the Ponchartrain Expressway on the center divide, between the
O'Keefe and Tchoupitoulas exits. We reasoned we would be visible
to everyone, we would have some security being on an elevated
freeway and we could wait and watch for the arrival of the
yet to be seen buses.
All day long, we saw other families, individuals and groups
make the same trip up the incline in an attempt to cross the
bridge, only to be turned away. Some chased away with gunfire,
others simply told no, others to be verbally berated and humiliated.
Thousands of New Orleaners were prevented and prohibited from
self-evacuating the City on foot. Meanwhile, the only two City
shelters sank further into squalor and disrepair. The only
way across the bridge was by vehicle. We saw workers stealing
trucks, buses, moving vans, semi-trucks and any car that could
be hotwired. All were packed with people trying to escape the
misery New Orleans had become.
Our little encampment began to blossom. Someone stole a water
delivery truck and brought it up to us. Let's hear it for looting!
A mile or so down the freeway, an army truck lost a couple
of pallets of C-rations on a tight turn. We ferried the food
back to our camp in shopping carts. Now secure with the two
necessities, food and water; cooperation, community, and creativity
flowered. We organized a clean up and hung garbage bags from
the rebar poles. We made beds from wood pallets and cardboard.
We designated a storm drain as the bathroom and the kids built
an elaborate enclosure for privacy out of plastic, broken umbrellas,
and other scraps. We even organized a food recycling system
where individuals could swap out parts of C-rations (applesauce
for babies and candies for kids!).
This was a process we saw repeatedly in the
aftermath of Katrina. When individuals had to fight to find
food or water, it meant looking out for yourself only. You
had to do whatever it took to find water for your kids or food
for your parents. When these basic needs were met, people began
to look out for each other, working together and constructing
a community.
If the relief organizations had saturated the City with food
and water in the first 2 or 3 days, the desperation, the frustration
and the ugliness would not have set in.
Flush with the necessities, we offered food and water to passing
families and individuals. Many decided to stay and join us.
Our encampment grew to 80 or 90 people.
From a woman with a battery powered radio we learned that
the media was talking about us. Up in full view on the freeway,
every relief and news organizations saw us on their way into
the City. Officials were being asked what they were going to
do about all those families living up on the freeway? The officials
responded they were going to take care of us. Some of us got
a sinking feeling. "Taking care of us" had an ominous
tone to it.
Unfortunately, our sinking feeling (along
with the sinking City) was correct. Just as dusk set in, a
Gretna Sheriff showed up, jumped out of his patrol vehicle,
aimed his gun at our faces, screaming,
"Get off the fucking freeway". A helicopter arrived
and used the wind from its blades to blow away our flimsy structures.
As we retreated, the sheriff loaded up his truck with our food
and water.
Once again, at gunpoint, we were forced off the freeway. All
the law enforcement agencies appeared threatened when we congregated
or congealed into groups of 20 or more. In every congregation
of "victims" they saw "mob" or "riot".
We felt safety in numbers. Our "we must stay together" was
impossible because the agencies would force us into small atomized
groups.
In the pandemonium of having our camp raided and destroyed,
we scattered once again. Reduced to a small group of 8 people,
in the dark, we sought refuge in an abandoned school bus, under
the freeway on Cilo Street. We were
hiding from possible criminal elements but equally and definitely,
we were hiding from the police and sheriffs with their martial
law, curfew and shoot-to-kill policies.
The next days, our group of 8 walked most of the day, made
contact with New Orleans Fire Department and were eventually
airlifted out by an urban search and rescue team. We were dropped
off near the airport and managed to catch a ride with the National
Guard. The two young guardsmen apologized
for the limited response of the Louisiana guards. They
explained that a large section of their unit was in Iraq and
that meant they were shorthanded and were unable to complete
all the tasks they were assigned.
We arrived at the airport on the day a massive airlift had
begun. The airport had become another Superdome. We 8 were
caught in a press of humanity as flights were delayed for several
hours while George Bush landed briefly at the airport for a
photo op. After being evacuated on a coast guard cargo plane,
we arrived in San Antonio, Texas.
There the humiliation and dehumanization of the official relief
effort continued. We were placed on buses and driven to a large
field where we were forced to sit for hours and hours. Some
of the buses did not have air-conditioners. In the dark, hundreds
if us were forced to share two filthy overflowing porta-potties.
Those who managed to make it out with any possessions (often
a few belongings in tattered plastic bags) we were subjected
to two different dog-sniffing searches.
Most of us had not eaten all day because our C-rations had
been confiscated at the airport because the rations set off
the metal detectors. Yet, no food had
been provided to the men, women, children, elderly, disabled
as they sat for hours waiting to be
"medically screened" to make sure we were not carrying
any communicable diseases.
This official treatment was in sharp
contrast to the warm, heart-felt reception given to us by
the ordinary Texans. We saw
one airline worker give her shoes to someone who was barefoot.
Strangers on the street offered us money and toiletries with
words of welcome. Throughout, the official relief effort
was callous, inept, and racist.
There was more suffering than need be.
Lives were lost that did not need to be lost. |
WASHINGTON - He's been called an idiot,
an incompetent and worse. The vilification
of federal disaster chief Michael Brown, emerging as chief
scapegoat for whatever went wrong in the government's response
to Hurricane Katrina, has ratcheted into the stratosphere. Democratic
members of Congress are taking numbers to call for his head.
"I would never have appointed such a person,"
said New York Sen.
Hillary Rodham Clinton.
"Let's bring in someone who is a professional,"
urged Sen. Barbara Mikulski, D-Md.
A more visceral indictment came from closer to the calamity.
Aaron Broussard, president of Jefferson Parish near New Orleans,
said the bureaucracy "has murdered people in the greater
New Orleans area."
"Take whatever idiot they have at the
top of whatever agency and give me a better idiot,"
he told CBS. "Give me a caring idiot. Give me a sensitive
idiot. Just don't give me the same idiot."
Republican Sen. Trent Lott of Mississippi, just back from
a week surveying damage in his home state, allowed that "mistakes
were made" but tried to counsel restraint Tuesday as calls
for Brown's removal escalated. But even Lott displayed some
of the potent emotions spawned by the horrific conditions on
the Gulf Coast.
"If somebody said, 'You pick somebody to hammer,' I don't
know who I'd pick," he told reporters.
"I did threaten to physically beat a couple of people
in the last couple of days, figuratively speaking."
It's not uncommon for the Federal Emergency Management Agency
- and whoever is in charge at the time - to catch blame in
the messy aftermath of disaster.
It happened after Hugo hit South Carolina in 1989 and Andrew
struck Florida in 1992.
After Andrew, Mikulski slammed the agency
for a "pathetically sluggish" response, and on the
ground, Dade County emergency director Kathleen Hale famously
summed up the frustration felt throughout the stricken areas
when she cried, "Where the hell is the cavalry?"
"There is nothing more powerful than the urge to blame," said
Eric Dezenhall, a crisis-management consultant who helps corporate
leaders and other prominent figures try to repair tattered
images. "It happens every time. It is a deeply embedded
archetype in the human mind."
He said the Brown episode is playing out
in classic fashion.
"You can follow the steps,"
he said. "First, outrage. Second, the headline: 'What
went wrong?' Third, the telltale memo that supposedly suggests
somebody knew and did nothing. I just
don't find this to be unique at all."
Brown, a 50-year-old lawyer, in some ways is an easy target.
The former head of the International Arabian Horse Association,
Brown had no background in disaster relief when old college
friend and then-FEMA Director Joe Allbaugh hired him to serve
as the agency's general counsel in 2001.
"There is a Jay Leno-esque comic undertone to his background," said
Dezenhall. "It sort of conjures up a who's-on-first kind
of thing."
But the dim view of Brown's qualifications
by senators seems to have emerged only in hindsight. Members
of both parties seemed little troubled by his background at
2002 Senate hearings that led to his confirmation as deputy
FEMA chief.
Indeed, Democratic Sen. Joseph Lieberman of Connecticut, who
led those hearings, called Brown's long-ago stint as assistant
city manager in Edmond, Okla., a "particularly useful
experience" because he had responsibility for local emergency
services.
As FEMA chief, Brown has pressed for greater attention to
natural disaster planning, including strategies for a major
hurricane in New Orleans, and he has had to contend with cuts
to FEMA's operating budget while more attention was paid to
fighting terrorism.
But as the enormity of the Gulf Coast damage gradually came
into clearer focus, Brown did not help his case with a number
of comments seen as insensitive or ill-advised. For example,
he acknowledged last week that he didn't know there were some
20,000 evacuees enduring heinous conditions at the New Orleans
convention center until a day after their difficulties had
been widely reported in the news.
ABC's Ted Koppel was incredulous as he asked
Brown, "Don't you guys watch television? Don't you guys
listen to the radio?"
"Forgive me for beating up on you there,"
Koppel later told Brown, "but you are the only guy from
the federal government who is coming out to take your medicine."
The doses keep getting stronger. But, for now at least, President
Bush is standing by his embattled FEMA chief.
"Brownie, you're doing a heck of a job," the
president told him last week.
And Brown, for his part, is trying to shrug off the criticism.
"People want to lash out at me, lash out at FEMA,"
he told reporters. "I think that's fine. Just lash out,
because my job is to continue to save lives." |
The Federal Emergency Management Agency
has done it again.
Already under fire for its woeful response to Hurricane
Katrina, the federal disaster agency appears to have turned
hurricane relief donations into a political payoff - until
it was challenged.
All last week, FEMA bureaucrats gave prominent placement
on the agency's Web site to Operation Blessing, the Virginia-based
charity run by controversial right-wing evangelist and Christian
Coalition founder Pat Robertson.
For anyone wishing to donate only cash,
the agency's site listed the names and phone numbers of three
groups: the Red Cross, Operation Blessing and America's Second
Harvest, a national coalition of food banks.
That first list was followed by a second, longer list of
several dozen religious and nonsectarian charities. This second
list was for anyone who wanted to give either cash or noncash
gifts.
Just as in an ordinary election, however, top ballot position
makes it far more likely you'll get noticed and chosen.
The same FEMA list was then disseminated by state and local
governments throughout the country. Both Gov. Pataki and Mayor
Bloomberg, for example, placed the same top three FEMA charities
on their Hurricane Katrina press releases and Web sites last
week.
Those familiar with Robertson and his charity were flabbergasted.
Operation Blessing, with a budget of $190
million, is an integral part of the Robertson empire. Not only
is he the chairman of the board, his wife is listed on its
latest financial report as its vice president, and one of his
sons is on the board of directors.
Back in 1994, during the infamous Rwandan
genocide, Robertson used his 700 Club's daily cable operation
to appeal to the American public for donations to fly humanitarian
supplies into Zaire to save the Rwandan refugees.
The planes purchased by Operation Blessing did a lot more
than ferry relief supplies.
An investigation conducted by the Virginia
attorney general's office concluded in 1999 that the planes
were mostly used to transport mining equipment for a diamond
operation run by a for-profit company called African Development
Corp.
And who do you think was the principal executive
and sole shareholder of the mining company?
You guessed it, Pat Robertson himself.
Robertson had landed the mining concession from his longtime
friend Mobutu Sese Seko, then the dictator of Zaire.
Investigators concluded that Operation Blessing "willfully
induced contributions from the public through the use of misleading
statements ..."
After the investigation began, Robertson placated state regulators
by personally reimbursing his own charity $400,000 and by agreeing
to tighten its bookkeeping methods.
Separating Operation Blessing from Robertson's many politically
oriented endeavors is not that easy, however.
The biggest single US recipient of the charity's largess,
according to its latest financial report, was Robertson's Christian
Broadcasting Network. It received $885,000 in the fiscal year
ended March 2004.
Robertson uses that Christian network for some markedly unchristian
purposes.
A few years back, he repeatedly defended
Charles Taylor, the former brutal dictator of Liberia who is
under indictment by a UN tribunal for war crimes.
As with Mobutu in the Congo, Robertson had
a personal stake in the matter: He had millions invested in
a Liberian gold mine, thanks to Taylor, according to press
reports.
Recently, Robertson called for the assassination of Venezuelan
President Hugo Chavez. Those who know Robertson's record raised
such an uproar that on Sunday FEMA suddenly rearranged its
entire Web site for hurricane donations.
Gone was Operation Blessing's name and choice location. Replacing
it was an alphabetical list of nearly 50 national relief organizations.
At FEMA, they take a while to get things right. |
NEW ORLEANS, United States - The prospect
of Hurricane Katrina survivors being dragged from their homes
loomed larger while lawmakers in Washington locked horns over
probing the federal response to the disaster.
With officials saying anywhere between 10,000 to 15,000
people remained in New Orleans, police and soldiers faced
some difficult choices in enforcing a mandatory order to
empty the city.
Mayor Ray Nagin authorised the use of force on Tuesday but,
with a number of residents still awaiting voluntary evacuation,
rescue teams have so far postponed physical confrontations
with those determined to stay.
Eventually, however, only the diehards will be left.
"Once all the volunteer evacuations have taken place,
then we'll concentrate our efforts and our forces to mandatorily
evacuate individuals," New Orleans police chief Eddie
Compass said, promising that his officers would use "the
minimal amount of force necessary."
Federal troops have joined in the house-to-house
search for survivors, but senior military officers made it
clear they would stand back if it came to manhandling people
out of their homes.
"When this turns into a law enforcement
issue, which we perceive forced evacuation is, regular troops
would not be used," said Major General Joseph Inge, deputy
commander of the US Northern Command.
As of Wednesday, there were 18,000 active-duty soldiers and
45,000 National Guard troops in the area of the US Gulf coast
devastated by Hurricane Katrina on August 29.
The decision to authorise forced evictions was clearly taken
reluctantly, with officials anxious to avoid traumatic scenes
involving people who have already suffered extreme deprivations
since Katrina hit.
In giving the order, Nagin cited the growing threat of disease
posed by the putrid waters surrounding the wooden homes of
many of the holdouts.
Health authorities said five people evacuated
from the Katrina disaster zone had died as a result of contact
with contaminated water.
The five had been killed by vibrio vulnificus, "a bacteria
that can enter somebody through a cut, a scratch or a wound," said
Tom Skinner, a spokesman for the government Centers for Disease
Control and Prevention (CDC).
Other medical officials said the deaths should
not be seen as presaging an epidemic, as the bacteria preys
mostly on the very old or those already suffering from a chronic
illness.
The floodwaters in low-lying New Orleans have receded as US
Army engineers have brought more of the city's damaged pumps
back in operation.
The drainage process is expected to take close to three months
and Nagin warned the country to brace for some
"awful" revelations as the dropping water levels
reveal more of Katrina's human cost.
The mayor said as many as 10,000 people
may have died in the city and a Louisiana health official
revealed Wednesday that some 25,000 body bags had been brought
into the area.
The city's official death toll currently stands at 83, but
that number is certain to rise over the coming week.
In Washington, President George W. Bush asked lawmakers for
a further 51.8 billion dollars in emergency funding to cover
costs tied to the hurricane relief and recovery effort.
Bush, who has come under fire for the federal response to
one of the worst natural disasters in US history, had signed
an initial emergency package totalling some 10.5 billion dollars
last week.
"We are sparing no effort to help those who have been
affected by Katrina and are in need of help,"
White House spokesman Scott McClellan said.
Congressional leaders, meanwhile, battled over the question
of who should handle the inquiry into how the Katrina crisis
was managed.
Democrats are demanding an independent
probe like the one, at first resisted by Bush, that looked
into the September 11, 2001 attacks. They
have also started a petition to sack the much-criticised
head of the Federal Emergency Management Agency, Michael
Brown.
Bush's majority Republicans only agreed Wednesday to a joint
Senate-House of Representatives investigation to look into
the actions of "all levels of government."
After promising to lead his own inquiry, Bush would not say
whether any aides would be fired over the slow response that
he has admitted was "unacceptable."
A USA Today survey released Wednesday said
42 percent of Americans felt Bush had done his job handling
Katrina "badly" or "very badly". Thirty-five
percent backed the president's effort.
Twenty-five percent criticised local authorities and 18 percent
the Louisiana state for the chaos.
Meanwhile Germany dispatched a team of disaster relief workers
Thursday to help hurricane victims, the Technisches Hilfswerk
(THW) agency said.
The 54-member THW team left the Ramstein US military airport
in western Germany bound for New Orleans early Thursday in
a C-17 Globemaster transport plane loaded with water pumps
and trucks.
A second contingent of 40 aid workers was to leave from Ramstein
later Thursday.
The move came as The Washington Times
reported that nearly 900 foreign nationals, many of them
French and British, are still missing in the areas devastated
last week by Hurricane Katrina.
While consular officials consulted by the daily reported some
160 French citizens and 96 Britons missing, Mexicans, especially
illegal immigrants, were expected to outnumber all other nationalities,
the daily said.
The US State Department Wednesday afternoon told the newspaper
that, based on numbers provided by various embassies, 883 foreign
nationals were still unaccounted for in the aftermath of Hurricane
Katrina. |
WASHINGTON - The federal government plans
to hand out debit cards worth $2,000 each to families displaced
by Hurricane Katrina.
Homeland Security Department Secretary Michael Chertoff, under
fire for his agency's response to the disaster,
held a conference call with governors of states with evacuees
and described the plan. While many details remained to
be worked out, the plan was to quickly begin distributing
the cards, starting with people
in major evacuation centers such as the Houston Astrodome.
Michael Brown, the head of the Federal Emergency Management
Agency which is administering the novel card program, said
it is aimed at those with the most pressing needs.
"The concept is to get them some cash in hand which allows
them, empowers them, to make their own decisions about what
do they need to have to start rebuilding,"
Brown said.
Republican Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney, who participated
in the conference call, said the cards will be offered
"to people in shelters as well as people who are not in
shelters but who have evacuated the area and need help." He
said the hope is the cards will encourage people to leave shelters
voluntarily.
Other FEMA officials warned not all families that fled their
homes will be eligible.
"For instance you may have some people who have insurance
and insurance is meeting their living expenses while they have
been displaced," said Ed Conley, a FEMA spokesman in Houston. "You
have some people who may be looking at an option such as a
cruise ship where all of their needs are going to be met. It
is going to vary by family."
The cards are to be used to help victims purchase food, transportation
and other essentials.
It's unclear how much the debit card program will cost the
government, but it could run into the hundreds of millions
of dollars since hundreds of thousands of people have been
displaced. [...] |
HOUSTON - Three truckloads of fashion
clothing seized by government agents for violating import quotas
arrived at Houston's Astrodome on Wednesday so Hurricane Katrina
refugees there can put it to use.
U.S. Customs and Border Protection delivered
about 100,000 items of summer clothing, with an estimated
value of $2.3 million, and said much more is on the way to
evacuees elsewhere.
"We normally would either sell this merchandise or destroy
it," said Robert Trotter, the agency's director of field
operations. "Or we would donate it on a smaller scale."
Some of the items are fakes, but Trotter said most are legitimate.
The hurricane relief operation, aimed at the more than 1 million
Gulf Coast residents displaced by Katrina last week, will involve
a total of $168 million worth of clothing.
The items delivered on Tuesday, much of it with designer labels
like Fubu and Code Blue, were handed to the Red Cross and local
church officials who were to distribute it.
"They will be able to tell us specifically
what they want and a personal shopper will go back and get
it for them," said Mike Firenza of St. Luke's Methodist
Church. "It will be one of the finest-dressed
shelters that there's ever been."
The Astrodome, a 40-year-old sports stadium that had fallen
into disuse recently, housed about 16,000 refugees on Tuesday.
Three other major shelters in Houston housed a total of 10,000. |
FIRST ASSESSMENT: Hurricane Katrina will
cause national employment to drop by 400,000 jobs, the Congressional
Budget Office predicted. Such a loss
would wipe out recent jobs gains achieved under the Bush administration.
ADDED WOES: The storm's havoc may also slow economic growth
by as much as a full percentage point this year and cause
gasoline prices to jump 40 percent
this month.
UNCLEAR FUTURE: With economists and
politicians forecasting varying outcomes, the hurricane's
long-term impact remains uncertain. |
WASHINGTON - Barbara Bush was making
"a personal observation" when she said poor people
at a relocation center in Houston were faring better than before
Hurricane Katrina struck, President Bush's spokesman said Wednesday.
Scott McClellan, the White House press secretary, did not
answer directly when asked if the president agreed with his
mother's remarks.
Mrs. Bush, after touring the Astrodome complex in Houston
on Monday, said: "What I'm hearing,
which is sort of scary, is they all want to stay in Texas.
Everyone is so overwhelmed by the hospitality. And so many
of the people in the arena here, you know, were underprivileged
anyway, so this is working very well for them." She
commented during a radio interview with the American Public
Media program "Marketplace."
McClellan, at the White House briefing, said: "I
think she was making a personal observation on some of the
comments that people were making that she was running into. ...
But what we're focused on is helping these people who are
in need."
Asked if Bush agreed with his mother, McClellan said:
"I think that the observation is based on someone or some
people that were talking to her that were in need of a lot
of assistance, people that have gone through a lot of trauma
and been through a very difficult and trying time. And all
of a sudden, they are now getting great help in the state of
Texas from some of the shelters." |
If you believe the oil industry's response
to Katrina, you'd think demanding environmentalists are to
blame for $3 per gallon gasoline because the tree huggers shut
down refineries with tough new rules. President Bush even mimicked
the industry excuse by waiving environmental standards in the
wake of Katrina. Well, the industry's
own internal memos show the intentional shrinking of American
refinery capacity in the 1990s was the oil companies' own idea
to pump up profits.
Take this internal
Texaco strategy memo:
"[T]he most critical factor facing the refining industry
on the West Coast is the surplus of refining capacity,
and the surplus gasoline production capacity. (The same
situation exists for the entire U.S. refining industry.)
Supply significantly exceeds demand year-round. This results
in very poor refinery margins and very poor refinery financial
results. Significant events need
to occur to assist in reducing supplies and/or increasing
the demand for gasoline."
The memo went on to discuss a sucessful campaign
in Washington State to shrink refined supply by removing other
additives in the gasoline that filled gas volume.
Another Mobil
memo shows the company promoted tough regulations in
California to shut down an independent refiner. A Chevron
memo acknowledged the industry wide need to shutter refineries
and discussed how refiners were responding in kind.
Large oil companies have for a decade artificially shorted
the gasoline market to drive up prices. Oil companies know
they can make more money by making less gasoline. Katrina should
be a wakeup call to America that the refiners profit widely
when they keep the system running on empty. It's time for government
to regulate the industry's supply. The
fact that President Bush received $2.6 million from the oil
industry for his reelection in 2004 should make regulation
of the nation's gas supply one of the Democrats' most important
talking points. |
"How does it feel
To be on your own
With no direction home."
Bob Dylan, "Like a Rolling Stone"
Let's be clear about one thing. Nothing that has happened
in the past week -- the mass destruction in the Mississippi
Delta, the obliteration of the city of New Orleans, the murderous
abandonment of thousands of people to death, chaos and disease will
change the Bush Administration or American politics at all.
Not one whit. The Bush Administration will not reverse its
brutal policies; its Congressional rubber-stamps will not
revolt against the White House; the national Democrats will
not suddenly grow a spine. There will be no real change,
and the bitter corrosion of injustice, indifference and inhumanity
that is consuming American society will go on as before.
One proof of this can be found in the first polls coming out
after the disaster, which show that a full 46 percent of the
American people approve of Bush's handling of the relief effort.
It seems inconceivable that any sentient being could witness
the agonizing results of the Bush team's dithering, dilatory
response an agony played out in the full glare of non-stop
media coverage
and not come away with a sense of towering anger at this criminal
incompetence. But it's obvious that nearly half the American
people have now left the "reality-based community" altogether;
they see only what they want to see, a world bathed in the
hazy, golden nimbus of the Leader. The fact the undeniable
truth
that behind this carefully-concocted mirage lies nothing more
than a steaming pile of rancid, rotting offal means nothing
to these true believers. The Lie is
better, the Lie is more comforting, the Lie lets them keep
feeding on the suffering of others without guilt or shame.
This painful split between obvious reality and popular perception
is nothing new, of course. Today we look at old footage of
Adolf Hitler and wonder how on earth such a pathetic and ludicrous
creature could ever have commanded the adoration and obedience
of tens of millions of people. Yet he did. As Eliot said, "Human
kind cannot bear very much reality."
The fact that a few conservative commentators and politicians
are making mild criticisms of Bush means nothing. There has
been much trumpeting of the remarks by David Brooks of the
New York Times that Bush's manifest failures in the Delta coming
after the debacle of the Iraq occupation, the torture revelations,
etc. could be a "watershed" moment when the
nation loses faith in its institutions, a situation Brooks
likened to the 1970s. But even in making
these comments on one hand, Brooks was taking them back with
the other, saying clearly that he might "get over" his
disappointment with Bush soon enough. Think
of it: Brooks has watched people literally dying before his
very eyes after being abandoned to their fate for days by Bush's
criminal negligence and he thinks he can "get over"
that at some point, and give his full-throated approval
to the Leader once again.
This is the general mind-set (if you want to dignify the inch-deep
shallowness of Brooks' intellect with the word "mind")
of all the conservative critics: gosh, Bush really dropped
the ball on this one! He'd better turn the PR thing around,
or he might lose some of the "political capital" he
needs to "advance his second-term agenda." That's
it. That's as far as it goes.
After all, they fully support the "agenda"
more war, more tax cuts for the rich, more impunity for
big corporations, more welfare for the oil barons, the coal
barons, the nuke barons, more coddling of elite investors,
more state power for Christian extremists, more media consolidation,
more graft, more kickbacks, more easy money for greasy palms.
And now that Karl Rove has finally figured out his response employing
brazen lies to smear state and local officials
you will very quickly see the conservative critics, especially
in Congress, fall into lockstep with the porcine counsellor's
program.
By the time Congress holds hearings into the disaster, they'll
be singing love songs to the Leader; the hearings themselves
will doubtless turn into a pageant of heroic tableaux -- glittering
stories of the heroic federal effort to rescue the perishing,
all of it driven by the calm and steady hand of the Commander-in-chief. Oh,
there might be a scapegoat or two for the Congressmen to pummel
with puff-cheeked righteous rage for the cameras. But anyone
hoping for a fearless, presidency-shaking probe will be disappointed.
Just as the media have always overhyped
Bush's popularity, they are now overhyping the "political
crisis" he is supposedly facing. There is no
political crisis whatsoever, if by "political crisis" you
mean something that will cause Bush to alter his policies.
The war in Iraq will go on. The war against the poor will
go on. The slow destruction of middle-class security and
stability will go on. The long and ferocious rightwing campaign
against the very idea of a "common good" will go
on, unabated
perhaps even strengthened as it faces a backlash from
the half of the American public that actually accepts the reality
of what they saw in New Orleans and all along the ravaged Gulf
Coast.
This is what you must understand: Bush and
his faction do not care if they have "the consent of the
governed" or not. They are not interested in governing
at all, in responding to the needs and desires and will of
the people. They are only interested in ruling, in using the
power of the state to force their radical agenda of elitist
aggrandizement and ideological crankery on the nation, and
on the world.
They have a large, hard core of true believers who will countenance even
applaud any crime, any corruption, any incompetence of
the Leader and his minions. With this base, and with all of
the branches of government already in their hands, the Faction
need only procure the reluctant support of just a small percentage
of the rest of the population through fearmongering,
through smears and lies, and, as we saw in 2000 and 2004, through
the manipulation of election results via politically connected
voting-machine corporations and politically partisan election
officials.
None of this will change because of what happened in New Orleans. If
these people could be touched by suffering and injustice,
by death and destruction, by corruption and incompetence,
then they would not be where they are today. If there
was a viable opposition in the American Establishment to
Bush's policies, it would have stood up long ago. Like the
people left behind in New Orleans, we're all on our own "with
no direction home."
How does it feel?
Chris Floyd is a columnist for The Moscow Times and regular
contributor to CounterPunch. A new, upgraded version of his
blog, "Empire Burlesque," can be found at www.chris-floyd.com. |
WASHINGTON - The anonymous donor turned
up at a U.S. diplomatic office and presented an envelope with
1,000 euros, about $1,200, for Hurricane Katrina relief efforts.
