© Fotolia
Would you consider the shutting down of an entire national economy for a disease such as the Black Death, which between 1347-1351 killed an estimated
60% of the population in the areas where it spread, to be a proportionate response? What about for a virus which carries — at the very most (see below) — a mortality rate of 1.4% for those who contract it?
Such decisions should be weighed in the balances. In the left-hand side, there is the number of people who could die from the illness, the burden this will place on the health care system and other vital services, and the consequent misery and devastation this will cause to individuals, to families, to businesses, and to society at large. In the right-hand side, there is the possibility of economic collapse, with the mass job losses, destruction of businesses, and extreme poverty this would bring for many.
For something like the Black Death, it is something of a no-brainer. If you don't shut down everything very quickly, not only will people start dropping dead like flies, but the economy you are attempting to save will soon have nobody to work in it. If you were foolish enough to try to keep your economy running during such a situation,
you'd end up with the worst of both worlds: almost no people and almost no economy.But what about the virus with a 1.4% (maximum) mortality rate for those who get it? How do the scales balance out there?
For some, even asking this question smacks of callousness, since it seems to them that what we are being asked to do is equate people with commerce and money. Well, perhaps there are some who do indeed see it in those terms, and somehow come to the conclusion that making money is more important than human beings. I am most assuredly not one of them. Yet it's actually nothing to do with people vs money at all.
It's actually all about people, since shutting down an entire economy, or thereabouts, is bound to have massive effects on large numbers of people.
Comment: The social implications of worldwide quarantines have had very little discussion in the media. So many people who have been barely able to make ends meet are now without money, food, or social contact. Stress is poorly delt with in the West, and our current lockdown is magnifying it by untold numbers.