
© Richard Gardner/Rex Features
Could homeopathy eat further into the NHS budget?
The fortunes of the UK's National Health Service (NHS) are about to be transformed with the help of the magical waters of homeopathic medicine. Top marks to
The Telegraph's science writer
Tom Chivers for quickly picking up on talk that the UK's new health minister, Jeremy Hunt - who replaced Andrew Lansley yesterday in a government reshuffle - thinks that homeopathy works, and should be provided at public expense by the NHS.
Since news of his appointment emerged, senior scientists have spoken up. John Krebs, professor of zoology at the University of Oxford, said: "There is overwhelming evidence that homeopathic medicine is not effective. It would be a real blow for those who want medicine to be science-based if the secretary of state were to promote homeopathy because of his personal beliefs."
Edzard Ernst, former director of complementary medicine at the University of Exeter, UK, added: "To praise the positive contribution of homeopathy to the NHS does not bode well for the new person in charge of UK healthcare. One can only hope that with the reality of the new job, there will be a more rational insight in the actual evidence on this topic."
How did Hunt's views on homeopathy emerge? Firstly, he signed a parliamentary document called an
Early Day Motion back in 2007, supporting the provision of homeopathic medicine by the NHS. Such motions are used routinely as barometers of parliamentary interest in issues - in this case, spending public money on treating people with aqueous solutions
so diluted that they no longer contain a trace of the supposedly active ingredients they began with.
By signing the motion, along with 205 other MPs, Hunt agreed that parliament "welcomes the positive contribution made to the health of the nation by the NHS homeopathic hospitals", and "calls on the government [then Labour] to support these valuable national assets".
Comment: The article fails to mention the obvious connection between inflammation and diet. Instead of inventing new biologic drugs to treat depression, it is better to work on fixing the core problem - a diet high in carbohydrates, gluten, casein, and vegetables.
Depression - Caused by Inflammation, Thus Like Other Diseases of Civilization