It was a way of repaying a debt to the United States for
being liberated by American soldiers from a concentration
camp and treated more than 60 years ago, Sean McCormack,
the State Department spokesman, said Wednesday in relating
the incident.
The donor was 90 years old, but that is all McCormack would
say by way of identification, although it was learned later
the donor was a woman. "This is a person who is not seeking
any publicity for this act - which in the time we live makes
it even more extraordinary,"
he said.
"This is a selfless act by somebody
who is repaying what they felt was a deeply felt debt of gratitude
to the United States," the spokesman said.
This is one of many stories from around the
world of individuals being very generous with the American
people at a time of need, McCormack said.
"It's extraordinary," he said. |
The dog opened his mouth to get the other bone, and
as he did, the bone he already had fell into the water.
- Aesop
All our seeming wakings are but the debris of evening
waters.
- Edward Dahlberg
Still water is like glass.
- Chuang Tzu
Welcome to Bantustan, Louisiana, where the first stage of
creating a large, armed, New World Order fortress, complete
with gated communities and an Israeli wall against the sea
and the riffraff, has begun. It is the inevitable course
of human history, playing like a bad rerun of humanity's
medieval nightmares.
In the meantime, the chief sephardic rabbi in Jerusalem declared that
the hurricane that obliterated New Orleans was God's punishment
because President Bush supported the eviction of Israeli settlers
from Gaza.
Take a taste, a gargantuan, thirst-quenching slug of that
delicious elixir brewed by humanity's most successful citizens,
that Cajun cabernet of pesticide-fouled Mississippi River water
curdling in the backwater blender of the Gulf of Mexico dead
zone, spiced by fragrances from all across the periodic table
of toxic elements and spiced with a disease-bearing melange
of decomposing dead animals.
Savor the bouquet. See how it tinkles on your tongue and wafts
into your hairy nostrils. Close your eyes and you can envision
the perfect portrait of human civilization.
They say we are 89 percent water. The quality of the water
within us is directly correlative to the ingredients of the
potion in the cauldron of New Orleans.
Note the bloated black man, floating face down in the brew.
Boats rush past, to and fro, hoping to pry decomposing remains
from dank attics, and occasionally, with luck, find some terrified
child shivering in the stinking darkness, while National Guardsmen
play cards at a nearby truckstop.
If there is a legitimate vision of hell in this life, New
Orleans after Hurricane Katrina is it (although this act has
also been seen recently in Fallujah, Kigali, Port-au-Prince
and many other locations as well).
Where your last breath, to last you for all eternity, is the
fetid stench of humanity's caustic creations, what kind of
hope could there be for anyone? Why did four people last week
die suddenly simply by breathing the air? Must be a new government
test.
The two major conspiracy angles on the New Orleans disaster
are (1) the hurricane was directed toward the city by artificial
means, and (2) the rescue efforts were deliberately inept to
increase the death toll among indigent African-Americans.
Culling the herd. That would be the neocon phrase, slurred
out as humor by people like Barbara Bush.
But when you observe who keeps getting it in the face, without
even perusing the obvious evidence all across history, you
realize there is and has always been a continuing war on blacks,
on the dark-skinned peoples of the world, and New Orleans is
- whether deliberately contrived or not - a genuine manifestation
of this nasty and pointless insanity.
Because so many ordinary people have tried to help New Orleans
storm victims and been thwarted by bureaucratic officialdom,
one can only draw the conclusion that the government has severely
limited its rescue efforts because there is no place in corporate
society for these people, and they need to be eliminated.
I thought it was very cool that so many of those like DU activist
Dennis Kyne and others who went to Texas to support antiwar
mom Cindy Sheehan smoothly moved their operation to New Orleans
to help out.
This small remaining segment of morally decent Americans knows
- much more authentically that the government could ever pretend
to know - that when people are dying you don't argue about
causes or rules. Perhaps that is the true test of being human.
9/11 taught us that our government will sacrifice 3,000 of
its own best and brightest without blinking an eye. New Orleans
is the message that the number eligible in this category, especially
if they're black, is much, much higher.
And it is a confession that a real population control program
is moving into high gear.
Good numbers in Indonesia, good numbers in New Orleans. Could
a West Coast quake be far behind? Heck, they have already caused
several of those in Iran.
And it's way past time for the government, after many decades
of trying, to develop a really effective biological agent -
the new flu as an expression of love in the New World Order
world - and you begin to get some sense of how twisted we have
become as a species.
Which leads to an examination of how twisted we have always
been. Kind of like ... on the bridge at twilight, a man with
a flashlight falls off a bridge, and what you can remember
was the rhythmic flailing of his arms as he fell. I dunno.
Maybe I'm thinking about 9/11 again...
Now the new images are of floating, inert, face down in poison
after rummaging through spoiled and flooded supermarkets looking
for clean water. I found it heartwrenching that a top choice
of New Orleans looters was disposable diapers.
How far? How far distant is the realization in the minds of
everyone that we have created a monster, and that monster is
what we do to ourselves and the planet.
Did you ever notice how the Andaman Island indigenents were
not harmed by the tsunami, or how animals are never killed
in these storms? I don't mean to point out faults in those
who were caught in the floodtide, but as regards our fitness
to survive as a society.
In our sparkling delusions, our high-minded ideals and low-flying
scams, we have abandoned the planet. Soon the planet, which
has gone out of its way to help us for millions of years, will
abandon us.
Where will your dreams be then? Floating on the bayou, baby,
with all the other dead birds.
John Kaminski is a writer who lives on a part of the Gulf
Coast of Florida that for some reason Hurricane Katrina inexplicably
swerved around on its way to New Orleans. He is the author
of "The Day America Died: Why You Shouldn't Believe the
Official Story of What Happened on September 11, 2001." http://www.johnkaminski.com/ |
WASHINGTON - The US military reportedly
failed to respond quickly to the devastation of Hurricane Katrina
as advisers weighed whether
President George W. Bush should take over relief operations from
state authorities.
At the heart of the dispute was a US law preventing military
troops from intervening in states where there is risk of
armed conflict without the approval of state authorities,
The New York Times said.
In the wake of Hurricane Katrina's August 29 strike on the
US Gulf coasts of Louisiana, Mississippi and Alabama, massive
flooding in New Orleans created a humanitarian nightmare punctuated
by looting and gunfire.
While Louisiana Governor Kathleen Blanco had authority over
the National Guard (state military forces), which arrived in
the crippled city a week ago -- four days after Katrina struck,
Navy and Coast Guard search and rescue teams had arrived on
the scene two days two days earlier.
Those troops, however, could not intervene
in New Orleans before Bush requested Blanco to surrender control
of the National Guard, by invoking the Insurrection Act, federal
and state officials told the daily.
Bush aides presumed Blanco would refuse to
surrender her authority, and Louisiana officials agreed that
the governor would not have given up control of the National
Guard, the daily said.
However, Blanco, who on August 31 asked for 40,000 federal
soldiers, said in an interview with the daily she was unaware
she had to specifically give up control of the National Guard.
"Nobody told me that I had to request
that," Blanco said. "I thought that I had requested
everything they had. We were living in a war zone by then."
The prospect of Bush taking over military control of a state
run by a governor of the rival political party -- Bush is a
Republican, Blanco, a Democrat -- also posed a political dilemma
to his aides, officials told The New York Times.
"Can you imagine how it would have been
perceived if a president of the United States of one party
had pre-emptively taken from the female governor of another
party the command and control of her forces, unless the security
situation made it completely clear that she was unable to effectively
execute her command authority and that lawlessness was the
inevitable result?" asked one senior administration official
who asked not to be identified. |
I'm extremely
depressed to report that things seem to only be getting sadder
concerning the people so devastatingly affected by Katrina
last week. Two car loads of us headed over to Falls Creek,
a youth camp for Southern Baptist churches in Oklahoma that
agreed to have its facilities used to house Louisiana refugees. I'm
afraid the camp is not going to be used as the kind people
of the churches who own the cabins believe it was going to
be used.
Jesse Jackson was right when he
said "refugees" was not the appropriate word
for the poor souls dislocated due to Katrina. But he was
wrong about why it is not appropriate. It's
not appropriate because they are detainees, not refugees.
Falls Creek is like a small town that
is closed down about 9 months out of the year. It is made
up of cabins that range from small and humble to large and
grandiose, according to how much money the church who owns
the cabin has. Each cabin has full kitchen facilities, bathrooms
and usually have two large bunkrooms - one for women and
one for men. The occupancy of the cabins varies according
to the church. This past week the Southern Baptist association
of Oklahoma offered the facility as a place to house refugees
from the Katrina disaster. Each church owning a cabin was
then called to find out if they would make their cabin available.
Churches across the state agreed.
I started my journey by loading six
large trash bags full of clothes in the back of my beetle
buggy. I then went to the local Dollar General and purchased
various hygiene products, snacks and even a set of dominoes
and a deck of cards. I had my daughter take her own shopping
cart and go and select her own items that she wanted to take.
I told her to imagine herself without anything in the world
and then select what she would need to live every day.
We then met up with my elderly parents
who had gone to the Dollar Store themselves, and to the grocery
store and had spent WAY too much of their limited social
security on the venture. But that's okay. We ended up having
to take both vehicles on the 150 mile round trip because
they were both pretty full. My son showed up and wanted to
go. He drove my parents while my daughter and I rode in my
car.
To say we all left with excitement
would be appropriate. My 78 year old mother is a "fixer".
She loves to help people and she absolutely needs someone
to dote over. That she was about to be able to help some
people who had lost all in their lives had her feeling physically
healthier than I've seen her in days. I
was glad to get the chance to actively do something other
than donate what little I can to some faceless charity hoping
it would get to the people who needed it. I felt glad
I could do some small something that might cut through the
helplessness I've felt over this situation. Both of my kids
were eager to assist.
The only odd thing that occurred prior
to setting off happened while I was gassing up in our small
town. My daughter was pumping the gas and a lady she knew
pulled up to an adjacent pump. My daughter started telling
her where we were going and that we were taking things to
the refugees. The lady told my daughter
that she had been told the Red Cross was not allowing any
one to deliver supplies. When I returned to the car
from paying for the gas my daughter informed of this. I told
her that the Red Cross would not be preventing the members
of our church from entering our own cabin, so it really didn't
matter. It was at that point we decided to stop back by the
house and get my daughter's camera so that she could take
pictures if required.
From the moment I heard about Falls
Creek being scheduled to receive refugees I had two thoughts
run through my mind:
1. What a beautiful place to be able
to stay while trying to get your life back in order.
2. What a terrible
location to be when you're trying to get your life back
in order.
The first thought is because Falls
Creek is nestled in the Arbuckle Mountains of south central
Oklahoma. One of the more beautiful regions of the state.
It would be a peaceful and beautiful place to try to start
mending emotionally, and begin to figure what you're going
to do next.
The second thought
comes because Falls Creek is very secluded and absolutely
nowhere near a population center. The
closest route from Falls Creek to a connecting road is
three miles on a winding narrow road called "High
Road" (It gets that name for two reasons - it's goes
over the mountain instead of around it like "Low Road"
does, and it's where the teenagers of the area go to party).
The road has not a single home on it for over 3 miles. After
battling that 3 miles over mountains, you'll find yourself
about 5 miles from the nearest town, Davis, Oklahoma, population
ca. 2000. This is no place to start a new life.
A few pictures headed toward Falls
Creek over High Road to give you a feel of the seclusion.
All of sudden the landscape changed
from picturesque mountainous rural America, to something
foreign to me as we approached the rear gate of the camp. Two
Oklahoma State Patrol vehicles and four Oklahoma Troopers
guarded the gate. We started through and they stopped
us.
"Can I help you, ma'am?"
I informed him we're here to deliver
supplies to *our church's name* cabin. He stood silent and
stared at me. My daughter turned and snapped a picture of
his vehicle - very conspicuously.
I smiled at him and he asked,
"Do you know where that cabin is located?"
I informed him I did. He looked at
me a bit longer and then said, "Ok" and stepped
away from the car. They stopped my parents' vehicle as well,
but I assume my son informed them he was with us. They let
them pass.
We made our way through the narrow
streets toward our church's cabin.
We noticed that the various church
cabins had numbered placards on them that normally weren't
there.
We arrived at our cabin and started
toting the clothes in. We finally found a group of men upstairs
in the dorms trying to do something alien to them - make
beds. They had almost completed the room of bunk beds and
told us we could go over to the ladies' dorm room and start
on it. We lugged our sacks of clothes back down the stairs.
Then we got the first negative message. "You
can't bring any clothes in. FEMA has stated they will accept
no more clothes. They've had 30 people sorting clothes for
days. They don't want anymore." My mind couldn't
help but go back over the news articles that have accused
FEMA of refusing water in to Jefferson Parrish, or turning
fuel away.
We lugged the bags of clothes back
to the car. We then turned to bringing in our personal hygiene
products. That's when we learned our
cabin had been designated a "male only"
cabin. Approximately 40 men, ranging from age 13 on
up would be housed there. We started resacking the female
products and sorted out everything that would be useful for
men.
We lugged the bags of female products
back to the car. We asked if they knew of a cabin that had
been designated for women. The "host"
(the hosts are Oklahoma civilians who have been employeed???
by FEMA to reside at each cabin and have already gone through
at least one "orientation" meeting conducted by FEMA
at "BASE" which is some unknown but repetitively
referred location within the camp) told us he believed McAlester
cabin was dedicated to females. He then
explained there were male, female and family cabins designated.
We then started lugging in our food
products. The foods I had purchased were mainly snacks, but
my mother - God bless her soul - had gone all out with fresh
vegetables, fruits, canned goods, breakfast cereals, rice,
and pancake fixings. That's when we got the next message: They
will not be able to use the kitchen.
Excuse me? I asked incredulously.
FEMA will not
allow any of the kitchen facilities in any of the cabins
to be used by the occupants due to fire hazards. FEMA will
deliver meals to the cabins. The refugees will be given
two meals per day by FEMA. They will not be able to cook. In
fact, the "host" goes on to explain, some churches
had already enquired about whether they could come in on
weekends and fix meals for the people staying in their
cabin. FEMA won't allow it because there could be a situation
where one cabin gets steaks and another gets hot dogs -
and...
It could cause a riot.
It gets worse.
He then precedes to tell us that some
churches had already enquired into whether they could send
a van or bus on Sundays to pick up any occupants of their
cabins who might be interested in attending church. FEMA
will not allow this. The occupants of the camp cannot leave
the camp for any reason. If
they leave the camp they may never return. They will
be issued FEMA identification cards and "a sum of money" and they
will remain within the camp for the next 5 months.
My son looks at me
and mumbles "Welcome to Krakow."
My mother then asked if the churches
would be allowed to come to their cabin and conduct services
if the occupants wanted to attend. The
response was "No ma'am. You don't understand. Your church
no longer owns this building. This building is now owned
by FEMA and the Oklahoma Highway Patrol. They have it for
the next 5 months." This scares my mother who
asks "Do you mean they have leased it?" The man
replies, "Yes, ma'am...lock, stock and barrel. They
have taken over everything that pertains to this facility
for the next 5 months."
We then lug all food products requiring
cooking back to the car. We start unloading our snacks. Mom
appeared to have cornered the market in five counties on
pop-tarts and apparently that was an acceptable snack so
the guy started shoving them under the counter. He
said these would be good to tide people over in between their
two meals a day. But he tells my mother she must take
all the breakfast cereal back. My mother protests that cereal
requires no cooking. "There will
be no milk, ma'am." My mother points to the huge
industrial double-wide refrigerator the church had just purchased
in the past year. "Ma'am, you
don't understand...
It could cause
a riot."
He then points to
the vegetables and fruit. "You'll have to take that
back as well. It looks like you've got about 10 apples there.
I'm about to bring in 40 men. What would we do then?"
My mother, in her sweet, soft voice
says, "Quarter them?"
"No ma'am. FEMA
said no...
It could cause a riot.
You don't understand the type of people that are about to
come here...."
I turn and walk out of the room...lugging
all the healthy stuff back to the car. My son later tells
me the man went on to say "We've already been told of
teenage girls delivering fetuses on buses." My
son steps toward him and says "That's because they've
almost been starved to death, haven't had a decent place
to get a good night's sleep, and their bodies can't keep
a baby alive. I'm not sure that's any evidence some one should
be using to show these are 'bad people'."
We then went to the second dorm room
and made up beds. When we got through and were headed outside
the host says to me and my daughter,
"How did you get in here?" I told him we came in
through the back gate. He replies, "No,
HOW did you get in here? No one who doesn't have credentials
showing is supposed to be in here." (I had noticed
all the "hosts" had two or three badges hanging around
their necks.) I told him it might have had something to do
with the fact my daughter was snapping pictures of the OHP
presence at the gate. He then tells us, "Well,
starting in the morning NO ONE comes in. So if you have further
goods you want to donate you will have to take them to your
local church. They will collect them until they have a full
load and then bring them to the front gate."
Me and my two kids then walked over
the hill to the camp's amphitheater.
First - just another OHP car...
The amphitheater is full of clothes (but
I'm not sure I'm seeing enough for 5000 people for 5 months).
But there was more...an Oklahoma Department
of Safety truck and a military vehicle...
and a cell phone tower (which fretling
didn't get a pic of...grrr). Falls
Creek, because it sits in a "bowl" surrounded by
mountains, is notorious for no cell phone coverage.
There were buses coming in the front
gate at about a rate of 1 every 2 or 3 minutes. We could
hear them below us as we walked back up the hill. We could
also see their white tops through the trees. We figured these
were busloads of refugees arriving, but we never saw these
buses in the camps, nor were any refugees visible at the
camp while we were there.
We then loaded back into our vehicles
and headed toward the cabin we had been told was for women
so that we could off-load our appropriate products. When
we arrived there was no one in the cabin so we preceded to
unload our vehicles and take the merchandise in to the cabin.
A horde of "hosts" who had been hovering at a nearby
cabin head toward us.
"Can we help you?"
I explained to them what we were doing.
"Uhh... you
can't just leave donated goods in the cabins. FEMA has stated
they want all supplies to go to their central warehouse.
They said they have had far too many supplies come in and
they need to handle them. You can't leave ANY clothes."
I just stared at them.
One chubby-checker, after several
moments of pregnant pause broken only by the sound of my
82 year old dad continuing to shuffle boxes out of the back
of his car (GO DAD!), says "I'll call 'BASE' and confirm
what should happen here."
I continue to stare.
He pounds out the number on his cell
phone and when some one picks up he chickens out and just
asks "I need to verify that cabin 11 is a female only
facility." When he hangs up he says that it is and I
respond, "Well, good, we'll get on with this then." It's
at that point my son pulls me aside and says, "Every
damned one of them have the same phone. That's what the comm
tower is for at the amphitheater. Now
we know how FEMA runs through billions, they've given every
one of these people a Cingular phone when walkie-talkies
would have worked just fine."
We off-load our goods into the McAlester
cabin. Fretling takes pics of the buckets of toys that have
been donated by citizens for the kiddos coming this way.
And a dorm room:
We then start out of the camp. I tell
my daughter I want to go out the main gate this time. Here
is what we saw on the way out:
Just another OHP car...
This cabin was apparently commandeered
by a group of people in navy blue jumpsuits with insignias
all over them. You can see them in the left side of this
pic. But they were standing all over the place on both sides
of the narrow street.
This is just one OHP car in a long
line of them parked along the side of the street.
Three firetrucks parked along the
river.
Talk about a surreal moment...troops
(unknown if Regular or National Guard) have taken up residency
in the Durant First Baptist Church cabin very near the main
gate of the camp.
Two things to point out in the pictures
above...we passed a row of about 6 or 8 ambulances parked
in the street just in front of the troop cabin, and the large
tent on the top of the hill...we have no idea what that is
for.
Main gate completely blocked by OHP
vehicles as we approach:
More OHP vehicles parked at the rear
gate as we pass by:
Now I'm starting
to understand why it doesn't matter that this location
is not conducive to starting a new life.
[edit on 9-6-2005 by Valhall] |
U.S. Geological Survey seismologist Lucy
Jones remembers attending an emergency training session in
August 2001 with the Federal Emergency Management Agency that
discussed the three most likely catastrophes to strike the
United States.
First on the list was a terrorist attack
in New York. Second was a super-strength hurricane hitting
New Orleans. Third was a major earthquake on the San Andreas
fault.
Now that the first two have come to pass,
she and other earthquake experts are using the devastating
aftermath of Hurricane Katrina as an opportunity to reassess
how California would handle a major temblor.
Jones, scientist-in-charge for the geological survey's Southern
California Earthquake Hazards Team, and other experts generally
agree that California has come a long way in the last two decades
in seismic safety.
In Los Angeles, all but one of 8,700 unreinforced masonry
buildings - considered the most likely to collapse in a major
quake - have been retrofitted or demolished. The state spent
billions after the 1994 Northridge quake to retrofit more than
2,100 freeway overpasses, reporting this week that only a handful
remain unreinforced.
Despite these improvements, however, officials
believe that a major temblor could cause the level of destruction
and disruption seen over the last week on the Gulf Coast.
More than 900 hospital buildings that state officials have
identified as needing either retrofitting or total replacement
have yet to receive them, and the state recently agreed to
five-year extensions to hospitals that can't meet the 2008
deadline to make the fixes. More than 7,000 school buildings
across the state would also be vulnerable during a huge temblor,
a state study found, though there is no firm timetable for
upgrading the structures.
And four Los Angeles Police Department facilities - including
the Parker Center headquarters in downtown - worry officials,
because they were built to primitive earthquake standards and
might not survive a major temblor. Only two of the LAPD's 19
stations meet the most rigorous quake-safe rules.
"We could be dealing with infrastructure
issues a lot like New Orleans," Jones said. "Our
natural gas passes through the Cajon Pass…. Water - three
pipelines - cross the San Andreas fault in an area that is
expected to go in an earthquake."
Railway lines are also vulnerable, she said.
A catastrophic temblor at the right spot along the San Andreas
could significantly reduce energy and water supplies - at least
temporarily, she and others said. Researchers
at the Southern California Earthquake Center said there is
an 80% to 90% chance that a temblor of 7.0 or greater magnitude
will strike Southern California before 2024.
"We aren't anywhere close to where I wish we were"
in terms of seismic safety, Jones said.
Seismologists are particularly concerned about a type of vulnerable
building that has received far less attention than unreinforced
masonry.
There are about 40,000 structures in California made from "non-ductile
reinforced concrete," a rigid substance susceptible to
cracking. This was a common construction ingredient for office
buildings in the 1950s and '60s, before the state instituted
stricter standards. Few such structures have been seismically
retrofitted, officials said.
Seismic safety advocates have also
recently lost some major battles in Sacramento. The state
rejected a proposal from the Seismic Safety Commission in
the wake of the 2003 San Simeon earthquake to force owners
of unreinforced masonry buildings to post warning signs. In
that quake, two women died when the roof slid off of a two-story
Paso Robles brick building where they worked.
Last week, the Legislature sent to the governor's desk a bill
that encourages local governments to develop retrofitting programs
for "soft story" wood-frame apartment buildings.
There are an estimated 70,000 such structures in the state,
and experts worry that they could sustain major quake damage,
because they often have tuck-under parking and lack solid walls
at their bases.
The danger of this kind of construction was illustrated in
the 1994 collapse of the Northridge Meadows apartment complex,
in which 16 residents were killed.
There are other potential safety gaps as well.
Although Los Angeles, Long Beach, Pasadena and several other
cities have reinforced almost all their masonry buildings,
about a third of such structures across the state remain unprotected,
said Frank Turner, an engineer with the Seismic Safety Commission.
A state study published last year on hazard
reduction paints a sobering picture of California's earthquake
danger. About 62% of the population lives in a zone of high
earthquake danger, including 100% of the population of Ventura
County, 99% of Los Angeles County and 92% of Riverside County.
Since 1971, there have been at least 13 earthquakes of magnitude
6.0 or greater in the state, and research conducted after the
1989 Loma Prieta quake in the Bay Area found a 62% probability
that at least one earthquake of magnitude 6.7 or more would
strike the Bay Area before 2032.
"We're pretty confident we have some of the best buildings
in the world here, but … there are always going to be
losses, because these are extraordinary events," Turner
said.
Still, Southern California's geography could help prevent
a catastrophe on the scale of that in New Orleans.
Because the Los Angeles region is so much larger than the
Louisiana city, it is difficult to conceive of a disaster - "short
of an A-bomb" - that would blanket the whole city, let
alone the whole county, in ruin, said Lee Sapaden, a spokesman
for Los Angeles County's Office of Emergency Management.
Earthquakes tend to do the most damage closest to the epicenters.
The 1994 Northridge quake, for example, damaged a large swath
of the San Fernando Valley as well as parts of Hollywood and
the Westside. But areas farther to the east and south, such
as Long Beach and Orange County, saw little damage.
A large quake in the Valley would probably still allow emergency
supplies and rescuers to reach the area from other locations
such as the San Gabriel Valley and South Bay, Sapaden said.
Emergency crews would have better mobility than those in New
Orleans, he added, because even if freeways were wrecked, aid
would probably be able to get through the vast majority of
areas on surface streets. "Here in Southern California,
Riverside, San Bernardino, Orange and Santa Barbara counties
would help us out, just like we would help them," he said.
One of the biggest concerns of seismic safety officials is
the fate of hospitals.
The 1971 Sylmar earthquake pushed Olive View Medical Center
a foot off its foundation, causing the first floor to collapse,
killing three patients and a hospital worker. The 1994 Northridge
quake knocked 23 hospitals temporarily out of service.
After that quake, the Legislature passed a law requiring that
hospitals retrofit buildings to withstand a major temblor or
replace them with new ones. About 78% of hospitals have at
least one building deemed at risk, said Jan Emerson, spokeswoman
for the California Hospital Assn.
But hospitals, many of which are fighting
budget problems, have balked at the price tag - estimated
at $24 billion for 2002-2030 - and in many cases have successfully
pushed Sacramento to delay the retrofitting deadline. The
state has already granted about 200 requests for extensions
to make the necessary repairs by 2013, according to a state
document.
Safety officials said more work is also needed at schools.
A 2002 state study found that more than 7,500
school buildings across California are expected to "perform
poorly" in a major temblor.
The Los Angeles Unified School District has completed seismic
upgrades to nearly 2,000 buildings, spending $222 million on
the effort, according to Richard Luke, director of design for
the district.
But the district has not finished upgrades on 600 portable
buildings and will look at an additional 239 buildings identified
by the Division of State Architect as possibly performing poorly
during a major quake.
Jones of the geological survey and Turner of the Seismic Safety
Commission believe that one worst-case scenario would involve
a massive temblor on the San Andreas fault around where major
utility lines run, possibly compromising water and power supplies.
"We should not be at all surprised if something similar
to Hurricane Katrina mirrors itself in California,"
Turner said. "There have been lots of articles written
about the failure of levees in the [Sacramento-San Joaquin]
Delta, the loss of drinking water in California. This is just
the tip of the iceberg."
About 60% of Southern California's water is imported from
outside the region in three major aqueducts that cross the
San Andreas fault, making them particularly vulnerable to major
earthquake damage.
One branch of the 444-mile California Aqueduct, which carries
water from the delta, virtually sits on top of the fault for
a few miles near Palmdale. A second aqueduct from the Colorado
River crosses the fault near Beaumont. And the Los Angeles
Aqueduct, which transports snowmelt from the eastern Sierra,
runs across the San Andreas in a mountain tunnel between Lancaster
and Santa Clarita.
Southern California water managers say they've made progress
in recent years building local reserves they could turn to
if they lost water from one or more of the transport systems.
With such efforts, "we feel even more confident we are
able to provide sufficient water to sustain us during an earthquake," said
Debra Man, chief operating officer of the Metropolitan Water
District of Southern California, the region's main water wholesaler.
Jim McDaniels, chief operating officer for the Los Angeles
Department of Water and Power's water system, said that if
disaster struck, the DWP could double its groundwater pumping
within the basin and draw from its four big local reservoirs.
