This is a response to "Who Controls the Platform?"-a multi-part Quillette series authored by social-media insiders. Submissions related to this series may be directed to pitch@quillette.com.Progressives who claim that "reality has a liberal bias" may be correct on certain issues. But problems emerge when the facts don't co-operate with the liberal narrative. We saw an example recently, when it emerged that actor Jussie Smollett had been formally charged with making up a hoax hate-crime involving MAGA-hat-wearing men assaulting him with bleach, a noose and racist, homophobic epithets. As Quillette's Andy Ngo noted, Smollett's original claim attracted an outpouring of performative sympathy from an all-star cast of liberal grandees. But when it turned out the attack never happened, most of those same commentators kept mum. A similar pattern played out with the boys from Covington Catholic High School caught on video at the Lincoln Memorial: Too often, observers seize on a fashionable narrative and either reject or ignore evidence that falsifies it-because what counts for them is less about the actual truth of a claim, and more about how much on-brand social-media value is associated with boosting it. Call it doublethink or virtue-signaling. But whatever label you choose, the phenomenon has real effects on public policy-as my own experience shows.
Society's Child

U.S. soldiers assigned to the 1st Armored Brigade Cavalry Team, 1st Cavalry Division’s, 91st Brigade Engineer Battalion begin loading their vehicles on rail for transport in Karliki, Poland, Nov. 6, 2018.
A police spokeswoman in Zagan, Anna Kublik-Rosciszewska, said the crash took place Sunday afternoon near Trzebien, on the A18 road as the troops were traveling in the direction of Wroclaw on a routine mission.
She said Monday that six of the troops were hospitalized and that two of them were in serious condition. The seventh was treated on the spot.
The troops are with the 21st Theater Sustainment Command, or TSC, based in Karliki, in Zagan region.
Comment: At least from the details so far, the fault appears to lie with the driver and/or the passengers. What's notable is that this is just the most recent in series of crashes and accidents within the US military:
- The US military's run of fatal accidents: Coincidence or crisis?
- Report: Huge spike in US military non-combat plane crash fatalities in 2017

