sott.net




Featured Book:

2500 Strand: Growing up in Hermosa Beach, California, during World War II

NEW!! Available Now!


SOTT Focus Listing

· SOTT Focus articles listed by author





Latest Topics on the Signs Forum
· Thank you for the podcasts!
[ aragorn ]
· Why China's buildings crumbled
[ dave613 ]
· Blood Ties That Blind
[ Laura ]
· Orphan work bill - Artists copyrights in the US in danger
[ Tigersoap ]
· Shine on You Crazy Diamond
[ starsailor ]
· NYC tomorrow - join the event in solidarity with Palestinians
[ Keit ]
· Vatican says aliens could exist
[ John G ]
· Migun, Far Infared, and Negative Ion Therapy
[ mamadrama ]

Firefox 2
This site best viewed
with Mozilla Firefox

SuperSearch Help

 

Michael Marshall
New Scientist
Fri, 09 May 2008 14:45 EDT

Science & Technology

Recently we praised the latest sci-fi blockbuster Iron Man for including so many real-world technologies.

It makes a change, since all too often Hollywood's use of science involves shocking blunders: including spaceships making whooshing noises in Star Wars to the journey to the centre of the Earth in The Core.

So, to give credit where it's due, we have picked out five more sci-fi films that go against the grain, and contain some accurate, plausible science. They may not be completely realistic, but they get it right when it matters most.

Be warned: this article inevitably contains a number of spoilers.

2001: A Space Odyssey (1968)

"Open the pod-bay doors, HAL."

Despite being made before the first moon landing, Stanley Kubrick and Arthur C Clarke's masterpiece is a strikingly realistic depiction of space travel.

It envisions interplanetary spaceships that use a variety of techniques to allow people to exist in zero gravity - some sections rotate to generate artificial gravity, others have walls covered in Velcro (or something similar) so that crewmembers wearing suitable shoes can walk across them.

Among the film's neater details:

* All scenes in outer space are silent - sound does not travel in a vacuum
* The stars do not move past the ship - for there to be a visible motion of the star field, the ship would have to be travelling at close to the speed of light
* The crew eat paste-like food and only drink liquids through straws.

Additionally, crew members are shown coping with the boredom and routine of a long, straightforward trek across empty space.

Newtonian physics is strictly obeyed in the behaviour of the ship and little "pods" that the astronauts use to travel outside it. Trouble only starts when a carefully-aligned radio transmitter, the crew's lifeline to Earth, begins to drift out of position.

Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind (2004)

"I walked out the door. There's no memory left."

The central character, Joel, discovers that his girlfriend Clementine has erased her memories of their relationship. Heartbroken and embittered, he goes to the company that performed the procedure and asks them to erase his memories as well.

However, as the procedure gets underway, he realises that he wants to keep the memories after all, and begins to resist.

This sort of selective memory erasure is well beyond our current technology, but there are good reasons to think it may not be impossible. Several forms of dementia affect particular types of memory - for instance semantic dementia, which targets only factual knowledge about the world, and not "personal" life memories.

Sensibly, the film depicts memory as essentially a network of links. In its frenetic second half, Joel is asleep while the technicians "operate" on his mind. We follow as he careens from recent memories of his relationship to those of his earliest childhood.

As he encounters each memory, it is identified by the technicians and erased, leading to spectacular sequences of him running through bookshops while books disappear from the shelves and escaping from a house that is disappearing one wall at a time.

Alien (1979)

"I can't lie to you about your chances, but you have my sympathies."

This sci-fi horror has a number of realistic touches, such as the use of suspended animation to keep the spaceship's crew alive during decades-long interstellar travel (no implausible faster-than-light travel for these astronauts).

It makes the list, though, for the vicious creature the crew encounters, in particular for the finer details of its life cycle.

The alien goes through three stages over the course of the film. It begins as an egg, which produces a kind of head-sized spider, equipped with a strong tail and a vaguely reptilian appearance. This attaches itself to the nearest living body and, while clamped over the face, implants an embryo into its victim's stomach. It then falls off and dies. The embryo survives by feeding on the victim's digested food. Eventually it breaks out (in the least pleasant way possible) and runs amok on the ship.

Every element of the life cycle can be found in nature, variously in parasites, robber wasps and social insects. Much of the film's suspense comes from the filmmakers' decision to let events unfold without too much explanation - the viewer has to piece the life cycle together for themselves.

Unfortunately, there are a couple of pretty dubious points. First, the adult somehow manages to grow from about 30 centimetres to 2 metres in a matter of hours. The alien is also equipped, throughout its life, with very strong acid for blood. For that to work, the rest of it must be made of Teflon, as conventional organic tissue would obviously be destroyed.

Gattaca (1997)

"We now have discrimination down to a science."

Andrew Niccol's film is noteworthy for its grimly plausible vision of a society dominated by genetic prejudice.

The majority of babies are conceived using IVF, following a process of preimplantation genetic diagnosis that weeds out all genetic imperfections. As a friendly geneticist explains to worried parents, "This child is still you, simply the best of you." Everyone's identities, and their genetic status, are also continuously monitored by biometric ID systems.

The central character, Vincent, is an "in-Valid" - he was conceived naturally, and consequently is short-sighted and has a heart defect. Debarred from all but the most menial jobs, he pays a crippled "Valid" to lend him his genetic identity - in the form of urine samples and the like - so he can pursue his dream of becoming an astronaut.

The society depicted in Gattaca is intentionally dystopic, sometimes to the point of parody. Most notably, Vincent's job interview at the Gattaca Aerospace Corporation consists entirely of a urine sample. However, genetics can only give statistical predictions, and rarely delivers 100% certainty. So the company would be well-advised to put him through a real interview as well.

Nevertheless, it is one of the few films to tackle the issue of genetic determinism: how much are we really controlled by our genes? Vincent out-competes genetically-superior characters mostly through sheer strength of will. Does that mean that genetic testing really cannot predict how people will perform - or does it just mean we haven't found the genes for willpower yet?

Solaris (1972 and 2002)

"I was haunted by the idea that I remembered her wrong, and somehow I was wrong about everything."

This Russian classic makes the list not so much for the specific science it portrays, as for its portrayal of the limits of science and of human understanding.

Psychologist Chris Kelvin is dispatched to a space station orbiting the mysterious planet Solaris, to find out why the crew has stopped responding to messages from Earth. He discovers them in a state of emotional breakdown, and is soon in the same condition himself. After falling asleep on the station for the first time, he wakes to find his wife Rheya, who committed suicide years before, next to him.

Somehow, and for no reason ever made clear, Solaris has brought Rheya back, constructing her using her husband's memories. But is she really Rheya, or is she just Chris's flawed recollection of her, seen through his own preconceived ideas and limited understanding? Solaris itself is equally inexplicable, creating bizarre geometric shapes across its surface that may or may not be alive.

Stanislaw Lem, who wrote the original novel, was convinced that extraterrestrial life would be so strange that humans would be unable to understand it. Solaris gets right to the heart of this idea.

Despite being a trained psychologist and an educated man, Chris cannot even understand his wife. How then, the film asks, could he possibly understand something as alien as Solaris? Devotees of quantum mechanics and the consciousness problem will no doubt sympathise.

Discuss on SOTT Forum


Reader Comments
 
(Register to add your comments!)
 
A Space Odyssey By Keit
Keit

Ok, I have to admit that while watching this movie I had a strong urge to fast forward (it was still a cassette video period) because movie's pace was way too slow for the usual Hollywood sci-fi flick (and actually much more realistic). But they don't call it classic movie for nothing. It had genuinely spooky and tense moments there, alright? Lack of background music just intensified the effect.

Not to mention the spookiness of Alien. This is entirely different story.

About the original Solaris by Tarkovsky. Yeah, it's a masterpiece without a doubt. Look for his other works like Stalker. Those movies go for a deep emotional/psychological effect rather than visual. But there is also a good sci-fi/horror movie on the same topic (though on a much shallower level) called Event Horizon
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0119081/


Added: Sun, 11 May 2008 16:20 EDT

Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind By Mkrnhr

I've re-whached this movie three days ago.
Apart a funny reference to mantauk in this movie (which deals essentially with altering memory and thus perception of reality), the most disturbing aspect is that of irresponsible people playing with you mind when you're asleep. At a certain level it could apply to our everyday's life. We are asleep, dreaming passively of fantasy dreams, while some other irresponsible and awaken people play with you. The solution for Joel was to awaken, to look at what was happening around, to understand his situation, and finally to act actively through his dream/memory rather then letting it happen. A very enjoyable love story otherwise ;)


Added: Sun, 11 May 2008 17:41 EDT

Solaris And Eternal Sunshine... And Space Odyssey By Apeguia
Apeguia

Wow! Solaris and Eternal Sunshine, two of my favorite movies of all times. (Space Odyssey is good too.)

About Solaris: I didn't watch Tarkovsky's original (have been looking for it without success), but I thought that the more recent version was pretty well done. But most importantly, the story is a magnificent metaphor for the basic dilemma of the human race: be 'happy' with an illusion or accept a harsh truth?? Quite esoteric, really.

I did watch Stalker - powerful stuff too. Funny, just yesterday I saw a quote from that movie while surfing the web. It goes:

"Here we are at the threshold. This is the most important moment of your lives. You have to know that here your most cherished wish will come true. The most sincere one. The one reached through suffering."

And a few days before someone made a reference to Space Odyssey. So now I feel the urge to quote:

"My God. It's full of stars!"


Added: Sun, 11 May 2008 19:07 EDT


 

Donate to Signs

Donate once - or every month! Click here to learn how you can help!

Have a question or comment about the Signs page? Discuss it on the Signs of the Times news forum with the Signs Team.

Emails sent to Signs of the Times, Ark, Laura, or Cassiopaea become the property of Quantum Future Group, Inc and may be republished without notice.

Some icons appearing on this site were taken from KDE-look.org, Afterglow, Mayosoft, Everaldo, IconDrawer, VisualPharm, IconFactory, Klukeart, Icons-land, and TpdkDesign.net
.

Remember, we need your help to collect information on what is going on in your part of the world!
Send your article suggestions to: SOTT e-mail address


Original content copyright 2008 by Signs of the Times. See: Fair Use Policy

251 people have viewed this page since Sun, 11 May 2008

ATOM Feed   RSS

[Valid Atom 1.0]   [Valid RSS 2.0]