Major gas lines also come into Southern California over the
San Andreas at several points, including at Indio, Palmdale,
the Cajon Pass and the Tejon Ranch. Still, officials at the
Southern California Gas Co. expressed confidence that the system
could withstand a strong earthquake, noting they have been
upgrading the pipeline for years.
Another open question is whether the major quake would cause
damage to fire stations, police headquarters and facilities
of other emergency agencies, possibly slowing their response.
A state study found that many of the 1,300 emergency operations
buildings were constructed before strict quake building standards
were enacted in 1986, and that only a portion of those had
been retrofitted.
At the LAPD, the only four facilities to meet the most recent
and rigorous "essential building" standards are the
department's newest: the West Valley and Mission police stations
and two 911 dispatch centers.
Yvette Sanchez-Owens, head of the department's facilities
management office, said she is most concerned about three stations
built in the 1960s: Rampart, Hollenbeck and Harbor. Police
officers at the Harbor station in San Pedro have been relocated
to trailers while a new station is built; officers could be
moved out of the Hollenbeck station in Boyle Heights sometime
this fall as preparation for construction of a new station
begins.
As for Parker Center, it already sustained significant damage
during the Northridge earthquake. It is also scheduled to be
replaced, but not for several years.
"It could be in real trouble," Sanchez-Owens said. "It's
definitely not built up to standard." |
SAN ANTONIO, Texas - A Mexican army convoy
of nearly 200 people crossed the border into the United States
on Thursday to bring aid to victims of Hurricane Katrina, becoming the
first Mexican military unit to operate on U.S. soil since 1846.
Mexico's first disaster aid mission to the United States
was greeted in San Antonio by honking car horns, welcome
signs and cheering people wrapped in or waving Mexican flags.
"San Antonio is probably the most Mexican city in the
entire United States," councilman Richard Perez said.
Of the city's 1.2 million residents, roughly 500,000 identify
themselves as being of Mexican descent, according to the U.S.
Census.
Earlier, dignitaries from both Mexico and the United States
greeted the soldiers at the Laredo border crossing.
The unarmed soldiers, physicians, nurses and dentists aboard
the convoy wore green uniforms with yellow armbands that said "Humanitarian
Aid" in Spanish.
Daniel Hernandez Joseph, the Mexican consul in Laredo, said
the cooperation was understandable since the United States
has helped Mexico following natural disasters, including the
Mexico City's earthquake in 1985.
"We know what it is like to be on the other side of this,
because of that we are saying thank you by responding in kind," he
said.
The convoy includes two mobile kitchens that can feed 7,000
people a day, three flatbed trucks carrying mobile water treatment
plants and 15 trailers of bottled water, blankets and applesauce.
After the convoy entered the former Kelly Air Force base,
soldiers began setting up the kitchen to feed about 500 people
Thursday night.
The Mexican government already was planning
another 12-vehicle aid convoy for this week. It has sent a
Mexican navy ship toward the Mississippi coast with rescue
vehicles and helicopters.
Mexico has sent disaster relief aid missions to other Latin
American nations, but not to the United States.
In 1846, Mexican troops briefly advanced just north of the
Rio Grande in Texas, which had then recently joined the United
States. Mexico, however, did not then recognize the Rio Grande
as the U.S. border.
The two countries quickly became mired in the Mexican-American
War, which led to the loss of half of Mexico's territory in
1848. |
GULFPORT, United States - US Vice President
Dick Cheney was confronted by an irate heckler when he toured
the US Gulf coast region devastated by Hurricane Katrina.
Cheney, who was sent to the region by President George W.
Bush amid intense criticism of the federal response to the
disaster, was briefing reporters in Gulfport, Mississippi,
on his impressions of the relief work when he was interrupted
by a bystander.
"Go f--- yourself Mr. Cheney!"
the unidentified man shouted. The man then repeated:
"Go f--- yourself!"
Asked by a reporter if had encountered similar protests during
his tour, Cheney replied: "That's the first time I've
heard it."
Returning to the issue at hand, Cheney said the hurricane
relief and recovery effort had made "significant"
progress over the past week.
"I think the performance in general, at least, in terms
of the information I have received from the locals is definitely
very impressive," he said.
Cheney visited the region with Homeland Security Secretary
Michael Chertoff, who has been one of the principal targets
of anger over the sluggish reaction of federal disaster agencies
as the extent of the catastrophic destruction wrought by Katrina
first became apparent.
"I'm here to help Mike and do everything I can to avoid
interference back in Washington if help's needed with related
agencies," Cheney said.
"I have enormous confidence in the secretary as does
the president," he added.
Later on in his tour, as he watched army engineers working
to block one of the breaches in the system of flood-prevention
levees around New Orleans, Cheney insisted that the city would
emerge from the devastation stronger than ever.
"If there is a place on the face of the earth to have
the resources to deal with this problem, it is the United States," he
said.
Cheney, Chertoff and Attorney General Alberto Gonzales later
accompanied Louisiana Governor Kathleen Blanco to the state's
emergency operations center in Baton Rouge for talks with state
and federal officials coordinating disaster aid.
The vice president said he would return to the affected region
on Saturday. |
DETROIT, United States - Even before Hurricane
Katrina tore through the southern United States, hampering
a big chunk of the US oil industry, consumers were having second
thoughts about gas-guzzling sport utility vehicles.
Katrina could now hasten the demise of the SUV, at least
in its current guise, after years in which it has ruled the
roost over the world's biggest auto market, analysts believe.
With gasoline prices surpassing three dollars a gallon (3.78
liters), it now costs 100 dollars to fill up the tanks of large
SUVs such as the Chevrolet Suburban used by President George
W. Bush's Secret Service escort.
"Potentially, Katrina could signal the death knell of
the SUV in as much as consumers are going to find themselves
once burned, twice shy to buy such vehicles,"
Wachovia economist Jason Schenker said.
"High gas prices and the perceived fragility of the US
energy sector are all likely to weigh on consumers' choices
for years," he said.
Sales of big SUVs dropped dramatically in
August, hurting both American and Japanese manufacturers, which
have been trying to edge into the segment over the past five
years.
The decrease came despite a fierce price war
among the Detroit Big Three -- General Motors, Ford and Chrysler
-- which have offered customers the same price on autos that
their own employees pay.
"Hurricane Katrina was definitely a catalyst for gas
prices but even before that we were facing an upward trend
in prices," said Mike Chung, market analyst at auto website
Edmunds.com.
"In response to that, consumers were beginning to look
at other vehicles outside of large SUVs. The SUV boom has definitely
changed. The whole segment has thinned out into several different
segments," he said.
GM reported that despite its elite credentials,
the Chevrolet Suburban saw sales drop 28 percent during August.
Ford said sales of the full-size Ford Expedition plunged 40
percent.
Toyota Motor said sales of its heavily
promoted Sequoia dropped 32 percent in August. Nissan
reported sales of the Armada, which is built in a portion
of Mississippi spared by Hurricane Katrina, fell seven percent.
Reviewing the August sales figures, analysts at Merrill Lynch
said that Katrina could accelerate "consumers' natural
migration away from large SUVs".
The big auto makers can see the writing on
the wall. Ford plans to halt production of the giant Ford Excursion
at the end of September.
"There is no question that the demand for traditional
sport utility vehicles has been affected by rising gas prices," Steve
Lyons, group vice president in charge of Ford sales and marketing
in North America, said recently. [...] |
Some people have referred to it as the "secret
government" of the United States. It is not an elected
body, it does not involve itself in public disclosures, and
it even has a quasi-secret budget in the billions of dollars.
[...]
Not only is it the most powerful
entity in the United States, but it was not even created
under Constitutional law by the Congress. It was a product
of a Presidential Executive Order. No, it is not
the U.S. military nor the Central Intelligence Agency,
they are subject to Congress.
The organization is called FEMA, which stands for the Federal
Emergency Management Agency. Originally conceived in the Richard
Nixon Administration, it was refined by President Jimmy Carter
and given teeth in the Ronald Reagan and George Bush Administrations.
FEMA had one original concept when it was created, to assure
the survivability of the United States government in the event
of a nuclear attack on this nation. It was also provided with
the task of being a federal coordinating body during times
of domestic disasters, such as earthquakes, floods and hurricanes.
Its awesome powers grow under the tutelage of people like Lt.
Col. Oliver North and General Richard Secord, the architects
on the Iran-Contra scandal and the looting of America's savings
and loan institutions. FEMA has even been given control of
the State Defense Forces, a rag-tag, often considered neo-Nazi,
civilian army that will substitute for the National Guard,
if the Guard is called to duty overseas.
The Most Powerful Organization In The United States
Though it may be the most powerful organization in the United
States, few people know it even exists. But it has crept into
our private lives. Even mortgage papers contain FEMA's name
in small print if the property in question is near a flood
plain. [...]
FEMA was created in a series of Executive Orders. A Presidential
Executive Order, whether Constitutional or not, becomes law
simply by its publication in the Federal Registry. Congress
is by-passed. Executive Order Number 12148 created the Federal
Emergency Management Agency that is to interface with the Department
of Defense for civil defense planning and funding. An "emergency
czar" was appointed. FEMA has only spent about 6 percent
of its budget on national emergencies, the bulk of their funding
has been used for the construction of secret underground facilities
to assure continuity of government in case of a major emergency,
foreign or domestic. Executive Order Number 12656 appointed
the National Security Council as the principal body that should
consider emergency powers. This allows the government to increase
domestic intelligence and surveillance of U.S. citizens and
would restrict the freedom of movement within the United States
and grant the government the right to isolate large groups
of civilians. The National Guard could be federalized to seal
all borders and take control of U.S. air space and all ports
of entry.
Here are just a few Executive Orders associated with FEMA
that would suspend the Constitution and the Bill of Rights. These
Executive Orders have been on record for nearly 30 years and
could be enacted by the stroke of a Presidential pen:
* EXECUTIVE ORDER 10990 allows the government to take over
all modes of transportation and control of highways and seaports.
* EXECUTIVE ORDER 10995 allows the government to seize and
control the communication media.
* EXECUTIVE ORDER 10997 allows the government to take over
all electrical power, gas, petroleum, fuels and minerals.
* EXECUTIVE ORDER 10998 allows the government to take over
all food resources and farms.
* EXECUTIVE ORDER 11000 allows the government to mobilize
civilians into work brigades under government supervision.
* EXECUTIVE ORDER 11001 allows the government to take over
all health, education and welfare functions.
* EXECUTIVE ORDER 11002 designates the Postmaster General
to operate a national registration of all persons.
* EXECUTIVE ORDER 11003 allows the government to take over
all airports and aircraft, including commercial aircraft.
* EXECUTIVE ORDER 11004 allows the Housing and Finance Authority
to relocate communities, build new housing with public funds,
designate areas to be abandoned, and establish new locations
for populations.
* EXECUTIVE ORDER 11005 allows the government to take over
railroads, inland waterways and public storage facilities.
* EXECUTIVE ORDER 11051 specifies the responsibility of the
Office of Emergency Planning and gives authorization to put
all Executive Orders into effect in times of increased international
tensions and economic or financial crisis.
* EXECUTIVE ORDER 11310 grants authority to the Department
of Justice to enforce the plans set out in Executive Orders,
to institute industrial support, to establish judicial and
legislative liaison, to control all aliens, to operate penal
and correctional institutions, and to advise and assist the
President.
* EXECUTIVE ORDER 11049 assigns emergency preparedness function
to federal departments and agencies, consolidating 21 operative
Executive Orders issued over a fifteen year period.
* EXECUTIVE ORDER 11921 allows the Federal Emergency Preparedness
Agency to develop plans to establish control over the mechanisms
of production and distribution, of energy sources, wages, salaries,
credit and the flow of money in U.S. financial institution
in any undefined national emergency. It
also provides that when a state of emergency is declared by
the President, Congress cannot review the action for six months.
The Federal Emergency Management Agency has broad powers in
every aspect of the nation. General Frank Salzedo, chief of
FEMA's Civil Security Division stated in a 1983 conference
that he saw FEMA's role as a "new frontier in the protection
of individual and governmental leaders from assassination,
and of civil and military installations from sabotage and/or
attack, as well as prevention of dissident groups from gaining
access to U.S. opinion, or a global audience in times of crisis."
FEMA's powers were consolidated by President Carter to incorporate:
* the National Security Act of 1947, which allows for the
strategic relocation of industries, services, government and
other essential economic activities, and to rationalize the
requirements for manpower, resources and production facilities;
* the 1950 Defense Production Act, which gives the President
sweeping powers over all aspects of the economy;
* the Act of August 29, 1916, which authorizes the Secretary
of the Army, in time of war, to take possession of any transportation
system for transporting troops, material, or any other purpose
related to the emergency; and
* the International Emergency Economic
Powers Act, which enables the President to seize the property
of a foreign country or national.
These powers were transferred to FEMA in a sweeping consolidation
in 1979.
Hurricane Andrew Focused Attention On FEMA
FEMA's deceptive role really did not come to light with much
of the public until Hurricane Andrew smashed into the U.S.
mainland. As Russell R. Dynes, director of the Disaster Research
Center of the University of Delaware, wrote in The World and
I, "...The eye of the political storm hovered over the
Federal Emergency Management Agency. FEMA became a convenient
target for criticism." Because FEMA was accused of dropping
the ball in Florida, the media and Congress commenced to study
this agency. What came out of the critical look was that FEMA
was spending 12 times more for "black operations" than
for disaster relief. It spent $1.3 billion
building secret bunkers throughout the United States in anticipation
of government disruption by foreign or domestic upheaval. Yet
fewer than 20 members of Congress , only members with top security
clearance, know of the $1.3 billion expenditure by FEMA for
non-natural disaster situations. These few Congressional
leaders state that FEMA has a "black curtain"
around its operations. FEMA has worked on National Security
programs since 1979, and its predecessor, the Federal Emergency
Preparedness Agency, has secretly spent millions of dollars
before being merged into FEMA by President Carter in 1979.
FEMA has developed 300 sophisticated mobile units that are
capable of sustaining themselves for a month. The vehicles
are located in five areas of the United States. They have tremendous
communication systems and each contains a generator that would
provide power to 120 homes each, but have never been used for
disaster relief.
FEMA's enormous powers can be triggered easily. In any form
of domestic or foreign problem, perceived and not always actual,
emergency powers can be enacted. The
President of the United States now has broader powers to declare
martial law, which activates FEMA's extraordinary powers. Martial
law can be declared during time of increased tension overseas,
economic problems within the United States, such as a depression,
civil unrest, such as demonstrations or scenes like the Los
Angeles riots, and in a drug crisis. These Presidential
powers have increased with successive Crime Bills, particularly
the 1991 and 1993 Crime Bills, which increase the power to
suspend the rights guaranteed under the Constitution and to
seize property of those suspected of being drug dealers, to
individuals who participate in a public protest or demonstration.
Under emergency plans already in existence, the power exists
to suspend the Constitution and turn over the reigns of government
to FEMA and appointing military commanders to run state and
local governments. FEMA then would have the right to order
the detention of anyone whom there is reasonable ground to
believe...will engage in, or probably conspire with others
to engage in acts of espionage or sabotage. The
plan also authorized the establishment of concentration camps
for detaining the accused, but no trial.
Three times since 1984, FEMA stood on the threshold of taking
control of the nation. Once under President Reagan in 1984,
and twice under President Bush in 1990 and 1992. But under
those three scenarios, there was not a sufficient crisis to
warrant risking martial law. Most experts on the subject of
FEMA and Martial Law insisted that a crisis has to appear dangerous
enough for the people of the United States before they would
tolerate or accept complete government takeover. The typical
crisis needed would be threat of imminent nuclear war, rioting
in several U.S. cities simultaneously, a series of national
disasters that affect widespread danger to the populous, massive
terrorist attacks, a depression in which
tens of millions are unemployed and without financial resources,
or a major environmental disaster. [...]
On July 5, 1987, the Miami Herald published reports on FEMA's
new goals. The goal was to suspend the Constitution in the
event of a national crisis, such as nuclear war, violent and
widespread internal dissent, or national opposition to a U.S.
military invasion abroad. Lt. Col. North was the architect.
National Security Directive Number 52 issued in August 1982,
pertains to the "Use of National Guard Troops to Quell
Disturbances."
The crux of the problem is that FEMA has the power to turn
the United States into a police state in time of a real crisis
or a manufactured crisis. Lt. Col. North virtually established
the apparatus for dictatorship. Only the criticism of the Attorney
General prevented the plans from being adopted. But
intelligence reports indicate that FEMA has a folder with 22
Executive Orders for the President to sign in case of an emergency.
It is believed those Executive Orders contain the framework
of North's concepts, delayed by criticism but never truly abandoned. [...]
The first targets in any FEMA emergency would be Hispanics
and Blacks, the FEMA orders call for them to be rounded up
and detained. Tax protesters, demonstrators against government
military intervention outside U.S. borders, and people who
maintain weapons in their homes are also targets. Operation
Trojan Horse is a program designed to learn the identity of
potential opponents to martial law. The program lures potential
protesters into public forums, conducted by a "hero"
of the people who advocates survival training. The list of
names gathered at such meetings and rallies are computerized
and then targeted in case of an emergency.
The most shining example of America to the world has been
its peaceful transition of government from one administration
to another. Despite crises of great magnitude, the United States
has maintained its freedom and liberty. This nation now stands
on the threshold of rule by non-elected people asserting non-Constitutional
powers. Even Congress cannot review a Martial Law action until
six months after it has been declared. For the first time in
American history, the reigns of government would not be transferred
from one elected element to another, but the Constitution,
itself, can be suspended.
The scenarios established to trigger
FEMA into action are generally found in the society today,
economic collapse, civil unrest, drug problems, terrorist
attacks, and protests against American intervention in a
foreign country. All these premises exist, it could
only be a matter of time in which one of these triggers the
entire emergency necessary to bring FEMA into action, and
then it may be too late, because under the FEMA plan, there
is no contingency by which Constitutional power is restored.
Written by Harry V. Martin with research assistance from
David Caul |
New Orleans - Heavily armed paramilitary
mercenaries from the Blackwater private security firm, infamous
for their work in Iraq, are openly patrolling the streets of
New Orleans. Some of the mercenaries say they have been "deputized" by
the Louisiana governor; indeed some are wearing gold Louisiana
state law enforcement badges on their chests and Blackwater
photo identification cards on their arms. They say they are
on contract with the Department of Homeland Security and have
been given the authority to use lethal force. Several mercenaries
we spoke with said they had served in Iraq on the personal
security details of the former head of the US occupation, L.
Paul Bremer and the former US ambassador to Iraq, John Negroponte.
"This is a totally new thing to have guys like us
working CONUS (Continental United States),"
a heavily armed Blackwater mercenary told us as we stood
on Bourbon Street in the French Quarter. "We're much
better equipped to deal with the situation in Iraq."
Blackwater mercenaries are some of the most feared professional
killers in the world and they are accustomed to operating without
worry of legal consequences. Their presence on the streets
of New Orleans should be a cause for serious concern for the
remaining residents of the city and raises alarming questions
about why the government would allow men trained to kill with
impunity in places like Iraq and Afghanistan to operate here. Some
of the men now patrolling the streets of New Orleans returned
from Iraq as recently as 2 weeks ago.
What is most disturbing is the claim of several Blackwater
mercenaries we spoke with that they are here under contract
from the federal and Louisiana state governments.
Blackwater is one of the leading private "security"
firms servicing the occupations of Iraq and Afghanistan. It
has several US government contracts and has provided security
for many senior US diplomats, foreign dignitaries and corporations.
The company rose to international prominence after 4 of its
men were killed in Fallujah and two of their charred bodies
were hung from a bridge in March 2004. Those
killings sparked the massive US retaliation against the civilian
population of Fallujah that resulted in scores of deaths
and tens of thousands of refugees.
As the threat of forced evictions now looms in New Orleans
and the city confiscates even legally registered weapons from
civilians, the private mercenaries of Blackwater patrol the
streets openly wielding M-16s and other assault weapons. This
despite Police Commissioner Eddie Compass' claim that "Only
law enforcement are allowed to have weapons."
Officially, Blackwater says its forces
are in New Orleans to "join the Hurricane Relief Effort." A
statement on the company's website, dated September 1, advertises
airlift services, security services and crowd control. The
company, according to news reports, has since begun taking
private contracts to guard hotels, businesses and other properties.
But what has not been publicly acknowledged is the claim,
made to us by 2 Blackwater mercenaries, that they are actually
engaged in general law enforcement activities including "securing
neighborhoods" and "confronting criminals."
That raises a key question: under what authority are Blackwater's
men operating? A spokesperson for the Homeland Security Department,
Russ Knocke, told the Washington Post he knows of no federal
plans to hire Blackwater or other private security. "We
believe we've got the right mix of personnel in law enforcement
for the federal government to meet the demands of public safety."
he said.
But in an hour-long conversation with several Blackwater
mercenaries, we heard a different story. The
men we spoke with said they are indeed on contract with the
Department of Homeland Security and the Louisiana governor's
office and that some of them are sleeping in camps organized
by Homeland Security in New Orleans and Baton Rouge. One of
them wore a gold Louisiana state law enforcement badge and
said he had been "deputized"
by the governor. They told us they not only had authority
to make arrests but also to use lethal force. We encountered
the Blackwater forces as we walked through the streets of
the largely deserted French Quarter. We
were talking with 2 New York Police officers when an unmarked
car without license plates sped up next to us and stopped.
Inside were 3 men, dressed in khaki uniforms, flak jackets
and wielding automatic weapons. "Y'all know where the
Blackwater guys are?" they asked. One of the police
officers responded, "There are a bunch of them around
here,"
and pointed down the road.
"Blackwater?" we asked.
"The guys who are in Iraq?"
"Yeah," said the officer.
"They're all over the place."
A short while later, as we continued down Bourbon Street,
we ran into the men from the car. They wore Blackwater ID badges
on their arms.
"When they told me New Orleans,
I said, 'What country is that in?,'" said one of the
Blackwater men. He was wearing his company ID around
his neck in a carrying case with the phrase "Operation
Iraqi Freedom" printed on it. After bragging about how
he drives around Iraq in a "State Department issued
level 5, explosion proof BMW," he said he was "just
trying to get back to Kirkuk (in the north of Iraq) where
the real action is." Later we
overheard him on his cell phone complaining that Blackwater
was only paying $350 a day plus per diem. That is much less
than the men make serving in more dangerous conditions in
Iraq. Two men we spoke with said they plan on returning
to Iraq in October. But, as one mercenary said, they've been
told they could be in New Orleans for up to 6 months. "This
is a trend," he told us. "You're going to see a
lot more guys like us in these situations."
If Blackwater's reputation and record in Iraq are any indication
of the kind of "services" the company offers, the
people of New Orleans have much to fear.
Jeremy Scahill, a correspondent for the national radio
and TV program Democracy Now!, and Daniela Crespo are in
New Orleans. Visit www.democracynow.org for in-depth, independent,
investigative reporting on Hurricane Katrina. Email: jeremy@democracynow.org. |
NEW YORK - Former New York mayor Rudy
Giuliani said an inquiry like that which probed the September
11 attacks may need to investigate the slow official response
to Hurricane Katrina.
But Giuliani, who was widely hailed for his handling of
the attack on New York's World Trade Center, quickly added
that any probe should be deferred until after rescue and
recovery operations end.
"Plenty of people have had their opportunity to explain
what they think went wrong. People responding are in the middle
of it and they need all the help we can get," the former
New York Mayor told NBC's
"Today Show" on the fourth anniversary of the September
11 attacks that killed nearly 3,000 people.
"We're going to learn alot from Katrina ... That'll be
the key thing that comes out of this, which is maybe we'll
figure out how to respond to these things better,"
Giuliani said.
He added that unlike the current barrage of criticism of the
federal government, the public and politicians, for the most
part, held their fire after 9/11.
"The criticisms came later and many of them were correct
ones, many of the things that were done right on September
11, things that were done wrong, and the September 11 Commission
...gave us a very, very interesting and helpful critique. That's
what we should do here,"
Giuliani said. |
The Nation -- Finally, we have
discovered the roots of George W. Bush's "compassionate
conservatism."
On the heels of the president's "What, me worry?"
response to the death, destruction and dislocation that followed
upon Hurricane Katrina comes the news of his mother's Labor
Day visit with hurricane evacuees at the Astrodome in Houston.
Commenting on the facilities that have been set up for the evacuees
-- cots crammed side-by-side in a huge stadium where the lights
never go out and the sound of sobbing children never completely
ceases -- former First Lady Barbara Bush concluded that the poor
people of New Orleans had lucked out.
"Everyone is so overwhelmed by the hospitality. And
so many of the people in the arena here, you know, were underprivileged
anyway, so this, this is working very well for them,"
Mrs. Bush told American Public Media's "Marketplace"
program, before returning to her multi-million dollar Houston
home.
On the tape of the interview, Mrs. Bush chuckles
audibly as she observes just how great things are going for families
that are separated from loved ones, people who have been forced
to abandon their homes and the only community where they have
ever lived, and parents who are explaining to children that their
pets, their toys and in some cases their friends may be lost
forever. Perhaps the former first lady was amusing herself with
the notion that evacuees without bread could eat cake.
At the very least, she was expressing a measure of empathy commensurate
with that evidenced by her son during his fly-ins for disaster-zone
photo opportunities.
On Friday, when even Republican lawmakers were giving the federal
government an "F" for its response to the crisis, President
Bush heaped praise on embattled Federal Emergency Management
Agency chief Michael Brown. As thousands of victims of the hurricane
continued to plead for food, water, shelter, medical care and
a way out of the nightmare to which federal neglect had consigned
them, Brown cheerily announced that "people are getting
the help they need."
Barbara Bush's son put his arm around the addled FEMA functionary
and declared, "Brownie, you're doing a heck of a job."
Like mother, like son.
Even when a hurricane hits, the apple does not fall far from
the tree. |
The last couple of weeks we’ve
been learning some truly awful, unbearable lessons. But one of
the lessons has been perversely prosaic: PR only goes so far.
Not only have we been parsing anew the limits of public relations,
but the limits of people who have become perilously, mindlessly
dependent on PR in place of action. Their leadership limits,
their moral limits.
When George Bush made his first, belated stop in New Orleans,
touching down at the city’s airport, he actually viewed
his visit as an appropriate occasion for a little light comedy.
Here’s the official White House transcript: “I
believe that the great city of New Orleans will rise again
and be a greater city of New Orleans. (Applause.) I believe
the town where I used to come, from Houston, Texas, to enjoy
myself -- occasionally too much (Laughter.) -- will be that
very same town, that it will be a better place to come to.
That’s what I believe. I believe the great state of Louisiana
will get its feet back and become a vital contributor to the
country.”
It was, of course, just the latest highlight in his career as
chief marketing officer for the Rove/Cheney/Rumsfeld neo-con
agenda. It’s a job that entails always sticking to a breezy,
upbeat storyline.
It’s no surprise that Bush took this PR-trumps-action
tack for Katrina. For much of his five years in office, he’s
seen that putting a faux-cheerful, faux-hopeful spin on even
the worst calamities (see also: the war in Iraq) meant that a
cheerful, hopeful spin would automatically float to the top of
the memepool, at least momentarily. If he kept repeating these
faux-cheerful, faux-hopeful things ad nauseum, he’d have
a great shot of at least partially obscuring all the actual rotting
nastiness lurking below the surface.
Of course, the problem post-Katrina is
that, unlike Iraq -- where journalists are no longer in the
thick of things (with most abandoning the idea of embedded
reporting) -- New Orleans had real journalists showing us the
reality behind the rhetoric. And enough of them were
sufficiently appalled at the government inaction that they
basically ended up begging the feds, on the air, to come to
the rescue. (Of course, that didn’t stop FEMA from issuing
an absurd directive last week that journalists avoid showing
dead bodies during the recovery process. Anybody who’d
seen Oprah Winfrey’s Sept. 6 show, which offered devastating
close-ups of victims’
bodies being left to rot, will feel outrage at the agency’s
hapless, belated attempt at covering up just how murderous its
glacial response was.)