Even before the coronavirus, living standards had flatlined amid wage stagnation and austerity.
A study by the Resolution Foundation thinktank said UK households had experienced flatlining living standards due to a lack of economic and pay growth in the past two years. Average incomes will not rise materially over the next two years either, it said.
The bleak forecast will hit lower-income families harder, according to the report, and child poverty could exceed previous highs reached in the early 1990s. Deprived families will bear the brunt of weak pay and benefit cuts, the report said.
While weak productivity and pay freezes were holding back living standards for most people, government policy was also hitting more deprived groups. The report noted the final year of the benefit freeze, which will reduce working-age household incomes by £1.5bn, will start in April, while the impact of the two-child limit on benefits will grow over the remainder of this parliament.
Comment: The situation in the UK is dire, and government 'austerity' is only making life worse:
- Shameless: UK MPs to get another pay rise taking the total to £11,000 in just 3 years
- UK's poverty wages, extortionate rents and austerity: Homeless families who work soars 73% in 5 years
- UK poverty: Hungry children 'eating from school bins' - head teacher
- Record 60% of Britons in poverty are in working families - study
- Fraud, deception, laundering - Bailed out banks still behaving badly and no one's stopping them
- The government/Poor leadership 35
- Immigration 19
- Healthcare 6
- Race relations/Racism 5
- Unifying the country 4
- Poverty/Hunger/Homelessness 4
- Environment/Pollution 3
- Ethics/Moral/Religious/Family decline 3
- Federal budget deficit/Federal debt 3
- Economy in general 3
Comment: See also:
- The American People Are Coming to Terms With The Fact That Their Government Is A Dictatorship
- Jackboots in the morning: No one will be spared from the American police state nightmare
- John W. Whitehead: What I don't like about post-9/11 America
- Dictator for Life? America already has one!
The suggestion caught people involved in the event's production, where planning begins at least six months in advance, off guard. "Clear History" didn't exist; it was barely an idea. But organizers still scrambled to build its announcement into Zuckerberg's F8 keynote address. They'd already scrapped plans to unveil Portal, a video calling device that Facebook's leadership thought might be seen as too invasive given the company's predicament.
It was a bold public relations play. And for those familiar with the origins of the Clear History announcement, it demonstrated not only Zuckerberg's unilateral power over product direction, but also Facebook's long history of prioritizing optics and convenience over substantive protections for the people who use it. Company sources who spoke to BuzzFeed News characterized Zuckerberg's proposal as "reactionary," a response intended to ease the negative attention on the company following the Cambridge Analytica firestorm. They also said it might explain why the Clear History tool, whose announcement was proposed on the fly by Zuckerberg, is still not available nearly a year after he introduced it on stage at F8.
Comment: While "clear history" sounds like a nice idea, that Facebook would actually delete the information it has already collected is naive. It might be 'deleted' in so far as you might not be able to access it anymore, but their whole model is based on the sale of information. They're not about to start removing their 'inventory' - ever. And that goes pretty much for all big tech.
In his annual letter, Buffet warned of a "megacatastrophe," which he said will cause unprecedented havoc not just to victims but to the financial world as well. "A major catastrophe that will dwarf hurricanes Katrina and Michael will occur - perhaps tomorrow, perhaps many decades from now," the Berkshire Hathaway CEO wrote. "'The Big One' may come from a traditional source, such as a hurricane or earthquake, or it may be a total surprise involving, say, a cyber attack having disastrous consequences beyond anything insurers now contemplate."
Comment: Elites like Buffet are quite often "in the know", but he isn't saying anything that a regular reader of this site doesn't know already.
After all, the transgender man and gay rights activist had received threats after having a banner year in this conservative town.
In the prior six months, he helped open the city's first gay community center, organized the first gay festival and, after 18 years of failed attempts, helped lead a bruising battle for an ordinance that prohibits discrimination against gays.
For his efforts, a local paper named him Citizen of the Year.
Comment: Another ideologically-possessed and pathological activist trying to hoax their way into the greater reaches of victimhood status. These people should be in institutions, not government.
Do not miss: The Jussie Smollett Hate-Crime Hoax is Nothing New in Trump's America
Schiff and others of his ilk are doing their best to blame the measles outbreak in the U.S. on social media systems that offer anti-vaccine messaging in their "recommended reading and groups" areas.
Comment: From Russiagate to the Jussie Smollett hate crime hoax - and now this, Adam Schiff can be relied upon to behave manipulatively and deceptively EVERY TIME.
In the above report about the letter that Schiff sent off to the heads of Facebook and Google, YouTube (owned by Google) was specifically mentioned as being illustrative of "the problem."
Comment: You Tube, like Google, Facebook and so many high tech and high profile companies are now mostly under the thumb of the most malevolent minds at the Pentagon, Big Pharma, the CIA, NSA, etc. Wholesale control over the minds, souls and bodies of the Western
world has become the sick order of the day.
According to the +972 Magazine, Israel's "State Archives" declassified secret documents last summer, but some 300,000 documents, which antedate the 1948 establishment of the regime, remained classified.
"The very existence of the 300,000 classified files-their names, dates, and origin within the state bureaucracy - had been kept a secret, until now. One-fifth of the files, deemed too sensitive still by the regime, were excluded from the disclosure," the report by Israeli Jewish journalist Asaf Shalev said.
"There were many people who were concerned about the opening of this catalog," Israel's "State Archivist" Yaacov Lozowick was quoted by the website as saying in a statement accompanying the release.
Some of the files, which were kept secret, reportedly date back to 1821, while 125 of them date back to the 19th century and nearly 2,000 papers predate the Nakba (Catastrophe Day). Files on the two most notorious Israeli massacres of Deir Yassin and Kafr Qasim are among the hidden documents, the website said.
This is not an unusual or maladaptive response. In fact, knowing when to stay quiet and knowing how to avoid conflict is a necessary and important part of being an adult. Most arguments are pointless and there is no reason to get into fights with people whom we otherwise want to cooperate with and build mutually beneficial relationships.
Nevertheless, I worry that intellectual self-policing is happening more and more often, particularly for those living in tight-knit and politically homogenous communities. In such environments, challenging the prevailing ideological orthodoxy - even if it's only to plead for more tolerance of diverse viewpoints - can lead to reputational damage, harassment, and, in some cases, career suicide.













Comment: See also: