After all the International Olympic Committee's own Schmid commission had reported that there was no proof of a government organised state sponsored doping conspiracy in Russia, and since the athletes had been cleared of the doping allegations there seemed no reason to exclude them.
In the event sanity - or at least justice - did not prevail. Not only did the International Olympic Committee refuse to allowed the cleared athletes to attend the PyeongChang Games, but Thomas Bach - the IOC President, who is himself a lawyer - not only criticised CAS's decision in intemperate terms but actually called for CAS to be reorganised:
We cannot have a situation of CAS losing its credibility with athletes... We have to do our job to make proposals so trust of the athletes can be restored..... [the CAS] ruling was extremely disappointing and surprising.....We feel that this decision shows the urgent need for reforms in the internal structure of CAS.....















Comment: It's truly outrageous, but it appears that almost no one feels any outrage about it.