On the very day the levees were about to give way in New Orleans,
the buzz in medialand was about a Miami Herald article linked
on Jim Romenesko’s media site. Romenesko summed it up thusly: “Is
journalism in danger of losing its young idealists to PR? Edward
Wasserman says young people want to do something ‘active’
-- to make things happen instead of reacting to events the way
they do in newsrooms. ‘Students come back from summer PR
internships with exciting tales of scanning the next day’s
papers for stories they helped bring about,’ he wrote."
That’s where our heads have been
in this country, and that’s where the president’s
head is: PR is considered action, while actual action is an
afterthought. Which is why Bush was able to publicly
say to FEMA Director Michael Brown, with a straight face, “Brownie,
you’re doing a heck of a job.” Whereas Bush & Co.
have mostly been able to explain away troop shortages and strategic
errors in Iraq (by simply denying shortages and errors), the
troop shortages in New Orleans -- and the calamitous lack of
federal strategy and response -- could not be dismissed by
the president’s cheerful quips.
Still, all he knew to do was keep up the PR talk, as if leadership
were made up solely of spin as opposed to, say, actually leading.
And so he continued with the PR-ification of life post-Katrina,
uttering this gem from Mobile, Ala.: “Out
of the rubbles (sic) of Trent Lott’s house -- he’s
lost his entire house -- there’s going to be a fantastic
house. And I’m looking forward to sitting on the porch.”
Sure, as Nicholas D. Kristof noted in The New York Times, the
deeper scandals are New Orleans’ grinding poverty, and
the fact that nationally “the number of poor people has
now risen 17% under Mr. Bush,” after having declined sharply
under Clinton Administration.
But from the Bush P.O.V., there’s a simple solution for
that hateful reality: Sell ‘em something else. Here’s
the pitch: close your eyes and imagine Lott, in an SUV, driving
to the nearest Home Depot to pick up some TimberTech all-weather
composite decking. It’ll be grey. With white railings.
That’d be nice, wouldn’t it? Wouldn’t you,
too, like to sit on a porch like that? |
NEW ORLEANS, United States - President
George W. Bush went into storm-wrecked New Orleans for the
first time, as the heavily-criticised head of the federal agency
overseeing disaster relief quit.
Two weeks after Hurricane Katrina turned the city into a
festering swamp, the gruesome job of recovering bodies gathered
pace and the confirmed death toll rose above 500.
Seeking to counter criticism of his handling
of the disaster, Bush toured parts of the flooded city in the
back of a military truck and from the air in a helicopter.
Bush had previously flown over New Orleans but not seen the
devastation from the ground. He later went to a suburb that
was badly hit by the August 29 storm and to visit Gulfport
in Mississippi.
The mounting criticism has seen Bush's approval ratings slump
to their worst levels since he took office in January 2001.
And yielding to intense pressure over criticism of the Federal
Emergency Management Agency's slow response to Katrina, agency
chief Michael Brown quit, US media reported.
Bush appeared not to know about the resignation. "I can't
comment on something that you may know more about than I do," he
told reporters while visiting the disaster zone.
But critics were delighted.
"Michael Brown's departure from FEMA
is long overdue, and his resignation is the right thing for
the country and for the people of the Gulf Coast states," said
Nancy Pelosi, the Democratic leader in the Senate.
Brown had been called back to Washington on Friday and replaced
as the pointman on the ground by Coast Guard Vice Admiral Thad
Allen. Bush had stood up for under-fire Brown in the immediate
aftermath of the disaster telling him: "Brownie, you're
doing a heck of a job."
But it was Brown's replacement who on Monday briefed Bush
and local and military officials about efforts to find temporary
housing for survivors.
Bush has refused to identify any specific failures in Washington's
response to Katrina but flatly dismissed critics who have noted
that most of those unable to flee the city were black.
"The storm didn't discriminate, and neither will the
recovery effort," he said, also rejecting reported comments
by National Guard Lieutenant General Steven Blum that a day
of response time was "arguably"
lost due to deployments in Iraq.
"It is preposterous to claim that the engagement in Iraq
meant there wasn't enough troops here. It's pure and simple," he
added. "We've got plenty of troops to do both."
On the ground, more pumps came online and other signs emerged
of attempts to bring life back to New Orleans.
Passes to cross a security cordon around the city were to
be issued to help small businesses hoping to reopen.
Owners of small shops, restaurants, hotels, gasoline stations
and supermarkets were to be allowed to visit their properties
to assess damage, said Louisiana state police spokesman Johnnie
Brown.
The city Louis Armstrong International Airport, which has
handled only humanitarian and military flights since Katrina
struck, was gearing up to reopen to commercial flights on Tuesday.
Despite the progress, the city's infrastructure
is wrecked, and reconstruction will take many years and cost
billions of dollars.
Many districts, especially in east New Orleans, remain under
deep brown floodwaters up to two metres (six-feet) deep and
covered with a floating sludge of trash and debris.
Teams fished out bloated corpses from the stinking, trash-strewn
mess, and urged residents who have not done so to leave for
safe shelter, although they were not using force to apply an
order to quit town.
In dry streets, skeletal dogs roamed for food, sometimes gnawing
at the carcasses of dead pets. An animal
rescue official said she had seen dogs eating human cadavers
on one highway exit ramp.
The confirmed death toll was certain to rise, although officials
have said they are confident that it will be less than the
10,000 dead estimated last week for New Orleans alone.
But the number of evacuees forced to seek refuge in homeless
shelters was down significantly, the Department of
Homeland Security said, with the number of people displaced
by Katrina now 141,000, down from 208,000.
To help the effort, Louisiana, Mississippi
and Alabama were crafting a multi-billion-dollar economic recovery
bill aimed at luring business back to the disaster zone, including
tax incentives and a huge bond issue, a Louisiana official
said.
A fresh storm -- this time poised off the US east coast --
continued to worry weather-watchers.
With winds receding on Monday morning, Ophelia was downgraded
from a hurricane to a tropical storm. But
the center said the storm could pick up force on Tuesday and
become a category one hurricane again. |
NEW ORLEANS - The bodies of more than
40 mostly elderly patients were found in a flooded-out hospital
in the biggest known cluster of corpses to be discovered so
far in hurricane-ravaged New Orleans.
The exact circumstances under which they died were unclear,
with at least one hospital official saying Monday that some
of the patients had died before the storm, while the others
succumbed to causes unrelated to Katrina.
The announcement, which could raise Louisiana's death toll
to nearly 280, came as President Bush got his first up-close
look at the destruction, and business owners were let back
in to assess the damage and begin the slow process of starting
over.
Meanwhile, encouraging signs of recovery were all around:
Nearly two-thirds of southeastern Louisiana's water treatment
plants were up and running. Louis Armstrong New Orleans International
Airport planned to open to limited passenger service Tuesday.
A plane carrying equipment to rebuild the city's mobile phone
networks took off from Sweden. And 41 of 174 permanent pumps
were in operation, on pace to help drain this still half-flooded
city by Oct. 8.
In Washington, Federal Emergency Management
Agency director Mike Brown announced he was resigning "in
the best interest of the agency and
best interest of the president." Brown
has been vilified for the government's slow and unfocused
response to a disaster that is already being called the nation's
costliest hurricane ever.
The bodies were found Sunday at the 317-bed Memorial Medical
Center, but the exact number was unclear. Bob Johannesen, a
spokesman for the state Department of Health and Hospitals,
said 45 patients had been found; hospital assistant administrator
David Goodson said there were 44, plus three on the grounds.
Also unclear was exactly how the patients
died.
Goodson said patients died while waiting to be evacuated over
the four days after the hurricane hit, as temperatures inside
the hospital reached 106 degrees. "I
would suggest that that had a lot to do with"
the deaths, he said of the heat.
Family members and nurses were "literally standing over
the patients, fanning them," he said.
Steven Campanini, a spokesman for the hospital's owner, Tenet
Healthcare Corp., said some of the patients were dead in the
hospital's morgue before the storm arrived, and none of the
deaths resulted from lack of food, water or electricity to
power medical equipment. Campanini said many of the patients
were seriously ill before Katrina hit.
Police Chief Eddie Compass declined to answer any questions,
including whether officers received any calls for help from
those inside the hospital after it was evacuated.
Dr. Jeffrey Kochan, a Philadelphia radiologist volunteering
in New Orleans, said he spoke with members of the team that
recovered the bodies from the hospital in the city's Uptown
section. He said they told him they found 36 corpses floating
on the first floor.
"These guys were just venting. They need to talk,"
he said. "They're seeing things no human being should
have to see."
Bush, in his third visit to New Orleans since the storm, made
his first foray to the streets Monday and toured the city for
45 minutes aboard the back of a truck, forcing him at times
to duck to avoid low-hanging electrical wires and branches.
[...]
Insurance experts have doubled to at least $40 billion their
estimate of insured losses caused by Katrina. Risk
Management Solutions Inc. of Newark, Calif., put the total
economic damage at more than $125 billion. [...]
"The really positive thing long-term
is, the core of our infrastructure of the $5 billion to $8
billion tourism industry remained intact," Perry
said. "As odd as it may sound right now, we are optimistic
that this recovery is not only going to happen, its going
to happen well and we're going to have a great city going
again."
The discovery at Memorial Medical Center was not the first
where workers have recovered a group of bodies from a health
care facility.
Saturday, a recovery team found eight bodies inside Bethany
Home, an assisted-living center near City Park. On Monday,
mortuary workers removed human remains from Lafon Nursing Home
of the Holy Family, but authorities
would not disclose the exact number of victims.
One side of the entrance to Lafon was spray-painted with the
date "9-2" and the words "59 live" and "16
dead," while the other side was spray-painted with the
date "9-9"
and the notation "14 dead."
Inside the nursing home, the pale-brown water mark on the
first floor was about 2 1/2 feet up the wall. On the second
floor, spray-paint markings indicated where some bodies had
been found: one under a hallway bulletin board, one in a community
room, two beside an elevator.
Individual rooms were filled with personal belongings - pictures
of friends, personal cards, flowers. In one room was a neatly
folded copy of The Times-Picayune with the headline, "Katrina
Takes Aim." |
Toxic chemicals in the New Orleans flood
waters will make the city unsafe for full human habitation
for a decade, a US government official has told The Independent
on Sunday. And, he added, the Bush administration is covering
up the danger.
In an exclusive interview, Hugh Kaufman, an expert on toxic
waste and responses to environmental disasters at the US
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), said the way the polluted
water was being pumped out was increasing the danger to health.
The pollution was far worse than had been admitted, he said,
because his agency was failing to take enough samples and was
refusing to make public the results of those it had analysed. "Inept
political hacks"
running the clean-up will imperil the health of low-income
migrant workers by getting them to do the work.
His intervention came as President Bush's approval ratings
fell below 40 per cent for the first time. Yesterday, Britain's
Deputy Prime Minister, John Prescott, turned the screw by criticising
the US President's opposition to the Kyoto protocol on global
warming. He compared New Orleans to island nations such as
the Maldives, which are threatened by rising sea levels. Other
US sources spelt out the extent of the danger from one of America's
most polluted industrial areas, known locally as "Cancer
Alley". The 66 chemical plants, refineries and petroleum
storage depots churn out 600m lb of toxic waste each year.
Other dangerous substances are in site storage tanks or at
the port of New Orleans. No one knows how much pollution has
escaped through damaged plants and leaking pipes into the "toxic
gumbo" now drowning the city. Mr Kaufman says no one is
trying to find out.
Few people are better qualified to judge the extent of the
problem. Mr Kaufman, who has been with the EPA since it was
founded 35 years ago, helped to set up its hazardous waste
programme. After serving as chief investigator to the EPA's
ombudsman, he is now senior policy analyst in its Office of
Solid Wastes and Emergency Response. He
said the clean-up needed to be "the most massive public
works exercise ever done", adding: "It will take
10 years to get everything up and running and safe."
Mr Kaufman claimed the Bush administration was playing down
the need for a clean-up: the EPA has not been included in the
core White House group tackling the crisis. "Its budget
has been cut and inept political hacks have been put in key
positions," Mr Kaufman said. "All the money for emergency
response has gone to buy guns and cowboys - which don't do
anything when a hurricane hits. We were less prepared for this
than we would have been on 10 September 2001."
He said the water being pumped out of the
city was not being tested for pollution and would damage Lake
Pontchartrain and the Mississippi river, and endanger people
using it downstream. |
New Orleans
provides us with a reliable template for judging what the Bush
administration will do in the event of a massive "casualty-producing" terrorist
attack. However depressing, this is useful information.
Special military units will be deployed to the affected areas
to patrol the streets in heavily-armored vehicles; conducting
house-to-house searches according to their own discretion.
The cities will be placed under martial law; invoking shoot
to kill orders for anyone either looting or out of doors after
the designated curfew.
Heavily-armed mercenaries and paramilitaries will be used on
various assignments that require secrecy or additional security.
We assume they will be used to protect dignitaries, perform harsh
and illegal interrogations, intimidate dissidents, and subvert
efforts by the media to provide accurate information from the
region.
A massive media campaign will be mounted to create a narrative
of an "involved and compassionate government"
providing security to their people in times of crisis.
Is this a fair description of what is taking place in New Orleans?
There's little doubt that the Bush administration capitalized
on the hurricane to activate its strategy to militarize the city.
There's ample evidence that they had extensive knowledge of the
magnitude of the disaster, and yet, chose to do nothing. In fact,
for more than 3 days they prevented food, water or medicine from
entering the stricken city. Here are just a few of the headlines
that illustrate this point, although there are numerous others:
"FEMA won't accept Amtrak's help in evacuations.''
"FEMA turns away experienced firefighters.''
"FEMA turns back Wal-Mart supply trucks.''
"FEMA prevents Coast Guard from delivering diesel fuel.''
"Homeland Security won't let Red Cross deliver food.''
"FEMA bars morticians from entering New Orleans.''
"FEMA blocks 500-boat citizen flotilla from delivering aid.''
"FEMA fails to utilize Navy ship with 600-bed hospital on
board.''
"FEMA to Chicago: Send just one truck.''
"FEMA turns away generators.''
"FEMA first responders urged not to respond.''
The administration's criminal negligence in the deaths of hundreds
if not thousands of New Orleans occupants is not in doubt, nor
is their predictable response in countering the bad press. Michael
Brown said it best when he noted that he wanted "to convey
a positive image of disaster operations to government officials,
community organizers, and the general public." Brown's "positive
image" of the catastrophe has been left to the usual Bush
media-operatives, who have deftly shifted the national dialogue
away from "criminal negligence" to the more benign-sounding "government
unresponsiveness" or "failure of leadership."
Neither of these have anything to do with the facts as we now
understand them. Many of the people who died in the disaster
were murdered by their government just as surely as if Bush
had personally held their heads under water himself.
Now, the city is a fully-militarized war-zone no different than
Baghdad or Kabul. Already, reports are coming in of doors being
kicked down by armed soldiers and terrified residents being shunted
off to special detention camps in hand cuffs.
We should not expect a different scenario when
America's major cities come under terrorist attack sometime in
the not-to-distant future.
A great deal has been written about the ethnic-cleansing operation
of New Orleans poor and black, that has paved the way for America's
flagship corporations to set up shop in the Big Easy.
What more can I add to the volumes that have been transcribed
about this global project? Americans have
been warned that they would be treated no differently than anyone
else, and that the masters of new world order claim no regional
loyalties. New Orleans merely adds an exclamation point to what
everyone should already know.
It should be instructive to die-hard supporters of the commander-in-chief
that the military deployment was accompanied by orders for all
residents to "surrender all legally-registered firearms" to
the authorities. I can only imagine the fidgeting at the next
NRA meeting when the membership conducts an open forum on the
governments' plan to disarm the nation in the event of a terrorist
attack. I am reminded of George Washington's sage advice:
"A free people ought not only to be armed and disciplined
but they should have sufficient arms and ammunition to maintain
independence from any who might attempt to abuse them, which
would include their own government".
Or, Thomas Jefferson:
"The constitutions of most of our states assert that
all power is inherent in the people. That it is their right
and duty to be at all times, armed."
That, of course, was before the reign of George 2 and the hasty
rescinding of the Bill of Rights. Did gun-lovers really believe
they would be spared Bush's terrible swift sword?
The "disarming" of America is a similar ruse to the
WMD-scare that was used to invade Iraq. The New American Century
is predicated on the belief that only the overlords will have
weapons. A careful comparison of Haiti to Iraq provides an interesting
contrast in the benefits of self-defense.
The deployment of mercenaries to the region
should be of particular concern to Americans. Currently, more
than 40,000 National Guardsman from Louisiana and Mississippi
are serving in Iraq. It would have been quite simple to return
them to their home states to meet the needs of the tragedy. Instead,
the Bush administration chose to use exorbitantly-paid mercenaries.
Why? Is it because pacification on a large scale cannot be accomplished
without a well-paid, elite-corps of corporate-warriors who are
free to carry out orders with complete impunity? Are mercenaries
imperative for neutralizing resistance, or is there another motive;
perhaps, covert or illegal operations directed against American
citizens that require additional secrecy?
In any event, paid killers should never be used on American soil.
New Orleans is looking more and more like a dress rehearsal
for an ambitious cross-country strategy. It is unlikely that
any plan for militarizing the country will evolve at a "snail's
pace" of one city at a time. The administration would have
to take advantage of massive
"casualty-producing" events occurring in many strategically
important cities at the same time. (Coordinated terrorist attacks?)
This would provide the necessary cover for the same scenario
we see presently unfolding in New Orleans.
It's worth thinking about. |
WASHINGTON - President Bush said Tuesday
that "I take responsibility" for failures in dealing
with Hurricane Katrina and said the disaster raised broader
questions about the government's ability to respond to natural
disasters as well as terror attacks.
"Katrina exposed serious problems in our response capability
at all levels of government," Bush said at joint White
House news conference with the president of Iraq.
"To the extent the federal government
didn't fully do its job right, I take responsibility,"
Bush said.
The president was asked whether people should be worried about
the government's ability to handle another terrorist attack
given failures in responding to Katrina.
"Are we capable of dealing with a severe attack? That's
a very important question and it's in the national interest
that we find out what went on so we can better respond," Bush
replied.
He said he wanted to know both what went wrong and what went
right.
As for blunders in the federal response, "I'm not going
to defend the process going in," Bush said. "I am
going to defend the people saving lives."
He praised relief workers at all levels. "I want people
in America to understand how hard people worked to save lives
down there," he said.
Bush spoke after R. David Paulison, the new acting director
of the
Federal Emergency Management Agency, pledged to intensify efforts
to find more permanent housing for the tens of thousands of
Hurricane Katrina survivors now in shelters.
It was the closest Bush has come to publicly finding fault
with any federal officials involved in the hurricane response,
which has been widely criticized as disjointed and slow. Some
federal officials have sought to fault state and local officials
for being unprepared to cope with the disaster.
Bush planned to address the nation Thursday
evening from Louisiana, where he will be monitoring recovery
efforts, the White House announced earlier Tuesday.
Paulison, in his first public comments since taking the job
on Monday, told reporters: "We're going to get those people
out of the shelters, and we're going to move and get them the
help they need."
Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff introduced Paulison
as the Bush administration tried to deflect criticism for the
sluggish initial federal response to the hurricane and its
disastrous aftermath.
Chertoff said that while cleanup, relief and reconstruction
from Katrina is now the government's top priority, the administration
would not let down its guard on other potential dangers.
"The world is not going to stop moving because we are
very focused on Katrina," Chertoff said.
Paulison, named to the post on Monday, said he was busy "getting
brought up to speed."
He replaced Michael Brown, who resigned on Monday, three days
after being removed from being the top onsite federal official
in charge of the government's response.
Paulison said Bush called him Monday night and "thanked
me for coming on board."
Bush promised that he would have "the full support of
the federal government," Paulison said.
Chertoff said the relief operation had entered a new phase.
Initially, he said, the most important priority was evacuating
people, getting them to safety, providing food, water and medical
care.
"And then ultimately at the end of the day, we have to
reconstitute the communities that have been devastated," Chertoff
added.
He said the federal government would look
increasingly to state and local officials for guidance on rebuilding
the devastated communities along the Gulf Coast.
"The federal government can't drive permanent solutions
down the throats of state and local officials,"
Chertoff said. "I don't think anyone should envision a
situation in which they're going to take a back seat. They're
going to take a front seat," he said.
Chertoff said that teams of federal auditors were being dispatched
to the stricken areas to make sure that billions of dollars
worth of government contracts were being properly spent. "We
want to get aid to people who need it quickly, but we also
don't want to lose sight of the importance of preserving the
integrity of the process and our responsibility as stewards
of the public money," Chertoff said.
"We're going to cut through red tape," he said, "but
we're not going to cut through laws and rules that govern ethics."
Meanwhile, Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld said that
some military aircraft and other equipment may be able to move
out of the Gulf Coast soon.
"We've got to the point where most if not all of the
search and rescue is completed," said Rumsfeld, who is
attending a
NATO meeting in Berlin. "Some helicopters can undoubtedly
be moved out over the period ahead."
He also said there is a very large surplus of hospital beds
in the region, so those could also be decreased. The USS Comfort
hospital ship arrived near the Mississippi coast late last
week. Rumsfeld added that nothing will be moved out of the
area without the authorization of the two states' governors,
the military leaders there and the president.
Elsewhere, workers with the Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention aren't finding many sick people, even though the
specter of diseases has alarmed relief and rescue figures.
Instead, between 40 and 50 percent of patients seeking emergency
care have injuries. The CDC has counted 148 injuries in just
the last two days, Carol Rubin, an agency hurricane relief
specialist, said by telephone from the government's new public
health headquarters in New Orleans' Kindred Hospital.
While she couldn't provide a breakdown, Rubin said chain saw
injuries and carbon monoxide exposure from generators are among
them. Those are particularly worrisome because they're likely
to become more common as additional hurricane survivors re-enter
the city in coming days, she said.
The message: Those injuries are preventable, if people take
proper precautions, Rubin stressed. |
WASHINGTON - A spate of bills to cut federal
red tape and otherwise make it easier to get aid to victims
of Hurricane Katrina has hit a slow patch as lawmakers wrestle
over how to shape their response.
Congress zipped through bills providing $62 billion in emergency
aid to hurricane victims but the broader legislative response
is a work in progress.
Included in this second phase are proposals to provide Medicaid
health benefits to those made homeless by Katrina, lift work
rules for welfare recipients, and implement tax changes to
help hurricane victims and charitable donors. More comprehensive
bills are to follow.
Republicans are starting to voice complaints
that Democrats are seeking to seize upon the tragedy to pass
more ambitious legislation than they otherwise could expect
to achieve in the GOP-dominated Congress.
"In some instances, (Democrats are) trying to up the
ante and use this crisis to accomplish goals that maybe they
wouldn't have otherwise been able to accomplish without a natural
disaster,"
Senate Finance Committee Chairman Charles Grassley, R-Iowa,
said. Grassley is at the center of the storm as he negotiates
over taxes, welfare and Medicaid.
For example, a House-passed bill to temporarily ease rules
requiring that welfare recipients work 30 hours a week for
their benefits and extend the welfare program is still pending
before the Senate, despite a big push by Majority Leader Bill
Frist, R-Tenn., to clear it for President Bush's signature.
Democrats are pressing for a more generous approach.
For their part, outgunned House Democrats have settled on
a far-reaching Katrina response plan, including housing vouchers,
increases in unemployment insurance payments and full Medicaid
coverage for hurricane victims.
Grassley has formally introduced a bipartisan tax break plan
costing up to $7 billion that would let hurricane victims tap
their retirement accounts, assist businesses and encourage
charitable donations. A House plan is still taking shape. [...]
On Wednesday, Congress was to begin investigating the government's
readiness and response to Katrina at a Senate
Homeland Security Committee hearing. Committee Chairwoman Susan
Collins, R-Maine, said the inquiry would investigate the sluggish
response at all levels of government.
"It's going to be an in-depth, extensive review,"
Collins said.
Democrats continue to press
for an independent, bipartisan panel modeled after the Sept.
11 Commission and they say congressional
inquiries should not be controlled by Republicans. [...] |
Overlooked in many news reports
about the unfolding storm disaster in the southern United States,
especially in the City of New Orleans, in the aftermath of hurricane
Katrina, is a potentially dramatic pollution issue related to a
toxic landfill that sits under the flood waters right in the
city's downtown, according to map overlays of the flooded area. The
situation could exacerbate the already dire threat to human health
and the environment from the flood waters.
The Agriculture Street Landfill (ASL) is situated on a 95-acre
site in New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana. The ASL is
a federally registered Superfund site, and is on the National
Priorities List of highly contaminated sites requiring cleanup
and containment. A few years ago the site, which sits underneath
and beside houses and a school, was fenced and covered with
clean soil. However, three feet or more of flood waters could
potentially cause the landfill's toxic contents – the
result of decades of municipal and industrial waste dumping – to
leach out.
Houses and buildings that were constructed
in later years directly atop parts of the landfill. Residents
report unusual cancers and health problems and have lobbied for
years to be relocated away from the old contaminated site, which
contains not only municipal garbage, but buried industrial wastes
such as what would be produced by service stations and dry cleaners,
manufacturers or burning. The site was routinely sprayed with
DDT in the 1940s and 50s and, in 1962, 300,000 cubic yards of
excess fill were removed from ASL because of ongoing subsurface
fires. (The site was nicknamed "Dante's Inferno" because
of the fires.)
The ASL can be thought of a sort of Love Canal for New Orleans
-– and now it sits under water.
The ASL site is three miles south of Lake Pontchartrain and
about 2.5 north-northeast of the city's central business district
(roughly halfway between the old French Quarter and the shore
of Lake Pontchartrain).
Disturbingly, the site is also very close to the Industrial
Canal Levee, a section of which collapsed and allowed flood waters
to pour in, almost directly in the direction of the ASL site.
Government reports describe ASL as being "bounded on the
north by Higgins Boulevard and south and west by Southern Railroads
right-of-ways. The eastern boundary of the landfill extends from
the cul-de-sac at the southern end of Clouet Street, near the
railroad tracks to Higgins Boulevard between Press and Montegut
Streets."
Locate that site on a map (see websites
below), and then overlay published maps of New Orleans flooding,
and one finds the old toxic landfill is situated right in the
middle of a huge area of three-foot flooding. That industrial
area is almost continuously connected with water to the downtown
and northern areas of the city. It's not outlandish to consider
the possibility that toxic waste from the landfill may mix
with floodwaters and spread far beyond the old landfill site.
Although the humanitarian rescue operation must take precedence
at the current time, authorities and the public must not overlook
this pollution situation, which in both the near and long-term
may be dangerous to human health and the environment. We must
hope that emergency responders will investigate this site as
soon as possible and take steps to mitigate potential off-site
migration of hazardous materials. It may be that sandbag walls
are required here, as well as on the broken levees.
This magazine will update the situation as more information
becomes available.
Story prepared by Guy Crittenden, editor. Contact 705-445-0361
or gcrittenden@solidwastemag.com (See useful websites below.)
Useful websites:
http://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/HAC/PHA/agriculturestreet/asl_p3.html
This website offers the Appendix to the government Public Health
Assessment and further technical details about the site, plus
a small map at the end.
http://www.umich.edu/~snre492/Jones/agstreet.htm
Environmental Justice Case Study website offers a detailed description
of the Agriculture Street Landfill, and the history of pollution
problems and residents seeking to relocate:
http://www.nbc17.com/hurricanes/4887230/detail.html
NBC-17.com website offers interactive map of New Orleans flooded
areas. (Look near top of blue sidebar at right beside main story
for "Interactive: New Orleans' Damage.")
http://maps.google.com
Google map of New Orleans can be pulled up at this website.
Enter "Higgins Blvd., New Orleans" to get the approximate
location of the landfill, then compare this with the NBC-17 map.
(Note: you can zoom in and out, and toggle around this Google
map, and also hit "satellite"
in the upper right to switch from map view to a satellite view
of the terrain.)
|
At a speech to the Heritage
Foundation yesterday, Laura Bush disclosed more about the White
House's unorthodox information-gathering methods. Speaking about
the good that has come from Katrina's aftermath, she said, "Maybe
the media hasn't shown us that much, but we've read about it
and we do know about it." Of course -- they subscribe to
the same relentlessly optimistic paper -- The Bullshit Express
-- as the Chertoff household. "Gulf Evacuees Say Group Showers
the Least Humilating Experience Yet" was the headline the
day after it told them "New Orleans Dodged the Bullet."
And later, special guest columnist Barbara Bush observed many evacuees "were
underprivileged anyway, so this -- this is working very well for
them." Yes, the Bullshit Express has been a font of stellar
coverage, almost as good as their Alternate Universe Pultizer Prize-winning
series, "Iraq in 2003: Mission Accomplished." |
Peter Berkowitz is a staff
attorney at a Massachusetts prison. He was traveling in New Orleans
with his wife Bruni & son Ernesto when the hurricane hit.
They were there because Ernesto was planning to start his freshman
year at Loyola of New Orleans. What follows is his letter to
his 80-something mother. It was forwarded to the PEACE-LIST at
Syracuse University by Carole Resnick <CaroleRes@msn.com>
on Wednesday, September 14, 2005.
9\5\05
Dear Mom:
This is pretty much what happened to us as far as I can remember
it. Some of it is probably off because we lost track of time
and days and nights blended. I'm still feeling very angry and
sad. Watching the news outrages me. I see "Dr. Phil" opining
on why people didn't evacuate New Orleans. He says they didn't
believe there would be a hurricane, or they didn't want to leave,
etc. Well there was no way to leave. We had no way out. People
with families and no resources had no way out. There were no
buses coming for people, or shelters to take people to. Just
announcements to leave. So naturally, the poorest, sickest, etc.
were left behind. No one, as far as I could see, wanted to be
there or elected to be there. No one really allowed them to get
out!
Anyway, we began hearing hurricane news on the television. By
Saturday, we were hearing insanely frightening news of a direct
category 5 hurricane hit and projections of massive flooding
and deaths of up to 30,000 people. Despite being through several
hurricanes, this seemed worse than imaginable. We were pretty
scared. Bruni and I had tickets out for Sunday, 8\28 at 2 pm
so we weren't worried. I called all the airlines and finally
got Ernesto a ticket to Chicago for 1 pm the next day.
Sunday morning we sent Ernesto back to school to get his things.
I called to check on my reservation and was told the flight was
cancelled. Bruni and I had no way out. Ernesto's flight was never
cancelled, but there were no taxis, buses, etc., or any way to
get to the airport.
So we bought some wine and canned goods and waited out the storm
in the hotel. With all the dire predictions, it was pretty nerve-wracking
to wait. I don't remember the storm too well. The winds picked
up at night and really roared during the day Monday morning.
The electricity went, but we had water. We watched the hurricane
from our room and from the lobby of our hotel. The two restaurants
attached to the hotel made coffee and sandwiches for the guests.
The bar was opened. Everyone cooperated, so it was not nearly
as bad as predicted. Being in the city, the hotel was pretty
well protected by other buildings. It was not nearly as bad (or
impressive) as the hurricanes we passed in Cupey.
So everything was fine and we were just waiting for the next
day to see when the airport would open and when we could get
out. It was quite a relief.
Tuesday morning at about 8 am, the hotel people knocked on our
door to say we were evacuating the hotel immediately for their
sister hotel the Saint Marie. The wanted to get all the guests
together for protection from looters at nighttime, because the
Saint Marie had a generator, and because it was 5 stories high,
and there was lots of talk of floods of up to 20 feet. So we
left for the Saint Marie, two blocks away. When we got there,
we were herded into the ballroom and told to stay there. As I
kept inquiring about our room, I was finally told there were
no rooms, that we could stay in the ballroom if we wanted as
the flood waters poured in, or we could go to the official evacuation
center at the Convention Center. We were effectively kicked out
of the hotel.
So we left with about 15 other guests and walked through the
streets, about 10 blocks to the Convention Center. Water was
clearly coming down the streets from the direction of Lake Ponchartrain,
and the flood news was terrible. At the front door, the workers
there told us to go around to the side. At the side, we were
informed that the Convention Center was not an evacuation center,
and that no one was permitted inside.
There was no one else there except for our group. Our concern
at the moment was not to be caught up in the flood. Behind the
Convention Center ran the "Riverwalk", a Mall and outside
walkway along the Mississippi. Right on the side of the Convention
Center was an escalator that ran up to a maybe 100 foot long
covered walkway that led into the Mall. The walkway was about
thirty feet high. We decided that it was the best place for now
to ride out the flood.
So we all went up and put down our bags. Ernesto and I walked
to the mall entrance, but the doors were locked. We thought maybe
moving into the mall might be better and safer. At the very corner
of the front windows to the entrance to the Mall, we found a
window shattered on the bottom by the storm. I broke the rest
of the window out so we could walk in. The Mall was full of shops
and food and drink kiosks. We showed it to the other people with
us. Since it was hot inside the Mall and the people were still
afraid of getting in trouble for "trespassing", they
elected to camp outside.
We decided to stay all together as a group. Since we had no
food or water and no way to get any, we went into the Mall and
began "looting", gathering food and water for our survival.
At this point, there was no communication with anyone. No one
knew what was happening. There were no police. There was nothing
other than news of terrible floods. Everyone was on their own.
So now, with some food and water, we sat down to wait. The entrance
to the Riverwalk had part of the roof still intact, so we were
able to wait in the shade.
Shortly after, we noticed a man with a rifle
and duffel bag walk up to the door to the Mall. We see him try
the door and find it locked. Then he simply smashed out the door
with the butt of his rifle and walked in. We, of course, decided
to not enter again until he left. Maybe half an hour later, he
marched past us and was gone. His duffel seemed a bit fuller.
We went in again and explored more, located where the food was,
found stores on a lower floor, etc. Some
time passed, and then the person with the rifle returns again.
This time we notice he is a cop, and he is with four other cops,
and they all have arms and duffel bags. And their only purpose
is to get whatever they can.
That really opened up the Mall for us. We gathered food, drinks,
and explored the stores. Some other tourists appeared and joined
us. We took chairs and tables out of the mall. The police had "opened
up"
Footlocker and other stores, so there were shoes and clothes
available for the taking. I wandered through looking for bedding
and ways to set up camp. I took the covers off of some kiosks
to use as a bed. Bruni found some semi-cushioned furniture and
we took cushions. One day we found pillows in a store.
Our group grew as new people came looking for ways to get out
of the expected flooding. At some point, I started to walk back
to our hotel to find out if we could stay there. On the way,
I ran into an employee of the hotel and her family who had also
been kicked out of the hotel. They came up and joined us as well.
The first night, there were about thirty of us up on the bridge.
The next day, some others arrived. I think the second day, Wednesday,
might be when the Convention Center opened, because one family
decided to move down there. I think it was one of the families
of the hotel employees. They had been enjoying the provisions
of the Mall with us. Once they moved down to the Convention Center,
word spread, and there was a steady stream of people coming up
and sacking the Mall. People came out with everything, as did
we. More stores were broken into, and people came out with bags
and bags of goods. And it spread and spread. We went in systematically
all day long taking out food and provisions.
During all of this, there were no police around. There were
no authorities around. There was no food. There was no water.
There was no information, other than the hysteria and rumors
from the radio. No one knew how long we'd be there. No one knew
when the floods would reach us. The news indicates that the airport
is under ten feet of water, that the main shelter, the Superdome,
has lost part of its roof and is flooding, that there is killing,
and looting, and who knows what else. Everything is rumor. No
one knows anything. If you see a cop, they
are on their own. They are also homeless, and if they talk to
you, it is to say you are on your own.
By Wednesday, the streets were filled with people who are at
the Convention Center. There are thousands of people in the streets.
No one has food or water. It is hot and miserable. It was maybe
Wednesday or Thursday that some people on the street began yelling
about dead bodies, and tossed a body wrapped in a sheet on the
side of the Convention Center just below us. A little later a
wheelchair with a dead woman appears there as well. Again, everything
is rumor. People are saying that the dead woman in the wheelchair
was bludgeoned to death in the Convention Center. At the same
time, hordes of people are coming up the steps past us and into
the Mall. They are breaking into all the stores, smashing cash
registers, etc. There is desperation all around. And anger. And
violence.
Our group is about 50. We are mostly tourists from the US, Australia,
England etc. There are also several families from New Orleans
who were flooded out who have joined us. Two of the people are
nurses. The bathrooms in the mall have overflowed. There has
been no water since Tuesday night. Food is rotting. Everything
smells, as do we. But we are organized. We have set up buckets
behind broken pieces of zinc roofing as bathrooms. We have sodas
and water stacked up in our kitchen. While there is still ice
in the Mall, we have some hams buried there. We have umbrellas
and trash cans and trash bags ... even disposable gloves to help
avoid disease. We also have dead bodies, dead rats, and shit
and stink all around. And we have no idea how long we are here
for.
Our group is mostly white and from Middle
America. They decide that the blacks (the Convention Center
is 99% black obviously) are planning to murder us to get attention
and help). There is mass hysteria in the group, and racism
is rampant. People don't know where to flee. Rumors are everywhere
about murder, rape, etc. There are shots during the
night Thursday or Friday. At 2 am, there is a huge explosion
across the river, and a huge fire. Smoke pours in from fires
in every direction.
There is some nasty racism in our group. One
day, when the hysteria is greatest, a black man stands up and
says, "Why do you think these people want to kill you? They
are surviving just the same as you. Struggling just the same.
Just as desperate as you. They don't care anything about you.
They are concentrating on surviving, etc."
That calmed people a bit and made them feel particularly foolish.
At the same time, more and more families from
the Convention Center were moving up to the walkway with us.
Our group grew to about 80. Each morning, people began to bag
the garbage. Others swept the walkway. Some set out breakfast
for everybody. Two women who were home care workers for the elderly
emptied and cleaned the shit buckets. A group would go into the
Mall and forage for provisions. Then we would sit all day and
wait.
I think on Friday the helicopters began
to arrive dropping water and MRE rations in the parking lot
in front of us. It was the first and only food and water ever
to arrive -- three days after the hurricane. And it was just
tossed from the helicopter for people to run after and gather.
The old and the sick had nothing. Again, no one knew
what was happening. Fires were burning all around. Everyone
was desperate and frightened. Everyone was just trying to survive.
And everyone, other than us tourists, was there because they
had been completely wiped out -- had lost their homes and every
possession and had young kids and elderly parents to feed.
As the helicopters arrived, we also ran down and gathered what
we could. We began to survive on the army rations. Ernesto and
I became friendly with the man who had given the speech chastising
our group. He invited me to go with him to the Convention Center
and distribute whatever Army rations we could pick up from the
next helicopter to the disabled there, since they had no way
to get rations. We gathered about 30 meals off of the next drop.
The drops were scandalous -- throwing food and
water out of a hovering helicopter -- people scrambling for food
to survive. Reduced to animals foraging -- when the copters could
have landed, imposed order with guards, and distributed food
with some respect and humanity.
Anyway, we walked through the Convention Center distributing
food. The Center takes up about eight city blocks. There must
have been 25,000 people camped out there without provisions,
without bathrooms, without water or electricity ... with no means
of survival. Families with little kids. Old people. People in
wheelchairs. There was no medicine. No nurses or doctors. There
was filth and garbage everywhere. Some people asked for food,
and we gave it. Others said they were fine and had eaten. Some
pointed out others who needed food. Like
our group, they were doing their best to survive, and sharing
whatever they had. We kept walking. The crowds went on and on.
People with nothing. Every one of them had lost everything. Abandoned.
Not knowing how they would eat, how they would survive. It was
the most disgraceful, sad, infuriating thing I had ever seen
in my life. Poor people discarded like garbage because they were
poor people.
Everybody was waiting for the promised buses to evacuate us.
Every day there were rumors of buses. Every day we waited and
watched. Nothing ever came. Every day there was more filth. More
people fainting from dehydration. Children were getting sick.
Disease was becoming a bigger worry.
Our community on the walkway was interesting.
One day a reporter came by and asked me if we had a "mayor" ...
we didn't. Everyone worked. Everyone joined in. Everyone did
the job that made them most comfortable. And everything functioned.
And as people joined us, they automatically joined in the work.
There were differences, but everyone worked. When there was talk
about leaving or looking for ways out, it was discussed collectively.
There was always a sense of staying together and getting out
as a group. There was also nastiness, and racism, and comments
about "the people down there" in the Convention Center.
We intervened with a lot with people in our group who were blaming
all the "people down there" for the violence. We intervened
when reporters started to come and were told that "the people
down there"
were looting and killing. We told them that they were doing just
what we were doing -- doing what was necessary to survive in
desperate circumstances.
I don't know what else to say. We were anxious all the time.
The nights were the worst ... partly because nights are generally
more frightening, but also because there were often shots or
explosions. There was always a surprise, and it was always bad
news. It seemed like it would never get better. We just waited
and scavenged. We worried that things would get more violent
as they got more desperate. We also made incredible friends and
saw amazing acts of kindness.
One morning, we woke and packed at 3 am because of a rumor that
the buses were coming early in the morning. We waited and hoped.
No buses came. We cleaned up camp and sat down to wait again,
hoping to get through another day without tragedy.
It was Friday or Saturday that we heard the
news that Bush was coming to view the disaster. That was when
I first thought we would be getting out. I knew that New Orleans
was another stage, and that the president wasn't going to show
up unless the troops were coming and the mess was going to be
cleaned up. Here was a chance to improve his ratings. Here was
a place where an appearance without an immediate success would
be a political disaster. Here was another excellent political
stage. And of course we looked down the next day at noon and
there were the troops. And a perimeter was set up. And piles
of water and food were set up in the parking area. And that was
the beginning of the evacuation. By the next day, the buses arrived.
I think we finally left at around 4 pm on Saturday.
Once the troops arrived, the general anxiety level went down.
Now it was just a question of getting out. Fires were burning.
When the wind shifted it was hard to breathe, but we knew if
no other disaster hit, we would get out soon. As always, they
told us the buses were coming. We didn't believe it for a minute. The
National Guard told us we had to vacate the walkway and go down
onto the street to await the buses. Of course we refused. We
told them we had a community here that was self sufficient. There
was no need for us to be on the street and in the sun for nothing.
That here, we were supplying food, medical services, etc to ourselves
and to anyone who had a need. By this time, we had about five
or six elderly and incapacitated people in our group. They had
been left behind by a hospital when they evacuated. They were
with a nurse who had been abandoned with them. We pointed out
that our sick could not go down. We had another nurse in our
group who was very well-spoken, and helped convince the National
Guard that we had to stay for reasons of the health of the children
and the elderly. So we stuck together and stayed on the walkway.
Nobody left until we finally saw the buses, and were assured
that everyone would get out. And then we marched out together
as a group, with much of the group still intact.
In convincing the National Guard to let us stay, one of the
more hateful and delusional of our group argued to the Guard
that we should be left on the walkway because of "racial
tensions". This was the same woman who had been telling
everyone who would listen that the blacks would slaughter us
to gain media attention so they would be evacuated. Anyway, between
all the arguments, we were allowed to stay. And it also resulted
in one of the most shameful moments of our stay. When the meals
were distributed in the parking lot, several distribution lines
were formed. We were given a separate line. Our line was escorted
to and from the food by Guardsmen. No one from our group was
ever able to walk alone. As always, it is the racist hysterical
argument that prevails. It was better not to get food then to
pass through that disgrace.
We were amazed when we walked down to the corner where the bus
was supposed to be that there was actually a bus. It took an
hour to get out of the city. The driver did not know where we
were going. As usual, we knew nothing. At some point, the cop
leading the line of evacuating buses informed us that we were
going to Fort Chafee, Arkansas. All we wanted was an airport,
but there was no way off a moving bus. Later, we were told we
were going to Fort Smith, Arkansas, even farther away. We demanded
to be let off. The cop told us that we would stop to eat in Shreveport,
Louisiana and we could get off there. Of course the bus didn't
stop. It did stop just across the Texas border, where a group
of people had voluntarily set up tables to distribute food and
help to the refugees.
We grabbed our bags and decided to find a ride into Shreveport.
There was no good reason for us to go to Fort Smith. Ernesto
found a volunteer to take us to a motel by the airport. Our first
priority was to bathe by this point. An airplane was next. Of
course no motels were available. So we decided to spend the night
at the airport. Another man offered to take us. As we were getting
in his car, he also offered us a shower at his house. We took
him up on it and headed off. We showered, chatted, etc. I made
plane reservations for 7 am the next morning. They invited us
to stay and sleep for the hour and a half that remained of the
night. They gave us food and little presents, a tee-shirt from
their local high school baseball team, etc. They were kind, concerned,
and really wanted to help and do the right thing. As we talked
it was also clear that they were religious conservatives, racist,
homophobic, etc. East Texas ... kindness and hatefulness on the
same plate.
Anyway, we're home. We're still angry and anxious.
Writing all this makes me relive it. Reading it makes Bruni cry.
What we saw was just too raw. Poor people abandoned because they
were poor. Poor people treated as trash. Poor people being branded
as looters and thieves for trying to survive. Our own country
treating us just as we treat the Iraqis, Palestinians, and every
other country that we exploit or invade. How can we ever deny
class warfare?
The other thing that struck me were the contradictions
in people ... how the kindest people in our group who gave aid
and compassion individually to blacks and whites, rich and poor,
also painted all those people at the Convention Center with the
same brush -- animals, looters, ignorants.
And it is no wonder when all the papers write
and all the news reports is looting and violence -- as if there
was no need or reason to "loot". Sure, there were some
violent people there. There are everywhere. But this handful
gets turned into "those people", and everyone gets
branded. So no compassion is needed for the poor. After all, "they
brought it on themselves ... they wouldn't let the government
help, even though the government tried so hard". And that
becomes what this country believes. And then of course the government
can "morally"
do nothing for the poor -- which is what it intended in the first
place.
That's all I have for now. After you read this, give me a call
and we can talk.
Love,
Peter |
What actually happened in New
Orleans these past two weeks? We need to sort through the rumors
and distortions. Perhaps we need our version of South Africa's
Truth And Reconciliation Commission. Some way to sort through
the many narratives and find a truth, and to find justice.
I spent yesterday inside the city of New Orleans,
speaking to a few of the last holdouts in the 9th ward/ bywater
neighborhood. Their stories paint a very different picture
from what we've heard in the media. Instead of stories of gangs
of criminals and police and soldiers keeping order, there were
stories of collective action, everyone looking out for each
other, communal responses.
The first few nights there was a large, free
community barbecue at a neighborhood bar called The Country Club.
People brought food and cooked and cooked and drank and went
swimming (yes, there's a pool in the bar).
Emily Harris and Richie Kay, from Desire Street, traveled out
on their boat and brought supplies and gave rides. They have
been doing this almost every day since the hurricane struck.
They estimate that they have rescued at least a hundred people.
Emily doesn't want to leave. She is a carpenter and builder,
and says, "I want to stay and rebuild. I love New Orleans"
Emily describes a community working together in the first days
after the hurricane. She also describes a scene of abandonment
and disappointment.
"A lot of people came to the high ground at St. Claude Avenue.
They really thought someone would come and rescue them, and they
waited all day for something - a boat, a helicopter, anything.
There were helicopters in the sky, but none coming down"
So people started walking as a mass uptown to Canal Street.
Along the way, youths would break into grocery stores, take the
food and distribute it evenly among houses in the community.
"Then they reached Canal Street, and saw that there was
still no one that wanted to rescue them. That's when people broke
into the stores on Canal Street"
I asked Okra, in his house off of Piety Street,
what the biggest problem has been. He said, "It's been the
police - they've lost the last restraints on their behavior they
had, and gotten a license to go wild. They can do anything they
want. I saw one cop beat a guy so hard that he almost took his
ear off. And this was someone just trying to walk home"
Walking through the streets, I witnessed hundreds of soldiers
patrolling the streets. Everyone I spoke to said that soldiers
were coming to their house at least once a day, trying to convince
them to leave, bringing stories of disease and quarantine and
violence. I didn't see or speak to any soldiers involved in any
clean up or rebuilding.
There are surely reasons to leave - I would not be living in
the city at this point. I'm too attached to electricity and phone
lines. But I can attest that those holdouts I spoke to are doing
fine. They have enough food and water and have been very careful
to avoid exposing themselves to the many health risks in the
city.
I saw more city busses rolling through poor areas of town than
I ever saw pre-hurricane. Unfortunately, these buses were filled
with patrols of soldiers. What if the massive effort placed into
patrolling this city and chasing everyone out were placed into
beginning the rebuilding process?
Some neighborhoods are underwater still, and the water has turned
into a sticky sludge of sewage and death that turns the stomach
and breaks my heart. However, some neighborhoods are barely damaged
at all, and if a large-scale effort were put into bringing back
electricity and clearing the streets of debris, people could
begin to move back in now.
Certainly some people do not want to move back, but many of
us do. We want to rebuild our city that we love. The People's
Hurricane Fund - a grassroots, community based group made up
of New Orleans community organizers and allies from around the
US - has already made one of their first demands a "right
of return for the displaced of New Orleans.
In the last week, I've traveled between Houston, Baton Rouge,
Covington, Jackson and New Orleans and spoken to many of my former
friends and neighbors. We feel shell shocked. It used to be we
would see each other in a coffee shop or a bar or on the street
and talk and find out what we're doing. Those of us who were
working for social justice felt a community. We could share stories,
combine efforts, and we never felt alone. Now we're alone and
dispersed and we miss our homes and our communities and we still
don't know where so many of our loved ones even are.
It may be months before we start to get a clear picture of what
happened in New Orleans. As people are dispersed around the US
reconstructing that story becomes even harder than reconstructing
the city. Certain sites, like the Convention
Center and Superdome, have become legendary, but despite the
thousands of people who were there, it still is hard to find
out exactly what did happen.
According to a report that's been circulated,
Denise Young, one of those trapped in the convention center told
family members,
"yes, there were young men with guns there, but they organized
the crowd. They went to Canal Street and looted,' and brought
back food and water for the old people and the babies, because
nobody had eaten in days. When the police rolled down windows
and yelled out the buses are coming,' the young men with guns
organized the crowd in order: old people in front, women and
children next, men in the back,just so that when the buses came,
there would be priorities of who got out first" But the
buses never came. "Lots of people being dropped off, nobody
being picked up. Cops passing by, speeding off. We thought we
were being left to die"
Larry Bradshaw and Lorrie Beth Slonsky, paramedics from Service
Employees International Union Local 790 reported on their experience
downtown, after leaving a hotel they were staying at for a convention. "We
walked to the police command center at Harrah's on Canal Street
and were told ...that we were on our own, and no they did not
have water to give us. We now numbered several hundred. We held
a mass meeting to decide a course of action. We agreed to camp
outside the police command post. We would be plainly visible
to the media and would constitute a highly visible embarrassment
to the City officials. The police told us that we could not stay.
Regardless, we began to settle in and set up camp. In short order,
the police commander came across the street to address our group.
He told us he had a solution: we should walk to the Pontchartrain
Expressway and cross the greater New Orleans Bridge where the
police had buses lined up to take us out of the City...
"We organized ourselves and the 200 of us set off for the
bridge with great excitement and hope. ...As we approached the
bridge, armed Gretna sheriffs formed a line across the foot of
the bridge. Before we were close enough to speak, they began
firing their weapons over our heads. This sent the crowd fleeing
in various directions...
"Our small group retreated back down Highway 90 to seek
shelter from the rain under an overpass. We debated our options
and in the end decided to build an encampment in the middle of
the Ponchartrain Expressway on the center divide, between the
O'Keefe and Tchoupitoulas exits. We reasoned we would be visible
to everyone, we would have some security being on an elevated
freeway and we could wait and watch for the arrival of the yet
to be seen buses.
"All day long, we saw other families, individuals and groups
make the same trip up the incline in an attempt to cross the
bridge, only to be turned away. Some chased away with gunfire,
others simply told no, others to be verbally berated and humiliated.
Thousands of New Orleanians were prevented and prohibited from
self-evacuating the City on foot. Meanwhile, the only two City
shelters sank further into squalor and disrepair. The only way
across the bridge was by vehicle. We saw workers stealing trucks,
buses, moving vans, semi-trucks and any car that could be hot
wired. All were packed with people trying to escape the misery
New Orleans had become"
Media reports of armed gangs focused on black
youth, but New Orleans community activist, Black Panther, and
former Green Party candidate for City Council Malik Rahim reported
from the West Bank of New Orleans, "There are gangs of white
vigilantes near here riding around in pickup trucks, all of them
armed" I also heard similar reports from two of my neighbors
- a white gay couple - who i visited on Esplanade Avenue.
The reconstruction of New Orleans starts now. We need to reconstruct
the truth, we need to reconstruct families, who are still separated,
we need to reconstruct the lives and community of the people
of New Orleans, and, finally, we need to reconstruct the city.
Since I moved to New Orleans, I've been inspired and educated
by the grassroots community organizing that is an integral part
of the life of the city. It is this community infrastructure
that is needed to step forward and fight for restructuring with
justice.
In 1970, when hundreds of New Orleans police came to kick the
Black Panthers out of the Desire Housing Projects, the entire
community stood between the police and the Panthers, and the
police were forced to retreat.
The grassroots infrastructure of New Orleans is the infrastructure
of secondlines and Black Mardi Gras: true community support.
The Social Aid and Pleasure Clubs organize New Orleans' legendary
secondline parades - roving street parties that happen almost
every weekend. These societies were formed to provide insurance
to the Black community because Black people could not buy insurance
legally, and to this day the "social aid is as important
as the pleasure.
The only way that New Orleans will be reconstructed
as even a shadow of its former self is if the people of New Orleans
have direct control over that reconstruction. But, our community
dislocation is only increasing. Every day, we are spread out
further. People leave Houston for Oregon and Chicago. We are
losing contact with each other, losing our community that has
nurtured us.
Already, the usual forces of corporate restructuring are lining
up. Halliburton's Kellogg Brown & Root subsidiary has begun
work on a $500 million US Navy contract for emergency repairs
at Gulf Coast naval and marine facilities damaged by Hurricane
Katrina. Blackwell Security - the folks that brought you Abu
Ghraib - are patrolling the streets of our city.
The Wall Street Journal reported that
the rich white elite is already planning their vision of New
Orleans' reconstruction, from the super-rich gated compounds
of Audubon Place Uptown, where they have set up a heliport
and brought in a heavily-armed Israeli security company. "The
new city must be something very different, one of these city
leaders was quoted as saying, "with better services and
fewer poor people. Those who want to see this city rebuilt
want to see it done in a completely different way: demographically,
geographically and politically"
While the world's attention is focused on New Orleans, in a
time when its clear to most of the world that the federal government's
greed and heartlessness has caused this tragedy, we have an opportunity
to make a case for a people's restructuring, rather than a Halliburton
restructuring.
The people of New Orleans have the will. Today,
I met up with Andrea Garland, a community activist with Get Your
Act On who is planning a bold direct action; she and several
of her friends are moving back in to their homes. They have generators
and supplies, and they invite anyone who is willing to fight
for New Orleans to move back in with them. Malik Rahim, in New
Orleans' West Bank, is refusing to leave and is inviting others
to join him. Community organizer Shana Sassoon, exiled in Houston,
is planning a community mapping project to map out where our
diaspora is being sent, to aid in our coming back together. Abram
Himmelstein and Rachel Breulin of The Neighborhood Story Project
are beginning the long task of documenting oral histories of
our exile.
Please join us in this fight. This is not just about New Orleans.
This is about community and collaboration versus corporate profiteering.
The struggle for New Orleans lives on.
Jordan Flaherty is a union organizer and an editor of Left Turn
Magazine (www.leftturn.org). He is not planning on moving out
of New Orleans. He can be reached at: anticapitalist@hotmail.com |
Editor's Note: A Bay Area man
goes to New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina and finds a war zone
of floating bodies, armed and angry survivors and threatening
policemen.
I just returned this past weekend from my first trip to Louisiana
since Katrina. It's beyond what you can imagine -- it's hell
on Earth.
I flew into Baton Rouge, which sits about 80 miles northwest
of New Orleans, and the city is destroyed, but not by the storm.
There are hundreds of thousands of refugees from New Orleans
in Baton Rouge. People are camping on the side of the roads,
in their cars if they have them, and all over the LSU campus.
The first thing you notice is how outraged everyone is.
The people of Baton Rouge don't want us here, and you can't
blame them. There seems to be no plan for the New Orleaneans
once they are dropped off in Baton Rouge, and locals are confused,
horrified or worse. They know this is potentially a permanent
situation, or at least the way it will be for the next several
months. It's safe to say they're as scared as the homeless and
exhausted refugees that litter their streets.
We rented four houses in Houma, La., which is about 50 miles
south of Baton Rouge or about 30 miles west of New Orleans. We
spent the weekend moving our family there, then our friends,
and then people we met who had no other options. When I left,
we had perhaps 40 people and another 20 on the way. It's an amazing
thing to see -- your best friends, family and everyone in between
huddled on floorboards, makeshift beds and sleeping bags. It's
truly like a nuclear bomb hit our city, and we are doing everything
we can just to keep everyone housed, fed and with clean water.
I decide to go into New Orleans as there are far too many people
from our home unaccounted for. It's Saturday, September 3.
There is no way to get into the city. The roads that are open
are being used to bring people out, and no traffic is headed
in. I drive a rental car 30 miles on backroads that I guess won't
be flooded. I make it about half way until can no longer get
into the city by car. With a backpack loaded with as much water
as I can carry, two packs of breakfast bars, three canisters
of bug spray, and an extra pair of shoes, I start walking.
First, there's the climate. It's almost 90 degrees, and the
humidity and the still water have made the swamp come alive with
bugs. The mosquito swarms and other bugs make sound like a blizzard.
I have to wear long-sleeve shirts and pants, and I'm drenched
with sweat.
The first group of people I meet are very friendly. I trade
my ipod for a kid's dirt bike so I can make better time, and
they give me extra water. They try to warn me it isn't safe to
head into the city. They warn me about what neighborhoods to
avoid, and that above everything else, it was critical to stay
away from the police. They'll force you to leave by putting you
on a bus destined for who knows where, and if you resist, they'll
arrest you. It's the first time I sense that the police and government
are seen as enemies by Katrina survivors. At first, I simply
consider that shortsighted, but over the next two days, I start
to understand why they think that way.
I get to the outskirts of the city by about 2 p.m. -- an upscale
neighborhood called Metaire, where most of the money of New Orleans
lives. To get that far already involved about half a mile of
swimming. Everything is destroyed. The area isn't just underwater,
it's more that the swamps have risen over New Orleans. There
are snakes and alligators everywhere, and the more you see, the
more you realize the city isn't going to be livable for who knows
how long.
Then there are the bodies. I first start seeing them as I cross
from Metaire into what is called Midcity, the neighborhood you
drive through to get to Jazz Fest and the fairgrounds. Until
now, I've only seen a few dead bodies in my entire life. Some
have been pushed against dry spots by, I presume, rescue workers.
Others are just floating in the water. There are houses with
red marks on them, meaning there's someone dead inside. The most
horrifying part of all is what happens when a body is floating
in the water for two or three days. It's barely recognizable
as a person. When you see one, it's riddled with mosquitoes and
who knows what else.
The city is not at all empty as the news says it is. I find
hundreds if not thousands of people in all the different neighborhoods,
and they have no intention of leaving. First and foremost, they
have nowhere to go. Many people don't want to leave. They don't
trust they'll ever be let back in, and they certainly aren't
going to allow their homes to be pillaged by people crafty enough
not to get kicked out. Finally, they just don't believe the argument
that the city will be unsafe and infested with disease.
They're armed and angry. They have already survived five straight
days of no food and no water, and they don't believe those who
haven't gotten them food or water are going to find a place for
them to live.
I grew up in the 9th Ward, one of the lowest income areas in
the city and the site of the first levee break. To get to my
childhood home, I would have to dive underwater just to get to
the roof. I go to the second house we lived in. Its roof has
been torn off and there's a body floating not 50 feet away from
the front porch. I wish I can say my friends' houses fared better.
Most were either completely submerged in 10 to 15 feet of water
or just not standing anymore. I find three people I know, and
they set off for Houma that afternoon.
People are furious. They feel they've been abandoned. You have
to understand, there's no power anywhere. The rescue crews are
going through New Orleans proper but not all the neighborhoods
where people live. Most people don't even think there's a rescue
effort underway at all. It becomes clear to me the one thing
people need is communication; without it fear takes over. There's
nothing more important to restoring order than giving the leaders
an ability to get messages to everyone.
I know everyone has heard about people firing on helicopters.
I'm certainly not saying it is right, but after being there,
I understand. For five days, helicopters are flying overhead,
but none of them are dropping water or food down for anyone.
They fly by using load speakers saying that anyone found looting
or stealing will be arrested, and those are the helicopters that
are followed by gunshots, from what I see.
The only government group anyone has seen are the police with
sawed-off shotguns threatening to arrest everyone who is walking
around on the streets.
Everyone is fearful for his future, and fear leads people to
do amazing, extraordinary things. It's a state of war. People
don't even know who they're fighting, but they know they're at
war. Twice, I bike away at full speed from people that come at
me. Before I leave the city, my cash, backpack loaded with food
and change of clothes and my camera are stolen. The final time,
two people robbed me of my water. They didn't even ask for cash
or my watch, just my water. It is desperation, and the last thing
I could ever feel is anger.
I'll never forget this weekend. I'll probably spend years wishing
I could. You just can't describe what it's like to see the hometown
that you love, that's a part of everything you are, littered
with floating dead bodies, and to see "your people" firing
guns at strangers and hating everyone and everything. It's one
of the worst things I've ever felt or seen. It's a war being
fought against no one. |
Bush has bitten the bullet
and realised that the only way out of the watery grave into which
his political fortunes were washed by Katrina is by the time-honoured
means of throwing money at the problem. However, he is still
George W., and that means that the money will be heading into
the pockets of his friends, cronies, and puppet masters. His
apology appears directed at the recipients of this new government
largesse: "Sorry I took so long to figure out another way
to steal from the poor and homeless. That Sheehan woman must
have rattled me more than I thought."
In the tradition of some of Bush's most memorable media events,
the somewhat mistimed "Mission Accomplished" banner
weeks into the Iraq invasion and occupation comes to mind,
the wag the dog specialists dressed the stage of the royal
master's mea culpa:
Bobby DeServi and Scott Sforza were on hand as we drove
up about 8 p.m. or so EDT handling last-minute details of
the stagecraft. Bush will be lit with warm tungsten lighting,
but the statue and cathedral will be illuminated with much
brighter, brighter lights, along nothing like the candlepower
that DeServi and Sforza used on Sept. 11, 2002, to light
up the Statue of Liberty for Bush's speech in New York Harbor.
Here's a quote from DeServi on the lit up cathedral: "Oh,
it's heated up. It's going to print loud.'' Bush will be
hidden from street view by a large swatch of military camouflage
netting, held in place by bags of rocks and strung up on
poles, if I remember correctly. (Elisabeth Bumiller NYT, Cited by
Wonkette)
Bush's speech to the victims was sorely missing the purported
audience -- those left homeless by the devastation. Rather than
face their wrath in the Astrodome or one of the detention camps
into which they have been herded, Bush was carefully hidden behind
military camouflage in the city his storm troopers had been fighting
to empty of the hold-outs, the ones who suspected that were they
to leave, they might never be allowed back in. As New Orleans'
mayor Ray Nagin announced that certain neighborhoods would be
open next week, we wonder about the real reason behind driving
out those who wished to stay? Has FEMA suddenly become so efficient
and effective that the threat of disease has ceased?
A report
from Houston says that according to a poll, 44% of those
evacuated don't want to return. They plan to stay where they
are. That's one way to rid the city of its poor.
Behind the heart-felt manipulation of last night's speech lies
a major political operation meant to save his administration
and his political testament. So before we get all teary-eyed
at the compassion Bush is showing for the victims, let's look
at some thoughts on how the money is going to be spent...
First, the majority of those stranded in New Orleans were poor
and black. So the first thing Bush does is to declare that the
federal legislation requiring that minimum wage be respected
during the reconstruction, the Davis-Bacon Act, does not apply.
Is the logic that it will be better to poorly pay more people?
Will the contractors be forgoing part of their profit margins
in the name of a humanitarian cause?
The next few articles look at what may be in store over the
next months and years, and how the disaster will be turned into
an opportunity to further entrench the neocon, neoliberal vision.
There are important questions, of which one of the most evident
is how the reconstruction will be financed? Bush is promising
$200 billion. Will he cut on the war in Iraq? Yeah, right! But
it will have to come from somewhere, and the US economy is already
in trouble with the huge deficits the war is imposing. |
Drill the Arctic National Wildlife
Refuge, suspend environmental regulations including the Clean
Water Act and the Clean Air Act, suspend prevailing wage labor
laws, promote vouchers and school choice, repeal the estate tax
and copiously fund faith-based organizations. These are just
some of the recommendations a trio of hearty Heritage Foundation
senior management officials are making to best facilitate the
rebuilding of the Gulf Coast.
Just as the Iraq War has been a Petri Dish for the neoconservative
foreign policy agenda, rebuilding the Gulf Coast in the wake
of Hurricane Katrina could prove to be
the mother of all testing grounds for a passel of active Heritage
Foundation's domestic policy initiatives.
Washington, DC's most prestigious and influential right wing
think tank has been rocking and rolling since Hurricane Katrina
devastated New Orleans and the Gulf Coast.
In a WebMemo entitled "President's Bold Action on Davis-Bacon
Will Aid the Relief Effort," Senior Research Fellow Ronald
D. Utt applauded Bush for suspending provisions of the Davis-Bacon
Act applying "to federally funded construction projects
in the Gulf Coast areas hit by Hurricane Katrina."
Utt wrote that the president "is to be commended for showing
the courage to take this important but controversial stand...
eliminating the 'prevailing wage' clause [which] should lead
to a more efficient and lower cost recovery." Finally,
without a hint of irony as to which entities will actually capitalize
on the disaster, Utt praises the president for showing courage "in
denying the politically powerful labor unions the unfair benefits
they would otherwise have reaped from others' misfortune."
Two Heritage Press Room commentaries warned against playing
the "blame game":
In her September 9, commentary entitled "Preventing future
catastrophes,"
Helle Dale, the director of the Douglas and Sarah Allison Center
for Foreign Policy Studies at the foundation, deflects blame
from President Bush while praising him for "the creation
of an investigatory committee to look into 'what went right and
what went wrong,' as the president put it."
James Carafano's September 13, Press Room commentary entitled "The
Limits of Relief," provides a litany of so-called reasonable
hypotheses as to why it took so long for the government to provide
relief for the victims of Hurricane Katrina.
It will be interesting to see how the foundation's commentators
spin President Bush's remarks on Tuesday, September 13, when
he said that he "take[s] responsibility" for failures
in dealing with Hurricane Katrina.
A far more impressive Heritage Foundation document, however,
says it all: An expansive Special Report written by Ed Meese,
Stuart Butler, and Kim Holmes, lay out the foundation's cross-pollinated
all-encompassing plan for rebuilding the Gulf Coast. Entitled "From
Tragedy to Triumph: Principled Solutions for Rebuilding Lives
and Communities,"
the Special Report provides a set of guidelines and recommendations
which come from the foundation's two-plus decade playbook.
Meese and comrades maintain that it is imperative "that
taking action swiftly does not lead to steps that cause dollars
to be used inefficiently or unwise decisions that will frustrate
rather than achieve long term success."
The Heritage Foundation's "Guidelines" for rebuilding
the Gulf Coast include:
- The federal government should provide support and assistance
only in those situations that are beyond the capabilities
of state and local governments and the private sector. State
and local governments must retain their primary role as first
responders to disasters. The federal government should avoid
federalizing state and local first response agencies and
activities.
- Federal financial aid, when necessary, should be provided
in a manner that promotes accountability, flexibility, and
creativity. In general, tools such as tax credits and voucher
programs, which allow individuals and families to direct funds,
should be utilized to encourage private-sector innovation and
sensitivity to individual needs and preferences.
- Consistent with genuine health and safety needs, red tape
should be reduced or eliminated to speed up private-sector
investment and initiative in the rebuilding of facilities and
the restoration of businesses. Regulations that are barriers
to putting people back to work should be suspended or, at a
minimum, streamlined.
- Congress should reorder its spending priorities, not just
add new money while other money is being wasted. Now
is the time to shift resources to their most important uses
and away from lower-priority uses to use taxpayer dollars more
effectively. It is critical that America focus on building
capabilities for responding to a catastrophic disaster, not
on catering to the wish lists of cities, parishes or counties,
states, and stakeholders.
- Private entrepreneurial activity and vision, not bureaucratic
government, must be the engine to rebuild. New approaches to
public policy issues such as enhanced choice in public school
education should be the norm, not the exception...The critical
need now is to encourage investors and entrepreneurs to seek
new opportunities within these cities...The
key is to encourage private-sector creativity -- for example,
by declaring New Orleans and other severely damaged areas "Opportunity
Zones" in which capital gains tax on investments is eliminated
and regulations eliminated or simplified.
- Funding from the federal government for homeland security
and disaster response and relief activities should focus on
national priorities, better regional coordination and communication,
and capitalizing federal assets.
- Catastrophic disasters will require a large-scale and rapid
military response that only the National Guard can provide.
The National Guard needs to be restructured to make it both
more effective and quicker to take action.
According to Meese, Butler and Holmes the key to successfully
rebuilding the Gulf Coast is to "encourage creative and
rapid private investment through incentives and reduced regulation,
and to channel long-term education, health, and other assistance
directly to the people and areas affected so that they can control
their future."
The report suggests that, "New Orleans
and other affected areas" be declared "Opportunity
Zones." In these areas, "the President should direct
an Emergency Board, drawn from federal, state, and local agencies
and the private sector, to identify regulations at all levels
that impede recovery and should propose temporary suspension
or modification of these rules."
Suspending Davis-Bacon "would significantly
reduce the cost of reconstruction and provide more opportunities
for displaced Americans who are without jobs to work on federal
projects to restore their neighborhoods." They
do not detail the putting in place of any mechanisms aimed
at preventing the reconstruction of the Gulf Coast from turning
into an Iraq-like rip off. In addition, they do not explain
how workers, many of whom have lost everything, can possibly
afford to rebuild their homes and their lives by working for
wages at, or close to, the minimum wage.
They recommend "repeal[ing] or waiv[ing]
restrictive environmental regulations that hamper rebuilding
a broad array of infrastructure from refineries to roads and
stadiums." They also advocate "substantial
changes in environmental laws such as the National Environmental
Policy Act (NEPA) and the Clean Water Act" which they
charge "have contributed to Katrina's damage,"
They believe the best way to get the energy infrastructure up
and running is to "waive or repeal Clean Air Act (CAA) regulations
that hamper refinery rebuilding and expansion,"
"waive or repeal gasoline formulation requirements under
the Clean Air Act so as to allow gasoline markets to work more
flexibly and efficiently and reduce costs to the American consumer," and "increase
the production of oil in the United States" by drilling
for oil in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge (ANWR).
As an indication of how out of touch the
Heritage Foundation is with the vast majority of the victims
of Hurricane Katrina, they are offering a so-called tax relief
package that will have little to no effect on most of the victims'
lives. Front and center are recommendations to: "streamline
or suspend" parts of the federal tax code in the so-called
Opportunity Zones; repeal the estate tax in order to prevent
the victims of the disaster from being "hounded by the
IRS"; "postpone payment of 2004 and 2005 individual
and business income taxes for Katrina's victims," and "waive
penalties for withdrawals from tax-advantaged savings such
as IRAs and 401(k) plans."
How many of the folks that you saw on the roofs
of their houses and stuffed into the crumbling Superdome have
IRAs and 401(k) plans, Mr. Meese?
The report goes on to propose
"refundable tax credits for the purchase of the kind of
health insurance that best meets their personal needs," voucherizing
public school education, and encouraging public/private partnerships "through
leasing" instead of constructing new public schools.
Finally, the report advocates the elimination
of any-and-all barriers that prevent "charitable and faith-based
groups, as well as uncertified or non-union individuals," from
participating fully in the reconstruction. |
Let's all be clear about one
thing.
As we suggested last night, and as President
Bush has now put us on notice, the Gulf Coast reconstruction
effort is going to be run as a patronage and political operation.
That's not spin or hyperbole. They're saying it themselves.
The president has put Karl Rove in charge of the reconstruction,
with a budget of a couple hundred billion dollars.
They've announced this in various ways over the last few days.
But here's another, from today's Times ...
Republicans said Karl Rove, the White House deputy chief
of staff and Mr. Bush's chief political adviser, was in charge
of the reconstruction effort, which reaches across many agencies
of government and includes the direct involvement of Alphonso
R. Jackson, secretary of housing and urban development.
Karl Rove runs political operations and manages
coalitions through patronage. That's what he does. And that's
what this is about.
Everybody realizes that. Don't expect much if any discussion
of this point in the major papers or on the networks.
It's shameless. But that's beside the point.
This is a time when the country needs an opposition party. Every
Democrat should be hitting on this. Take the politics out of
the reconstruction effort. He put his chief
spin-doctor in charge of the biggest reconstruction and refugee
crisis the country's probably ever faced. That tells you all
you need to know about his values. Nothing that happened in the
last couple weeks meant anything to him. And nothing has changed.
Same as Iraq. Same stuff. |
Speculators
Rushing In as the Water Recedes
Would-be home buyers are betting New Orleans will be a boomtown.
And many of the city's poorest residents could end up being forced
out. |
By David Streitfeld, Times Staff Writer |
BATON ROUGE, La. - Brandy Farris
is house hunting in New Orleans.
The real estate agent has $10 million in the
bank, wired by an investor who has instructed her to scoop
up houses - any houses.
"Flooding no problem," Farris' newspaper ads advise.
Her backer is a Miami businessman who specializes in buying
storm-ravaged property at a deep discount, something that has
paid dividends in hurricane-prone Florida. But he may have a
harder time finding bargains this time around.
In some ways, Hurricane Katrina seems to have taken a vibrant
real estate market and made it hotter. Large sections of the
city are underwater, but that's only increasing the demand for
dry houses. And in flooded areas, speculators are trying to buy
properties on the cheap, hoping that the redevelopment of New
Orleans will start a boom.
This land rush has long-term implications in
a city where many of the poorest residents were flooded out.
It raises the question of what sort of housing - if any - will
be available to those without a six-figure salary. If New Orleans
ends up a high-priced enclave, without a mix of cultures, races
and incomes, something vital may be lost.
"There's a public interest question here," said Ann
Oliveri, a senior vice president with the Urban Land Institute,
a Washington think tank. "You don't have to abdicate the
city to whoever shows up."
For now, though, it's a seller's market, at least for habitable
homes.
Two months ago, Steve Young bought a two-bedroom condo in New
Orleans' Garden District as an investment for $145,000. Last
month, he was transferred by Shell Oil to Houston. Last week,
he put the condo on the market.
In a posting on Craigslist, an Internet classified advertising
site, Young asked $220,000. He got a dozen serious expressions
of interest - enough so he's no longer actively pursuing a buyer.
"I'm pretty positive the market's going to move up from
here,"
he said.
So, to their surprise, are many others.
"I thought this storm was the end of the city," said
Arthur Sterbcow, president of New Orleans-based Latter & Blum,
one of the biggest real estate brokerages on the Gulf Coast.
"If anyone had told me two weeks ago that I'd be getting
the calls and e-mails I'm getting, I would have thought he was
ready for the psychiatric ward."
Messages from those wanting to buy houses
- whether intact or flooded - and commercial properties are
outrunning those who want to sell by a factor of 20,
said Sterbcow, who has set up temporary quarters in his firm's
Baton Rouge office.
"We're pressing everyone into service just to answer the
phones,"
he said.
These eager would-be buyers may be drawing their
inspiration from Lower Manhattan, which proved a bonanza for
those smart enough to buy condos there immediately after the
Sept. 11 attack.
Of course, in southern Louisiana, everything
is hypothetical for the moment. The storm destroyed many property
records and displaced buyers, sellers, agents and title firms,
so no deals are actually being done. Insurance companies
haven't started to settle claims yet, much less determine how,
or whether, they will insure New Orleans in the future. The
city hasn't even been drained.
But people are thinking ahead, influenced
by a single factor: the belief that hundreds of billions of
dollars in government aid is going to create a boomtown. The
people administering that aid will need somewhere to live,
as will those doing the rebuilding. So will employees of companies
lured back to the area, and the service people that attend
to them.
All this will lead to what Sterbcow delicately
calls a "reorientation" of the city.
"Everyone I talked to has said, 'Let's start with a clean
sheet of paper, fix it and get it right,' " he said. "Some
of the homes here were only held together by the termites."
What the owners of the city's estimated 150,000 flooded houses
will get out of "reorientation" is unclear, especially
if the houses were in bad shape and uninsured.
Some black New Orleans residents say dourly that they know what's
coming. Melvin Gilbert, a maintenance crew chief in his 60s,
stood outside an elegant hotel in the French Quarter this week
and recalled how the neighborhood had been gentrified.
He remembered half a century ago when the French Quarter had
a substantial number of black residents.
"Then the Caucasians started offering them $10,000 for
their homes,"
he said. "Well, they only bought the places for $2,000,
so they took it and ran."
The white residents restored the homes, which rose quickly in
value. Gilbert said he expected the same dynamic when the floodwaters
receded in the heavily black neighborhoods east of downtown.
The question of who should own New Orleans is
already sparking tension. The first posting seeking New Orleans
property "in any condition or location" was placed
on Craigslist on Aug. 29, while the storm still raged. With small
variation, it was repeated numerous times over the next week.
Some readers were infuriated. "Do you read/watch/understand
any of the news broadcasts coming from the city? Or do you just
go to 'Cashing in on Desperation, Despondency, and Depression:
How to Make a Zillion Dollars investing in Disaster Area Real
Estate' seminars. Sheeeeeesh!"
wrote one.
The process of tracking down owners of deluged
houses is greatly slowed by the absence of records. It's not
going to be easy to find these people, said Farris, the Baton
Rouge real estate agent.
What would she pay for a ruined house?
Farris demurred, saying it was too early to tell, but probably
only the value of the land, if that. Though the French Quarter
may be back to life within months, outlying districts such as
North Bywater and the Lower 9th Ward will take years, if
they ever do. Investors might hope this is the equivalent
of buying land on the outskirts of a boomtown, but it's not a
guarantee.
For one thing, there are already proposals to convert certain
flooded areas - including some water-logged neighborhoods - into
parks. Under the Supreme Court's recent ruling broadening the
definition of eminent domain, speculators could be forced to
sell their properties to the government.
That would be a great outcome for many homeowners in the parishes
south and east of New Orleans that bore the brunt of the storm.
Six months ago, Todd La Valla, a Re/Max real estate agent, bought
a four-unit apartment building for $59,000 in the community of
Buras, an unincorporated hamlet in Plaquemines Parish 55 miles
southeast of New Orleans.
The tenants evacuated in the storm, or at least La Valla hopes
they did. He's sure the building is gone too, like just about
everything else in the area. La Valla had no insurance, which
means his $10,000 investment is probably a complete loss.
Yet where there's disaster, there's opportunity.
"I've had calls from investors in Los Angeles,
Las Vegas, New York looking to buy property," La Valla said. "This
is going to be hard for the poor, the elderly, those that didn't
have insurance. But it's going to be great for some people."
At first, Lucia Blacksher thought she was in the bad news group.
In June, she and her boyfriend put their entire savings, about
$35,000, into their dream house - a century-old shotgun Victorian
in the New Orleans neighborhood of Mid-City. When the storm came,
they fled to Blacksher's parents' house in Birmingham, Ala.
The house, which cost $225,000, is partially flooded. Her boyfriend,
a Virginian who figures he's seen enough of hurricanes to last
him the rest of his life, wants to move. The insurance company
won't return calls.
Last week, Blacksher was worried she would lose her beloved
house either to foreclosure or a forced sale. One of those bottom-feeders
would get it.
She was more optimistic Wednesday. Somehow, she would get through
this.
"Because the house survived the storm, it will be even
more valuable,"
she said. "You could offer me $300,000 and I wouldn't take
it. No way." |
WASHINGTON (AP) - Fewer than
half of the hurricane Katrina evacuees living in shelters in
the Houston area want to go home again, according to a poll by
the Washington Post and the Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation.
Forty-three per cent said they wanted to move back home when
they can. About the same number of evacuees
- 44 per cent - said they wanted to permanently relocate,
and most of them wanted to stay in Houston, said the poll published
Friday.
The slow response to the storm strained faith in government. Six
in 10 said the experience had made them feel that the government
didn't care about people like them.
But their religious faith has been strengthened,
eight in 10 said. And 90 per cent were hopeful about the future.
The evacuees polled, all from New Orleans or elsewhere in Louisiana,
also said:
- More than half of their homes had been destroyed. Two-thirds
were renters and a third were homeowners.
- Almost 75 per cent didn't have insurance
to cover their losses.
- More than half didn't have health insurance,
a usable credit card with them, or a bank or chequing account
from which they could withdraw money.
- More than two-thirds said they didn't evacuate because they
didn't realize how bad the storm and its aftermath would be.
More than half - 55 per cent - said one factor was that they
didn't have a car or a way to leave.
The survey of 680 randomly selected evacuees at Houston-area
shelters was conducted Sept. 10-12 by ICR. The margin of error
was said to be plus or minus four percentage points. The Harvard
School of Public Health collaborated on the project. |
As a consequence of the catastrophe
that occurred in New Orleans, people in the US and throughout
the world have started to re-examine the record of the present
leaders of the first world superpower. A shift in opinion has
taken place almost overnight. History, throwing us all back into
our seats, suddenly opened its throttle.
Katrina - everyone refers to the hurricane
by her name as if she were some kind of avatar - revealed that
there is dire and increasing poverty in the US, that black
people are typically treated as unwanted second-class citizens,
that the systematic cutting of government investment in public
institutions has produced widespread social disequilibrium
and destitution (40 million Americans live without any aid
if they fall ill), that the so-called war against terrorism
is creating administrative chaos, and that within and against
all this, voices of protest are being raised loud and clear.
All this though was evident before Katrina
to those living it, and to those who wanted to know. What she
changed was that the media were there for once, showing what
was actually happening, and the fury of those to whom it was
happening. With her terrible gesture she wiped the opaque screens
clean for a little while.
In some gnomic way the as-yet-innumerable dead on the Gulf coast
spoke not for but with the 100,000 Iraqis who have died as a
consequence of the ongoing disastrous and criminal war. Time
and again in the US press, Katrina and Iraq are being mentioned
together. Yet Katrina was regular. She belonged to the familiar
weather conditions which affect the Gulf of Mexico. She was not
hiding in Afghanistan. And merciless as she was, she did not
belong to any axis of evil. She was simply a natural threat to
American lives and property, and she was heading for Louisiana.
It was in the self-interest (as well as the national interest)
of the president and his chosen colleagues to meet the challenge
she threw down, to foresee the needs of her victims and to reduce
the ensuing pain and panic to the minimum possible. If they,
the government, happened to fail to do this, they would be able
to blame nobody else, and they themselves would be blamed. A
child could foresee this. And they failed utterly. Their failure
was technical, political and emotional. "Stuff happens,"
murmurs Donald Rumsfeld.
Is it possible that this administration
is mad? Let us try to define the variant of madness,
for it may be that it has never occurred before. It has very
little to do, for example, with Nero when he fiddled while
Rome burned. Any madness, however, implies a severe disconnection
with reality, or, to put it more precisely, with the existent.
The variant we are considering touches upon
the relationship between fear and confidence, between being threatened
and being supreme. There is no negotiation between the two. Their "madness" operates
like a switch which turns one off and the other on. And what
is grave about this is that it is in the long periods of negotiating
between fear and confidence that the existent is normally surveyed
and observed in its multitudinous complexity. It is there that
one learns about what one is facing.
Five days after Katrina had struck, when President Bush finally
visited the devastated city, he astounded journalists by saying: "I
don't think anyone anticipated the breach of the levees." On
the same day, in the wrecked small town of Biloxi, the president's
flying visit was preceded by a team who quickly cleared the rubble
and corpses from the route his cortege would take. Two hours
later the team vanished, leaving everything else in the town
exactly as it was.
The calculations of the present US government are closely related
to the global interests of the corporations, and what has been
termed the survival of the richest, who today also vacillate
abruptly between fear and confidence.
The lobbyist Grover Norquist, who is a talking head for corporate
interests and to whom Bush and co listened when planning their
tax reforms for the benefit of the rich, is on record as saying: "I
don't want to abolish government. I simply want to reduce it
to the size where I can drag it into the bathroom and drown it
in the bathtub."
All political leaders sometimes parry with the truth, but here
the disconnections are systematic and crop up not only in their
announcements but in their every strategic calculation. Hence
their ineptness. Their operation in Afghanistan failed, their
war in Iraq has been won (as the saying goes) by Iran, Katrina
was allowed to produce the worst natural disaster in US history,
and terrorist activities are increasing.
An ignorance about most of what exists, and
an abdication from the very minimum of what can be expected of
government - are we not approaching disconnections which amount
to what can be called madness when found in the minds of those
who believe they can rule the planet? |
Yesterday
city councillor Lynne Pope woke up to find 191 emails waiting
for her.
Now she is trying to figure out what to say to the family
from New Orleans who, after watching police shoot a family
member, pinned a note to his body - but now can't find him.
And how does she reply to the mother looking for her 22-year-old
son who is autistic and can't communicate, or to the mother
who asked to have her eight-year-old daughter's name taken
off the missing person's list because the child's body has
been found.
Pope, along with Peter Koch in Switzerland and Texan Jonathan
Cutrer are the core of a group of volunteers who have set up
a website, Katrina Evacuee Help Center at www.disastersearch.org,
to help those affected by Hurricane Katrina.
Pope, who runs an internet design business, was participating
in an international software development forum, online, when
a pastor from Louisiana, who is in charge of the shelters in
his area, posted a message asking for help with his website,
Pope said. "When Peter got talking to him we found the
problem wasn't his website, but that there was not a centralised
unified database for people to use. We
actually thought that the Federal Government disaster agency
would have set something up before the disaster . . . so as
nobody had done it, we did."
In the first 24 hours more than 500 people visited the site
and by the time it was launched 12 families had made contact
with each other for the first time since the hurricane struck,
she said.
"We didn't even get to develop the site and test it before
people were using it.
"The need is so urgent."
The site contains the names of more than
300,000 people still missing after the hurricane.
While Pope receives a couple of emails a day asking to have
names removed from the list because people have been found,
she receives "dozens and dozens" asking to remove
names because their bodies have been found, she said.
"There have been many tears."
The team members, who do not get paid, have had hundreds of
volunteers from all around the world, including web designers
and software programmers, helping out and have been working
hard out for 18 to 20 hours a day for the past 11 days, she
said.
A big problem is getting word out to people on the ground
that there is a large website worth looking at, she said.
As well as missing persons, other features of the site include
downloadable government aid forms, a volunteer register, morgue
listings and a job registry. The database can be searched via
cellphone and one volunteer group has been distributing cellphones
around the shelters and others have been setting up internet
booths at the shelters.
Pope said they are now getting support from US senators and
many agencies were contacting them to add their databases to
one central location.
"It's getting bigger by the day." |
WASHINGTON - President Bush is urging
Congress to approve a massive reconstruction program for the
hurricane-ravaged Gulf Coast and promising that the federal
government will review the disaster plans of every major American
city.
The government failed to respond adequately to Hurricane
Katrina, Bush said Thursday night from storm-damaged New
Orleans as he laid out plans for one of the largest reconstruction
projects ever. The federal government's costs could reach
$200 billion or beyond.
The president, who has been dogged by criticism that Washington's
response to the hurricane was slow and inadequate, said the
nation has "every right to expect" more effective
federal action in a time of emergency such as Katrina, which
killed hundreds of people across five states, forced major
evacuations and caused untold property damage.
Disaster planning must be a "national security priority," he
said, while ordering the Homeland Security Department to undertake
an immediate review of emergency plans in every major American
city.
"Our cities must have clear and up-to-date plans for
responding to natural disasters and disease outbreaks or a
terrorist attack, for evacuating large numbers of people in
an emergency and for providing the food and water and security
they would need," Bush said.
He acknowledged that government agencies lacked coordination
and were overwhelmed by Katrina and the subsequent flooding
of New Orleans. He said a disaster on this scale requires greater
federal authority and a broader role for the armed forces.
He ordered all Cabinet secretaries to join in a comprehensive
review of the government's faulty response.
"When the federal government fails to
meet such an obligation, I as president am responsible for
the problem, and for the solution," Bush said, looking
into the camera that broadcast his speech live on the major
television networks from historic Jackson Square in the heart
of the French Quarter. "This government will learn the
lessons of Hurricane Katrina."
Bush faced the nation at a vulnerable point in his presidency.
Most Americans disapprove of his handling of Katrina, and his
job-approval rating has been dragged down to the lowest point
of his presidency also because of dissatisfaction with the
Iraq war and rising gasoline prices. He has struggled to demonstrate
the same take-charge leadership he displayed after the Sept.
11 terror attacks four years ago.
In his speech, the president called for a congressional investigation
besides the administration's self-examination. [...]
House Speaker Dennis Hastert, R-Ill.,
speaking after the president's address, acknowledged that
the recovery programs would add to the nation's debt. GOP
leaders are open to suggestions from lawmakers to cut government
spending elsewhere, but the task is urgent, he said.
"For every dollar we spend on this means a dollar that's
going to take a little bit longer to balance the budget," Hastert
said.
Congress already has approved $62 billion for the disaster,
but that is expected to run out next month.
Even before Bush spoke, some fiscal conservatives
expressed alarm at the prospect of such massive federal outlays
without cutting other spending.
"It is inexcusable for the White House and Congress to
not even make the effort to find at least some offsets to this
new spending," said Sen. Tom Coburn, R-Okla. "No
one in America believes the federal government is operating
at peak efficiency and can't tighten its belt."
Bush repeated a hotline number, 1-877-568-3317, for people
to call to help reunite family members separated during the
hurricane. Moments later, Sen. John Kerry, D-Mass., criticized
Bush, saying "Leadership isn't a speech or a toll-free
number."
"No American doubts that New Orleans will rise again," Kerry
said. "They doubt the competence and commitment of this
administration."
Bush proposed establishment of worker recovery accounts providing
up to $5,000 for job training, education and child care during
victims' search for employment. He also
proposed creation of a Gulf Opportunity Zone in Louisiana,
Mississippi and Alabama offering tax breaks to encourage businesses
to stay in the devastated region and new businesses to open.
Bush said the goal was to get evacuees out of shelters by
mid-October and into apartments and other homes, with assistance
from the government. He said he would work with Congress to
ensure that states were reimbursed for the cost of caring for
evacuees.
He also said he would ask Congress to approve an Urban Homesteading
Act in which surplus federal property would be turned over
to low-income citizens by means of a lottery to build homes,
with mortgages or assistance from charitable organizations. |
WASHINGTON - Former US president Bill
Clinton sharply criticised George W. Bush for the Iraq War
and the handling of Hurricane Katrina, and voiced alarm at
the swelling US budget deficit.
Breaking with tradition under which US presidents mute
criticisms of their successors, Clinton
said the Bush administration had decided to invade Iraq "virtually
alone and before UN inspections were completed, with no real
urgency, no evidence that there
were weapons of mass destruction."
The Iraq war diverted US attention from the war on terrorism "and
undermined the support that we might have had," Clinton
said in an interview with an ABC's "This Week" programme.
Clinton said there had been a "heroic but so far unsuccessful" effort
to put together a constitution that would be universally supported
in Iraq.
The US strategy of trying to develop the Iraqi military and
police so that they can cope without US support "I think
is the best strategy. The problem is we may not have, in the
short run, enough troops to do that," said Clinton.
On Hurricane Katrina, Clinton faulted the authorities' failure
to evacuate New Orleans ahead of the storm's strike on August
29.
People with cars were able to heed the evacuation order,
but many of those who were poor, disabled or elderly were left
behind.
"If we really wanted to do it right, we would have had
lots of buses lined up to take them out," Clinton.
He agreed that some responsibility for this
lay with the local and state authorities, but pointed the finger,
without naming him, at the former director of the Federal Emergency
Management Agency (FEMA).
FEMA boss Michael Brown quit in response to criticism of
his handling of the Katrina disaster. He was viewed as a political
appointee with no experience of disaster management or dealing
with government officials.
"When James Lee Witt ran FEMA, because he had been both
a local official and a federal official, he was always there
early, and we always thought about that," Clinton said,
referring to FEMA's head during his 1993-2001 presidency.
"But both of us came out of environments with a disproportionate
number of poor people."
On the US budget, Clinton warned that
the federal deficit may be coming untenable, driven
by foreign wars, the post-hurricane recovery programme and
tax cuts that benefitted just the richest one percent of
the US population, himself included.
"What Americans need to understand is
that ... every single day of the year, our government goes
into the market and borrows money from other countries to finance
Iraq, Afghanistan, Katrina, and our tax cuts," he said.
"We have never done this before. Never
in the history of our republic have we ever financed a conflict,
military conflict, by borrowing money from somewhere else."
Clinton added: "We depend on Japan, China, the United
Kingdom, Saudi Arabia, and Korea primarily to basically loan
us money every day of the year to cover my tax cut and these
conflicts and Katrina. I don't think it makes any sense." |
It has been one month and one week since I sat in a ditch
in Crawford, Tx. I can hardly believe it when I think of
it myself. So much has happened in that time, and really,
so little.
I got to Camp Casey III in Covington, La today, after getting
up at 3am to head for the airport. Now it is 3am the next day
and we are driving in a car to try and find a hotel to sleep
anywhere around Jackson, Miss. I was prepared to be shocked
by what I saw in Louisiana, but I guess one can never really
fully prepare for such devastation and tragedy. After living
in a country your entire life it is so difficult to see such
callous indifference on an immense scale. When
I reflect on how the mother of the imbecile who is running
our country said that the people who are in the Astrodome are
happy to be there, it angers me beyond comparison. The
people in LA who were displaced have nice, if modest homes
that are perfectly fine. I wonder why the government made them
leave at great expense and uproot families who have been living
in their communities for generations.
After we arrived at Camp Casey III, we took the Veterans for
Peace "Impeachment Tour Bus" into New Orleans after
stopping at the distribution center to pick up some supplies
in Covington. The stench and the destruction are unbelievable. I
saw some hurricane zones in the panhandle of Florida last year
that were pretty bad but that couldn't have prepared me for
this.
I saw in the paper that George Bush said the recovery in the
Gulf States would be "hard work." That's what he
said about sending troops to Iraq and looking at the casualty
reports everyday: "It's hard work." That
man has never known a day of hard work in his life. The
people on the ground in Covington scoffed at George's little
junket to Louisiana yesterday. He stayed in the French
Quarter and a Ward that weren't even damaged a bit. The VFP
took me to the city of Algiers on the West Bank. The part of
Algiers we went to was very poor and black. The people of Algiers
know what hard work is.
Algiers had no flooding. All of the damage was from winds.
There are trees knocked over and shingles off of roofs. There
are signs blown over and there was a dead body lying on the
ground for 2 weeks before someone finally came to get it. Even
though Algiers came through Katrina relatively unscathed, our
federal government tried to force (mostly successfully) the
people out of the community. Malik Rahim, a new friend of ours
and resident of Algiers, told us stories of the days after
the hurricane. The government declared
martial law, but there was no effective police presence to
enforce it. Malik said the lawlessness was rampant. People
were running out of food and water and they were being forced
to go to the Superdome. They didn't want to go to the Superdome,
because their homes were pretty intact: they wanted to stay
and have food and water brought to them. A town of 76,000 people
dwindled down to 3,000. The die hards were rewarded last Wednesday
when the VFP rolled into town with food and water. The
Camp Casey III people were the first ones to bring any relief
to Algiers. The people who were supposed to look after its
citizens, our government, failed them.
In Algiers, in the space of 2 short weeks, Malik and his community
has opened a clinic which also doubles as a food and supply
distribution center. We need more help in Algiers. Malik and
the other dozens of fine volunteers are planning on opening
2 more clinics in Algiers and Malik would dearly love someone
to give him a flat bottomed boat so he can go to the flood
drenched poor communities that still have not been helped and
bring them food, supplies, and medical attention. Medical professionals
are dearly needed. Malik has also set up a communications center
in an apartment next to his house which is for the community
to use. The aid that is being given in Algiers is completely
driven by the needs of the community. They have a saying in
Algiers: Not Charity, Solidarity.
The citizens of Algiers desperately needed help and hope before
the hurricane. When I think of how many other poor neighborhoods
are being decimated and made so desperate and hopeless by the
failed policies of the Bush administration, it makes me so
angry. But when I see what the people
of Algiers are doing to help themselves and the people of America
are doing to help them help themselves, it gives me hope. I
think Algiers can be a model for all of our communities.
One thing that truly troubled me about my visit to Louisiana
was the level of the military presence there. I imagined before
that if the military had to be used in a CONUS (Continental
US) operations that they would be there to help the citizens:
Clothe them, feed them, shelter them, and protect them. But
what I saw was a city that is occupied. I saw soldiers walking
around in patrols of 7 with their weapons slung on their backs.
I wanted to ask one of them what it would take for one of them
to shoot me. Sand bags were removed from private property to
make machine gun nests.
The vast majority of people who were looting in New Orleans
were doing so to feed their families or to get resources to
get their families out of there. If I had a store with an inventory
of insured belongings, and a tragedy happened, I would fling
my doors open and tell everyone to take what they need: it
is only stuff. When our fellow citizens
are told to "shoot to kill" other fellow citizens
because they want to stay alive, that is military and governmental
fascism gone out of control. What I saw today in Algiers
lifted up my spirits, but what I also saw today in Algiers
frightened me terribly.
The people who are running the clinic in Algiers gave me a
list of desperately needed supplies:
- Blood pressure medication---properly packaged.
- Allergy medication---properly packaged
- Vitamin B
- Pens, paper, sharpies, index cards
- Glucometers and test strips
- Full O2 tanks
- Power strips and extension cords
- Non-DEET insect repellent
- Mini bottles of Hand Sanitizer
- A copy machine is urgently needed
- People: Call: 512-297-1049
Send supplies to:
Fed Ex or UPS
Veterans for Peace Ch 116
C/O 645 Kimbro Dr.
Baton Rouge, La. 70808
Mark them: For the Medical Clinic in Algiers
The children in Algiers have also been out of school. Malik
would like to open a school and they need school supplies and
teachers.
I have a testimony from a doctor that came to Louisiana to
help that I will post tomorrow. The failure in every level
of our government is criminal negligence. Tens of thousands
of families in our country have been devastated because of
the incompetence and callousness of our so-called leadership.
America is stepping up to the plate to help Americans. America
stepped up to the plate to hold George accountable for the
abomination in Iraq. One thing George
has taught us is that we are self-sufficient and we have a
country that is worth fighting for and we are not going away.
I was told that Pat Boone was on a conservative
radio talk show in San Francisco (yes they
do exist) with Melanie Morgan (who has
a vendetta against me) and he told the
listeners that after we "stole the
supplies" from the Red Cross, we gave
them to the "enemies of America who
are like the people who want to fly airplanes
into our buildings." Boone
says that we were giving them to enemies
of America, because we were distributing
the supplies from a Mosque. First of all,
accusing me of stealing is slander, I think,
and second of all: we were helping Americans.
Just because their government abandoned
them, we shouldn't feed them and give them
medicine and supplies? I thought Pat Boone
was supposed to be a Christian man? Thirdly,
isn't Freedom of Religion one of our Constitutional
guarantees?
It is a Christ-like principle to feed the hungry, clothe the
naked, and shelter the homeless. That's what is happening in
Algiers and other places in Louisiana...but by the people of
America, not the so-called "Christians" in charge. If
George Bush truly listened to God and read the words of the
Christ, Iraq and the devastation in New Orleans would have
never happened.
I don't care if a human being is black, brown, white, yellow
or pink. I don't care if a human being is Christian, Muslim,
Jew, Buddhist, or pagan. I don't care what flag a person salutes:
if a human being is hungry, then it is up to another human
being to feed him/her. George Bush needs
to stop talking, admit the mistakes of his all around failed
administration, pull our troops out of occupied New Orleans
and Iraq, and excuse his self from power. The
only way America will become more secure is if we have a new
administration that cares about Americans even if they don't
fall into the top two percent of the wealthiest. |
WASHINGTON - President Bush's push to
give the military a bigger role in responding to major disasters
like Hurricane Katrina could lead to a loosening of legal limits
on the use of federal troops on U.S. soil.
Pentagon officials are reviewing that possibility,
and some in Congress agree it needs to be considered.
Bush did not define the wider role he envisions for the military.
But in his speech to the nation from New Orleans on Thursday,
he alluded to the unmatched ability of federal troops to provide
supplies, equipment, communications, transportation and other
assets the military lumps under the label of "logistics."
The president called the military "the
institution of our government most capable of massive logistical
operations on a moment's notice."
At question, however, is how far to push the military role,
which by law may not include actions that can be defined as
law enforcement - stopping traffic, searching people, seizing
property or making arrests. That prohibition is spelled out
in the Posse Comitatus Act of enacted after the Civil War mainly
to prevent federal troops from supervising elections in former
Confederate states.
Speaking on the Senate floor Thursday, Sen.
John Warner, R-Va., chairman of the Armed Services Committee,
said, "I believe the time has come that we reflect on
the Posse Comitatus Act." He advocated
giving the president and the secretary of defense "correct
standby authorities" to manage disasters.
Presidents have long been reluctant to deploy U.S. troops
domestically, leery of the image of federal troops patrolling
in their own country or of embarrassing state and local officials.
The active-duty elements that Bush did send to Louisiana
and Mississippi included some Army and Marine Corps helicopters
and their crews, plus Navy ships. The main federal ground forces,
led by troops of the 82nd Airborne Division from Fort Bragg,
N.C., arrived late Saturday, five days after Katrina struck.
They helped with evacuations and performed search-and-rescue
missions in flooded portions of New Orleans but did not join
in law enforcement operations.
The federal troops were led by Lt. Gen. Russel Honore. The
governors commanded their National Guard soldiers, sent from
dozens of states.
Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld is reviewing a wide
range of possible changes in the way the military could be
used in domestic emergencies, spokesman Lawrence Di Rita said
Friday. He said these included possible
changes in the relationship between federal and state military
authorities.
Under the existing relationship, a state's governor is chiefly
responsible for disaster preparedness and response.
Governors can request assistance from the Federal Emergency
Management Agency. If federal armed forces are brought in to
help, they do so in support of FEMA, through the U.S. Northern
Command, which was established in 2002 as part of a military
reorganization after the 9/11 attacks.
Di Rita said Rumsfeld has not made recommendations to Bush,
but among the issues he is examining is the viability of the
Posse Comitatus Act. Di Rita called it
one of the "very archaic laws" from a different era
in U.S. history that limits the Pentagon's flexibility in responding
to 21st century domestic crises.
Another such law, Di Rita said, is the Civil War-era Insurrection
Act, which Bush could have invoked to waive the law enforcement
restrictions of the Posse Comitatus Act. That would have enabled
him to use either National Guard soldiers or active-duty troops
- or both - to quell the looting and other lawlessness that
broke out in New Orleans.
The Insurrection Act lets the president call troops into
federal action inside the United States whenever "unlawful
obstructions, combinations or assemblages - or rebellion against
the authority of the United States - make it impracticable
to enforce the laws" in any state.
The political problem in Katrina was that Bush would have
had to impose federal command over the wishes of two governors
- Kathleen Blanco of Louisiana and Haley Barbour of Mississippi
- who made it clear they wanted to retain state control.
The last time the Insurrection Act was invoked was in 1992
when it was requested by California Gov. Pete Wilson after
the outbreak of race riots in Los Angeles. President George
H.W. Bush dispatched about 4,000 soldiers and Marines.
Di Rita cautioned against expecting quick answers to tough
questions like whether Congress should define when to trigger
the president's authority to send federal troops to take charge
of an emergency, regardless of whether a governor agreed.
"Is there a way to define a threshold, or an anticipated
threshold, above which a different set of relationships would
kick in?" Di Rita asked. "That's a good question.
It's only been two weeks, so don't expect us to have the answers.
But those are the kinds of questions we need to be asking." |
NEW ORLEANS - The mayor of New Orleans
has set up an "extremely problematic" timeline for
allowing residents to return to the evacuated city, which is
still threatened by a weakened levee system, a lack of drinkable
water and heavily polluted floodwaters, the head of the federal
relief effort said Saturday.
Coast Guard Vice Adm. Thad Allen said federal officials
have worked with Mayor Ray Nagin and support his vision for
repopulating the city, but he called Nagin's idea to return
up to 180,000 people to New Orleans in the next week both "extremely
ambitious" and "extremely problematic."
"Our intention is to work with the mayor ... in a very
frank, open and unvarnished manner," Allen told The Associated
Press in an interview at Department of Homeland Security headquarters
in Baton Rouge.
Nagin has announced that the city's Algiers section, the
Garden District and the French Quarter would reopen over the
next week and a half, bringing back more than one-third of
the city's half-million inhabitants. All the areas to be reopened
were spared Katrina's flooding. Electricity and clean water
have been restored to some sections.
Allen said a prime public health concern is the tap water,
which in most of the city remains unfit for drinking and bathing.
He said he was concerned about the difficulties of communicating
the risk of using that water to people who return and might
run out of the bottled water they brought along.
"The water that's there is only good for firefighting
and flushing," he said.
Another concern, Allen said, was the risk of another storm
hitting the region, threatening an already delicate levee system
and possibly requiring residents to be evacuated again.
"Something less than a Category 4 storm is going to
present significant issues that might require the evacuation
of the general population. You want to make sure you have your
arms around how you will do that," he said.
Allen called on the mayor to be "mindful of the risks" and
said he would inform Nagin of his concerns when they meet on
Monday.
Allen was not the only official with doubts about the mayor's
plans.
The mayor's homeland security director, Terry Ebbert, backed
away from Nagin's promise on Friday, saying only that the city
would assess the situation in the French Quarter from "day
to day." Asked repeatedly whether that meant it could
open sooner or later than Sept. 26, he declined to elaborate.
Ebbert said the city's recovery depends on getting businesses
reopened, but he said the repopulation of the city was being
done "in a progressive manner" to ensure the safety
and health of residents. A dusk-to-dawn curfew was planned.
Meanwhile, some business owners were being allowed back into
the city Saturday to get a head start on opening the rollicking
bars, stores and restaurants that keep the good times rolling
in New Orleans.
Margaret Richmond stood watching, tears streaming down her
face, as members of the 82nd Airborne Division used a crowbar
to try to pry open the door of her looted antiques shop on
the edge of the city's upscale Garden District.
The store, Decor Splendide, had been looted in the chaotic
days after Katrina struck. Antique jewelry, a cement angel
with one wing broken off and lamps were lying scattered on
the floor. Someone had wedged a piece of metal in the door
to jam it closed, hoping to deter other looters.
"What they didn't steal they trashed," Richmond
said, gazing through a window of her shop, before the soldiers
were able to break open the door. "They got what they
could and ruined what they left."
Business owners, facing damage that could take months to
repair, said hopes for a quick recovery may be little more
than a political dream.
"I don't know why they said people
could come back and open their businesses," said Richmond,
whose insurance policy will cover the lost merchandise. "You
can't reopen this. And even if you could, there are no customers
here." [...]
These neighborhoods were the lucky ones. They never flooded. Still,
nearly three weeks after Hurricane Katrina, about 40 percent
of the Big Easy was under water.
But that is down from 80 percent after the storm, and engineers
say water is dropping rapidly. While water in some low-lying
areas had been as deep as 20 feet, the deepest water in the
city Friday was 5 feet, exposing still more of the dead.
The death toll along the Gulf Coast rose
to 816, including 579 in Louisiana.
Security will be tight in the reopened neighborhoods, with
Nagin and others vowing never again to let New Orleans slip
into the lawlessness that gripped the city in the days after
the storm. This week, he warned potential looters that soldiers
carry M-16 rifles "and they might have a few bazookas
we're saving for spec people." |
NEW YORK - British Prime Minister Tony
Blair has complained privately to media tycoon Rupert Murdoch
that the BBC's coverage of Hurricane Katrina carried an anti-American
bias, Murdoch said at a conference here.
Murdoch, chairman of the media conglomerate News Corporation,
recounted a conversation with the British leader at a panel
discussion late Friday hosted by former president Bill Clinton.
"Tony Blair -- perhaps I shouldn't repeat this conversation
-- told me yesterday that he was in Delhi last week. And he
turned on the BBC world service to see what was happening in
New Orleans," Murdoch was quoted as saying in a transcript
posted on the Clinton Global Initiative website.
"And he said it was just full of hate
of America and gloating about our troubles. And that was his
government. Well, his government-owned thing," he said
of the publicly owned broadcaster.
Murdoch went on to say that anti-American
bias was prevalent throughout Europe.
"I think we've got to do a better job at answering it.
And there's a big job to do. But you're not going to ever turn
it around totally," said Murdoch, one of three media magnates
who spoke at Clinton's "Global Initiative" forum
on peace and development.
The former US president, who held his conference to coincide
with the United Nations summit in New York, agreed that the
BBC's coverage was lacking.
While the BBC's reports on the hurricane were factually accurate,
its presentation was "stacked up" to criticize President
George W Bush's handling of the disaster, Clinton said.
"There is nothing factually inaccurate. But ... it was
designed to be almost exclusively a hit on the federal response,
without showing what anybody at any level was doing that was
also miraculous, going on simultaneously in a positive way," Clinton
said.
Blair's remarks, as reported by Murdoch, are sure to aggravate
the already difficult relations between the prime minister's
government and the BBC. [...]
A former BBC foreign correspondent and MP,
Martin Bell, defended the BBC's coverage of the hurricane and
alleged that Blair was trying to curry favor with a powerful
media owner who controls important British newspapers.
"Tony Blair was telling Murdoch what
he wanted to hear because he needs Murdoch's support," Bell
was quoted as saying by British media.
The BBC said it had received no complaint from Downing Street
about its coverage.
Blair's office declined to comment. |
UP
IN FLAMES
Tons of British aid donated to help Hurricane Katrina victims
to be BURNED by Americans |
From Ryan Parry, US Correspondent
in New York
The Mirror
19 September 2005 |
HUNDREDS of tons of British
food aid shipped to America for starving Hurricane Katrina
survivors is to be burned.
US red tape is stopping it from reaching hungry
evacuees.
Instead tons of the badly needed Nato ration
packs, the same as those eaten by British troops in Iraq, has
been condemned as unfit for human consumption.
And unless the bureaucratic mess is cleared up
soon it could be sent for incineration.
One British aid worker last night called the
move "sickening senselessness" and said furious colleagues
were "spitting blood".
The food, which cost British taxpayers millions,
is sitting idle in a huge warehouse after the Food and Drug
Agency recalled it when it had already left to be distributed.
Scores of lorries headed back to a warehouse
in Little Rock, Arkansas, to dump it at an FDA incineration
plant.
The Ministry of Defence in London said last night
that 400,000 operational ration packs had been shipped to the
US.
But officials blamed the US
Department of Agriculture, which impounded the shipment under
regulations relating to the import and export of meat.
The aid worker, who would not be named, said: "This
is the most appalling act of sickening senselessness while
people starve.
"The FDA has recalled aid
from Britain because it has been condemned as unfit for human
consumption, despite the fact that these are Nato approved
rations of exactly the same type fed to British soldiers in
Iraq.
"Under
Nato, American soldiers are also entitled to eat such rations,
yet the starving of the American South will see them go up
in smoke because of FDA red tape madness." [...]
"Everyone is revolted by the chaotic shambles
the US is making of this crisis. Guys from Unicef are walking
around spitting blood.
"This is utter madness. People have worked
their socks off to get food into the region.
"It is perfectly good Nato approved food
of the type British servicemen have. Yet the FDA are saying
that because there is a meat content and it has come from Britain
it must be destroyed.
"If they are trying to argue there is a
BSE reason then that is ludicrously out of date. There is more
BSE in the States than there ever was in Britain and UK meat
has been safe for years."
The Ministry of Defence said: "We
understand there was a glitch and these packs have been impounded
by the US Department of Agriculture under regulations relating
to the import and export of meat.
"The situation is changing all the time
and at our last meeting on Friday we were told progress was
being made in relation to the release of these packs. The Americans
certainly haven't indicated to us that there are any more problems
and they haven't asked us to take them back."
Food from Spain and Italy is
also being held because it fails to meet US standards and has
been judged unfit for human consumption.
And Israeli relief agencies
are furious that thousands of gallons of pear juice are to
be destroyed because it has been judged unfit.
The FDA said: "We did inspect some MREs
(meals ready to eat) on September 13. They are the only MREs
we looked at. There were 70 huge pallets of vegetarian MREs.
"They were from a foreign nation. We inspected
them and then released them for distribution." |
In a September 3rd press
release, Louisiana's Senator Mary Landrieu said the following
about the Bush administration and the "relief effort":
But perhaps the greatest disappointment stands at the
breached 17th Street levee. Touring this critical site
yesterday with the President, I
saw what I believed to be a real and significant effort
to get a handle on a major cause of this catastrophe. Flying
over this critical spot again this morning, less than 24
hours later, it became apparent
that yesterday we witnessed a hastily prepared stage set
for a Presidential photo opportunity; and the desperately
needed resources we saw were this morning reduced to a
single, lonely piece of equipment.
It seems that Landrieu was a first hand witness to the extreme
cynicism of the Bush administration when it comes to honesty
and respect for human life. What is patently obvious is that
people like Bush, Cheney, Rumsfeld and Rove care only for appearances
and ensuring that the public continues to think their leaders
are decent human beings when in fact nothing could be further
from the truth.
How many more acts of unmitigated callousness will it take
before people start to accept the fact that the idea that our
leaders actually give a damn about the life of the average
citizen is simply not true, and never was. |
A 64-year-old Alabamian frets about frayed
race relations. A Utah software programmer ponders the slow
government response to Hurricane Katrina and decides he'll
turn to his church first in a disaster created by nature or
terrorists.
A woman scraping by on disability pay in northern Virginia
puts her house on the market because of surging post-storm
gas and food prices. Cheaper to live in Pennsylvania, she
figures.
As the Gulf Coast braces for another monster storm, a new
Associated Press-Ipsos poll shows Katrina prompted a rethinking
of some signature issues in American life - changing the way
we view race and our safety, how we spend our money, even where
we live.
The poll shows that issues swirling around Katrina trump other
national concerns.
Asked to rank eight topics that should
be priorities for President Bush and Congress, respondents
placed the economy, gas prices and Iraq high.
But when Katrina recovery was added to the list, it swamped
everything else.
Like bands of the storm itself, Katrina's reach in American
life is vast: 1 in 3 Americans believes the slow response will
harm race relations. Two-thirds say surging
gas prices will cause hardship for their families. Half say
the same of higher food prices.
In Las Cruces, N.M., Ariana Darley relies on carpools to get
to parenting classes, or to make doctor's appointments with
her 1-year-old son, Jesse. Before, she chipped in $5 for gas.
Now, she pays $10 to $15.
"I didn't think it would affect me," she says by
telephone, with Jesse crying in the background. "But it
costs a lot of money now. I have to go places, and now it adds
up."
After a crisis with indisputable elements of race and class
- searing images of mostly poor, mostly black New Orleans residents
huddled on rooftops or waiting in lines for buses - some Americans
worry about strains in the nation's social fabric. [...]
The poll underscores the literal reach of Katrina as well:
55 percent of Americans say evacuees from Katrina have turned
up in their cities or communities, raising concerns about living
conditions for the refugees, vanishing jobs for locals and
- among 1 in 4 respondents - increased crime.
Among respondents with incomes under $25,000 per year, 56
percent were concerned about living conditions for refugees
in shelters; that was higher than among those who make more
money. And the poll indicates people in the South, which has
absorbed huge masses of evacuees, are most concerned about
the costs to their local governments.
Ann McMullen, 52, of Killeen, Texas, who works as a school
administrator at Fort Hood, says she worries about gang violence,
simply because of the prodigious numbers of people flowing
into Texas communities.
"They can't even locate the sex offenders," she
says. "And every population has gang members. It's theft,
it's murder, it's more chaotic crimes in the community. Hopefully
we'll be able to put these people back to work."
The poll also exposes a divide among Americans in how the
government should respond when disasters strike areas particularly
prone to catastrophe - landslides, earthquakes, hurricanes. Half
say the government should give people in those zones money
for recovery, but almost as many say those people should live
there at their own risk.
About 4 in 10 say the government should prohibit people from
building new homes in those endangered areas in the first place.
As McMullen puts it: "You're asking for another disaster
to happen."
Katrina has also raised grave doubts among Americans about
just who will protect them in the aftermath of a natural disaster
or a terrorist attack.
Only about a quarter of Americans believe the federal government
was as prepared as it should have been to cope with a disaster
of Katrina's magnitude. Only slightly more than half, 54 percent,
are confident in the federal government's ability to handle
a future major disaster. [...]
For Pam Koren, the storm's impact has been more immediate
- and more drastic.
Suffering from low blood sugar, spasms of the esophagus and
nerve damage, she exists now on disability pay and contributions
from her daughter, who attends college and works as an assistant
youth minister.
With gas and food prices rising after the storm, she says,
she was forced to put her house in Burke, Va., on the market.
She is considering east-central Pennsylvania, and a less expensive
home.
"I'm a wreck because I'm not sure I'm making the right
decision," she says. "I didn't want to have to do
this, but things have become so tight I have not had a choice.
I did not expect things were going to get this bad."
The poll of 1,000 adults conducted by Ipsos, an international
polling company, had a margin of potential sampling error of
plus or minus 3 percentage points. |
Major contracts
for the Hurricane Katrina clean-up have been awarded without
bidding or with limited competition, prompting controversy
in the United States.
The devastating storm created contracts worth more than $1.5bn
awarded by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) alone.
Most are for the clearing of debris, trees and shattered homes
across the ravaged Gulf coast.
But more than 80% of those awarded by FEMA were reportedly handed
out with limited competition.
Two major companies
in particular have raised questions – the
Shaw Group and Kellogg, Brown & Root,
a subsidiary of Halliburton, formerly headed
by Vice President Dick Cheney.
"When you do something like this, you do increase
the vulnerability for fraud, plain waste, abuse
and mismanagement," Richard Skinner, inspector
general for the Department of Homeland Security,
told the New York Times.
"We are very apprehensive about what we are seeing."
He said many deals appeared to have been clinched with little
more than a handshake and that shortcuts may have resulted in
a lot of waste.
Various industry and government officials have questioned the
costs of debris-removal contracts, claiming that the Army Corps
of Engineers allowed a rate that was too high, the newspaper
reports.
It cites government records which show that more than 15 contracts
exceed $100m, including five of $500m or more.
Congressional investigators are reportedly investigating the
$568m awarded to AshBritt, a Florida-based company that was a
client of the former lobbying firm of Republican Mississippi
Governor Haley Barbour.
It also notes considerable price disparities, for example trailers
costing anything between $15,000 and $23,000 and house inspection
services that could cost $15 to $81 per home.
Several companies awarded valuable contracts have attracted controversy
for similar work elsewhere.
Among them, Kellogg, Brown & Root – which
has been given contracts worth $60m – was
rebuked by auditors for unsubstantiated
billing for reconstruction work in Iraq.
The company will perform more than $45m in repairs to levees
in New Orleans and military facilities in the region. A spokesperson
was unavailable for comment. |
By now, I think everyone has fully catalogued the multitude
of ways in which Katrina will change everything. Ornery contrarian
that I am, I've become pretty convinced that Katrina will
change nothing (except, well, New Orleans, Gulfport, etc.)
in the long term. That said, the strongest candidate for
Katrina Makeover so far has been: The media. The rise of
a "new," "adversarial" media is the most
viral meta-meme making the rounds. I predict it'll be dead
before New Orleans is dry. I'll explain why, but first, a
quick survey:
New
York magazine: "In many ways, [Anderson] Cooper
and [Brian] Williams defined a fork in the road for the
future of broadcast journalism."
The
New York Times (9/5/05): "CNN…and National
Public Radio…both found their voices amidst the
chaos."
The New York Times ("Reporters Turn From Deference
To Outrage" 9/5/05): "...it is clear that television
is having a major mood swing."
USA Today "Katrina
Rekindles Adversarial Media" (9/5/05): "Reporters
covering Hurricane Katrina on the scene showed their
human - and often angry and frustrated - face as they
questioned the slow response over the weekend…
"Says Fordham University communications professor
Paul Levinson, 'The media rose to the occasion, shone their
light on the desolation and the needy, and kept it focused
there until the cavalry finally began to arrive.'
"...some observers say that Katrina's media legacy
may be a return to a post-Watergate-like era of tougher
scrutiny of the federal government and public policy issues.
"'If any good comes from the catastrophe, it will
be that it signaled the beginning of the media's reassertion
of aggressive, in-your-face reporting, in which it confronts
government wrongdoing, rather than just swallowing the
government's public-relations handouts,' Levinson says."
USA
Today (also Peter Johnson, but later in the day): "...experts
and journalists predict that mounting questions about
U.S. government preparation, policies and response to
Hurricane Katrina will result in intense news coverage
for months.
"Katrina 'doesn't just have legs, it has tentacles,'
says Bob Lichter of the Center for Media and Public Affairs.
'Its implications reach into hot-button controversies involving
race, poverty, economics and partisan politics. The reach
of this story will make the O.J. Simpson case look like
a news brief.'"
Milwaukee
Journal-Sentinel (9/6/05): "...reporters and
anchors have been asking tough questions in combative
and even angry tones."
SF
Indymedia (9/6/05): "Not for decades has there
been such merciless questioning of the president and
his administration by the U.S. media."
Reuters (9/7/05): "American
TV reporters and newscasters are covering Hurricane Katrina
and problem-plagued relief efforts with a sense of outrage
and antagonism many thought had long gone out of fashion
in broadcast journalism."
Chicago Tribune "A
Cronkite Moment in the Gulf Story" (9/9/05): "...we
might be witnessing something no one thought was possible
in this age. This may be a Cronkite Moment."
Boston
Phoenix (9/9/05): "...it took a hurricane to
wake up the press, raise the issue of race and class,
and redefine the political landscape.
"Hurricane Katrina did not simply destroy physical
infrastructure, social fabric, and countless lives on America's
Gulf Coast. It blew away the ground rules that had defined
post-9/11 American politics and protected the most polarizing
administration in recent history…
"All the elements that George W. Bush and Karl Rove
had exploited for political gain - a timid and kowtowing
mainstream media, a deafening silence about America's growing
underclass, the fear that criticizing the White House in
the era of Al Qaeda was tantamount to treason, and Bush's
can-do, cowboy image - were shattered by the same winds
and rains that savaged casinos in Biloxi and homes in Jefferson
Parish."
USA
Today (9/11/05): "ABC News executive Paul Slavin
[says] 'Katrina has uncovered grave weaknesses in this
country's ability to handle a crisis, and we need to
make sure we hold officials accountable and investigate
as best we can both what happened and what might happen.'"
Salon even posted a "Reporters
Gone Wild" compilation reel.
So, what does the post-Katrina news media look like? In condensed
form, the storyline goes like this: Their "timid and kowtowing" nature
"shattered" by Katrina, the "rekindled" media
are "asking tough questions," shining "their
light on the desolation and the needy" with "merciless
questioning of the president and his administration" in "a
return to a post-Watergate-like era of tougher scrutiny of
the federal government and public policy issues" "with
a sense of outrage and antagonism many thought had long gone
out of fashion" and "aggressive, in-your-face reporting,
in which it confronts government wrongdoing;" "something
no one thought was possible in this age... a Cronkite moment," complete
with "reporters gone wild."
Wow. That's amazing. And indicative of a grave misunderstanding
of some elemental forces that shape news media's editorial
judgment. This mistake about the media will, very quickly,
come to be seen just as ironically as we now consider the post-9/11
obituaries for irony itself.
Katrina became a media storm for a very simple
reason: Its sheer magnitude overwhelmed the fundamentally flawed
media levee known by the misnomer of "objectivity." My
personal theory is that Watergate, rather than inspiring investigative
journalism, inspired a generation of people who became journalists
not to challenge power, but to gain the fame that comes with
journalism's podium.
Look past the headlines of the stories I've posted above,
and you'll see in them the seeds for the return of old-time,
useless "journalism." Here are a couple important
points SF Indymedia made, though I think the author missed
the meaning of the former:
"Never before, say some observers, have US reporters
been so emotionally involved in a story to the point of
being enraged."
"They are not just telling a story, they have become
part of it."
"'Has Katrina saved the US media,?' asked BBC reporter
Matt Wells who sees the shift in tone as a potentially
historic development."
"A number of US journalists who cover federal politics,
especially television presenters, had become part of the
political establishment, says Wells."
"'They live in the same suburbs, go to the same parties.
Their television companies are owned by large conglomerates
who contribute to election campaigns.'"
"It's a 'perfect recipe' for fearful, self-censoring
reportage, he says, but thinks 'since last week, that's
all over'."
No, it's not. And the reason is that after Katrina, the same
reporters who were emotionally engaged, and outraged, will
return to their desks and their bureaus. And their suburbs.
And their parties.
The emotional root of The New Adversarialism
is just one reason it will be short-lived; such high-pitched
feelings can't and won't last (and shouldn't: Journalists
who really cared about Katrina's victims would have wept
less afterward and done more boring, public-policy stories
beforehand). Nikki
Finke in the LA Weekly attributes the death of The New
Adversarialism to corporate politics. But even more profoundly
at work here is the dynamic of how the media engage not with
emotion but with the nature of reality itself.
Yes, this was the first time many of these reporters and journalists
saw such conditions on U.S. soil, but the reason that translated
into outrage had to do not with emotion, but fact and objectivity.
This was the first story in which a critical mass of high-level,
decision-making media were on the ground to witness X and have
government officials tell them to their face "-X."
It was the first time they were directly, personally cognizant
of the Bush administration's willingness to lie to their face
about matters they could verify instantly with their own eyes.
This was a shocking event. It was an outrage. Look at who
was outraged: Primarily reporters on the ground. The
schism at Fox News was not between secret liberals and true
conservatives, it was between Shepard Smith knee-deep in reality
and Bill O'Reilly back in the studio.
Katrina changed the nature of media coverage because it overcame
the media not emotionally but epistemologically. If
human suffering were the sole trigger for media outrage, why
have the past few years' rising poverty rate - casting millions
of Americans into squalor and despair - not unleashed the same
fury Katrina did? It's because
the causal nature of the former is more elusive than the latter.
That cognitive distance between cause and effect guarantees
the old media will return far too soon.
Why? Media decision-makers don't understand very well themselves
why Bush budget policies are factually, objectively, inarguably
biased toward the rich: Hence, they won't articulate, let alone
explain, that position to their viewers. Media decision-makers
don't understand very well themselves not just why evolution
is real but must be real: Hence, they wrongly assume they're
fulfilling their responsibilities by presenting "both" "sides," when
they're actually abdicating their responsibilities by treating
one "side" as though it's credible. A
journalist's job is not merely to say, "He said/She said." A
good journalist says, "He said/She said, but our investigation/analysis
revealed that Her numbers have a greater claim to factuality
and He has a history of twisting facts." Katrina
did the journalism for them by literally swamping journalists
with irrefutable, unmistakeable facts.
Without a hurricane at their doorstep, the flow of facts fueling
The New Adversarialism will dry up. Don't believe me? It's
already happening. Ask Larry
Johnson. Already, and on the issue of Katrina itself, he's
allegedly been informed by MSNBC that verifiable, quantifiable,
empirical matters of fact are actually matters of "opinion" and "perspective."
On the Daily Show, one of the newest and last TV outlets of
genuine journalism, Brian Williams, The
Transformed Man, was asked who was at fault. "I'm
gonna let that one go," he said. "I don't do opinions,
I'm going to leave it to others." But Brian, dude, it's
not an opinion. It's a matter of law and statute and the performance
of public officials under same. Williams mistakes it for opinion
because he'd have to convey it in the same way he would an
opinion: Not with video of a starving flood survivor, but with
nothing more than his assertion that, yes, NBC has assessed
applicable laws and statutes and determined that Agency X bore
primary responsibility for evacuation coordination and State
Department Y was legally in charge of initial law-enforcement
response and X only provided 72.3% of buses needed and Y failed
to implement maximum-response measures. It feels like an opinion
because it can be disagreed-with (out of dishonesty or ignorance)
but that doesn't obligate Williams to treat it like an opinion.
The ultimate evidence that this is not a Cronkite moment comes
from the simple fact that Cronkite's moment was his declaration
of U.S. woes in Vietnam. It became a Cronkite moment because
Cronkite did not have the luxury of video proving him right
but put his credibility on the line to warn America what the
reality was even though Americans could, out of ignorance or
ideology, reject his assessment in a way they could not reject
video. Katrina gave American media the safety net of objectively
indisputable, immediately verifiable reality. Vietnam did not.
Katrina will actually prove to be the anti-Cronkite moment.
If today's media wants a Cronkite moment, they already have
had several years of opportunity to claim that moment: In Iraq.
That they have failed to do so, that
they still embrace and mistake omni-subjectivity as objectivity,
indicates that we're already returning to the "who-knows-what's-true" school
of anti-journalism journalism that nurtured the growth of
neglectful government that made possible the post-Katrina
woes over which those same journalists wept. And already
it makes those fleeting days of early September - of direct
confrontation and confident assertion of fact - seem positively
antediluvian.
New GNN contributor Jonathan Larsen helped launch Air
America Radio, co-creating and producing "Morning Sedition" and "The
Rachel Maddow Show." Previous credits include "Anderson
Cooper 360," "The Daily Show with Jon Stewart" and
ABC's "World News Now." His blog, Petty Larseny,
can be found here. |
WASHINGTON - A combative Michael Brown
blamed the Louisiana governor, the New Orleans mayor and even
the Bush White House that appointed him for the dismal response
to Hurricane Katrina in a fiery appearance Tuesday before Congress.
In response, lawmakers alternately lambasted and mocked the
former FEMA director.
House members' scorching treatment of Brown, in a hearing
stretching nearly 6 1/2 hours, underscored how he has become
an emblem of the deaths, lingering floods and stranded survivors
after the Aug. 29 storm. Brown resigned Sept. 12 after being
relieved of his onsite command of the Federal Emergency Management
Agency's response effort three days earlier.
"I'm happy you left," said Rep. Christopher Shay,
R-Conn. "Because that kind of, you know, look in the lights
like a deer tells me that you weren't capable to do the job."
"You get an F-minus in my book," said Rep. Gene
Taylor, D-Miss.
At several points, Brown turned red in the face and slapped
the table in front of him.
"So I guess you want me to be the superhero, to step
in there and take everyone out of New Orleans," Brown
said.
"What I wanted you to do is do your job and coordinate," Shays
retorted.
Well aware of President Bush's sunken poll
ratings, legislators of both parties tried to distance themselves
from the federal preparations for Katrina and the storm's aftermath
that together claimed the lives of more than 1,000 people in
Louisiana, Mississippi and Alabama.
|
Freudian
Slip: actual
Sky News tagline in aftermath of hurricane Rita. |
Brown acknowledged making mistakes during the storm and subsequent
flooding that devastated the Gulf Coast. But he accused New
Orleans Mayor Ray Nagin and Louisiana Gov. Kathleen Blanco,
both Democrats, of fostering chaos and failing to order a mandatory
evacuation more than a day before Katrina hit.
"My biggest mistake was not recognizing by Saturday that
Louisiana was dysfunctional," Brown told a special panel
set up by House Republican leaders to investigate the catastrophe. Most
Democrats, seeking an independent investigation, stayed away
to protest what they called an unfair probe of the Republican
administration by GOP lawmakers.
"I very strongly personally regret that I was unable
to persuade Governor Blanco and Mayor Nagin to sit down, get
over their differences and work together," Brown said. "I
just couldn't pull that off."
Brown also said he warned Bush, White House
chief of staff Andrew Card and deputy chief of staff Joe Hagin
that "this is going to be a bad one" in e-mails and
phone conversations leading up to the storm. Under pointed
questioning, he said some needs outlined to the White House,
Pentagon and Homeland Security Department were not answered
in "the timeline that we requested."
Blanco vehemently denied that she waited until the eve of
the storm to order an evacuation of New Orleans. She said her
order came on the morning of Aug. 27 - two days before the
storm - resulting in 1.3 million people evacuating the city.
"Such falsehoods and misleading statements, made under
oath before Congress, are shocking," Blanco said in a
statement.
In New Orleans, Nagin said that "it's too early to get
into name-blame and all that stuff" but that "a FEMA
director in Washington trying to deflect attention is unbelievable
to me."
White House spokesman Scott McClellan urged Congress to undertake "a
thorough investigation of what went wrong and what went right
and look at lessons learned."
Brown, who remains on FEMA's payroll for two more weeks before
he leaves his annual $148,000 post, rejected accusations that
he was inexperienced for the job he held for more than two
years during which he oversaw 150 presidentially declared disasters.
Before joining FEMA in 2001, he was an attorney, held local
government posts and headed the International Arabian Horse
Association.
"I know what I'm doing, and I think I do a pretty darn
good job of it," he said.
He said FEMA coordinates and manages disaster relief, but
the emergency first response is the job of state and local
authorities. Brown also said the agency was stretched too thin
to respond to a catastrophe of Katrina's size. "We were
prepared but overwhelmed is the best way I can put it," he
said.
Brown described FEMA as a politically powerless
arm of Homeland Security, which he said had siphoned more than
$77 million from his agency over the past three years. Additionally,
he said Homeland Security cut FEMA budget requests - including
one for hurricane preparedness - before they were ever presented
to Congress.
Rep. Harold Rogers, R-Ky., who oversees House spending on
homeland security operations, said Congress has approved spending
levels for FEMA and other preparedness programs far above requests.
In Miami, Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff told
reporters that Brown "speaks for himself and he's entitled
to his point of view, and I don't have anything to add."
Brown's defiant demeanor Tuesday mirrored his comments after
being dismissed from overseeing the Katrina response, when
he accused the news media of making him a scapegoat and blamed
local officials for the uncoordinated response.
He had been "just tired and misspoke" when a television
interviewer appeared to be the first to tell him that there
were desperate residents at the New Orleans Convention Center,
and testified he had already learned the day before that people
were flocking there.
No longer needing to maintain a cordial relationship with
Congress, Brown didn't hesitate to punch back at lawmakers
who questioned whether the government would learn from mistakes
before the next disaster strikes.
"I know what death and destruction is and I know how
much people suffer," Brown told Taylor. "And it breaks
my heart. I pray for these people every night. So don't lecture
me about knowing what disaster is like."
Yet Brown struck a conciliatory tone with Rep. Kay Granger,
R-Texas, who chastised him for not seeking fiscal or oversight
help from Congress before the storm.
"I don't know how you can sleep at night," Granger
said. "You lost the battle."
Brown, his voice dropping slightly, responded: "I
probably should have just resigned my post earlier and gone
public with some of these things because I have a great admiration
for the men and women of FEMA and what they do, and they don't
deserve what they've been getting." |
NEW ORLEANS - Police Superintendent Eddie
Compass stepped down from his post four weeks after Hurricane
Katrina destroyed the city where he grew up and spent 26 years
policing, saying he knew in his heart it was time to walk away.
His resignation follows the storm's turbulent aftermath,
during which looters ransacked stores, evacuees pleaded for
help, rescue workers came under fire and nearly 250 police
officers left their posts.
"Every man in a leadership position must know when it's
time to hand over the reins," he said at a news conference
Tuesday. "I'll be going on in another direction that God
has for me."
Compass, 47, gave no reason for leaving,
saying only that he would be transitioning out of the job over
the next six weeks. Neither he nor Mayor Ray Nagin would say
whether Compass had been pressured to leave his job.
Nagin, who appointed Compass chief in 2002, said it was a
sad day for the city of New Orleans but that the departing
chief "leaves the department in pretty good shape and
with a significant amount of leadership."
On the streets of the Algiers neighborhood, the first in Orleans
Parish to be open to residents, some said Compass' resignation
was a loss for the city.
"He was stretched beyond the limits of human endurance," said
Ruth Marciante, pausing outside a Winn-Dixie supermarket. "Under
the circumstances I think he did a superhuman job. I wish the
next guy who takes that job a lot of luck."
But another Algiers resident, Donald De Bois Blanc, said he
had complained to police about looting in the hurricane's aftermath,
and gotten only shrugs in return.
"I don't think Compass did a terribly good job," he
said. "The department was inept."
Lt. David Benelli, president of the union for rank-and-file
New Orleans officers, said he was shocked by Compass' resignation.
"We've been through a horrendous time," Benelli
said. "We've watched the city we love be destroyed. That
is pressure you can't believe."
Benelli would not criticize Compass.
"You can talk about lack of organization but we have
been through two hurricanes. There was no communications, problems
everywhere," he said. "I think the fact that we did
not lose control of the city is a testament to his leadership."
As the city slipped into anarchy during the first few days
after Katrina, the 1,700-member police department suffered
a crisis. Many officers deserted their posts, and some were
accused of joining in the looting that broke out. Two officers
Compass described as friends committed suicide.
Gunfire and other lawlessness broke out around the city. Rescue
workers reported being shot at. Compass publicly repeated allegations
that people were being beaten and babies raped at the convention
center, where thousands of evacuees had taken shelter. The
allegations have since proved largely unsubstantiated.
Earlier in the day Tuesday, the department confirmed that
about 250 police officers - roughly 15 percent of the force
- could face discipline for leaving their posts without permission
during Katrina and its aftermath.
Even before Katrina hit, Compass had his hands full with an
understaffed police department and a skyrocketing murder rate.
Before Katrina, New Orleans had 3.14 officers per 1,000 residents
- less than half the ratio in Washington, D.C.
The mayor has named Assistant Superintendent Warren Riley
as acting superintendent.
On Tuesday, the state Health Department reported that Katrina's
death toll in Louisiana stood at 885, up from 841 on Friday.
It also was the second day of the official reopening of New
Orleans, which had been pushed back last week when Hurricane
Rita threatened. Nagin welcomed residents back to the Algiers
neighborhood on Monday but imposed a curfew and warned of limited
services.
Nagin also invited business owners in the central business
district, the French Quarter and the Uptown section to inspect
their property and clean up. But he gave no timetable for reopening
those parts of the city to residents. |
Continue
to September 2005
Remember,
we need your help to collect information on what is going on in
your part of the world! We also need help to keep
the Signs of the Times online.
Send
your comments and article suggestions to us
Fair Use Policy Contact Webmaster at signs-of-the-times.org Cassiopaean materials Copyright ©1994-2014 Arkadiusz Jadczyk and Laura Knight-Jadczyk. All rights reserved. "Cassiopaea, Cassiopaean, Cassiopaeans," is a registered trademark of Arkadiusz Jadczyk and Laura Knight-Jadczyk. Letters addressed to Cassiopaea, Quantum Future School, Ark or Laura, become the property of Arkadiusz Jadczyk and Laura Knight-Jadczyk Republication and re-dissemination of our copyrighted material in any manner is expressly prohibited without prior written consent.
|